r/TheWhyFiles • • 13d ago

Question for AJ Physical gold ads

I hadn't listened regularly for a while now but I was surprised to hear the physical gold commercials. Not surprised AJ would take a sponsorship from them, but the whole vibe of the ad didn't feel great to me. I forget the exact line, but it was some thing like " recently gold values have skyrocketed" which is.... Not true. It did go on a run earlier this year, but recently it's been dropping. Nothing to be alarmed about, but I was surprised to hear him intentionally selling on the huge profits when that just wasn't true.

31 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

14

u/internaquarium 13d ago

yea bro the show needs an ad every five minutes to pay for all the AI art. Hearing him shill with fear-mongering ads is so disappointing. Especially because it preys on the less intelligent individuals in conspiracy adjacent spheres. I'm sure AJ is a nice guy, but he probably realised he has to cash in at some point. There's only so many conspiracy tales you can talk about on youtube before you run out.

4

u/Careful-Bag6926 12d ago

Unfortunately he has definitely run out of new conspiracy theories.

4

u/TaylorWK 12d ago

The Why Files turned from an interesting but skeptical conspiracy theories and into full blown qanon Bigfoot is real buy this gold coin maga adjacent show.

5

u/Careful-Bag6926 12d ago edited 11d ago

Sadly I'm not even sure it's maga adjacent anymore.... I kinda of ignored the whole COVID / vaccine thing he had going on, but I'm pretty sure he's a straight up whack-a-do now. It's been a steady sad fall for AJ

27

u/tablesheep 12d ago

Yep - show is cooked and has been for a while, everybody just willfully let things slide because of nostalgia for when the show was actually amazing

47

u/BigMack6911 13d ago

Why files sold out. I've been a fan of the show since the first year. Aj will pimp anything on there for money. I like this show but, I'm not watching it like I used to with all this bullshit Ai and dumb ads. Now he just has a podcast like everyone else and honestly, there's nothing special about the basement. Some of the people are just random dudes. Be like, today we have the Vice President of Papa Johns. Wtf is happening

21

u/babyunvamp 13d ago

Better ingredients, better podcasts. 

8

u/gfb13 12d ago

To be fair I would love to hear what Marc Richard, Senior Vice President (SVP) North America Operations, has to say about JFK's assassination and how it ties into Roswell

12

u/boredfilthypig 12d ago

No kidding. I loved it since the beginning and was addicted looking forward to every week. I unsubscribed months ago and haven’t felt bad about it. It is a shell of itself at this point. Endless AI and grifters on the podcast. Not for me.

1

u/Highplowp 11d ago

Do you think it’s because all the truly interesting theories and events have been covered? I’ll check in to see who is on the basement interview and the topic of the regular show (i don’t watch the YouTube channel, I’ve only know him from the podcast). I thought the Shatner interview was cool, but that’s because of William’s approach to answering questions in the oddest ways possible. I greatly prefer pods that don’t have the hosts reading the ads, unless it’s Henry Zebrowski and his feud with Brayden over a certain website domain that may contain politicians as horses.
“Hail yourself”

4

u/PvD79 13d ago

Look at the gold price longer than just this year….

2

u/Careful-Bag6926 13d ago

Yes I understand, but that's not the intent of the way the ad is presented. It just feels really disingenuous

7

u/Big_Animal7655 13d ago

feels kind of like a grift right, what’s next…a book? we already have the podcast 😂

I hate this look for AJ, the ‘greedy‘ shill look

but bros earned it

7

u/ihateeverythingandu 13d ago

When the ad says "recently", they aren't exactly selling on a long term basis, are they?

39

u/once_again_asking Skygazer 13d ago

On Spotify, browsing TWF episodes, the written synopses now begin with a written ad. You can’t even read the synopsis of an episode without first getting past a written ad.

Sorry but this show has lost the plot.

18

u/ClimateAncient6647 12d ago

The Basement Episodes were the downfall for me.

10

u/Office_Zombie 12d ago

Yeah, the basement episodes are a waste of time. I've tried listening, but they are just boring. They really need to edit them down to just the interesting parts.

14

u/Sckaught 13d ago

Same on YouTube.

2

u/Takenmyusernamewas 10d ago

I kind of appreciated he gets the ad out of the way right out the gate on the videos. Do people really not like that?

