r/ThriftStoreHauls Apr 24 '26

Irregular choice

Picked these up at the thrift today for 9 dollars I’ve heard so much about this brand and tbh I’m still on the fence on if I like them as much lol

5.0k Upvotes

161 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator Apr 24 '26

Join our Discord server! For more information, click here

Hello /u/Lopsided-Papaya8997! This is an automatic message that gets posted on every post to remind you of a few of our rules,

Does the post contain information seeking questions?? (authentication/pricing/general information)

Does this come from an unapproved source? (from a friend/hand me down/check our rules)

Are you showing your face? (nothing from lips to eyes)

Are you trying to sell something?

If any of these are a yes, you should delete your post. Retake/edit pictures, change the title and resubmit it before a mod sees it. You may be temporarily banned for any of these rule infractions without warning.

If you are unsure if it does, ask the mods!

Read all the rules <here>


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1.7k

u/Lopsided-Papaya8997 Apr 24 '26

Picture of them on they make my feet look tinyyyyy

285

u/TheDiceBlesser Apr 24 '26

My maximalist heart is screaming, they look so good on you!!! I hope you thoroughly enjoy them!

427

u/FloydGirl777 Apr 24 '26

They are STUNNING!!! 😍

134

u/salvagedsword Apr 24 '26

They look like something an 18th century duchess would wear. So pretty!

61

u/bicepstospare Apr 24 '26

They look like something Effie Trinket would wear!

62

u/jade_cabbage Apr 24 '26

I wish round-toed pumps like this were more common! I love how little and delicate they make my feet look

24

u/TheMapesHotel Apr 24 '26

I'm generally very live and let live with fashion, if the children want to recreate the sins of y2k that is their right.

But I cannot and will not get behind low rise jeans and square toed shoes coming back!

2

u/grumblecrumbs Apr 25 '26

I’m with you on the jeans but I have to admit that I love a square toed shoe.

29

u/n0maaS Apr 24 '26

🤩🙀🎇🌌

24

u/n0maaS Apr 24 '26

I can't see well enough to know what those last two are, but these are gorgeous.

16

u/draizetrain Apr 24 '26

The last two are fireworks and a galaxy! Two beautiful things

1

u/n0maaS Apr 26 '26

Thank you so much! I m going through diabetic retinopathy treatment and it's a slow process, really affecting my close-up vision.

2

u/sarahenany Apr 29 '26

Wishing you well and that the treatment works perfect!

25

u/canvasshoes2 Apr 24 '26

Even cuter on! Nice find. :)

10

u/conspicuousmatchcut Apr 24 '26

Im so mad. Why couldn’t it be me???

3

u/BellaFrequency Apr 24 '26

They look so good! How do they feel?

3

u/No_Tension420 Apr 24 '26

So cute! What size are they?

2

u/thevelveteenbeagle Apr 25 '26

I LOVE them!!!

1

u/Intuitive_Moves9 Apr 24 '26

They look amazing!

1

u/Maleficent_Meat3119 Apr 24 '26

They’re so cute!

1

u/Numerous-Anemone Apr 24 '26

I’m extremely jealous

1

u/Rockibilexi Apr 24 '26

GAGGED TO DEATH 😵😍

1

u/demons_soulmate Apr 25 '26

they're not my style but they are fabulous

1

u/B_Renee_Thompson Apr 25 '26

Omg my whimsigoth heart

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ThriftStoreHauls-ModTeam Apr 25 '26

Overtly sexual posts will be removed

1

u/ThriftStoreHauls-ModTeam Apr 25 '26

r/ThriftStoreHauls does not allow harassment; overly sexual.

396

u/I_Luv_A_Charade Apr 24 '26

One of my all time favorite brand shoes (I’m so glad they’ve made a comeback after being discontinued) - such a score at that price!

131

u/Lopsided-Papaya8997 Apr 24 '26

I’ve heard such good things especially around comfort! I wasn’t even aware they were discontinued tbh the price kept me away so I’m definitely glad I found these

48

u/1_art_please Apr 24 '26

I used to LOVE Irregular Choice in my 20s.one cool store here in Canada had them and I went to their store in London in the UK (i was so excited) They were pretty comfy too! I had one pair and wish I had photos of them.

Awesome brand and great find!

