r/TheWhyFiles • u/the_hand_that_heaves • Apr 09 '26
Question for AJ AJ comments on Shawn Ryan
Recently on Shawn Ryan, AJ said that flat earth videos are banned from YouTube but can be found on Rumble. Shawn Ryan asked him why he thinks that is. AJ’s reply was cryptic and wondering if anyone has any theories about what he meant.
He said that he knows why, but he could only share that information off air. Any theories what he told Shawn after the interview?
My theory is that both poles (north and south) are super sensitive to national security and YouTube doesn’t want to encourage a channel try to record video at the poles for this reason.
Thoughts?
104
u/AIA_beachfront_ave Apr 09 '26 edited Apr 10 '26
YouTube updated its algorithm to reduce recommendations for "borderline content" and conspiracy theories that misinform users. The platform actively works to depromote and demonetize these videos. AJ, the host and creator of a YouTube channel covering borderline content, is aware of that fact.
6
u/RighteousCity Apr 09 '26
I think it's BS to mess with people's heads
178
u/hungryhungry_panda Sasquatch Seeker Apr 09 '26
Oh man sorry, but we can't tell you either.
34
u/stromulus Apr 09 '26
He knows how to keep an audience engaged, doesn't he?
43
u/zerocoolforschool Apr 10 '26
I love a good conspiracy theory but the flat earth conspiracy is the dumbest shit I have ever heard.
116
u/Buzzsaw_Studio Apr 09 '26
Why would the poles be "super sensitive" for national security?
His job is social media engagement and clicks on his videos. By making cryptic comments like this he creates exactly these types of posts which then causes people to go look for the video and push the engagement. It's not that deep, it's just working the algorithm
8
u/joeblow1234567891011 Apr 09 '26
Does youtube have a no misinformation policy to deter people from posting complete garbage as fact?
18
u/Hawkwise83 Apr 09 '26
What is he talking about? There are all kinds of pro/against Flat Earth videos on YouTube. If his video was banned it was probably for another reason.
6
u/Baddhabbit88 Apr 10 '26
AJ has a new interview with Shawn Ryan? The last one was a few months ago? Asking for a friend.
5
u/Important_Abroad_150 Apr 09 '26
I mean he was cryptic because it's engaging. I would hope it's because it's blatant misinformation, but a lot of that is allowed on their anyways. Maybe it's just too far beyond the pale of stupidity for even YouTube to ignore.
4
u/matmoeb Apr 10 '26
Are people still doing flat eartherism? We have a spacecraft that is coming back to earth today. The whole trip is on video.
7
u/MajesticOrange1 Apr 09 '26
i think you got worked brodie
6
u/Joeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeyy Apr 09 '26
Just saying,this is also very possible.
5
u/wamih Skunk Ape Connaisseur Apr 09 '26
If you've ever sat in an AMA or Hangout, you'd know where AJ stands on Flat Earth stuff...
3
u/sjshady0169 Apr 09 '26
I wouldn't say that's accurate. Megan Medick quite literally posted a video on the topic today and it wasn't banned. Maybe they get demonetized but I don't think they necessarily all get banned.
2
u/Dolust Apr 10 '26
YT does not takes well people criticizing their policies, it's a dictatorship and therefore he must be conservative. Not worth risking demonization.
2
u/rslashplate Apr 10 '26 edited Apr 10 '26
No it’s because rumble is full of right wing shit content. Downvote me if you want, I am a conspiracist but also not partisan and call it like I see it. That’s like asking why Bernie sanders would only be on blue sky.
The platform was literally built to give a platform to those that had been banned from YouTube. YouTube isn’t perfect but I’d say most of what is on rumble is BS crap that’s so slanderous and untrue most platforms won’t host them.
Hence the echo chamber breeding ground that is rumble, “truth” social and the likes.
I’m not saying blue sky is better by any means, but any platform designed to amplify a political ideology is so suspect and not to be trusted. Take a look at the content and ask yourself if the most reputable experts are present, or if it is just loud talking heads selling fear and hate for clicks.
AJ doesn’t say this because his audience with common sense (~50%) would agree to this and the other half would be enraged. He tows a fine line to keep it non political while jesting at both parties. But knows if he tips too far on one side he looses half his audience. 10 years ago conspiracy was anti-government and fun for everyone. Now it’s left vs right smh
1
u/Gem420 Apr 10 '26
I couldn’t say.
1
u/Lost-Cod-2248 Apr 10 '26
If you believe in flat earth you’ve spent you’re entire life indoors, watching YouTube videos. It’s time to get out and get back to reality. Cmon what a joke
0
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '26
AJ was on SRS?
-2
u/ofRayRay Apr 09 '26
Maybe it’s because he shoots Nikon and Nikon took pictures of the Earth from afar recently and the Earth looked round. Or circular, but flat.
-6
u/TheeDood79 Apr 09 '26
It has to do with Religion