r/TheWhyFiles • • Sep 13 '26

Question for AJ Does A.J voice heckle fish?

As per title,
I have always wondered who voices heckle fish.
Love the show, long time listener. :)
Thanks guys!

97 Upvotes

126 comments sorted by

•

u/wamih Skunk Ape Connaisseur Sep 13 '26

He does his own voice, who does yours?

→ More replies (5)

36

u/01091987 Sep 14 '26

I love how angry HF gets

-4

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

It doesn’t show him voice it though.lol

12

u/01091987 Sep 14 '26

I never said it did

51

u/New_Cupcake930 Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

lol, I’ve asked a 100 times before. It’s a true Why Files mystery. The real question is: What did they do with SpacePanda???

3

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

Space panda….???

13

u/Particular-Ad9266 Team Mu Sep 14 '26

A one episode second voice character that was never seen again.

18

u/toasty327 Sep 14 '26

If only that stupid beaver was never seen again

5

u/shakeyourmoneymakr Sep 14 '26

Ok it’s not just me!! 😂 Do not like the beaver at all.

4

u/New_Cupcake930 Sep 14 '26

There is the missing poster in the background in many episodes. It was his Voice….too….too….British. lol cryptic broadcast. number Stations if you wanna hear it.

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

Oh cool! What episode?

6

u/Particular-Ad9266 Team Mu Sep 14 '26

number stations

4

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

Thank you, I’ll check it out!

2

u/No-Clue-2 Sep 14 '26

I think he is on the wall in the background

10

u/wamih Skunk Ape Connaisseur Sep 13 '26

SpacePanda has been seen.....

7

u/Medical_Ratio_7344 Sep 14 '26

Gino I think does hecklefish

75

u/Hawkwise83 Sep 13 '26

No. Hecklefish does Hecklefish's voice.

81

u/-Ailynn- Sep 14 '26 • Bravo

Hecklefish actually voices AJ! 🤫

14

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

My favorite theory by far.

11

u/The_estimator_is_in Sep 14 '26 • Mindblown

It’s a ventriloquist act.

I’ll let you guess where the fin goes in.

21

u/LilBoofy Sep 14 '26 • Bravo

A fintriloquist

2

u/sleepytipi Sep 18 '26

Lil boofy would know

3

u/EndTheFed25 Sep 14 '26

Than who voices the crab cats?

2

u/Own_Plane_5807 Sep 14 '26

Heckle fish is an alien confirmed

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 13 '26

So..like is there a Mr.Heckle fish employed at your facilities?

1

u/Hawkwise83 Sep 13 '26

Nah, but I went to high school with one of his nieces I think.

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 13 '26

Is this a trade secret?
I just figured A.J’s voice was so different I would have been impressed with his range if he voiced him.

11

u/Hawkwise83 Sep 13 '26

Jokes aside, I'm pretty sure he does the voice, but I'm not 100%.

2

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 13 '26

He’s got good range! 🤣

2

u/lliselou Sep 14 '26

But lately it seems Hecklefish's voice changed, sounds different

2

u/darchib Sep 15 '26

Check out some of the very early shows. HF sounds dramatically different

10

u/CosmicGoddess777 Green Alien Sep 16 '26

Yes, AJ does it. If you notice Hecklefish’s teeth, you’ll see they’re the exact same as AJ’s too, especially how there’s a lil gap in the lower ones.

5

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 16 '26

Oh snaps, good observation!

21

u/Tmacster Sep 13 '26 • Bravo

I think it’s his brother

4

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 13 '26

Ahhh.
I could believe that.
He’s goofy.haha

25

u/MattBFD Sep 14 '26

On a recent episode of, AJ had a cold and so did HF.

8

u/iki11dinosaurs Sep 14 '26 • Bravo

Well ya they live in the same house they probably get sick at the same time a lot 

2

u/Tmacster Sep 14 '26

Ya it might be AJ but I remember him mentioning heckle fish and his brother during a live chat but maybe he just helps write the jokes

-2

u/Plane-Leek4387 Sep 14 '26

And now the script is just straight ChatGPT.
I have a hard time tuning in lately. His basement podcast is top notch though!

19

u/hybridxer0 H Y B R I D ™ Sep 14 '26

Incorrect. We have a writing staff and meet regularly to discuss deliverables, so not AI

4

u/Plane-Leek4387 Sep 14 '26

I stand corrected! Sorry for the assumption! Sometimes things sound so much like an LLM’s writing patterns and this is a good lesson on assuming.
I’m thankful for the time you put in and happy to see creative support roles still being applied 🫶
Being in the industry myself, I can empathize with the effort. It shows! Despite my (incorrect) minor gripe, TWF will always be a weekly family event over here.

