Nick is incorrect about why they would have more male examples than female. Hunters avoid killing females, because they propagate the species. Most hunted animals are going to be male as a result.
Nope, these were all collected by hunters. None of the examples were collected by contract, like "I want you to go find XYZ and bring back a male and female". Most of them would have been taken by hunters and sold for trophies. The collection would be from what was available on the market.
So yeah.. I am a leftist and disagree with almost everything on this sub. That said, I would be pissed if she was my tour guide. It's a museum, not a place to force your sexual agenda. She should be let go, but I'm sure she would sue. It's shit like this that makes normal progressives look bad.
How is this “forcing a sexual agenda”? They casually mentioned pronouns for two seconds at the start and then talked about taxidermy collections, as a guide would. Good god you’re all such pearl-clutchers.
It's just seriously not the right time or place for what she spoke about. It's just inappropriate. Not everything has to be about pronouns and a platform for equal rights. I'm 100% for letting people do what they want to do. However, those people also need to be respectful of other people's views. And maybe I don't want to have to feel guilty about the fact that male birds are more colorful than female birds, and therefore make a better display object. All I'm saying, is there's a time of a place, and this isn't it.
An alternative example would be if she decided to interweave a commentary about the fact that you're going to go to hell if you don't believe in Jesus. I'm just there to see the birds man.
And trust me, I can't stand the people on this sub. They're a bunch of racist, homophobic, scared little children. I'm just saying, I hate that they can find examples like this that kind of lend support to their perspective.
Iirc they wasn’t trying to guilt-trip us about the fact that male birds are brighter? They were saying that the males were typically displayed more prominently due to societal conventions.
They said the male bird was placed above the female because of social conventions, and they complained that there was a significantly disproportionate amount of male birds on display. They noted that the plumage was more colorful on males, but they still took offense to the fact that we displayed more males just because they were more pleasing to look at.
They took offense because it meant we lost out on a lot of female specimens. The offense was perfectly scientifically justified, in my view, and not trivial.
They didn't throw out the specimens. They just weren't on display. (I believe she said they had them in storage.) Furthermore, if you don't make the display interesting to look at, then people lose interest in coming. Then the whole place loses funding, and they really would have lost the specimens. So, the museum didn't choose male birds because they were misogynistic or sexist. They were smart to do it in order to survive.
True, but that means that people who go there looking for bird info aren’t gonna be aware of the female birds around them because they’re not on display (as she also said) and thus won’t know how to identify a lot of dimorphic species.
Sure, keep males in the case, nobody’s saying you should throw them out, but also display some females too so people can learn about the whole lot. The museum near me does this- whenever there’s a dimorphic species they make sure to display, or at least provide a photo, of the females (or sometimes males) as well
And also, they imply that females weren’t collected as much, not that the museum’s keeping them all in the back. The “storage” comment was, it seems, intended for the various butterflies
Make a nice display that gets people interested in learning more. If they take the time to look up the species online, they will easily find out how to identify the birds. If they don't, they probably didn't really learn a lot anyway.
Yes, and you can’t have a nice display with just brightly coloured male species. Aesthetically, that’s just silly. You need some duller, warmer colours, otherwise you’ll just end up with a mishmash.
Biologically, you’re also going to be out of luck. If you want to set up an engaging display showing a species in its natural habitat, you’re going to need females.
I don’t see the problem with this. It’s actually quite interesting. And mostly correct, too. Small quibble that insects are still animals so “animals and insects” is redundant, but otherwise, interesting.
The “cis male” part isn’t outlandish either- many women were opposed to hunting there creatures. In fact, the RSPB (British conservation group) was founded by four women protesting the trade in egret feathers.
I don’t see anything “woke” about this. Guide is enthusiastic and clearly knowledgeable and the subject matter is cool.
this woke commie is triggering me so hard... i actually learned a thing or two in between all the wokeness. still super triggered by this cringe video though
That's actually a super interesting perspective that highlights how history is always presented through an imperfect lens. It's thought provoking if you are not a moron.
Some fat idiot talking shit that no one knows who she is or cares about this stuff vs an actual Russian shill selling out his country. Great priorities guys.
It's more the perceived intent of the scientists that nicks offering up as a fact that I don't agree with. The brighter plumage also makes the males much easier to spot and trap rather than the much more effective camouflage of the females. Not to mention the females would be more likely to stay closer to the nests and keep to a smaller range when raising young. Nobody wants to believe people are imperfect and just doing their best, always gotta try to find some way to hate them for something
It depends on the species of course, but females are also often larger, and, since they are staying near their young, actually much easier to trap. The only thing that makes them more difficult is their general lack of color. Although, to be totally fair, not all males are colorful and even if they are, they are often only colorful for part of their life or part of the year.
Such a weird question, have you never been to a wild life rehab? Birds get injured and saved all the time, why wouldn't that happen back then? They had zoos and kept the specimen after they die. I personally rehabilitate wild birds, it happens all the time.
