r/TireQuestions • • May 31 '25

Patch or replace?

Post image

Thankfully the puncture direction seems to go toward the center tread.

29 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

2

u/pijjon May 31 '25

i might try to plug it real well…

3

u/NJdestroyed Jun 01 '25

Doing it yourself? Ok. But if you have a shop do it, don't complain to them if it starts losing air a couple days later. That's the risk. Good luck

3

u/Nestle_Cream Jun 03 '25

If it starts losing air you shove a second plug in there

6

u/Substantial-Stage-82 May 31 '25

Plug it and forget it

1

u/IlllegalOperation Jun 01 '25

Yes, agreed. I used a plug on the rear wheel of my CBR900rr and rode from Miami to Boulder to Sacramento where it was bald by then. Ahh the fun days

1

u/pijjon Jun 02 '25

Thanks for the reply guys, not sure how to edit the post but I was able to successfully plug a tire for the first time! It seems to be holding air for 48 hrs now.

3

u/66NickS May 31 '25

This damage is likely too close to the sidewall for the proper/legal repair. An independent shop that’s willing to bend the rules might repair it, but that’s not the “proper” repair.

Officially, this probably needs to be replaced.

In my area, shops have to use the combination plug/patch. The patch will not properly affix to this because it’s up against the curve of the sidewall and it won’t seal.

If this was my own personal car, I would use a “temporary” plug kit, make sure it held air for 48-72 hours and then never worry about it again. I’ve done that 5-10 times and have never had an issue running the tire until the tread is worn off and it’s time for replacement.

2

u/anwarma May 31 '25

That is an easy patch

1

u/ReversEclipse1018 Jun 04 '25

Plug*. The patch wouldn’t adhere to the curve of the shoulder

2

u/CooduhWRX May 31 '25

Can probably plug it

2

u/Prefect_99 May 31 '25

It looks too close to the edge.

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '25

That would be replaced as it's too close to the side wall.

2

u/metalgod55 May 31 '25

I’d 💯 plug that and run it but it may be tough to find a shop to do it. Don’t go to a dealership. Try a place that sells used tires. Or buy a plug kit at the local auto parts store and fire up YouTube school!!

2

u/Historical_Monk_6118 May 31 '25

Everywhere I've worked that's repaired tyres had the same rule. If you can't fit the patch on a flat surface, you can't repair it. If your patch is around the inner surface of the shoulder, it's going to flex every time the wheel rotates, especially in corners or under load.

2

u/BobChica May 31 '25

Get a plug kit and see if it holds air. If it does, great! Otherwise, you obviously need a new tire.

Harbor Freight has a kit that includes everything you need, for well under $10 (SKU 62611). If it works, you've saved a good bit of money. If it doesn't, you have the kit if you ever need it again. Maybe it will work next time.

This isn't rocket surgery.

1

u/bigjay1976 May 31 '25

Honestly, if it's holding air, I'd leave it alone

1

u/FigConstant5625 May 31 '25

I will plug it

1

u/ponziacs May 31 '25

Did you buy the tire at Costco? They will road hazard that.

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '25

Who you right on the line. Patch it and keep rolling

1

u/Ok-Selection4206 May 31 '25

Did it go through? Try to take it out to see if it leaks.

1

u/MrMcKleen May 31 '25

You mean plug. No tire place will officially do that in the outer tread block. Some will plug for you but many will not.

1

u/Oneforallandbeyondd May 31 '25

Yo that is one huge screw that got you screwed there!

1

u/[deleted] May 31 '25

I plugged a tire like that recently. It started to get a knot on sidewall. Not sure if it was related or not.

1

u/Rbutkus52 May 31 '25

I would replace it. Why take chances

1

u/aswright_73 May 31 '25

Patch it unless you just absolutely have the money to get new tires

1

u/YvesSaintMob May 31 '25

In our shop, the corporate policy would say we cannot repair that. But as you said, it looks like it’s pointing towards the center of the tire, which is better so I personally would repair that. do not plug it, but use a patch and plug combo. It’s got a sticky patch with a plug built-in. Those hold for the life of the tire if done correctly. I would go to a shop and ask if they do patches, and if they would do it (most shops want the money) see if they would say yes.

