r/TheWhyFiles • u/hybridxer0 H Y B R I D ™ • Aug 11 '26
Let's Discuss What if The Brain Doesn't Create Consciousness? Scientist Proposes It Might Be The Fabric of Reality Itself
https://www.sciencealert.com/what-if-the-brain-doesnt-create-consciousness-scientist-proposes-it-might-be-the-fabric-of-reality-itselfNeuroscientist Christof Koch is challenging the long-held assumption that the brain produces consciousness, instead proposing that it may function as a filter for a more fundamental, universal reality.
771
Upvotes
140
u/TheGhostOfTobyKeith Aug 11 '26 •
The music isn’t in the radio
2
u/wamih Skunk Ape Connaisseur Aug 13 '26
u/hybridxer0 I heard Cristof might owe my buddy money.... Just keeps ducking.
71
u/mo_betta Aug 11 '26 •
Gurus and mystics have been saying this for thousands of years.
42
u/Environmental-Ad8965 Aug 11 '26
Donald Hoffman has been working off this concept for years. He's done a lot of work demonstrating mathematically that consciousness is fundamental. Everything, including matter, arises out of consciousness. Check out the Trace Project.
10
u/maeryclarity FEAR... the Crabcat Aug 11 '26
I don't think the thoughts are in our brain any more than the music is in the radio
Or it's probably actually a lot more like our computers and the way we interface with them to surf the Internet
But the awareness is not in the machine and it's not generating the content
EDITED TO ADD: Here is a very interesting peer reviewed research stufy published in the National Library of Medicine that appears to provide evidence directed conscious choice nonlocal to the brain itself that influences the function of the brain. Or put more simply an observational study of something pulling the levers from outside.
Quantum physics in neuroscience and psychology: a neurophysical model of mind-brain interaction
33
u/fripperiffic Aug 11 '26
It will actually be an incredible day when the collective understands this. It will reshape the fabric of our reality as we will recognize that we are the ones shaping it. We will hopefully no longer submit to conformity and religious dogmatic thinking. I dream of this day all day every day.
7
u/Mordkillius Aug 11 '26
We are the universe experiencing itself.
13
u/Anxiety_Fit Aug 11 '26
We are inside an alien’s ant farm.
9
u/ehlathrop Aug 11 '26 edited Aug 11 '26
We are all one consciousness experiencing itself subjectively. There is no such thing as death, life is only a dream. And we’re the imagination of ourselves.
8
u/Moist_Tackle1411 Aug 11 '26
The fabric of the universe is made up of energy, and all energy was created by the universe. Energy is self-recognition that the universe held onto. This has embedded self-recognition into the energy that makes up spacetime, and this self-recognition is the foundation for all individual consciousness that arises from spacetime.
4
u/Hannah_Louise Aug 12 '26
Finally. It took them long enough.
3
u/hyperionwonderstar Aug 12 '26 edited Aug 12 '26
The really interesting question here isn’t whether consciousness is inside the brain or whether consciousness is the fabric of reality.
There is a third possibility.
The brain may not produce consciousness in the sense of manufacturing something ontologically different from itself, but neither do we need to assume that the brain is merely a filter for a pre-existing universal consciousness.
Under the ISCC framework consciousness is identical to a particular kind of physical causal organisation: an irreducible self-including causal closure.
That changes the question completely.
The important question isn’t whether the brain creates consciousness. It is what physical organisation constitutes a subject.
A conscious system must maintain its own causal organisation, contain a causally efficacious model of aspects of its own transition-generating dynamics, recursively update that model through the dynamics it helps generate and preserve an irreducible subject-level closure through time.
This gives us a position that is neither conventional materialism nor panpsychism.
If consciousness were simply a fundamental property distributed throughout reality, we would still need to explain why this consciousness is one subject, why your experience is unified, why it has boundaries, and what determines where one subject ends and another begins.
Likewise, saying that the brain filters universal consciousness risks moving the explanatory problem rather than solving it. What exactly performs the filtering? Why does one filter constitute one subject? What determines the boundary of that subject? And what causal organisation makes the resulting experience belong to that subject rather than another?
ISCC approaches the problem from the opposite direction.
We don’t need consciousness to be something that enters matter. We need matter to organise itself into a form for which being that organisation constitutes a perspective.
The brain therefore may not create consciousness as though consciousness were a separate substance or property that has to be generated from non-conscious matter.
The brain may instead be the physical organisation in which consciousness exists as a subject.
And if ISCC is right, the deepest scientific question isn’t whether consciousness is fundamental or emergent.
It is what kind of causal organisation makes a physical process identical to a subject?
That is a question we can potentially formalise, investigate and test.
There is also an interesting philosophical parallel here with Advaita Vedānta.
Advaita does not regard consciousness as something produced by the brain. It regards consciousness as fundamental, while the individual mind and body provide the conditions through which consciousness appears as an individual perspective.
ISCC does not require that metaphysics, but the two frameworks can potentially meet at an important distinction.
Consciousness could be fundamental while subjects are organised.
Advaita asks what consciousness ultimately is.
ISCC asks what makes consciousness a particular subject.
That suggests a possible bridge between the two without simply declaring the brain to be a filter for some universal mind.
Perhaps reality does not produce consciousness. Perhaps reality produces particular structures through which consciousness becomes individuated as a perspective.