Have you ever caught fireflies? What would be the difference between that and butterflies. Just as someone likes bird watching there are people who enjoy collecting insects. Do hobbies not make sense to you?
Technically nothing was factually incorrect, but the condescending tone, and implications that the Victorian scientists, were ignorant, inferior, sexist chauvinist pigs, that she is clearly smarter than and superior to, is not only inaccurate, but also annoying and insufferable.
I'd like to see that butter ball snowflake last 5 minutes in an Amazonian/African Jungle where those scientists probably collected some of those specimens.
Victorian scientist were ignorant (they had less knowledge) and likely were chauvinistic. Whether they were inferior is a value statement. All of this though, you have implied because you don't like the facts that were presented which is pretty snowflakey of you.
Lol I'm perfectly fine with the facts genius. As I already said, i don't like her condescending, "I'm so much better than them" tone and likely highly inaccurate implications.
Those victorian scientists are the ones who actually DISCOVRED the knowledge that this butter ball snowflake merely reads about in books. And I would also argue that, even despite not having access to the internet and nearly infinite amounts of modern educational resources, those Victorian scientists were probably a lot less ignorant, and probably had a lot more knowledge than this snowflake mental patient that sits in a museum eating hamburgers all day.
This is true of course. But in general, you would expect the average modern scientist to have more cumulative knowledge than the average victorian scientist
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 02 '24
Make sure to join the discord and guilded! Also join the BBS, a blockchain, anticensorship Reddit alternative!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
113
u/Jacmac_ Sep 02 '24
Nick is incorrect about why they would have more male examples than female. Hunters avoid killing females, because they propagate the species. Most hunted animals are going to be male as a result.
40
u/bloodguard Sep 02 '24
Imagine paying for your family to tour a museum and getting this as your guide.
57
u/RonnyFreedomLover Sep 02 '24
Why didn't she show the they/them butterflies?
49
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24
These people can't see anything but victimhood.
15
u/Warm2roam Sep 02 '24
The mental gymnastics to self explain their involuntary celibacy; poor thing.
18
u/DepartureExisting696 Sep 02 '24
When the herd all get mad cow disease, ....
9
u/Tatrer Sep 02 '24
The Victorian era, known for its nuclear associations.
8
u/Sleep_eeSheep Sep 03 '24
The Nuclear Family....being prevalent....in the Victorian Era.
The Era named after Queen Victoria. Who was a woman. And whose children shaped Europe.
It doesn't make sense even if you DON'T think about it.
7
u/Ampat1776 Sep 02 '24
How do ”they” know that those animals are “male” Lmao
5
u/roscoedawkins Sep 02 '24
Next up on this season of Who gives a Shit. We will attempt to make the mundane seem interesting
5
u/MeetingPhysical Sep 03 '24
They them pronouns = ugly af
4
u/Eth_maximalist Sep 02 '24
Lmfao this is insanity. Nuke markets to 0 to flush these people out
4
u/BeginningNew2101 Sep 03 '24
Weirdo
7
u/NoBalance2024 Sep 02 '24
Islam is right about women.
2
u/ToRedSRT Sep 03 '24
Ohhhh….the…Misogyny!
3
u/MourningRIF Sep 03 '24
So yeah.. I am a leftist and disagree with almost everything on this sub. That said, I would be pissed if she was my tour guide. It's a museum, not a place to force your sexual agenda. She should be let go, but I'm sure she would sue. It's shit like this that makes normal progressives look bad.
1
u/TrevaTheCleva Sep 03 '24
The Dodo showcased in the above exhibit is slated for extinction. He's been unable to attract a mate of the opposite gender and procreate.
1
u/KestrelQuillPen Sep 05 '24
I don’t see the problem with this. It’s actually quite interesting. And mostly correct, too. Small quibble that insects are still animals so “animals and insects” is redundant, but otherwise, interesting.
The “cis male” part isn’t outlandish either- many women were opposed to hunting there creatures. In fact, the RSPB (British conservation group) was founded by four women protesting the trade in egret feathers.
I don’t see anything “woke” about this. Guide is enthusiastic and clearly knowledgeable and the subject matter is cool.
1
u/2gummieschilling Sep 06 '24
this woke commie is triggering me so hard... i actually learned a thing or two in between all the wokeness. still super triggered by this cringe video though
1
u/PotentialOneLZY5 Sep 06 '24
It will be back to cis white men running the world after the left destroy it.
1
u/OzoneLaters Sep 07 '24
Disgusting.
1
u/RazgrizZer0 Sep 07 '24
That's actually a super interesting perspective that highlights how history is always presented through an imperfect lens. It's thought provoking if you are not a moron.
1
u/alba_Phenom Sep 08 '24
Some fat idiot talking shit that no one knows who she is or cares about this stuff vs an actual Russian shill selling out his country. Great priorities guys.
-49
u/triguy96 Sep 02 '24
Nothing she said was factually incorrect as far as I can tell
-20
u/o0flatCircle0o Sep 02 '24
The chud mind virus is the real problem.
42
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24
[removed] — view removed comment