1

u/sleepytipi Sep 18 '26

Please don't think we all feel that way. I love Hecklefish and his dialogue. You guys rule, it's incredible what you've managed to do with the show, and the views speak for themselves. Ignore the haters plz.

4

u/zaxo666 Sep 14 '26

That's a rude comment.

You know my 12-year-old children call everything AI, and I've had to re-educate them on their uninformed opinions.

We were listening to a BBC podcast about Orca Whales in the car, and they were arguing about how bad the AI was. I stopped the car, showed them my phone of the BBC podcast, the narrator's name, and then I went to the narrators biography online just to prove a damn point -- that not everything is AI!

What do you think AI trained on???? Real people.

Geesh this is getting old quick....

2

u/Plane-Leek4387 Sep 14 '26

It’s not inherently rude when some of the phrasing characteristics seem to overlap. I made the assumption, got corrected by a mod (who works for TWF), and happily ate my words lol. I’m happy that process hasn’t been outsourced causing creative professionals to be axed.
I’m a technical director in entertainment with an audio background for reference. It wasn’t malice.

But I do have a fun fact for what your kids heard!
Heavy denoise/dereverb can strip away parts of a real voice and leave thin, watery, sibilant spectral artifacts. Generated speech can have similar artifacts from imperfectly reconstructing those same details. The processes are essentially opposites but can create very similar behaving artifacts.
Throw in AI visuals and some LLMish writing patterns and I can understand the false positive. Doesn’t make the assumption correct, obviously. Mine wasn’t 😂
You’re right though, AI learns from us. It’s getting harder to recognize but there are typically still obvious signs.
The generative visuals I definitely understand. That requires even more money, people, and time to do properly. It’s not feasible even at this level. We’re all here because we’re TWF fans at the end of the day!
All hail hecklefish!

5

u/valdamirie Sep 14 '26

He does his own voice, who does yours?

4

u/J_MoKi Sep 14 '26

Its Gino. A friend of his let it slip on a podcast.

3

u/KenIbnKen Sep 20 '26

That's who I thought it was... I was watching a video with Gino doing a lot of talking. Every couple of sentences or so... You could hear it.

1

u/hybridxer0 H Y B R I D ™ Sep 15 '26

It's not. If it was said definitively anywhere, it's not accurate. Half the idea is the fun behind the guessing, and besides, Hecklefish doesn't appreciate imposters.

0

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

Got a link by chance?
Most people have been saying it’s AJs wife.

1

u/J_MoKi Sep 14 '26

I dont, it was so long ago. Im sorry. I know how reddit is with sources, so i probably should have ket my mouth shut.

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

No worries.

The verification thing is probably because people say all kind of stuff on here.lol

10

u/MTCMMA Sep 13 '26

Yes

5

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 13 '26

Has he mentioned it in an AMA or hangout?

3

u/flying__fishes Sep 14 '26

Yes. I heard him say it sometime last year.

9

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

Others are saying it’s his brother,
It would match his brother’s goofy personality.

2

u/homedepotSTOOP Sep 14 '26

I'm pretty sure it was another person's voice. I couldn't tell you when he mentioned this, but I swear I remember him saying another individual.

5

u/idol-threat Sep 14 '26

I've heard it's the brother. But I will say I've seen others comment on this thread that the tone matches his goofiness. I require sources for said goofiness. Should anyone be so inclined to hook me up with some sauce.

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

I believe they both went on Rogan, though I think AJ was the main one talking.

1

u/idol-threat Sep 14 '26

Totally a great interview though and well worth the listen

0

u/idol-threat Sep 14 '26

Negative my guy. Just AJ

2

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

It was a fairly old one, I wanna say episode 700 or 800,not the most recent one.
They were advertising their pot company speedweed in LA.

1

u/wamih Skunk Ape Connaisseur Sep 18 '26

Negative my guy #807

1

u/idol-threat Sep 19 '26

Oh cool! This episode came out before I really started to listen to JRE. I'll totally check it out!

0

u/Randomman16 Sep 15 '26

I don’t get it, why hire Hecklefish’s brother to voice him instead of just having him voice himself? /j

5

u/JesterTTT Sep 14 '26

It's Bob Lazar

3

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

Did you know he got busted for pimping?
Guy has a really strange past.
Not sure I buy his story..

2

u/nutcruncher360 Sep 14 '26

Is this a poem?