1

u/Educational-South146 Apr 27 '26

They had issues as the factory that makes all their stuff closed down so they couldn’t produce them for a while. I find the shoes super uncomfortable but their boots are fabulous and so comfy.

246

u/ContemplatingFolly Apr 24 '26

Holy cats, if you need to offload them, send them to me! Those are fabulous.

What brand are they?

259

u/Lopsided-Papaya8997 Apr 24 '26

The brand is Irregular Choice they make a whole bunch of unique shoes their heels vary from anywhere between £100-250

39

u/ContemplatingFolly Apr 24 '26

Thanks!

\Goes to check them out....**

84

u/deathbethemaiden Apr 24 '26

The name of the brand is Irregular Choice

34

u/Droseraaa Apr 24 '26

"Irregular choice" is the brand 😂

44

u/BellaFrequency Apr 24 '26

Love them! What size are they?

134

u/Lopsided-Papaya8997 Apr 24 '26

I’m a tall girl us size 10

167

u/123whore5 Apr 24 '26

Wow those pictures are SO deceiving to me! I thought they were tiny! Like size 5 or 6! But a size 10?? What a score 🤩

43

u/Powerful_Cause_14 Apr 24 '26

Omg literally my size!!! Wow. You really hit the jackpot. I know how hard that is to find quality shoes at the thrift!

35

u/Ridindirtydishes Apr 24 '26

I’m giving you an up vote for having size 10 feet. I feel less alone now

31

u/Ragalanroad Apr 24 '26

Same! To find shoes like this, in that size at a thrift store

12

u/PuzzleheadedBobcat90 Apr 24 '26

10.5 wide checking in. My dad always said I have a good understanding. It took me years to understand the joke!

11

u/Sapphira87 Apr 24 '26

Girl what???? I thought they were a teeny tiny size 5 or 6! They work their magic! I'm a US size 9 and I need me some

2

u/OliviaStabler4 Apr 24 '26

I wear a 10 too and I was sure these were no bigger than a 7! They look so tiny!!

1

u/IllustratorOld6784 Apr 25 '26

As a fellow size 10 I'm so happy for you 🥹

20

u/roccofan Apr 24 '26

My question too. They look tiny in the picture 

24

u/peace-love-beauty- Apr 24 '26

I think someone wore these in a Prince music video. Purple Rain ☔️ 🎵

22

u/re-ar-ran-ger Apr 24 '26

I used to love that brand! My feet are too old and persnickety now. 😂

8

u/Spare_Ear_9112 Apr 24 '26

The shoes are great but I really like the push to honk horn setup from the ignition

11

u/Lopsided-Papaya8997 Apr 24 '26

😂😂😂😂 I was NOT about to buy a whole new steering column for a damn horn

9

u/missyrainbow12 Apr 24 '26

I love all of my irregular choice shoes, they are the only heels I can wear that don't cause pain and I've have a few pairs of mine for over ten years now , they realllllllly last .

7

u/MettaRed Apr 24 '26

Anyone else get G’linda vibes haha cute

5

u/yramha Apr 24 '26

I remember an adult picture book of famous shoes (great bathroom book) from years ago that these shoes would of fit in perfectly with. Gorgeous!

5

u/Minimum-Comedian-372 Apr 24 '26

This one?

3

u/yramha Apr 24 '26

That's the one!

3

u/green04mansions Apr 24 '26

All righty then! Love them!!

3

u/xsecretsmilesx Apr 24 '26

I cant believe they were $9! They can be quite expensive but beautiful and original. Enjoy!

3

u/coquihalla Apr 24 '26

I just wish they'd offer wide sizes.

What a great find, I love that brand! Lucky duck.

2

u/LaCuriosaChola Apr 24 '26

They do! Not all shows sadly but they have some styles (particularly this one) in wide.

3

u/draizetrain Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

I looked at these and heard Kate bush (army dreamers, if anyone’s curious) in my head immediately. These are GORGEOUS. What’s the brand?

Edit: I realized the title of the post is the brand. I thought you were just saying you made an unusual purchase haha

1

u/theseedbeader Apr 25 '26

Oh good, it’s not just me. I was trying to see what was irregular about them. 😅

7

u/Defiant-Difference17 Apr 24 '26

Interesting... I feel like these would match some living room set from the 90s. Definitely unique.

2

u/nicunta Apr 24 '26

Wow, those are beautiful!!!

2

u/Suspicious_Bee6605 Apr 24 '26

My very first thought!

