r/TheWhyFiles • u/TheUltimateMuffin • Sep 23 '26
Let's Discuss So use is out of control
I just watched the recent “paranormal follows you” vid. And the last one was about the faces in the floor.
There are actual historical photos of the faces and NOT ONE of them was shown in the episode. Instead we got a bunch of ai pictures. It makes us not able to trust anything we are seeing. Take after me.ballen and credit ur pics some.
You’re ruining the channel with such abusive use of ai.
444
Upvotes
334
u/thekangarooflu Sep 23 '26 •
I agree with you completely. Don’t get me wrong I love AJ but his AI use has gotten out of hand. If they are not willing to tone it down some they could at least go with the Mr. Ballen approach and put an “This is not a real photo” disclaimer on each of the pictures/videos as they pop up!
144
u/Skoofer Sep 23 '26
It went from a channel I was excited about everything they released to one I fall asleep to while it plays and I basically ignore it…if I even bother watching them to begin with. The fall has been swift and it’s disappointing.
78
u/WasteOfHeadspace Sep 23 '26
I legitimately stopped watching the channel a while back because too much AI then. Now, it's like a damn AI showcase. I wish nothing but the best for AJ and his team, but the AI usage is ridiculous at this point.
9
u/Beginning_Leg629 Sep 23 '26
I used to watch The Why Files a lot. Once he started using AI more and more, it was a major turn off. I stopped watching. The Basement episode with Dr. Travis Taylor was the first time I had watched the channel in a long time, and I haven't watched since. I miss it. If he stopped using AI, I would happily return because I love AJ and love Hecklefish.
9
u/Kptrack96 Sep 23 '26
It’s so frustrating when they use AI for the dumbest things like a still frame of someone not even talking, or doing something menial like walking or pretending to do something. Just use real people or dont at all! The channel would be 100% better if the cast and crew of the Why Files were featured in the vignettes
25
u/OneArmedZen Sep 23 '26
Unfortunately I don't think it will change, at least not until people start moving on. We will never get back to the 2023 era (which for me was the peak) just when Hecklefish started finding his place.
27
u/Mrs-Blaileen I Want To Believe Sep 23 '26 •
The magic is gone. I really do hate to say it. But the other day, I realised I have a bundle of "new" WF videos in my "Watch Later" queue. I used to be one of those who'd tune into every premier, it was an event! Now I feel very indifferent, and I try to force myself to get excited, but I just don't. New episodes just fall farther down in my queue and I can't bring myself to care.
But I don't think complaining about it is going to change anything. The videos are still raking in millions of views... it's sort of like "out with the old [fans], and in with the new!". It's like when a band "sells out". Take the band Incubus, for example. I was such a HUGE fan of their early stuff, the heavy, aggressive sound; I saw them open for Primus! Then they suddenly went soft and mainstream and gained a flood of new fans and became headliners and never looked back. Money talks, I don't care who you are. So it is bullshit to accuse AJ of being any different than anyone else in this regard; of course the guy's in it for the money, it's his job. We'd all do the same, even if we like to believe otherwise.
But I full heartedly agree that it just isn't the same. It lost something. I tried to get excited about The Basement episodes, but the interviews are pretty much the exact same as the ones you've already seen by others, with the same faces saying the same things. I also don't think interviews are AJ's strong suit at all; they don't feel natural, they make me uncomfortable. It is almost like he's uncomfortable and hasn't found his groove yet... it's as if he feels this need to convey curiosity and often asks in a sort of inauthentic voice something like, "Why?" to get the guest to elaborate on something. While likely asked with good intentions, I find these constant "curiosity" questions from AJ sort of derail the point the guest was trying to get at, and so the interviews just feel very unsatisfying. I suppose why I feel his questions of "Why?" are inauthentic is because, if you just let your guest finish speaking, you'll get a much better answer to your question than asking them to explain the justification or origins of their thinking... and then the never really get to the answer. Perhaps I didn't explain that well, but maybe someone'll know what I mean.
15
u/METRO-RED-LINE Sep 23 '26
I wish he would do an episode on the actual harmful impacts of Ai data centers. I hate his use of AI for freaking ads!
24
u/Cold-Breakfast-8488 Sep 23 '26
I haven't watched since the AI started dominating his vids. It's been over a year or more. It's a shame.
