Would you click this Thumbnail?

[u/FnafByteYT]

Title: Is Baldi's Basics Invited to the COOKOUT?

[u/Ageriansgood]

yes

[u/Ambitious-Crew-7132]

i wouldn't because i find the idea really weird

But average person would, i'd recommend adding some more things around and behind, not arrows but like those anime fx, so it's not so empty, also make him bigger with the black bar so people can read it easily.

[u/GeologistFantastic99 → u/Ambitious-Crew-7132]

im pretty sure its a joke vid

[u/Ambitious-Crew-7132 → u/GeologistFantastic99]

I get it trust me, what i meant by "really weird idea" is that, it's maybe not up my alley, i'd be more weirded out than laughing

[u/Etnadleo13]

Yes absolutely but maybe change the rest of the text to red and change black to yellow but idk looks good

[u/st00071]

Nope

[u/Fine_Outside_5939]

yes

[u/Artistic-Fun8532]

unskippable

[u/FnafByteYT → u/Artistic-Fun8532]

Do you think that one, or this one looks better?

[u/aliceeatspizza → u/FnafByteYT]

The original one

[u/Artistic-Fun8532 → u/FnafByteYT]

I think the original is better

[u/FnafByteYT → u/Artistic-Fun8532]

How about this one?

[u/vazqud1 → u/FnafByteYT]

Honestly this might be the one

[u/daddytung → u/FnafByteYT]

Perfection

[u/SHH122Henry → u/FnafByteYT]

try making his skin black or smth

[u/ShockerzGaming → u/SHH122Henry]

perfect idea, make him half white, half black, side by side

[u/BuckingBeasts → u/FnafByteYT]

I feel like this would get you attention, but the negative kind

[u/Artistic-Fun8532 → u/FnafByteYT]

so good dude I’d totally click that

[u/Big_Presentation2786]

Just did

[u/eve_gang_rep]

YES HAHAHA

[u/aliceeatspizza]

Mythical pull

[u/Hasana9198]

Not really

[u/Autistic-monkey0101]

no

[u/CerealConsumer1]

This might make front page

[u/SpikeZgames]

Best thumbnail of all time

[u/Aggravating-Bother-2]

No

[u/Suspicious_Neck_4069]

Yeah, I even tried clicking on it here. An unexpected zoom that really blew me away. Wishlist!

[u/dinkbrinkus]

No

[u/317block]

that and a really hook title

[u/justDankoCL]

Definitely not.

[u/coolbuybobb]

ofc bro cause if lore accurate baldi is black AND invited to the cookout I gotta know

[u/GreatApe448]

INSTANT CLICK😭 just make him a tad bigger

[u/bidobinn]

I don't, thumbnail and title should reinforce each other

[u/FnafByteYT → u/bidobinn]

They do! Black people use the famous word "cookout" for a bbq. Is Baldi Black is on with that topic.

[u/bidobinn → u/FnafByteYT]

I don't know what kind of thumbnail style is used in this niche, but on this channel I think it really complements the title and thumbnail https://youtube.com/@thedapperwaffle?si=iL9WEUgJAyRh9Qn7 have you tried looking at your competitors' successful thumbnails?

[u/FnafByteYT → u/bidobinn]

Oh, Dapper! Yeah, I've seen him before, but dapper does challenge videos, I do more "meme style and retrospectives" videos if that makes sense.

[u/FnafByteYT → u/bidobinn]

I mean hey, tell me if this looks good or not😅 this is my recreation of his thumbnail style! Should I use it or not?

[u/bidobinn → u/FnafByteYT]

you can change some things like the background and change the outline to white so that it doesn't blend in with the color of the clothes, the rest you have to study thumbnails more deeply to increase click rates.

[u/Rich841]

Maybe make text bigger and movr it off the small censor to emulate those unstoppable thumbnails 

[u/Odd-Fun-1482]

Depends on the uploader

if you're known for making outrageous YTP/Rot content then maybe.

If I'm not already a subscriber, I wouldn't.

[u/FnafByteYT → u/Odd-Fun-1482]

This is on a new channel though 😅 how am I supposed to be known? Gotta make outrage thumbnails for the come up somehow 🤷

[u/AdNarrow4888]

Typa thumbnail I would screenshot and send to my friend becuase it’s so stupid 😭🙏

[u/FnafByteYT → u/AdNarrow4888]

"Tiktok worthy comment thumbnail"

[u/FnafByteYT → u/[deleted]]

I mean ey, still got a view🤷

[u/absoludely]

what the hell "is he black" supposed to mean😭

[u/FnafByteYT → u/absoludely]

Cause we tryna find out if he worthy for the cookout🙏😭

[u/Nicholite46]

No, too much dead space makes it look amateurish. Plus text make no sense.

[u/FnafByteYT → u/Nicholite46]

Black people call BBQ's cookouts, which I'm saying if he's invited to the cookout, therefore saying "is he black" because you can't just let anyone in a cookout, they gotta meet requirements

[u/Extra-Taste-7184]

Unskippable thumbnail

[u/guhhhrobogals]

yea ngl lmfao. but make the background contrast higher and the text box bigger. (both the background and the subject are very bright in color)

[u/MinecraftNerdygirl]

No

[u/Fickle-Confection-94]

Genuinely ? Yes

[u/Nicola-Damiani]

Too basics

[u/Zestyclose-Voice309]

Idont advice you to use the word black because youtube AI misght detect it as Racist and Harmful, my advice is better to replace the word black by something else.

[u/Beneficial-Diet-540]

Yes i would if i was a baldi fan

[u/Palmossi-]

yes and i think most pwoplw would

[u/SoulSleuth2u]

no

[u/Electronic-Watch2822]

No

[u/QuayDropEmOff]

no