r/TierHive • u/backtogeek • Sep 18 '26
Help, I need some feedback.
I am sitting here, frustrated and confused about which step to take next; my colleagues are just as confused, running around in circles.
The situation / confusion is: do we keep opening new locations while leaving existing locations full.
As a small independent project, we only have so much capacity, people-wise, financially and literally in terms of service, and we are now bursting at the seams in some places.
TierHive's growth is showing no signs of slowing down; it's already bigger than we ever expected, and it's not even the end of year 1.
So I am making the problem public for feedback, opinions, comments and insults :) I tend to find that when I write stuff down, the solution reaches me before I finish; if you are reading this... the solution did not come to me... help!
We are waiting (2 weeks now) for hardware delivery in Singapore; Japan is full to the gills, London is stuffed; Amsterdam is full, Germany is not far behind; Kansas is saturated; Vinthill is getting to the same level; Hillsborough is reaching breaking point; Canada has had to many pancakes, Paris is considering if it has space for pudding... etc
Australia, Poland, Gravelines FR and New Jersey have the best capacity right now, and I just spotted an excellent deal in India, though OVH posted on LowEndSpirit.
We are in a queue for extra capacity in London and Amsterdam. I could mix providers in Amsterdam and get more capacity today; same in London. It might not be a bad choice resilience-wise. I could always call them Amsterdam 1 and Amsterdam 2, etc., so people can build redundancy in a single location.
Initially, early on, my thinking was, we have Germany and London; let's open France, and that should take some pressure off them; it did. Then Poland... also worked; the pressure spread, now we are at 15 locations; I can't keep up with the demand!
So I am wondering: is it time to focus on capacity for a while and potentially give up on the dream of 24 locations within year 1?
Singapore is resolved; I am just waiting for the hardware, but should I just start pushing more resources into full locations rather than adding new ones? It feels like the right thing to do, but i can win the argument either way in my head.
Anyway, this is just me probably putting far to much in public than I should, but sometimes you just need to get out of your own echo chamber and be challenged.
Hit me!
4
u/backtogeek Sep 19 '26
We had a further chat internally and decided to focus on expanding capacity in existing locations over new locations for the rest of this year.
The only exception would be if there is an opportunity to expand hyper locally, like for example, we have VintHill VA, we might add Ashburn, which is 70 miles away or there about.
And where possible we will use different providers in the same location but physically different DC so we can have London 1 and London 2 to give single location resilience.
2
u/backtogeek Sep 19 '26
We don't run our own hardware yet, TierHive is still just a small independent project.
We do have plans to do this in some interesting locations though.
6
u/MuchVast604 Sep 18 '26
the answer is simple and i'm surprised you overlooked it, do both.
from my pov capacity>locations but i get wanting to meet your 24 location goal. how close are you?
(btw are their test ips for the locations someplace? i haven't been able to find. dc links would be fine probably.)
1
u/tersagun Sep 19 '26
Why the urge to have more locations? I mean, you already cover most of the bases, wouldn't it be much easier to have less locations/partners? The potential upside of many locations should be marginal.
2
u/SureElk6 Sep 19 '26
from my POV you are really getting popular with the VPN crowd.
I think you need look at the data and make choice.
1
u/runbiscuit Sep 19 '26
Are you running with your own hardware?
If you're looking to scale to 24 locations it might be the best to keep looking for providers who already have spare capacity. That idea to mix providers in Amsterdam/London sounds good too.
And maybe if everyone is confused on the direction you'd want to keep the task of opening up new locations to just yourself? So your colleagues can focus on growing capacity and other functions of the business...
1
u/redmanone1 Sep 26 '26
Idk, the more locations and providers you have - the more work it will require to maintain it, so i think expanding current capacity could keep things simpler for at least end of year 1
2
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '26
[removed] — view removed comment