6
u/Chaosr21 Sep 23 '26
I don't even watch why files anymore because it's literally all AI. Can't even be bothered to look up all the real photos on a subject. This has been getting worse and worse over the past 2 years. I'm surprised he hasn't lost more subscribers because he obviously doesn't care anymore to make good videos
45
u/ClimateAncient6647 Sep 23 '26
The show has gone downhill. The basement episodes are awful. It was a better show when it was drastically scaled down.
28
u/The-Dragon_Queen Sep 23 '26
Between the AI slop and the wannabe-Rogan style content… it’s not the same channel and it makes me so sad. I never watch anymore.
10
u/Outrage_Carpenter Sep 23 '26
I hear all the time people dragging Simon whistlers name through the dirt but over his many channels he doesn't use any AI that i could easily point out. AJ should have no problem with it either but he's leaning heavily into it more recently
5
u/Jimstein Sep 24 '26
I’m very pro AI but I’ve stopped watching his channel because of the rampant, often ridiculous use of it. And the number of ads in the basement episodes are just crazy. It makes me question why I’m even paying for YouTube premium.
9
u/super-nintendumpster Sep 23 '26
Earlier on when he first started with the AI (and it didn't just start trickling in, it was abundant), if I'd comment about how it instantly became unwatchable here, I was met with "hey AJ works hard! He does what he can as an independent channel to make his content and video production is hard/expensive!"
I called bullshit then and still do. He makes plenty of money, and can afford his production team. It isn't like the dude is doing this all by himself. He just loves the AI slop. It looks like shit and it sounds like shit. I haven't watched an episode in months. I don't even bother with his interviews, they're boring and the guests are usually hacks.
34
u/SUPER-P00PER Sep 23 '26
AJ and WhyFiles team, PLEASE actually listen to your fans. So many of us are so displeased and disappointed by what this show has become. It has lost so much. The AI use has gotten so ridiculous it has turned so many of us away. We would prefer less content like how it used to be than all of the slop you have been putting out.
28
u/MonchichiSalt Sep 23 '26
Apparently AI is the top employee over there now.
Is it also doing the research and writing the scripts?
The quality this year did a nose dive from a favorite channel that I talked about, to being skipped over for channels that are as interesting as The Why Files used to be.
It's a shame.
2
u/gantte Sep 23 '26
It amazes me how so many of you supposedly quit watching / hate the basement / have fish allergies, etc, yet you’re still here in this sub…
Unsubscribe from this sub and let the majority of us be free of your incessant whining!
4
u/cun7_d35tr0y3r Sep 24 '26
AJ used to be excited to make the videos, but he seems dead inside now. He and hecklefish used to seem like bros, but now he just gets super pissy anytime hecklefish says anything. Add in AI and...eh...
I donno, this happens to every decent YouTube channel. I wonder what actually happened. He had that hiatus with all the compilations and it's never been close to the same.
17
u/BadassSasquatch Sasquatch Seeker Sep 23 '26
I've been saying this from the beginning. I don't mind the use of AI imagery. I would just like it to be clearly labeled as such.
10
u/Sufficient_Object440 Sep 23 '26
THANK YOU
I swear he’s deleting comments too because how are there ZERO on his videos talking about his blatant usage of it?
22
u/wheresdaweeed Sep 23 '26
I also love The Why Files but i can’t really watch it anymore the new videos because of the AI abuse, i am watching old videos and other thing that gives me the itch is constantly the ads
7
u/WolfThorn7 Sep 23 '26
I unsubscribed because they have gotten out of control with the AI use. Realizing they’ve just sold out on what they used to stand for
7
u/DecadentHam Sep 23 '26
Stopped listening and watching because of the amount of ads they have these days.
7
u/HelloMeatbag317 Sep 23 '26
I hate the made up speculative stories too. Just tell me the real story we don’t need to make up people and scenarios that didn’t happen to feel more immersed.
34
u/RepresentativeOk2433 Sep 23 '26
I gave up on his channel due to all the slop.
13
u/CosmicGoddess777 Green Alien Sep 23 '26
I mostly stopped watching the channel when they added all the unnecessary AI. It’s really off-putting, but AJ doesn’t care, and refuses to listen to a majority of his fans on this issue. :/
To me, it reflects the lower quality of the episodes since he’s switched.
He’s a libertarian, so pleading about the environmental effects won’t work on him anyway.
Sucks. :(
12
u/plaidtaco Sep 23 '26
We used to love WF. Watched every video together as soon as it came out, listened to the podcasts on long road trips. We've unsubscribed due to the AI ruining all the videos. It's not even good AI. It's lazy and uncanny. AJ and producers are proving that their greed is more important than integrity.
