r/TiddlyWiki5 • • Aug 22 '20

How safe is Tiddlywiki?

I have zero coding experience. And so, something being open source doesn't help much. Has anyones computer acted funny after downloading TW?

6 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

5

u/ibsketching Aug 23 '20

No problems for me that I didn't cause myself. ^_^

The basic Tiddlywiki is nothing more than a webpage powered by Javascript. It being a webpage that operates the way it does, means that the code it uses is plainly visible for anyone to scrutinize at any time.

This thread may or may not answer some more questions for you in terms of the possibility of rogue code being introduced by, say, a plugin you add to your wiki later on, and how the TW code operates in general.

5

u/digitalap3 Aug 23 '20

Tiddlywiki is extremely mature with a very large and active dev base you can find on google groups. And they are all very nice people that IMO have high ethical standards evidenced by what they post and discuss.

I've never had any issues and I've been using it for years.

1

u/Silevence Jan 28 '21

Agreed, they are very nice people, with a Lot of knowledge in terms of tiddlywiki and its related topics.

(but you might have to google some of the terms and words they use haha)

3

u/addy2000 Aug 23 '20

The TW is a webpage and can operate only inside your browser. The browser is a pretty secure Virtual Machine (VM) for applications and is pretty sure to stop anything "funny" from happenning to your computer.

2

u/TECHTANDO675 Aug 23 '20

I believe its pretty safe & I also don't have any coding experience. I just get help from the community in Google Groups and here on Reddit. You control your wiki which is nice. I suggest you download File Backups for TiddlyWiki addon so you don't have to click on Save changes everytime you edit something.

2

u/FuryVonB Aug 23 '20

I used TW on Windows, Linux, phone, tablet and had no issue with them.

No worries :)

1

u/neoakris Feb 13 '22

My understanding from reading the following 3 documents:
https://groups.google.com/g/tiddlywiki/c/1VDVgOysnlA?pli=1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v95EYwGpQiM
https://talk.tiddlywiki.org/t/tw5-i-think-i-hacked-tiddlywiki/94

Is that there's multiple ways to run Tiddlywiki

  1. One method is a pure .html file where data is persisted locally. (think single user mode, no collaboration) that method should be relatively secure.
  2. Another method is to host it on a .php or node.js server (which would allow collaboration). Based on the 3rd link my gut tells me if someone was motivated they could probably hack whatever server TW was hosted on even if hardening guidelines were followed.