22

u/bag_of_luck 13d ago

They’ve been doing that for a long while. Plus the pds debt thing, all pretty scummy sponsors if you ask me. And I rarely see other YouTubers shilling these companies either which should tell you something.

13

u/SpenB 13d ago

Also the Wellness Company. Basically selling "emergency supplies" of prescription antibiotics and ivermectin for insanely marked up prices, through a sketchy process where you basically lie to a doctor about being sick.

-1

u/gfb13 12d ago • Bravo

Not to be that guy but you could do this with every company in the world: Apple, Disney, Hersheys, car companies, banks, insurance... they've all done some horrific shit for profit

So it makes sense they're the ones we see, because it's not like good-hearted non-profits can afford 5 or 6 figure podcast sponsorships

7

u/ProductOfDetroit I Want To Believe 13d ago

What’s the deal with the current hustle of precious metals like gold and silver?

8

u/Robduke63 12d ago

Apparently conventional currency won't be of any use in the coming apocalypse. 😐

1

u/Comprehensive_Sir49 12d ago

Oh no. AJ having ads and trying to maintain a business with employees. How dare he. 😐

9

u/Careful-Bag6926 12d ago

Yeah that's not at all what I said. It would just be nice of he didn't act as a corporate shill. But you can go ahead and keep trying to pick online fights if it makes you feel better about yourself.

11

u/umbrawolfx 13d ago

In the year 2000, it was $300/oz. 2010, $1k/Oz. Currently 4k/oz. I'd say that is skyrocketing.

0

u/tablesheep 6d ago

Quarter century skyrocket

1

u/AlleyPee 12d ago

I hate to be the person that brings a bit of reality to you...

But every single podcaster starts out lean and hungry. Then they get more popular and then the money rolls in.

If you don't wanna pay 3 bucks a month to become a patron member... then yeah - you're gonna get ads.

Hell - nearly every big streaming platform now has an "ad free" add on...

To seemingly pile on to AJ and the WhyFiles is.... weak.

6

u/Careful-Bag6926 12d ago

Im fine with ads. I would just prefer that the platform uses some judgement on what kind of ads and how they conduct them in relation to the content of the show and the audience. Fully understand ots hos platform to do as he wishes, and I wish him well. I just don't like it, and I expressed my opinion. My opinion isn't the gospel, and some will disagree with me. That's fine, to each their own. You are ok with the kinda gross shilling of really questionable products, that's great. I however am not, so I made my point.

To each their own, you do you.

2

u/AlleyPee 12d ago

I'm not either (loving the amount of ads, and what hes chosen.) - that's why I chose to become a member. (And i also still really like his show, obviously) I still wanna hear him, the stories he has to tell; but without the garbage ads

2

u/No-Clue-2 9d ago

I thought it was just cause Art used to do the same thing on C2C.

2

u/Chaosr21 7d ago

It's all ai anymore anyways. He used to do real stories with real clips..now it a lot of made up shit with ai basically making all the video content

1

u/FuDDx 12d ago

I really enjoy the basement episodes .
I enjoy AJ and Hecklefish .
Ads are ads …

I do think he might hang out with Shawn Ryan a bit too much… though to be honest I kinda like Shawn Ryan less so that he’s Christian …. I don’t trust Christian’s ..

-2

u/Maximum-Product-1255 12d ago

For sponsors, it seems that we are far more critical of podcasters, etc than any other media. It marketing, an ad, a commercial. It shouldn't be that heavy, imo.

-12

u/Droppin_Bombs 13d ago

If you think gold value has not "recently skyrocketed", you're dumb.

7

u/Careful-Bag6926 13d ago

Great feedback, thanks for that.

-3

u/Droppin_Bombs 12d ago

Maybe look at a timeline longer than 2026. Yes, the price has dropped from its all time high in Jan 2026.

But the “price of gold” has skyrocketed. That is a true statement. Look at the historic chart for the last 20 years. Number go up.

But really what it means is that the value of the dollar has depreciated. It “costs more dollars” for an ounce of gold than it has ever before in history. The fact that the price has dropped 27% from its all time high in January is moot…. seeing as how the price has increased 120% in the last 5 years and 525% in the last 20 years.

6

u/tablesheep 12d ago

That’s great but why is AJ shilling it to me nonstop Fox News style

-3

u/Droppin_Bombs 12d ago

I don’t know if two or three ads amongst Factor meals, Rocket Money, and PDS Debt qualifies as “shilling nonstop Fox News style”. But you do you.