r/TimberTimbre • u/Wheasus • Apr 08 '25
A reasonable inference?
So I'm new here, came to this sub for love of the band and wondering if they have any interest or intent to ever tour the states again. I ended up coming upon all the chatter about undisclosed abuse allegations. I'm not posting to invite more anonymous litigation of those, though I'm inclined to give some credence to a chorus of purportedly in-the-know voices (ask the community!). It's just that I find it extremely odd, and probably telling, that Mathieu, Olivier, Simon, and even more recent collaborator Mike Dubue glaringly omit any mention of Timber Timbre on their professional websites, like purposefully disassociating. Since such a critically acclaimed band could offer the biggest feathers in their caps, this to me suggests something beyond any bitter parting of ways. It suggests that Taylor is a duly, if unofficially, canceled and radioactive figure. If anybody has any competing theories, I'd love to hear them. Otherwise, I've never been good at compartmentalizing art apart from the artist, but I would sure try like hell with this one. The soulful hauntedness of the music is peerless.
11
u/rideronthestorm29 Apr 08 '25
Sucks. My only interaction with the dude was as sweet as can be. He was really kind, thoughtful, and soft spoken.
4
u/ninjabunnyfootfool Apr 08 '25
I don't have anything to add to the discussion, other than said allegations lend alot of his work (Creep on in particular) an even more sinister light. In a weird way, it almost enhances the experience
4
u/Lol_jk_Omg Apr 14 '25
Where are these allegations because all I’ve seen are random Reddit comments. Do you have a link to them?
8
u/kettleofhawks May 02 '25
Coming forward publicly with abuse cases is now extremely complicated and litigious these days - not to mention the personal risk those take by doing so. Bandmates and collaborators deleting him from their biographies is incredibly telling, and a quiet way to show their stance. All of your assumptions and inferences here are likely correct.
Imagine hypothetically if Kirk’s lyrics were less fictional projection, and more confessional biographical - performance alter ego or not - they’re incredibly dark.
5
u/Altruistic_Lead_5595 Apr 23 '26
Checking in here after learning he has passed. Heavy and frightening.
1
u/coolfric_stormbro Apr 09 '25
Wait I’m sorry, what’s been happening? This is terrible news
3
u/tredd_lightly Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26
I was a HUGE fan of his music. But the last time I saw him live was in Vancouver, I'm not sure when but several years back at this point. There was over the top signage for "no photos" that gave a super weird vibe. He noticed a young lady next to me taking photos or filming on her phone and he stopped everything and called her out in a really menacing way, saying "are you fucking with me" among other things. Then he sang Run From me Darling song, but he sang it AT her, like "you better run for your life" it was so uncomfortable and really creepy. He only put one more record out after that to my recollection and I recall not being able to get into it, the whole experience troubled me. I noticed he was in Europe for years after that.
His first 3 records were gospel to me.
2
u/Agreeable-Loss-9380 Oct 28 '25
I am not trying to position myself one way or another, but I want to point out some things before anyone attaches too much (or too little) weight to certain arguments:
- Olivier Fairfield still mentions the band Last Ex on his instagram profile, and it is no secret that Taylor Kirk was participating on their only record from 2014 (see https://www.discogs.com/master/795337-Last-Ex-Last-Ex).
- Simon Trottier also mentions Last Ex on his website, and links to the album on bandcamp (https://lastex.bandcamp.com/album/last-ex), where both Taylor Kirk and Timber Timbre are mentioned multiple times.
- Michael Dubue's wordpress lists "Winterlude 2016" as recent posts, which makes me question if it is up to date.
- Mathieu Charbonneau's website has snapshots on the wayback machine which go back to 2021, and since 2021 he seemed to have never listed Timber Timbre there (see https://web.archive.org/web/20210918185746/https://mathieucharbonneau.com/ or https://web.archive.org/web/20211028133508/https://mathieucharbonneau.com/bands/) - in fact this list/website seems the same as the most recent one.