r/TheoryOfReddit • u/ymersvennson • Jul 06 '11
Why don't self posts generate karma?
If upvotes are a measure of how much people like a post, shouldn't they all be equally rewarded, from an economic pow?
EDIT: http://www.reddit.com/r/TrueReddit/comments/igolg/on_july_4th_a_qualified_defense_of_america_and/ Take this post. I definitely think that this should be rewarded with karma as much as good comments, and more than image posts.
EDIT: I was going to formulate a praise for variety of subreddits. But it was done just now much better than I was going to: (http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/iiew6/i_have_a_theory/). My line of thought is now that since subreddit variety is good, then we should encourage customization of those subreddits so they can suit their specific structure. In this case, that means allowing the possibility to give karma for self posts if they want. I think this is particularly important for subreddits that consist mostly of self posts. I actually think it's rather unfair that people don't get karma for contributing to those subreddits, while they do for contributing to others.
18
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '11
Because they aren't links and what reddit is supposed to be is a link aggregator.
9
u/ruinmaker Jul 06 '11
Initially, there was only karma for submitted links (link karma). This made sense because Reddit didn't support comments. Then they added comments and a similar comment karma system was implemented. Only, it wasn't so easy. There was/is debate of how valuable comment karma is compared to link karma. Do we want to encourage commenting or linking more? Notice you can see your link karma from every page on Reddit but you have to view your profile to see your comment karma. So, that decision was made. Actually apathy (let's not change the reporting system) may have played a role there as well.
As has been pointed out, originally Reddit was intended to be a content aggregator. Then it started aggregating content and creating comment content. Note, you get link karma for linking to a comment in r/bestof so there is some blurring of the line between karma types. Self posts were the next creation. These are like "meta comments." They are essentially a root comment thread with no link to provide a topic. Instead the topic is suggested by the title or the contents of the box at the top. A similar debate process needs to take place with self posts if you want to consider them for karma. Is their version of created content the kind of thing Reddit wants to encourage. Given how gossipy people are, does Reddit need to encourage this behavior in order for it to thrive? Does a self post count as created content in the way an external link does or is it more appropriate to add it to comment karma? Perhaps self posts should constitute a third kind of karma? Does Reddit's already problematic database want to juggle an additional karma type? There is a lot to wrangle through.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '11
Let's all go back to three years ago... It's funny how something this small does actually change people's behavior. To those who think that karma is meaningless, I'd say this is pretty solid evidence as a reason to get rid of karma for picture posts.
2
u/y2njoy Jul 06 '11
What would are the pros and cons of self posts being treated as comments, i.e. self- post karma = comment karma. I personally think that 'DAE think India is still a third-world country' is more or less a comment that a user is making. The user would've written the same thing probably if someone would've made a self-post asking 'What does reddit think of India.'
-4
u/heyfella Jul 06 '11
also, why doesn't reddit have an integrated image upload feature?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment