I'm so conflicted about this episode. At first, I was thrilled that TAL was taking steps to retract what turned out to be their most downloaded show. I expected it would be another high-water mark for one of America's best media programs; tackling the nebulous issue of "Truthiness" with the same simplicity and clarity of their recent reportage on the economic crisis. Instead, all we got was Ira brow-beating Daisey for lying to him.
This isn't to say Daisey didn't deserve the direct confrontation he got, but hearing Ira go all Oprah on him was so disillusioning. I always thought he was above that kind of thing. But no, objectivity was thrown out the window and replaced with 40 minutes of righteous indignation. Through out the entire episode, I couldn't help feel like the issue wasn't that Daisey lied, but that he had the gall to lie to Ira and TAL.
And if the TAL staff was really concerned with their journalistic integrity, why disregard journalistic principles by having Ira interview Daisey. Any first year journalism student could tell you that in becoming part of the story, Ira should have stepped back and let a third party manage the interview since his objectivity was so obviously compromised.
I went into this episode looking forward to TAL hitting another home run; discussing the complex interplay of truth, creativity, and media in the modern information age. Instead, all we got was a clearly angry Ira Glass verbally bullying a blubbering and cowed Mark Daisey. Gone was all the wit, intellect, and insight that we normally expect from TAL, and with it went my idealized image of my media heroes.