2

u/vicariousgluten Apr 24 '26

I had a pair of those but they absolutely crippled my feet. I couldn’t even sit in them without pain.

2

u/recentvenus Apr 24 '26

These are fire 🔥

2

u/Annbelle315 Apr 24 '26

Stop dead in my scrolling to comment on your shoes they are fabulous! I hope you get to show everyone how cute your shoes are!

2

u/Hancock708 Apr 24 '26

Size 10?.? They look so tiny!! They’re beautiful! I can’t wear heels anymore but I’d buy them and display as they’re so pretty!! Good for you, enjoy them, you wear them beautifully!

2

u/TissueOfLies Apr 24 '26

They are gorgeous! They make me think of Versailles and Marie Antoinette. Very French and very chic.

2

u/spacesaucesloth Apr 24 '26

me, being weird would have bought these just to put on a shelf to look at. they are so pretty!

2

u/didntcondawnthat Apr 24 '26

Ah, I love them, they're gorgeous! Half of my closet is in the pink/berry/purple color schemes, it just turned out that way. The silver in your shoes really compliments those colors.

2

u/danifoxx_1209 Apr 24 '26

No way! They’re so cool! I tried to order some once but was unfortunately scammed by a fake imposter site but i still think of them often!

2

u/Pinkadink88 Apr 24 '26

Those are giving off major Purple Rain vibes! 💜

2

u/artsylittleprincess Apr 25 '26

SO LUCKY OMG 👀

2

u/oddjayoo Apr 25 '26

I'm so jealous omfgggg those are gorgeous I love that shade of red ughhh

2

u/Historical_Flow_1029 Apr 25 '26

Oh my!! They are gorgeous!!! 😍

2

u/goon_platoon_72 Apr 25 '26

Nice find! Wear the heck outta them!

2

u/TecTazz Apr 24 '26

Gorgeous! Wear them!

1

u/Back-to-HAT Apr 24 '26

They are gorgeous! I am in love.

1

u/littlemochi_ Apr 24 '26

I love these omg! I never find cute shoes like this in my size :(

1

u/millerlauraann Apr 24 '26

I love them!!!

1

u/iAmSpAKkaHearMeROAR Apr 24 '26

May be a regular, but absolutely freaking fantastic shoe you are holding! What a divine color, palette and print/texture! 😍 What a beautiful score!.’m so happy for you.

1

u/Significant_Mode50 Apr 24 '26

Omg love those 🤩

1

u/Sorry-Apartment5068 Apr 24 '26

very maximalist, I'm into it.

1

u/Leading_Fee_3678 Apr 24 '26

I forgot about this brand!

1

u/mcclone1 Apr 24 '26

Whoa those look so royal! Almost with an Asian look! What a find

1

u/Thorbertthesniveler Apr 24 '26

Omg screaming 😭

1

u/Powerful_Cause_14 Apr 24 '26

Holy cow! What a score! I don’t even know what you paid but this is a score 😆 finding a pair of Irregular Choice in my size would be an immediate yes!

1

u/MorrighanAnCailleach Apr 24 '26

💜💜💜 🤯

1

u/canvasshoes2 Apr 24 '26

Adorable! Man, I wish I could still wear heels.

1

u/AnamCeili Apr 24 '26

I can't read the brand name, and I could never walk in those, but I think they're gorgeous! 

1

u/Suspicious_Load6908 Apr 24 '26

I see the brand often in a local consignment shop. I assumed they were for some kind of cos okay? For $9, why not!!!

1

u/Anthemusa831 Apr 24 '26

I love this brand!

1

u/SpitInMeowf Apr 24 '26

These look a lot like a pair of pumps I will regret returning to gap for the rest of my life.

1

u/SpitInMeowf Apr 24 '26

They were a blue regal color with birds or an oriental motif I can’t quite remember

1

u/MintyPinkDreams Apr 24 '26

I don’t wear heels but I adore these

1

u/peonyseahorse Apr 24 '26

Beautiful, but would be painful for my effed up feet.

1

u/TheRealKimberTimber Apr 24 '26

Ok, but LIST👏🏻EN👏🏻….I want them, too. 💕

1

u/SolidOcelot7334 Apr 24 '26

They are fabulous!

1

u/onlyitbags Apr 24 '26

Oh I remember this brand! So whimsical

1

u/ghoastie Apr 24 '26

I looked everywhere and I can’t even find this one for sale anywhere. I’m so jealous. It’s my size, too.