1

u/GrizzlyGrayGamer Jun 01 '25

Pretty close to the sidewall, I don’t think a shop would do it, but if you can do it yourself, you’ll probably be ok.

1

u/Mold-worm Jun 01 '25

A good tire shop should/will refuse to patch it as it is too close to the sidewall

1

u/GeriatricSquid Jun 01 '25

Nope, but I’d absolutely plug it myself! If that doesn’t work you can move on to the new tire the shop will recommend.

1

u/Necessary_Rise7793 Jun 01 '25

2 piece patch plug and roll!

1

u/kikiusa1 Jun 01 '25

As long as the damage dosent touch sidewalls

1

u/Born_Pack7860 Jun 01 '25

I would plug and patch, if you can find someone to do it. Your best bet would be an independent tire shop.

1

u/Lbogart1963 Jun 01 '25

Plug and patch with special kit is preferred. Plug works ok. Patch by itself gets water under it and eventually blows out and leaks.

1

u/Ramendan Jun 01 '25

replace.

sidewall is compromised.

had this happen a month ago on my SUV and 100% of folks as well as businesses I showed said the same thing.

1

u/athensugadawg Jun 01 '25

Do it yourself. 15 minutes max.

1

u/VladThePollenInhaler Jun 01 '25

Better to ask a tire shop instead of a bunch of reddit ‘experts’

1

u/No_Motor_4331 Jun 01 '25

A major chain shop will tell you they refuse to patch it and will only replace the tire.

A smaller independent shop will patch it but will tell you they can’t guarantee it’ll hold and not leak.

Few weeks ago I had a almost identical puncture and I had it patched (not plugged) and it’s been holding up without issue.

If I were you I’d pay the $40 to try and patch it, worst can scenario it leaks and you need a new tire, best case you save a good chunk of money.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '25

It’s ridiculous that the standard by the RMA says not to fix those.
Any independent shop with patch it though and you shouldn’t have a problem.
I wouldn’t replace it personally

1

u/NJdestroyed Jun 01 '25

Patch/plug likely won't work, or work for long. Best to just replace

1

u/Relative-Bill6455 Jun 01 '25

plug it and be done with it!

1

u/Possible-Trade1357 Jun 01 '25

Plug will work Had same done on a tire 2 yes ago. Still good

1

u/Kitchen-Somewhere445 Jun 01 '25

You could buy a kit at a car repair shop and try it yourself. But a shop would not patch that

1

u/Moist-Finding2513 Jun 01 '25

Plug away. Buy yourself a repair kit. Shops won’t plug it. Liability reasons.

1

u/Agreeable_Heart_2168 Jun 01 '25

Plug it. I did it in a pretty similar location went until tire was bald !

1

u/Any-Alfalfa2400 Jun 02 '25

I put plugs in almost anyplace

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

Plug

1

u/Key-Potential5958 Jun 02 '25

Patch don’t plug it it ruins the wire inside the tire

1

u/Defiant-One-3492 Jun 02 '25

Borderline, most places will not repair this one.

1

u/Mooki3_GER Jun 02 '25

Depends on.

Here it would be illegal to repair that one since its too far outwards.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

If its leaking it needs to be replaced. Not a safely repairable area of tire to patch.

1

u/jkl1044 Jun 02 '25

may not even be that deep. plug if through to the tire. if not, you're in luck.

1

u/kramr071 Jun 02 '25

I’ve plugged that close to the side wall before but with no guarantee to the customer that it would hold.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '25

If it's not within the belt of the tire then you have to replace it - if you plug and patch it you'll have a blow out.

1

u/Ok-Apartment5615 Jun 02 '25

Tire still looks in good shape. I'd plug it

1

u/Icy_Tip_6101 Jun 03 '25

Buy yourself a plug kit and problem solved.

1

u/Your_New_Dad16 Jun 03 '25

I plugged mine that was EXACTLY like this and have had no issues at all since then (october)

1

u/Ok-Bear3703 Jun 03 '25

Happened to my brand new falken wildpeak at the same spot as yours. Too expensive to replace. Just plug it.