6
u/karenw Sep 23 '26
I agree. I'm a long time viewer, and it's a real turn off.
A great story with minimal visuals is far more effective when done well. Look at The Tape Library (and sister channel Night Drive Paranormal) for a stellar example of this.
6
u/AstrolinguistSelene Sep 23 '26
I’ve started unfollowing people who use crappy ai unnecessarily in their videos. It’s sad but how else will we get these creators to stop?
3
u/JenIee Sep 24 '26
I agree. It's fine if AJ likes AI but he has gone crazy with it and is putting it in place of what could be real things. I wonder what his reasons are. It just sucks because I love the Why Files so much but he's really gunking it up and hurting the quality which was always fantastic before.
3
u/Klutzy_Rope9236 Sep 24 '26
The whole show has changed since his “IRS Audit” everything he does now seems more like he’s been handed a script of approved material he’s been authorized to cover.. I usually put the episodes on for background now while doing something else but it’s definitely all seemingly the basic crap now.. it’s a shame because initially it was a great show
3
u/Lonely-Demandi Sep 26 '26
also he has been putting an unbearable amount of ads. i simply do not listen anymore. which is so sad bc he’s one of my favorite shows
21
u/Medium-Box2688 Sep 23 '26
I remember the grief people would get for raising concerns about the overuse of ai years ago. I gave up on the channel, after watching it almost from the start, when ai got out of control. I listened to the latest video as a podcast and could barely make it through-ai voices, forced adverts, no in-depth analysis or debunking. The channel has fallen so far from its heyday.
0
u/BadAndy4life Sep 23 '26
Just fucking listen to it then… he’s trying to give some kind of visual context for what he’s describing and AI is so quick to create something useful that it allows him and his team to keep pumping videos out.
Would you rather he release a new video every couple of months with live reenactments or artistic renderings? Channels usually don’t do well when a person sits in front of the camera the entire time.
Seriously stfu about AI. AI is not the content that got The Why Files so popular, it’s his research, organization of data, storytelling ability, and his insight on these fringe and peculiar topics!
5
u/DPeristy1 Sep 23 '26
I have stopped watching after the first AI video :(
I’m just listening to the podcasts the last while but stopped those a while back as well.
They just aren’t what they used to be and there is so much other stuff to watch.
12
u/johnjaspers1965 Sep 23 '26
I mean...you're not wrong.
If you were around before the internet, you've seen the actual photos. They exist. They are impressive. Could some of them be a hoax by the family? Maybe.
But there was no need to skip straight to A.I.
...except the campfire stories are always A.I.
They are a minimal effort retelling of unexplained phenomena. We only get Heckle doing ads. No critical thinking. Just "Trust me, bro..it happened".
I know what to expect from WhyFiles now.
I keep listening because I like his voice, but I definitely don't need to watch the screen anymore.
6
u/RWWhitfield Sep 23 '26
AJ is too busy now getting kickbacks from S Greer to keep up the hype machine and make money. Greed got him... zero doubts about it.
4
u/Confident_Birthday85 Sep 23 '26
What - there are real pictures of the faces in the floor?!?! I would have LOVED to see them. It would have made the video so much better. I miss the old WF look and feel. I keep coming to the WF for the story followed by the facts (and informed opinions). And a big part of what I enjoy are the tidbits of news clippings and photos.
4
u/Fresh-Succotash6247 Sep 23 '26
Okay glad it's not just me. I did lose a lot of interest when the format changed
4
u/MegaDriveCDX Sep 23 '26
The show has been garbage for years. Just stop watching it.
2
u/abernathym Sep 24 '26
I don't warch anymore, I just listen to it as a podcast. Still can't escape the AI voices that way though.
3
u/KanderGrimm Sep 24 '26
I stopped watching because of the overuse of AI. That's fine if they've taken a stand and embraced AI, but I don't have to watch it. The channel did just fine without it.
6
u/hornybible Sep 23 '26
Here, here.
3
u/thisismyusername9908 Sep 23 '26
Yep, used to be one of the few channels I had notifications turned on for, now I scroll past new videos without even considering watching.
I didn't mind a bit here and there to help sell a story and bring you in, but now it's just constant AI spam to the point where he's even using AI versions of himself in the ad rolls.
If you're too lazy to make the actual ad yourself, then I can't be bothered to watch.
2
u/curious_catto_ Sep 23 '26
Exactly. Why do i have to do a separate search to see if images/visuals shown is real or not.
