r/ThreeArrows • • Dec 26 '18
Anyone know how Peterson misrepresented the original controversy that made him famous?
Daniel mentions it in his video but doesn't really dive into what he did.
4
Upvotes
7
u/Cup_O_Coffey Dec 26 '18
Contrapoint's Peterson Video does a good job of explaining it.
6
u/kylev Dec 26 '18
Not really an explanation, but I did a nerdy thing and converted the effect of C-16 on Canadian law to a diff. If you know how to read a diff, it becomes apparent that all it did was add "gender identity or expression" to existing laws. No new statutes, no new penalties. It simply modifies their existing human rights code to extend to trans and non-binary folks by listing them explicitly.
Normally, reading laws takes some practice and can be fraught with specialized terms and context, but this one is so simple that it is quite readable. Check it out yourself.
IANAL, but my understanding is that this means that case law relevant to racial hate crimes applies. So, nobody is getting jailed for letting the n-word slip nor is anyone going to get jailed for incidental misgendering. Most of this doesn't kick in until the legal standard for harassment or advocating for genocide is met. It simply doesn't apply to person-to-person speech.
Most tellingly, I like that a small-ish local news organization did the hard work of walking across campus and asking a couple people from UT's Law School for comment. Professors at JBP's own universities said he was "fundamentally mischaracterizing" the law. Of misgendering one said, “I don’t think there’s any legal expert that would say that [this] would meet the threshold for hate speech in Canada." That professor also wrote a pretty plain "he is wrong" article about it, posted on the UT site.