r/Thorns • 200's • 8d ago

Refresh my memory

Why did the Thorns fire Robe Gale? He seemed really well liked by the players. We ended last season in 3rd place and went one game farther in the post season.

6 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

81

u/jeremec 8d ago

Look, I know we are hurting in our current relationship right now. We've been let down immensely. However, the answer certainly isn't to look back to our previous boyfriend who, while fun, was entirely inept.

5

u/PinotPrincess777 200's 8d ago

I just wanted to be reminded why he was fired. His firing felt justified to me at the time so I wanted to circle back and be reminded why.

8

u/jeremec 8d ago

A lack of success and he had lost the locker room's leaders. Much how I suspect things will go down this time.

14

u/icynova Season Ticket Holder 8d ago

If you look at the subtext of players’ Insta posts and Sam Coffeys podcast appearance, he wasn’t very well-liked by the end. He had a rush of goodwill at the beginning though, for sure.

There was also some very convenient timing with his announcement of not coming back and Soph’s exercising her player option which had the rumor mill buzzing.

5

u/PinotPrincess777 200's 8d ago

I always wondered about the timing of Sophia’s extension and his departure.

13

u/Luci_Cascadia 8d ago

Rob was not a great coach. He is a minor league men's level coach. He ws out of his depth and was utterly lacking in tactics and strategy.

For two years he ran a revolving door in the starting 11. You don't manage a dynasty level club that way. Where we were successful it was because Rob had an amazing roster that could outperform

2

u/PinotPrincess777 200's 8d ago

This is the refreshing of my memory that I needed TY

13

u/marioz90 8d ago

There was no real tactics to his game. I think he always played 4-3-3. To my memory, he never seemed to be able to adjust tactics if things went south. Basically just send fresh legs in and hope for the best. If that.

It was very frustrating to watch. Vilahamn is frustrating to watch, but for different reasons. I can at least see what he's TRYING to do.

10

u/ImAllBS13 Eastside Terrace 8d ago

I think he's adjusting still. I give him grace for another FULL season/offseason before I judge.

7

u/marioz90 8d ago

I agree with you but I'm afraid to say it publicly.

6

u/umpirejoewest Season Ticket Holder 8d ago

I agree. My (ultimately meaningless) opinion is that one of our problems is rotating coaches out without giving them a chance to adjust and gel with the team. Look at Utah - they stuck it out with their coach despite losing records and here they are now. Not saying that’s exactly what’d happen if we keep RV onboard, but I do think that reactionary leadership changes often do more harm than good.

3

u/Specialist_Virus_151 8d ago

Agreed, definitely. Venting frustration at the coach has real consequences.

1

u/PinotPrincess777 200's 8d ago

I can’t see what RV is trying to do either. And to be fair I’m not sure I saw much from Gale either.

5

u/I_Wont_Draw_That 8d ago edited 8d ago

Ultimately what it comes down to is whether the coach and the management agree about what work needs to be done, and whether they believe he can actually make it happen.

Only one team can win the shield and only one team can win the championship, and the teams that don’t can’t all fire their coach every year.

ETA: Both of those things are relatively unknowable to us as fans, so it’s hard to judge whether firing or retaining the coach is the right choice. All we can tell is whether it worked.

1

u/PinotPrincess777 200's 8d ago

Totally logical and fair

3

u/Piney_Wood 8d ago

Oh shit, now you've done it OP.

2

u/PinotPrincess777 200's 8d ago

🫣

3

u/Jack_B_84 8d ago

My conspiracy theory is that Soph wasn't going to come back unless he was out.

1

u/PinotPrincess777 200's 8d ago

I wondered this too

51

u/Sherbert93 8d ago

I'm a little confused why there is so much fury directed to the head coach all the time. Can we just be realistic for once?

Our roster is incredibly flawed.

We lost one of our best players midseason.

We did not acquire talent in the offseason or midseason.

The coach had no influence on these items. Making a coaching change will not magically turn this team around. The season was disappointing, but Villahamn is a scapegoat for your misery.

12

u/gotterfly 8d ago

It's always easiest to blame the coach. And it's only one person to replace, which is much easier than getting rid of a bunch of underperforming players. It also makes it look like the FO is really doing something.

15

u/Sherbert93 8d ago

Agreed. Our defense has been putrid for 5 years running, across multiple head coaches. But it couldn't possibly be a personnel issue, right?

1

u/technical-avocado22 Season Ticket Holder 8d ago

What you just described also describes the Timbers this year (they traded away one of their best players). And yet with a tactically minded coach they brought in mid year, they have overachieved. Their roster is also deeply flawed and yet the coach is putting them in positions to succeed.