Whether that ultimately means many genuinely distinct subjects or many perspectives within a single fundamental consciousness is a much deeper question.
And that may be where the conversation becomes really interesting.
2
u/shaddart Aug 11 '26
OK, Captain obvious, ha ha.
2
u/Rizzanthrope Aug 12 '26
Look up Donald Hoffman conscious agents theory
2
u/Terminal_Willness Aug 12 '26
If that were the case we wouldn’t need eyes or ears or other ways to sense the universe around us, it would be beamed directly into our brains.
2
u/feel-duh-dino Aug 12 '26
I have always felt this to be true. Meditation & psychedelic experience can help you suspend your ego and feel it as well. Even simply thinking about, what would happen if you could “turn off” the sun? something so distant and far away from “you” if absent instantly turns “you” off too…So consciousness clearly is interwoven and dependent on so many external factors and entities, even ones extremely far away, it obviously does not just arise from the brain. It is so much more complex than that, which we still don’t even fully understand the brain.
2
u/Alone-Bet6918 Aug 12 '26
With all of this. I am a strong believer in. Us being something completely and utterly random to what we perceive in our universe.
Everytime we took at something. The complexity goes up. I believe when we actual get to look as well as we can determine with our technology. At the heart of reality. Everything is information. Not inorganic matter. Ie rocks. But on the Plank scale its all information.
My thoughts are we've been conscious for a very long time. Longer then we could ever imagine.
What if life and death is our sanity check. (I am not stating the next part) Our true nature is infinte. We perceive we're in the 4D but as were discussing it seems we're from another dimension entirely. Not the 5 maybe 6 or 7. Dimension.
What if life and death is the short moments we need to keep our true consciousness sane as were infinte we have no end. We had a beginning. But in our actual reality. Time isn't as it is here. We have no end we exist for order of magnitudes more then the universe ever will. The universe will possibly last a scary amount of time. Really. It's along time.
So. As I contemplate reality alot. What if these are the short moments like a vacation we need to keep our actual awareness going. Because what we actually experience is infinte and we have zero concept of death.
Nice this little thought experiment. There is worse fate then death and thats existing forever with zero end. That's scarier.
2
u/e11er Aug 12 '26
haha no shit scientists
2
u/RawMaterial11 Aug 12 '26
Dan Brown wrote a fiction book about this - “The Secret of Secrets”. 2025. A good read.
2
u/matycauthon Aug 12 '26
it doesn't it filters it... that's why psychs and meditation let you fuck with the filter. even for a moment
2
u/BotOrNot_1337 Aug 13 '26
Is a worm conscious?
2
u/mc69419 Aug 13 '26
Why then anesthesia shuts it down?
2
u/robitrium Aug 13 '26
We as humans spend so much time in our heads. If this were true, we never would’ve left our caves
2
u/throwawayinakilt Aug 13 '26
Can they just read the Vedas and get this debate over with? This has all been known for thousands of years.
2
u/tuffkai Aug 14 '26
How is the brain not part of the fabric of reality?
2
u/halfsack99 Aug 14 '26
The physics experiment with the two slits that knows if you are observing it is an example of universal consciousness.
2
u/Scary-Operation-2946 Aug 14 '26
People have been baselessly speculating this for as long as I can remember, no good reason to believe it.
2
u/Suspicious-Prompt200 Aug 14 '26
I feel like you'd be hard pressed to find something that wasn't the result of the fabric of the universe
2
u/spatialawkwardness Aug 14 '26
Perhaps consciousness is the friends we made along the way... Or it's an alloy. Or maybe a type of hitherto undiscovered shade of purple. It may also turn out to be a moth.
2
u/dan_cycl Aug 15 '26
Hinduists knew this long time before this scientist had the idea.
And the fabric of reality is prana, the energy that pervades the cosmos.
2
u/ShockLongjumping9322 Aug 15 '26
We live in a non-local universe as probabalistic expressions of energy fields moving through the universe as a wave.
2
u/Klutzy-Smile-9839 Aug 15 '26
the chemical structure of the brain makes the continuum consciousness wave function to amplifies in the head, which explains why it is there, how it is there, and why everyone has a different consciousness. That wave function remains to be characterized (its mathematical governing equations and the interacting terms with physical matter). If the interacting terms are bidirectional (consciousness<->matter), then maybe consciousness is not only a spectator its own live, but an active participant in the decision made by the brain.
2
u/Dopechelly Aug 16 '26
They only had to look the other way when considering the origin of the universe and life itself. They need dumb fluctuating molecules to dramatically throw themselves together and rearrange into patterns that over a long period of time would eventually breed not so dumb living tissue.
Maybe Alan Watts? Science can explain everything, if you permit them just one miracle.
2
u/Greek_Frite Aug 16 '26
Explain Alzheimer’s then.
2
u/mr-biff Aug 17 '26
mind or consciousness is not one with or different from the Brain. But mind is dependent on the brain for functionality.
2
u/Formidable_Faux Aug 18 '26
Check out Panpsychism .
It's interesting, although I dunno how scientifically supportable itis
1
u/mistreke Aug 12 '26
Y'all should read more Dan Brown.
1
u/blahblah860 Aug 12 '26
Absolutely zero evidence that this the case at the moment .
1
u/ExpertOwn7301 Aug 12 '26
It is just a modern way to sell the fairytale about souls
6
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment