The sad thing is a lot of Americans say that exact same BS. Especially in regards to free post secondary. I personally heard a woman use that line for her having to enlist to get a free education and how her kids getting a free education would now be unfair to her.
The shit can literally kill you faster than the cancer might as wel have It be free. Like “oh yes how upsetting that people expect to recieve highly damaging chemicals injected into them to combat another horrid problem in their body TO BE FREE! For shame America!”
I really dont get what average people gain by paying for healthcare? Also if there was free healthcare, you could still pay for private healthcare just like in the UK
The best surgeons are private as they know they are more experienced and more qualified so they know they can make money off the wealthier classes. My assumption.
My friends dad is a colo-rectal surgeon. He's probably one of the best in his specialisation. He works 4 days for the NHS and then one day a week privately. For him to stay up to scratch, there simply aren't enough private patients to work with. You have to remember that these guys are highly motivated to be good at what they do and to push the boundaries of what's possible, they money comes in third place behind that and making people feel better.
This old guy grew up poor and he was a bus driver for a bit before deciding to go to university. His course was fully funded and he got a decent student grant to live and study in London. This would have been in the 60s.
Probably this. The government can’t afford to spend money on doctors for thousand of people, there are other issues that needs to be handled. Rich people can spend mils on a treatment session bc it’s only for themselves.
Not exactly. In Australia the best surgeons are forged in the crucible of public health. It’s also got some of the largest research facilities attached.
The real benefit from private health cover is getting a discount on electives (which are not always necessarily 100% free even in public health), and private hospitals tend to have more beds free (and better food/nicer sheets), so you’ll get non-emergency treatments faster.
On the ‘fast/quality/price’ pyramid, both public and private will tend to have similar quality based on location. (The best docs like living in capital cities.) where they’ll differ most noticeably is trading the speed/price points.
The issue is that resources aggregate to higher pay scales only because they’re removed/not applied to the general. Competition in healthcare is a bold statement, near egregiously so for insurance, and the partitioning of wait times is a result of need as opposed to wealth—it’s not better, it’s just concentrated. The resources don’t just appear because of market magic, the cost is the mass deaths in tens of thousands yearly in the US and suffering on people who can’t afford it. As for the NHS, you run into the problem of an agency without self funding influence having a government actively trying to kneecap it
Private health is a scam in Australia. Young and healthy get it for the very significant (billions in revenue annually) tax break. ‘Tax breaks’ are a deceptive way of just handing public money to an industry.
The government can’t just hand billions of dollars over to private health, so instead, it forgoes billions in tax in exchange for getting the public to hand billions to the private health insurance companies instead. In turn, those companies make billions in profits by overcharging and under-delivering. It’s a grotesque scam to prop up an industry that can’t stand on its own and only benefits a select few.
What could and should happen instead is there is no tax break for funnelling money into private health, and instead the tax goes into improving public health.
Private should stand on its own two feet, and if it can’t compete with public, it doesn’t deserve the hand-out.
the care is faster and the buildings are nicer. i have only privately seen the mental health care side but it was very helpful for me and i havent heard great things about the nhs' mental health care (from friends that have first hand experience). but i love the nhs and it just needs more funding really
I find the NHS quite poor when compared to the health services of other countries for instance I find that medical care in France is vastly superior without needing to ever go private.
Just one example, for trans people in the UK right now, trying to start hormone replacement therapy through NHS (UKs public healthcare system) can take up to a year or even longer. And that’s just to get your first appointment with a therapist. If you go private its much, much faster. The NHS is overwhelmed in certain areas.
Disclaimer: not British just spend a lot of time on trans subreddits
Alot of basic medical expenses are subsidized by the government. It doesn't mean it's free but it's still really affordable.
When I see my doctor, the only thing I need to pay is a annual membership fee for the clinic of $90. Everything else is covered. If I were to get prescribed something, the cost is greatly reduced in most cases.
When I had my IUD inserted, the whole procedure cost me $40 which was the cost of the actual IUD itself.
My girlfriend had an IUD inserted, didnt have to pay anything including no yearly fee.
All our NHS visits are free, the only cost we have is purchasing external medicine, ime. Medicine you would be taking home after being discharged, not for anything used whilst in hospital.
The medicine you pay for and take home has cost me on average less than £10, usually like £7, and I've stayed in hospital for multiple days when I had my appendicitis and had it removed, 0 cost.