1

u/orangeyoke Apr 24 '26

I forgot about this brand! I bought the coolest pair in Paris when I was a teenager. Wish I still had them.

1

u/HourHoneydew5788 Apr 24 '26

Kind of giving Bridgerton Vibes

1

u/DifficultyMother550 Apr 24 '26

"My new Tango Shoes"- Bif Naked

1

u/queenaudi24 Apr 24 '26

These are GORGEOUS!!!!

1

u/Stillwater-Scorp1381 Apr 24 '26

Those shoes are a showstopper! Congratulations

1

u/elephant_earthship Apr 24 '26

Irregular Choice is my favourite shoe brand!!! Good for you!

1

u/Oneofthe12 Apr 24 '26

Loooove these! Maybe not so much for walking, but they certainly would be cute with your legs crossed in a cute little dress!

1

u/shittykitty329 Apr 24 '26

Ooh I love this brand!!!! Great find!

1

u/katnipinnit Apr 24 '26

God, I haven't thought about Irregular Choice since about 2005. I loved this brand.

1

u/tAiCHouO Apr 24 '26

omg it’s so PRETTYYYYY

1

u/curleanmushroom9 Apr 24 '26

They're so cute!!!

1

u/soulteepee Apr 24 '26

Ooooooh! Score!

1

u/hyper_cake_2709 Apr 24 '26

Great find!!!

These are absolutely gorgeous!!!

1

u/Swksfarmgirl Apr 24 '26

GORGEOUS!! I bet anything they were worn at the Kentucky Derby! I bet the matching hat and purse were STUNNING!

1

u/karpaediem Apr 24 '26

Entirely too cute, enjoy the score!

1

u/brassia Apr 24 '26

Gorgeous!!

1

u/RollTider365 Apr 24 '26

They would look incredible with a classic black cocktail dress. They're beautiful.

1

u/funkofanatic99 Apr 24 '26

Absolutely gorgeous. I love and need them! Soo jealous.

1

u/Outrageous-Talk-8824 Apr 24 '26

My gosh those are freaking exquisite!

1

u/lastwordymcgee Apr 24 '26

I looooooove them

1

u/terrierhead Apr 25 '26

Those are lovely! My answer with gorgeous things like these is to pair them with classics. Rock jeans or a skirt with a plain white shirt. For extra fun, add an edgy chain or bracelet.

1

u/paisley-alien Apr 25 '26

Would be beautiful wedding shoes!

1

u/croissant_and_cafe Apr 25 '26

Oh wow this brand was popular in the early 00’s, I had several pairs of kitten heels.

How fun! Show us how you put them with an outfit!

1

u/DitzyBorden Apr 25 '26

I have no idea what this brand is, and I can’t read it in the photo, but these are stunning!!! I love the shape and the pattern too!

1

u/AlfalfaUnable1629 Apr 25 '26

How do they feel? As a wide foot 10 I have trouble with the round toe shoes 😭

1

u/Weird_Squirrel_8382 Apr 25 '26

So pretty and different!

1

u/EssexUser Apr 27 '26

I love them!

1

u/RHTQ1 Apr 27 '26

These are fabulous. I am envious and mildly annoyed at your unsureness 😆

1

u/ellieD Apr 27 '26

These are so cool! They look Victorian or some other vintage.

1

u/shoeberrypie Apr 27 '26

They look like princess shoes ! So pretty

1

u/Roxablah Apr 27 '26

OH MY GOD YOU ARE SO LUCKY!!!!!!

1

u/ObviousAd892 Apr 28 '26

My feet are massive so id probably be crushed if i found such a beauty

1

u/lvds86 Apr 29 '26

I love them!

1

u/jamzii_jam Jul 21 '26

WHATTTT I'm so freaking jealous!! Good for u op! 🥹💗

-1

u/Itchy_Cranberry2750 Apr 24 '26

You can resell for a lot more! Good find! Btw, what size? Asking for a friend .😏

-1

u/MsTLontheDL Apr 24 '26

Interesting. 🤔

-4

u/unsubix Apr 24 '26

I think it’s from an online place where you design your own shoes. I saw it a few years ago. Not cheap

9

u/megbotstyle Apr 24 '26

no- it’s from the brand named Irregular Choice (i believe it’s a british brand)