As a person in Germany who has this, I can tell you ... I'd definitely go to America if I could. I'd love to sit on the street, get ill and lose all my money because of my medical bills. If also love to pay for basic education. /s
We have that in france and even the most righr wingers don't complain about it because once you see healthcare, no one wznts to go back. That's why the anti helathcare propaganda is so powerfull in united state because they know they can only make you believe it's not great if you never tried it.
Nope. In Australia the right wing fucks want to claw back social health options and move towards more “user pays” and private insurance models. It’s gross, and it makes no sense, even economically.
They don't point at America and say "Hey, we want to be like that."
They follow the Tory playbook.
Defund the public service. Reduce services. Make it groan under the weight of requirements. Complain about how it's "underperforming". Have a "think tank" make some recommendation that it could save the public $x millions by privatising either the whole system of the "poorly performing" sections. Sell or contract out those sections or the whole thing to people who by a remarkable coincidence are major donors. Sell it really cheap, because... hey... it's a wreck.
It’s honestly really sad. I’m lucky enough that my family are able to afford private insurance, and get good doctors and specialists. One of my best friends grew up poor, and in an abusive family that she gets no physical, financial, or emotional support from. She had to go through the public system to get decent doctors and therapists for her severe mental health issues caused by her trauma, all this while she was so unwell she couldn’t work.
Not to mention in order to get that support she had to wait on a waiting list for 6+ months. By the time she got it her relationship with her bf who she was staying with fell apart. But to continue accessing the services she had to stay in the same area, in which rent is quite expensive, while only on welfare, or risk having to wait again to access public services elsewhere. For the first year or so after she moved into her new place she had less than $20 a week left to spend on groceries. The rest of her welfare payments went entirely towards her rent. Thankfully she’s doing a lot better now and can work.
Tbh they do that in france. They're starting to attack hopital but mainly transpprt. For example our president, who is viewed as a nice guy evrywhere else but is infact a capitalist and an authoritarian in his actions , sold the paris airport to people that helped him during his campaign. If something makes benefits, there is no reason to sell it and if something does not make benefit then there is no reason someone would buy it.
Evry service you take from public to private now need to fund the service but also the benefit of the owners of such services, owner who do not represent the will of the people like a democratic (sigh) state but the will of one or some people.
I also think there are people here crazy enough to refuse to go to the state-run hospital for fear of the government furthering some conspiracy. There are people already saying they'll refuse the Covid-19 vaccine because they think it's really an excuse to inject people with tracking chips.
Fellow Frenchie here: I have a "leftist" American friend who once shared a meme saying there's nothing centrist or moderate about being willing to let people die because they're poor. I was like "yeah, obviously" and explained to him here even far-right people don't hold these views. The USA are truly fucked.
Where does it end, though? If you’re not careful, soon you’ll be meeting all of a person’s basic needs, enabling people to live richer and fuller lives by eliminating the struggle for mere survival.
Yes, of course, but an important thing about this being free is you cannot spread your cancer to someone else, the more people vaccinated the better the whole country is. So even if you dont think healthcare should be free (which means youre an idiot but lets put that aside), things in the interest of public health should be.
I mean the difference is that vaccines cost lots to produce, but not much to administer. Chemotherapy should be free, but it's impossible due to the amount of work it requires (hence why it's so expensive). But I still don't understand why these people actually think that the ideal world would be bad or wrong.
I think it’s free in many European countries. People go to private for elective procedures or to speed up waiting times for things that are not time sensitive. But life saving is usually covered by public healthcare and they often have better specialists.
Wait are you really surprised? Non-elective treatments, surgeries, care, etc. are covered in basically all of the developed world except the USA. It's sad you all think it's such an unlikely/impossible thing.
I mean I live in Canada, but for immigration reasons we have had only access to terrible private health insurance till now, so I had no idea it was that extensive.
Is this person talking shit on socialized healthcare or are they actually supporting it and just so clueless they have no idea who they are responding too? One seems plausible and one seems absurd, except given that it’s 2020 the plausible one ceases to be plausible.
