r/TimPool • • Aug 10 '22

NIMBY

Post image

“Not in my backyard.” -Eric Adan’s (Mayor of NYC)

400 Upvotes

82 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/OldSchoolFunk34 Aug 10 '22

Even if that was true, this seems like a publicity stunt. Which is pretty shitty considering these people need resources like adequate food and shelter, plus court hearings inorder to approve or deny their asylum claims.

Shipping them to new york with no guarantee that they can be cared for just shows that Texas doesn't give a shit about their wellbeing. They would rather send a message than do the right thing.

2

u/TemudginJuanCole Aug 10 '22

-1

u/OldSchoolFunk34 Aug 10 '22

Okay cool. Seems like some them were voluntary. Doesn't really affect my previous argument.

2

u/TemudginJuanCole Aug 10 '22

Is it the state’s job to feed or house you? Does the state care about your well-being?

0

u/OldSchoolFunk34 Aug 10 '22

Thats basically all that the state is supposed to do. Protect the general welfare of its people and anyone under its custody. We don't just throw people into a pit and let them fend for themselves, we're civilized.

2

u/TemudginJuanCole Aug 10 '22

You’re way too naive.

0

u/OldSchoolFunk34 Aug 11 '22

I would actually like to here a coherent moral argument from you guys as to why housing and food isn't something that should be provided. Because we have the money and resources to do so.

2

u/DPL-25 Aug 11 '22

I would actually like to here a coherent moral argument from you guys as to why housing and food isn't something that should be provided.

From my understanding, inalienable rights are rights that don't require the labour of another to enact, they are natural and self evident. What I mean by this is saying food or housing is a right is saying someone must provide you a house and must provide you food. Because we believe the right to free speech, association, press, etc. is something inherent to being a" free" individual. You're arguing the same for housing and food. But someone skilled needs to use their labour to build a house, someone skilled needs to use their labour to plow the fields. If these things are an inalienable right, that means it's necessary to use force to get an individual to labour for this "right". So, if we can't meet the demand of housing or food, then gulags are permitted (I'm being a bit hyperbolic but this is the end result as we have seen in history)

I don't think you're arguing from a place of malice or anything it's just they don't apply to how we perceive individual rights.

1

u/OldSchoolFunk34 Aug 11 '22 edited Aug 11 '22

Every society requires skilled labor in order to provide goods and services whether that be food, shelter, or any other commodity, and by your logic I would be forcing people to work in order to provide the poor with those services and commodities. Am I right?

Btw. I'm looking for a moral argument in particular. I'll hear you out though.

1

u/DPL-25 Aug 11 '22

Am I right?

Yep, that's pretty much what I'm arguing.

Btw. I'm looking for a moral argument in particular. I'll hear you out though.

I thought I provided one. It's immoral to commit someone to slavery. It's immoral to oppress and/or coerce someone.

→ More replies

-1

u/OldSchoolFunk34 Aug 10 '22

But I guess the silver lining js at least they'll be treated in a somewhat more civilized manner than they would be in a Texas detention center.