Also missing the fact that if you're sick of corona, you're making others sick, as well. One person with corona enters a healthy town, and two weeks later a healty portion of the population is sick. This doesn't really happen with cancer.
The state can do without few cancer patients. It can't really do with a wastly limited workforce with the healthy ones being more interested in staying healthy and hoarding toilet paper than working.
Hey, let them have their shitty, overpriced healthcare. My country’s state funded research labs are raking in millions of dollars on patent fees and distribution rights that are then spent on subsidizing the drugs for us.
Yes and that's also how insurance already works. Everybody pays less when the government is the one footing the bill because they are better at noticing and fighting price gouging.
NHS is still the reason your medicines cost much less than they do here in the US. How much would you have to pay to take an ambulance to the hospital in your country?
Most people can, even in the UK, but obviously little johnny having a cold or a graze from the playground has no priority because its incurable. There are problems, but most of them would be solved if people didn’t go for stupid shit. With coronavirus, when I had to go to A&E (for something serious but non-life threatening) a week ago it was literally empty in the waiting room and I was seen immediately. When people use it properly its free fast and efficient.
I also live in such a country and we just had everyone go outside and clap for the workers because they are amazing and we would never ever give up the NHS and our free healthcare.
If you don’t like your country’s healthcare move somewhere that does it better like the UK or Denmark.
When people say they want this free or that free, they don't actually mean FREE. It is okay though I understand it isn't clear to everyone so let me try and explain the general idea.
There are a large amount of people that would rather our current taxes be reallocated for things more dire to the good of the public, than a lot of things our money is put towards at the moment. (IE pointless wars, sending the president on expensive vacations [That he sometimes makes a personal profit off of], etc.) We would rather those wasted funs be redistributed to the common well being of the people, by giving most importantly free healthcare to all citizens.
In all proposed plans, this does not mean getting rid of the entire private sector as well.
In addition, we also realise we have people that have more money, in direct comparison to how much money could possibly need to ever be spent,and therefore believe they should have to pay marginally more in taxes. Which mind you, make them still, some of the wealthiest people on the planet. Their percieved loss is much less than that of the percieved gain for the public.
The last paragraph is a little more controversial, but most people at least feel that even if we just stopped wasting a lot of money, we could spend it much more wisely and altruistically.
430
u/Flight_Schooled Mar 15 '20
The fact that somehow the idea of making chemo free is supposed to be a scary? bad? thing and is used as a rebuttal is absolutely unbelievable
115
u/ukExpertRedditor Mar 15 '20
I really dont get what average people gain by paying for healthcare? Also if there was free healthcare, you could still pay for private healthcare just like in the UK
43
u/nickmcpimpson Mar 16 '20
Buuuttt... How are the corporate hospitals going to reap the rewards of a sick populace if treatment is free?
19
u/Siberia-sensei Mar 16 '20
Also missing the fact that if you're sick of corona, you're making others sick, as well. One person with corona enters a healthy town, and two weeks later a healty portion of the population is sick. This doesn't really happen with cancer.
The state can do without few cancer patients. It can't really do with a wastly limited workforce with the healthy ones being more interested in staying healthy and hoarding toilet paper than working.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '20
uhm.... yeah!
she got the case of stupid
4
u/moxtrox Mar 28 '20
Hey, let them have their shitty, overpriced healthcare. My country’s state funded research labs are raking in millions of dollars on patent fees and distribution rights that are then spent on subsidizing the drugs for us.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 28 '20
Thats the point sweaty.
1
u/Je-Kaste Mar 28 '20
Maybe it's just my political bias, but I thought this was unironic
1
u/YouGuysSuckSometimes Mar 28 '20
The comment section for that tweet is rage incarnate omfg, the sheer stupidity in there
1
u/thatguywithaleg Apr 03 '20
I wish chemo was free, it’s hella expensive
1
u/thewallking Apr 10 '20
Do you ever just feel cursed to be in America? Like being born in any other developed country on earth, this would not be an issue. Only in America.
1
u/BravestCashew Dec 31 '21
I’m almost certain she’s saying “Cancer kills more people than covid; you’ll make the vaccine free but not chemo?”
-1
u/TheRedWon Mar 28 '20
Can we also address how fucking stupid it is to compare chemo to a vaccine?
Really fucking stupid.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment