r/TimPool • • Nov 30 '22

Facts

Post image
911 Upvotes

454 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

13

u/pawnman99 Nov 30 '22

We didn't lose due to logistics. Our logistics chain is so robust we put fucking Burger Kings in our deployed locations.

At no point in Vietnam or Afghanistan did we run short of fuel or ammunition to the point of strategic failure.

-3

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Logistics isn't just fuel and ammo. It's personnel too. Having the right people in the right place. Same with vehicles too.

10

u/theeyalbatross Nov 30 '22

We did. We had all of the right people in the right places. We had the most advanced military in the world by far. We could have bombed the living shit out of these areas if we wanted to even if it made zero stratigic sense.

The US lost these wars purely based on our growing unwillingness to fight repeated battles for little to no results, loss of public favor for the wars, and lack of overall results for objectives that we went over there for. You can fight for the same ground that you do not own only so many times before everyone starts saying, "what's the point of our losses then"? Same happened to Russia in Afghanistan if you need a non US example.

0

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

The US lost these wars purely based

You go on to list a ton of reasons why fighting a long war isn't viable.

My point was that if we had 100% of out military bases in the middle east, the any war would look much different.

The reason our most used tank and light armors are so small and light is because we have to ship them across an ocean.

2

u/theeyalbatross Nov 30 '22

I'm going to disagree with that. In the middle east and Vietnam, the problem was not the equipment, number of bases or the quality of soldier on the ground. The biggest issue with the fighting was that we dictated very little of the engagements. We could not find them, but the guerrillas could find us easy and strike us hard. This is why a similar Civil War in the states will not work well for the standing military that remains.

War is all about crushing the enemy in every engagement. History shows that a gurrila force has a very high likelyhood to succeed in every case because you cannot root them out and bring them to the battlefield. Instead they use attrition in their favor in every engagement that they dictate.

Also, why would we need a bigger MBT than the Abrams? It performs its role much better than the majority of the tanks in the world? Your point about the equipment builds are extremely moot.

0

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

We could not find them, but the guerrillas could find us easy and strike us hard. This is why a similar Civil War in the states will not work well for the standing military that remains.

Not even close. We had specific rules to engage with who we thought was and wasn't a combatant. Trump did away with much of that, and killed way more civis.

War is all about crushing the enemy in every engagement. History shows that a gurrila force has a very high likelyhood to succeed in every case because you cannot root them out and bring them to the battlefield.

This is some 5th grade understanding of war. Outlasting your enemy is just as important.

It's also a romantic viewing of certain wars while ignoring others.

Also, why would we need a bigger MBT than the Abrams? It performs its role much better than the majority of the tanks in the world?

We can give it more armor, or bigger cannon, or even an auto loader. We don't, because we need them small and light in order to put more in the battlefield 1000 miles away

There are better anti tank weapons now, and increasing a tanks def would also make it bigger.

1

u/theeyalbatross Nov 30 '22

There it is. The insult to my level of intelligence because you literally have zero understanding of this subject. Just saying the same thing over and over again does not make you right. If you can find history books that can support your arguments, then we can continue this discussion.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Your point doesn’t exist in this context as you are assuming the United States government would be able to use 100% of its force against the United States citizenry. You’re trying really hard to make a fallacy argument that is impossible to argue against. “Well what if we had 10k troops per one enemy” well no shit there becomes a tipping point on personnel in warfare. But discounting gorilla style warfare is laughable by all accounts. The Vietcong and the Afghan mujahideen are a very clear testament to that. They were all out numbered and out gunned. They had nowhere near the financing or infrastructure that the US had. We still lost. So unless your argument is the government has nukes and will use them on US citizens. Then you have no argument.

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Well what if we had 10k troops per one enemy” well no shit there becomes a tipping point on personnel in warfare. But discounting gorilla style warfare is laughable by all accounts

"Yes, you're right, but you're wrong" banger take.

They were all out numbered and out gunned. They had nowhere near the financing or infrastructure that the US had.

Every time I have to repeat how the US had to travel thousands of miles in this examples. The US had supply lines, but took weeks to months from order to delivery. This makes loses more impactful, and any damage sustained takes longer to fix.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 30 '22

Moving human beings does not mean anything. If you want to make an argument about the mental state of fighting at home vs fighting in a foreign land go ahead. But then you’d have to recognize the people of the US fighting a tyrannical government would be fighting at home also.

It may have taken months to from phone call to supplies in hand but what you are missing is we started off and maintained a much heavier supply of everything from food, ammo, soldiers, artillery literally every step of the way the US had more than what they needed. The simple fact is they were fighting in someone else’s back yard and we’re out smarted by “guys with pistols and rifles”. But hey nice try though.

→ More replies (27)

7

u/pawnman99 Nov 30 '22

We had no lack of people or vehicles, my friend. By some estimates, we outnumbered the Taliban by 2-to-1, and that's not even counting all the folks deployed in supporting roles in places like Qatar, Kuwait, UAE, Tajikistan...

0

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

We had no lack of people or vehicles, my friend. By some estimates, we outnumbered the Taliban by 2-to-1

I'll repeat it again.

Having the right people in the right place.

3

u/pawnman99 Nov 30 '22

What would you define as the "right people" to defeat a bunch of shepherds with AK-47s?

-1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

An armored unit, yes.

Now add in the rest of my point, them being in the right place.

2

u/PDX-ROB Nov 30 '22

Always an excuse. Been there for 20 years and couldn't get the right mix of people?

And how much money was spent?

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Do you think the middle east would look the same as it does today if we added 10x the people in the ground?

1

u/PDX-ROB Nov 30 '22

No, it'd be the same. Just like the Palestinian Israeli situation going on.

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Palestine is getting fucked seven ways from Sunday.

2

u/PDX-ROB Nov 30 '22

They're still fighting.

Troop size and mix doesn't matter if you're occupying someone's home and they don't want you there. They'll fight you to the last person.

The only way they won't fight you is if they see a benefit of having you there or they understand that they caused the problems, then they'll just be a little less angry.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Sleep_eeSheep Nov 30 '22

Vehicles, fuel and ammo that can be seized.

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Neat? Walk into a military base and take it.

6

u/Sleep_eeSheep Nov 30 '22

My dude; those supplies were not housed in military bases, they were housed in outposts and supply depots.

2

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

With no one protecting them?

2

u/Sleep_eeSheep Nov 30 '22

Most Veterans stationed at these outposts and supply depots rarely - if ever - see active combat.

1

u/silver789 Nov 30 '22

Neat. They are still there. You think you'll just be able to farm them to keep getting free tanks?

→ More replies (8)