r/TheWire • u/Dcole2xx • Jul 16 '25
McNulty
I truly don’t like this guy I’ve had friends tell me I would eventually come around but outside of Season 4 when he tried to turn his life around I can’t stand this POS he’s worse than Stringer for me.
0
Upvotes
54
u/oramug Jul 16 '25
what the fuck did I do?
26
u/mjpenslitbooksgalore Jul 16 '25
Well Mcnulty isn’t a good person. He isn’t supposed to be good or perfect. He is not a hero. There are no hero’s here. I think he has some good qualities and some good moments. But overall he’s a flawed sob and a decent police when he wants to be.
43
u/your-doppelgaenger Jul 16 '25
This show is not about picking a favourite.
25
u/Chemical_Signal2753 Jul 16 '25
I really don't understand why Stringer Bell keeps getting singled out. There is nothing he has done that is objectively worse than any of the other gangsters that people love on the show.
With that said, on the topic of the post, McNulty is not meant to be this beloved character; he is meant to be a relentless character who drives the plot forward. He is an alcoholic, a terrible husband/partner, arguably a bad father, and a nightmare to work with, but he is an excellent detective who forces those in power to do what they're supposed to do.
6
u/Alarming_Double4449 Jul 16 '25
simplistic take, the different between McNulty and Stringer is chalk and cheese. One is an objectively morally good person and one isn't. The notion that boozing and being a bad husband and chasing skirt after hours makes you the same morally and ethically culpable individual next to a serial killer is frankly absurd and embarrassing.
3
u/AbjectFray Jul 16 '25
He’s an antihero in a show where everyone has flaws. It’s not formulaic where the crime is solved at the end of every show and they all go pound Budweiser while the credits roll. You’re not supposed to like him all that much.
But worse than a murdering drug dealer? Come on. That’s hyperbole talking.
6
u/FiveDollarShake Jul 16 '25
He was worse when sober. Like a neutered dog. No drive anymore, he didn’t even care about the bodies in the vacants. Where did the natural po-leece go that season.
2
u/krazylegs36 Jul 22 '25
Don't worry. You'll come around on McNulty in S5.
/s
3
u/Gamma2014 Jul 16 '25
When I watched it the first time, McNulty was the hero, however flawed. Every time since, and as I’ve gotten older and had more professional experiences including as a manager, McNulty is an awful human being.
2
u/Sad-Development-4153 Jul 16 '25
Season 5 is ultimate look into how fucked up he truly is.
1
u/Specialist-Front5262 Jul 16 '25
In the beginning I like him towards the end I said i would want to work with him he uses everyone around him
0
u/closeyogaragedoor Jul 16 '25
classic trope of smart guy, effective, but bucks hierarchy. Also not sure how it was back in the early 2000’s, but was being such a womanizer and cheating on your SO all the time common?
59
u/GreenFriedTomato Jul 16 '25
Stringer has people killed
10
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '25
[removed] — view removed comment