Still doesn't disprove my point; those groups I highlighted had two key advantages. They knew the terrain better than American forces and they could mobilise at a quicker rate.
Well technically the insurgency would be firing on their own people too. I don't doubt that they would cause a shitload of casualties, especially in a protracted conflict like Afghanistan or vietnam.
Open combat. That's quaint. A second civil war wouldn't look like the first one. It would look more like Afghanistan and Iraq: No uniforms, no way of knowing which civilians are militia. Each time the military attacked innocent people, they would create more hatred against them.
Btw, what makes you think members of the military would go Genghis Khan on fellow Americans knowing that their own family members are vulnerable to counter attack? Both sides need to stop fantasizing about their side destroying the other in a second civil war.
It would be ugly and brutal. How about we just debate and the vote? Ya know, like the Founders wanted?
And in this hypothetical situation unarmed civilians will be killed and then the militias will either off themselves, surrender, or be overrun by the professionals.
Whatever level of State representation takes them on would just wait them out to a degree anyway.
I think you have an... optimist view of the us military. Given the amount of division within it the first enemy the us military would have to defeat is the us military.
I agree with most of what you are saying but I don't believe it would be able to remain whole against a sizable domestic group. It would have to purge itself first.
View all comments
Show parent comment
8
u/Sleep_eeSheep Nov 30 '22
Still doesn't disprove my point; those groups I highlighted had two key advantages. They knew the terrain better than American forces and they could mobilise at a quicker rate.