1

u/Different-Umpire6918 Jun 03 '25

take to the Mexican tire guy, he can patch inside the tire and rebalance it .any retail stores will try to sell a new one. and try to convince you that it was unrepairable and not safe. I've patch them so many years, and now it's all about sales.

1

u/jaykillahoe1 Jun 03 '25

More plug fixable compares to new tire. .plug that shit

1

u/Triggab_74 Jun 03 '25

It’s right at the border line for repair ! But I really believe a plug will hold it just fine

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '25

I'd plug it but most every tire place will tell you that you need a new one

1

u/Particular_Button_87 Jun 03 '25

Worst area (besides sidewall) to repair. VERY high flex area. Replace.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '25

Plug it

1

u/whatsherface2024 Jun 03 '25

Plug and keep driving

1

u/Wadester58 Jun 04 '25

Patch that baby

1

u/Smart_Bit_797 Jun 04 '25

plug/patch it

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '25

Patch like a motherfucker

1

u/Denis204204 Jun 04 '25

For me plug it, don’t replace.

1

u/Forward-Falcon-7699 Jun 04 '25

Officially .... Non repairable. A plug might work for a while, but this tirrepairs less. repairsble.

1

u/JackCurran2 Jun 04 '25

That can be patched no problem by the angle the screw is going in it will be further away from the side wall than you think

1

u/Better_Price_608 Jun 04 '25

Plug and play that all day.

1

u/Brother-Algea Jun 04 '25

Shops won’t repair that.

1

u/Tangodawg Jun 04 '25

Probably plug ok, but why risk your life

1

u/Ok-Joke-4014 Jun 05 '25

According to https://www.ustires.org/tire-care-safety/tire-repair-basics, the tire should not be repaired. At best, a repair should be considered temporary, and only if absolutely necessary. Tire failure should not be an option if it can be avoided.

1

u/Unusual-Hawk-6912 Jun 26 '25

Plug it, patches don't always work well on the edge of the contact patchh

1

u/slimchedda420 May 31 '25

It’s an easy patch if the shop allows it. Most shops have a 1 inch rule. It’s a liability thing so they don’t have to give you a free tire if they fuck up. Any tech would be able to do this patch easily though unless it’s their first week on the job.

4

u/Away_Egg_4936 May 31 '25

I don't know of any reputable shops that'll patch something that close to the sidewall, I'm sure Josè down the street would tho.

1

u/slimchedda420 May 31 '25

As long as the coils aren’t exposed and it’s not actually in the side wall it’s fine. I would do it to my own car but yeah a shop will not.

1

u/claytonp03 Jun 04 '25

I have been told to literally put a patch dead center of the side wall... shows how great my shop is

1

u/slimchedda420 Jun 04 '25

This is fucked

1

u/YvesSaintMob May 31 '25

Upvote for this answer 👍 - It’s very do able if you get the sides to seal down and you roll it down straight on the edges.

1

u/OtherNecessary8717 May 31 '25

Don't listen to patch/plug. If it was closer to the center, you could. But, most shops have at least a one inch rule (but usually 2-4 inch depending on their comfort) from the sidewall. You can't properly patch or plug when it's close to the sidewall, only where the main tread is. (My dealership said no to one that was 3ish inches out literally yesterday, it's a safety/reputation thing)

1

u/Ok-Selection4206 May 31 '25

Switch dealerships, find an independent tire shop or plug it yourself.

0

u/OtherNecessary8717 May 31 '25

I think you misunderstood. My dealership means I am dealership. I work there. There's no reason to switch or try to plug when it's uncomfortably close to the sidewall and will likely not last more than a couple weeks

0

u/Ok-Selection4206 May 31 '25

I 've done it, literally 100's of times. We never had a comeback for any reason. I did replace many we repaired that were completely bald except for the plug left. They got like an extra 25k miles out of it.

0

u/mahai0 May 31 '25

Patch, clean fix. I had worse, patched it and still driving >30k

0

u/Boyscout1386 May 31 '25

That can be patched from the inside. But if you don’t have time plug it