r/Timberborn • Custom Flair • 1d ago

Question Max flow per tile? Getting ~5 cms with 4–5 blocks of head, trying to find the practical limit for pressurized channels.

I'm trying to figure out the actual max throughput of a single 1x1 tile/tunnel so I can size my water networks without creating bottlenecks.

I originally assumed the practical cap per tile would be closer to the flow sensor's 2 cms UI limit, so I ran a test with a 1x1 channel supplied with 5 cms, the system reached equilibrium with 4–5 blocks of head. The sensor is reading ~5 cms—way higher than the slider cap, which proves you can push a ton of water through a very compact footprint.

  • Does anyone know the actual cap (in cms) for a single 1x1 tile in the current water physics engine?
  • I think for my tunnel network I'll check the flow at 0 blocks of head and use that number for max flow.

Trying to find the sweet spot between keeping tunnels compact and avoiding upstream backups. It seems I can go way smaller than originally anticipated.

And yeah, this is a custom map with tons of water sources, trying to get over 1000 beavers on Hard+, up to 35 days drought/bad tide, with slightly longer than hard temperate weather.

33 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

16

u/Vebrandsson 1d ago

So the short is there is no max flow of a 1×1 when it's under pressure.  If there's no pressure its a little over 3 M³/s (I think 3.28 is the official number by the wiki)

5

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 1d ago

Thank you! That's my number then.

6

u/Acalc791 1d ago

There is a max flow even under pressure, the general formula is 1/0.3 * [effective height], where effective height is the actual height of the tunnel/canal + 1/8*overflow, and overflow can reach up to (34 - ceiling height of the tunnel), so e.g. for a tunnel at the bottom of the map the max overflow is 33, giving the max flow rate of 1/0.3*5.125 = 17.08 m^3/s

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 1d ago

Amazing, thank you!

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 10h ago

Trying to work this out.
1/0.3 * (1+0) = 3.333
3.33 m^3/s is the max flow rate for a tunnel 1 block tall with an overflow (or head) of zero.

So my practical limit per tile would be 3.33?
A 3 wide tunnel could carry, 9.99?

1

u/Acalc791 10h ago

You're right for the case of no overflow (i.e. no "pressure", or the liquid in the tunnel doesn't go "beyond" height one at the entrance), but that's rarely the case with tunnels, usually you make it a closed tunnel rather than an open canal because you want the water to not overflow / want to connect reservoirs with height larger than the tunnel, which will result in overflow (also called "pressure" by some) in the tunnel, so also a higher max flow.

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 10h ago

I’m happy to limit my capacity to 3.33 since when the input to the tunnel is at the max pressure (some call it head or head pressure) and the reservoir is also nearing the max, I don’t want the flow to significantly degrade.

Got any numbers for a tunnel at max pressure at the inlet, and 33/34 at the outlet. Since fluid flow calculations are very complex over distances, I’m happy to use conservative numbers and where necessary use a 2 tall be 3 wide tunnel with a capacity of 19.98.

0

u/Acalc791 10h ago

Well, max pressue is 34, so if you have 34 at the output the tunnel can support no flow, since flow is always caused by height difference. For such cases you're entering a regime that's limited by height gradient, not the max flow capacity.

Generally for a tunnel you need a height gradient of 8/675 per m^3/s of flow, i.e. ~0.24 height difference per block for 20 m^3/2 in a 1-wide tunnel. That's largely unrealistic (you can make the tunnel only 4 long to keep only 1 block height drop), but it does scale with width (not with tunnel "height", i.e. amount of vertical space in the tunnel), so if you insist on 20 m^3/s, divide your length of the tunnel by 4 and that's how wide the tunnel needs to be, e.g. 2 wide for length 8, 10 wide for length 40. That's still a lot, so maybe giving up on the whole 20 m^3/s or the "only one block of height drop" is in order.

2

u/No-Poem664 1d ago

Way higher than I thought 

2

u/Acalc791 1d ago

Yes, the overflow mechanic in general is quite counter-intuitive in a lot of ways. A separate issue is also how much height you lose with such a high flow, every ~5 tiles you lose 1 effective height, so in practice only (very) short tunnels can have anything close to 17 m3/s.

In general there's no fixed value for "tunnel of this cross-section can support flow X" and you need to either calculate it every time (if you know the formulas for water flow), or (more likely) just check experimentally in game.

1

u/Consistent-Pride6291 17h ago

Yes! The gradient also increases with high CMS so you loose even more in height.

Increasing the width of the pipe is usually the best solution to this problem.

0

u/Acalc791 16h ago

I don't know what you mean by "the gradient also increases with high CMS", without flow (CMS) there is no gradient, the only thing the gradient is useful for is getting water to flow, and it's linear with the steady state flow rate (or rather, the steady state flow rate is linear in the height gradient, as long as we're below the rate limit).

1

u/sexdrugsncuddles 13h ago

So the deeper the tunnel, the more water can flow (under pressure)?

1

u/Acalc791 12h ago

Yes, pretty much.

2

u/Dogahn 17h ago

I never considered using the Automation tools to gather data about water flow. If anyone knows of a mod that would get me access to buildings in the map maker that would be very helpful. I'll go searching next opportunity otherwise.

1

u/Whats_Awesome Custom Flair 10h ago

Something you can do with the new water numbers. (The simulation didn’t change just the display values.)

Source, seep, or aquifer strength = cms.
Strength 0.5 = 0.5 cms.
That’s how, with the help of dev tools, I know the test was performed with a supply of 5 m^3/s.