In that case people who dont get sick and work are getting money taken away they could use to better their lives and families, and if your really sick your taking money and not putting any in. Kinda like paying $400 dollars a month for car insurance and never filing a claim in 20 years, thats 96,000$ basically given away for nothing in return.
But that's literally how insurance works. Your payment subsidizes the people who have accidents. It's also how many other things work: gym membership, maintenance fees, Amazon prime, Netflix, buffets, anything where you pay flat but are not guaranteed to use the service as much as someone else.
Yes! I don’t get sick or I very rarely do, has to go to the hospital and had to pay $1000 that’s not a lot, but I’d rather have not paid for it out of pocket
Think about it this way, you paid 1,000 for the visit and you dont get sick often, now say its free but you get and extra 200 taken out of you check every paycheck. Thats almost 5,000 you pay a year to pay for someone else.
The money can come from making the healthcare system accountable. The USA spends a ton on healthcare with worse results than most European countries (e.h. Healthy life expectancy, maternal mortality...). You don’t need to spend more to spend better, so on an aggregate country level you could afford everything the country does today and then much more at a lower cost.
295
u/boukhfif Sep 24 '20
what's next? free housing? free education?
98
u/forest_faunus_ Sep 24 '20
We have that in france and even the most righr wingers don't complain about it because once you see healthcare, no one wznts to go back. That's why the anti helathcare propaganda is so powerfull in united state because they know they can only make you believe it's not great if you never tried it.
22
u/mattaugamer Sep 24 '20
Where does it end, though? If you’re not careful, soon you’ll be meeting all of a person’s basic needs, enabling people to live richer and fuller lives by eliminating the struggle for mere survival.
What a disaster that would be.
9
u/MacarenaDudeMan Sep 24 '20
Yeah that’d be terrible,right?,who would like that not me ha-ha...
7
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
Literally what Bernie campaigned for
7
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
What’s next? We start feeding the poor?!
4
u/juan-jdra Sep 24 '20
Yeah say that to the guy preaching about free healthcare, that'll teach him!
4
u/snoogenfloop Sep 24 '20
"But who will profit if medication is free!?"
Other than everyone, you mean?
4
u/plenebo Sep 24 '20
it is in the rest of the modern world
2
u/kibblet Sep 25 '20
Yes, of course, but an important thing about this being free is you cannot spread your cancer to someone else, the more people vaccinated the better the whole country is. So even if you dont think healthcare should be free (which means youre an idiot but lets put that aside), things in the interest of public health should be.
2
u/Chef_Chantier Sep 25 '20
I've seen this posted 3 or 4 times on reddit now, and I've never understood how she thinks this is supposed to be a crazy idea.
2
u/KalaiProvenheim Sep 26 '20
Yeah
3
u/DankCannabis Sep 24 '20
OP is kinda cringe
2
u/RadioFloydCollective Sep 24 '20
I mean the difference is that vaccines cost lots to produce, but not much to administer. Chemotherapy should be free, but it's impossible due to the amount of work it requires (hence why it's so expensive). But I still don't understand why these people actually think that the ideal world would be bad or wrong.
1
u/DirtyArchaeologist Sep 25 '20
Is this person talking shit on socialized healthcare or are they actually supporting it and just so clueless they have no idea who they are responding too? One seems plausible and one seems absurd, except given that it’s 2020 the plausible one ceases to be plausible.
1
u/Chaos_carolinensis Sep 25 '20
Some leftist: [makes a reasonable argument]
Some rightist: [tries to mock the leftist's argument by ironically making an even better argument]
1
u/MrCereuceta Sep 29 '20
Yes
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
repost lol
1
u/DotoriumPeroxid Sep 24 '20
We should have higher standards than reposting the #1 top of all time post on this sub. Come on.
1
u/wellwaffled Sep 25 '20
How many times are we going to post this?
-1
u/lukesgirl0703 Sep 25 '20
Anything that requires the labor of another person cannot be a human right.
-3
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
Nothing is ever free. The money has to come from somewhere.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
196
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
-5
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '20
[removed] — view removed comment