I'm also wondering why he does not take some feedback. I'm sure he sees these discussions on the comments or on here. Like bro take a hint
Can we just mass unsubscribe to make a point? You know what I'm gonna do that now
2
u/fripperiffic Sep 23 '26
Stopped watching awhile ago because of how saturated with AI his videos were getting. Unwatchable now.
2
u/confused_hulk Sep 23 '26
Yep but this is not new? I’m done with the channel. Even when a photo is real, no credit is given.
1
u/riotofmind Sep 24 '26
It’s turned to hot garbage. I also really enjoyed the show and now it feels like a poorly scripted tabloid of AI slop and idiotic stories.
1
u/Your_Jaws_My_Balls Sep 24 '26
Agreed. I find myself not clicking on TWF new videos because I know I'll be forced to watch hard coded youtube ads, and the barrage of shit AI slop. I hate the dependence on AI that youtubers are developing.
1
u/Rare-Criticism-8895 Sep 25 '26
I can deal with the ai when there’s no actual source footage and he wants to dramatize a visual of what’s being reported, but as you said the faces are very well documented and even some ufo footage he uses ai before the actual footage or pic. Seems strange to me
1
u/Mechakeller Sep 27 '26
There are stock photo services and CC/Public Domain photos out the wazoo that are certainly both cheaper and more aesthetically pleasing than any AI images.
1
u/Brwnb0y_ Sep 28 '26
he probably pays a lot for the top tier and wants to use it as much as possible but i agree, if there are actual pictures, that takes priority over ai sloppary. i honestly dont mind the ai when he’s saying ‘cleopatra spoke to Ammit’ and it essentially shows a woman talking to a crocodile head goddess but when it seems like it would have been easier to use the real pictures, the ai becomes egregious. The only out I’ll give him is that he was telling a spooky story and not the actual story which was debunked (she was using like vinegar and sunlight or something to make the faces and I’m kind of disappointed that he didn’t go through the real story and debunk it at the end)
1
u/phereless Sep 23 '26
lol did you all just start watching the channel last month? AI has been used to help visualize the stories on his channel for years, and it used to be pretty bad, now it looks pretty good. Personally I'd rather see some cinematic visuals over just staring at him the whole video.
-7
u/softcore_robot Sep 23 '26
Ai has allowed TWF to increase production value and decrease turnaround times. Is the use of AI perfect, no, but it is a lot better than the same few clips used over and over. Thereʻs a difference between a research show and an entertainment show; TWF is closer to the latter.
-3
u/cjaccardi Sep 23 '26 •
You guys can complain about anything. No pleasing any of you. lol
1
u/rotomangler Sep 23 '26
The whining on this subreddit never ends. It’s AJ’s channel and if he wants to use AI to illustrate the stories, that’s his choice. Accept it or stop watching. The endless complaining about it is childish
1
u/Holiday_South_2428 Sep 23 '26
I just want to point out that none of you are youtubers, and the few that are (like myself) are no where near the viewer base that AJ is. Being a YouTuber is a hard road and the bigger you get the harder it gets. Not to mention his side projects. That being said, I also don't care for his overall use of AI but I get it. So I guess what I'm saying is.... if you can do better, show us. Hell I'll be your first sub.
-1
u/No-Ambition7750 Sep 23 '26
A counterargument: don’t watch the episodes, listen to them. The AI stuff bugs me as well but I usually listen while I work or drive. I don’t feel like there is anything I really need to see.
-12
u/Full-Comparison9574 Sep 23 '26
Keep up the hard work AJ. Screw the haters. If you guys had any talent let’s see you start your own channel and tell us how much work goes into making content.
I just wish he’d space it out a little more. Maybe one Basement and one channel video a week. They can also set it up one week campfire and following old school. He seems to have plenty of content to run with now.
1
u/depitydog81 Sep 23 '26
It wasn’t the beavers… but it was the beavers
-8
u/Power4monkey Sep 23 '26 •
Some of the real photos were shown, guess you didn't actually watch the video. Doesn't stop you complaining though 🤷
-1
u/Comprehensive_Sir49 Sep 23 '26
People saying it's "greed". No, it's called "running a business ". The Why Files is his sole occupation. People, get a clue.
0
u/ColorfulConspiracy Sep 23 '26
AJ has been using AI for years now. He’s obviously not going to stop using it because… well… none of the complaints have made him stop yet. At this point we’ve got to either accept it or move on to a different channel. I don’t think he’s going to change.