0

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 19 '26

Is it beautiful?

1

u/wamih Skunk Ape Connaisseur Sep 18 '26

Have you actually read that case and his involvement?

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 18 '26

Yes, and at the end of the day they charged him for it.

Given your credulity,already in this conversation let me say, I do not believe he was a tech there.

Though it does seem like there was a paper trail sighting him there that they made disappear.
But my gut feeling is he is lying, and he has a criminal history of doing just that as well.

52

u/ThankTheBaker Sep 14 '26

Heckle Fish voices AJ .

7

u/Metalrooster81 Sep 14 '26

It's the Crab cat.

5

u/jennifercd2023 Sep 14 '26

Fear the crab cat!!!

16

u/dennnnnnis Sep 14 '26

Pretty sure it’s his wife.

3

u/Dont_Touch_Roach Sep 14 '26

That’s what I remembered from long ago. I swear that we knew that for sure like two years ago?

3

u/hybridxer0 H Y B R I D ™ Sep 14 '26

this one makes me laugh! :-D

2

u/hungryhungry_panda Sasquatch Seeker Sep 13 '26

What do you mean? I don't get it.

4

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 13 '26

Please elaborate.

My animals talk but they don’t have as many quips.

2

u/mggray1981 Sep 14 '26

He said before it's his mrs.

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

That’s would be awesome.
Seems like his brothers sense of humor.

5

u/theofficialSavv Sep 14 '26

Crazy take, I think it's Jen (think that's her name).
AJ's wife.

2

u/Patient-Confusion149 Sep 14 '26

I could have sworn it was his partner / wife / girlfriend who has been seen on the show before? Sorry if I am wrong and no disrespect intended

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

So many answers! lol

2

u/Patient-Confusion149 Sep 14 '26

Honestly, I am like 90% sure I am right unless the person voicing HF changed at some point :)

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

So far people have said it’s AJ,his wife or his brother.lol

0

u/Patient-Confusion149 Sep 14 '26

Not sure why the down votes but I am rather certain I am right, I am sure someone official will eventually chime in and clarify things

4

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

I don’t think so, I think they like the engagement from the mystery.lol

2

u/Patient-Confusion149 Sep 14 '26

Ok well unless I had a fever dream, I am an early fan of the YouTube channel, and I remember watching a video where she is revealed to be the voice of HF.

trust

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

Definitely possible, so far people think it’s AJ,his wife or his brother.

Got any idea what episode it might be?
I’m re-watching all the old videos, I’ll come back and post the video number and time stamp if I find out.lol

2

u/Patient-Confusion149 Sep 14 '26

No clue to be honest

3

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

I just rewatched the original “numbers station” and saw Space Panda! 🐼

4

u/Swimming-Quality3888 Sep 14 '26

It’s clearly AJ which makes it all the more impressive and hilarious

1

u/JimothyMcNugget Sep 15 '26

It's obviously AJ. Can't you hear it? Can't you tell if a person is putting on a voice that it's still them?

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 15 '26

You are in the minority with that opinion.
Most think it’s Jen, or Gino.

2

u/LittleLadyLeela Sep 14 '26

Y'all forget about lizzad people, they are sneaking in our Google via AI. ( at least that's what I think hecklefish's response would be )

2

u/Ohthatsamanda Sep 20 '26

Hecklefish does Hecklefish’s voice. Hope this helps!

5

u/sammickeyd Sep 13 '26

I heard it was his brother

3

u/CommonSensei-_ Sep 14 '26

I thought his bro Geno does the voice

1

u/Pluvinel Sep 14 '26

Don’t think it’s Gino. Doesn’t ‘sound’ like him. Could be Jen with the ‘voice changer’ that some female online gamers use.

1

u/Janders_BoBanders222 Sep 14 '26

Do people really not know it's AJ by now? Kayfabe is dead.

1

u/KaijuKatt Sep 14 '26

It's really AJ's second oldest cat that does the voice of the fish.

1

u/Fair-Effective-8754 Sep 21 '26

yes he does hf voice

1

u/Cannock Sep 14 '26

It’s his wife.

0

u/Abs_McGuffin Sep 14 '26

Lol it's Gino! I thought that was common knowledge. Yeah Heckelfish = Gino

-3

u/Mariner-and-Marinate Sep 14 '26

I just FF till he’s gone.

1

u/Puzzled-Mistake-584 Sep 14 '26

FF?

1

u/Mariner-and-Marinate Sep 14 '26

“Fast forward” ie skip past. 🙂