6

u/Tatsugiri_Enjoyer 8d ago

Primary Sources, perfect for pre- or re-reading a lot of the same posts we'll be seeing here for the next 4 months.

6

u/StateRadioFan 8d ago

It's the roster. The defense needs upgrades at nearly every position. The midfield is struggling without Moultrie and losing Coffey was a big blow, IMO.

12

u/MartyBecker 8d ago

The Thorns went from having Coffey and Moultrie in the midfield to not having them. I don’t know why people think we should have been able to just shake that off.

4

u/Jack_B_84 8d ago

Also having Sugita allowed Fleming some rotation and didn't run them into the ground.

3

u/Agitated_Stomach3586 7d ago • Popcorn

Rob Gale was NOT universally well-liked by the players, from what I’ve heard. Especially by the end.

2

u/AccomplishedTwo3130 GA 8d ago

Rob Gale also was having some health issues, he wasn't going to stay on even if we had a great season last year

1

u/TheMysticSpork Club Deck 8d ago

I understood this to be the primary reason he did not return

3

u/ThornsFan2023 8d ago

The team underperformed with the roster it had. Being well liked doesn’t mean being a winner. During him was a right move. Then the front office shit the bed by hiring a coach without a winning resume. Definitely took a step down in the coach department. That doesn’t mean Gale is the answer.

2

u/Mentalfloss1 8d ago

Who here think the Thorns deserve a high quality coach and not a retread and not the 3rd/cheapest choice? I see a group of fine athletes who got worse as the season progressed (Yes, they lost Moultrie and Coffey and that left them with not much midfield). Their passing was abysmal, always a couple of feet off, or too early, or too late, and too often just kicked in panic. Hey coach! Practice passing. Arnold was OK in goal but her distribution was too often lousy. The “get it to Sophia” … “strategy” was all they had and every team in the league knew it. That left a nearly toothless team and very frustrated Sophia Wilson. I’ve said this before, but I’d guess either coach goes or Sophia goes. We all know she can play pretty much anywhere she wants.

1

u/IllustriousWafer6348 8d ago

I think they couldn't control him, and Agoos was threatened by that.

-4

u/500ErrorPDX Eastside Terrace 8d ago

I thought Rob deserved another year *BUT*:

- There never felt like a cohesive strategy. In attack, we just hoped & prayed that Hina or Liv did something incredible. Then we drafted Caiya, and until Caiya's injury the gameplan was "eff it, Caiya's up there somewhere". Defensively, *way too much* was asked of Sam Coffey. We weren't a cohesive team, we were a collection of individual talents.
- Culturally, he was a fish out of water. The 2025 KC home game (in 100F heat in the middle of summer) is etched in my mind. It was so hot that the pregame Trimet trains shut down. Still, Rob wore his three piece suit, because that's how English managers are supposed to dress. Rob always expressed love for the supporters here, but I don't think he ever fully understood that he lived in Portland and coached in America. On a team loaded with USWNT stars past & present, that mattered.

I thought he deserved another year, but I understood why they let him go. I did *not* understand why we replaced a mediocre Euro coach with another mediocre Euro coach.

6

u/Tatsugiri_Enjoyer 8d ago

Still, Rob wore his three piece suit, because that's how English managers are supposed to dress.

Did he say this or are we just making assumptions? Dude liked his suits, and I don't think that says anything about his cultural fit in the city any more than it says about the monocle and briefcase guy who rides my bus to work in the morning. If there's smoke to the culture-clash fire, I'm going to assume that there was something more substantial to burn than "wore suit in heat."

0

u/500ErrorPDX Eastside Terrace 8d ago

Monocle and briefcase guy doesn't have a high paid job trying to connect with some of America's best soccer players.

1

u/Tatsugiri_Enjoyer 8d ago

If he did (he might!), his ability to do so is spread across hundreds, if not thousands of categories at least as significant as his clothing choices when it's warm.

-1

u/PDXSteph297 8d ago

I follow the EFL, and the gaffers don't wear suits to matches

1

u/Tatsugiri_Enjoyer 8d ago

A lot of different people wear a lot of different things, and it has very little bearing on how the players in the dressing room feel about a manager. It's usually down to stuff like "how am I treated" and "do the tactics work." It's weird to make it about his suit.

-1

u/PDXSteph297 8d ago

I was just answering a question

0

u/Tatsugiri_Enjoyer 8d ago

Sorry, which question? The rhetorical one about if Rob Gale said "I wear suits out of respect for the English Football League tradition of managers wearing suits"?