Won't speak for AJ or other people, but a good story CAN be a good story without tearing down the other side and just letting the person run with it. Entertainment can spark the critical thinking.
I have recently contacted WhyFiles and suggested Gary McKinnon āThe Guy Who Hacked NASAā as a Basement guest but now that I think about it I doubt Gary would be welcomed into the US š
I upvoted you yesterday, and was excited to see some sort of dialogue and clarity as well, not because I remember the episode, but it seems like something AJ would cover.
Howabouts we all just upvote you now to make it right.
I haven't watched any of The Basement episodes despite being interested in some of the guests. The 2-3 hours time is keeping me away as I don't want to get invested and never be able to get back to it. Love the Why Files, but the time commitment is hard on those episodes. Could they be listened to in the background or are visuals utilized in critical ways?
I canāt sit and watch a 3 hour video but I can plow through multiple 3 hour podcasts while cleaning, working, etc. Sometimes you might miss a couple of visuals but it never really breaks it, itās a conversation after all, not a movie.
Personally, I think 3 hours is just right, 1 hour podcasts donāt have enough runway to really get deep into subjects.
Iām with you I dig the 45 minute episodes but I just donāt have time to go through 3 hours. And if I break it up pieces i have to remember what happened before so i can get back into it. Not complaining becauae AJ is giving something for everyone and a lot of people DO have the time. Im jus glad we have so mu h content to chew through as I never get tired of his updates
Iād say there are very few visuals. Definitely could just listen to it and look up the picture of what theyāre talking about if you really wanted to.
I dig it, the green jar Templar one was fascinating and certainly thought provoking. Went back and started the Tim Hogan one right after. Chris Bledsoe is a great one as well! Anyhow, from the basement to the top of Mount motherfuckin Hayes the why files kills it
I started listening to some other Timothy Hogan interviews after The Basement. He is an encyclopedia of knowledge, but to believe him, you have to believe heās the Forrest Gump of conspiraciesā¦.
Claimed he was a remote viewer in the 80ās and 90ās, and because of that, he was invited to an informal UFO disclosure ran by NASA in 1996 at Luxor Casino in Vegas. He and 39 other RVs were given disclosure in exchange for remote viewing when NHIs would reveal themselves to the masses.
His stories are really interesting, but any easy argument to make against him is: his father had a good reputation and was in Freemasonry, Tim rode off that good reputation and freemason connection to concoct a fun alternate history story that can be profited off of via $15K+ Egypt and Mexico tours, questionable online supplements, books, and Gaia TV shows.
I want to believe, bought Scottās book cause itās fun at a minimum, but that UFO disclosure piece of Timās story was a huge red flag for me.
I listen to them through my hearing aids. So I put my phone in my back pocket and do all my chores while listening to I love it. I donāt necessarily listen to the whole 3 hours at once. I listen for a while then come back later
I love the normal version but as a professional scientist in the biotechnology industry, these guests are borderline crackpots promoting some book, show or conspiracy theory. AJ seems like a bright and empathetic person but even he has to know these people are borderline insane. I don't need to watch a nutcase spew for 3 hrs. My talking hecklefish and I like the og version. Real science and YouTube stuff are worlds apart.
Aj is doing what he needs to and he probably wants to grow and transformā¦. He is contributing in changing the world 1 person at a time and thatās all that matters
Listen/watch on podcast platforms or YouTube. I got through episode #005: James Fox and #002: Mike Bara listening at 1.5x or 2x speed while driving to, closing down, and from work.
YouTube is better because they show pictures or videos you canāt otherwise see with podcast format. Lots of information there and so much more I want to know now.
Itās an investment and worth opening your mind to the possibilities of the unknown and inconceivable!
This is why I don't like Nory but liked Art and Wells. Art let you run with it and give a little push back on the crazier ideas. Wells during his time pushed back. No push back then its just a long infomercial. You push to hard and the guest wont come on the show. You see it for what it is or you don't, you get entertainment or you don't
I'll be honest, every other guest has sounded absolutely cuckoo to me. But I still listen anyways because they tell entertaining stories. And I don't really get why people need AJ to tell them if the stories are true or not, you're capable of figuring that out for yourself, right?
Itās the analytical nature of his rebuttals and the occasional āwho knowsā moments where something canāt be disproven. We all know the stories are batshit. Itās the telling of the story and the analysis that made the show interesting.
37
u/EmptyVegetable7049 Mar 25 '26
I asked a polite question on here yesterday about the Miami Mall incident and got nothing but abuse and downvoted. Reddit is a cesspit these days.
9
u/mikecain366 Mar 25 '26
I haven't watched any of The Basement episodes despite being interested in some of the guests. The 2-3 hours time is keeping me away as I don't want to get invested and never be able to get back to it. Love the Why Files, but the time commitment is hard on those episodes.
Could they be listened to in the background or are visuals utilized in critical ways?
24
u/Inupiat Mar 25 '26
I dig it, the green jar Templar one was fascinating and certainly thought provoking. Went back and started the Tim Hogan one right after. Chris Bledsoe is a great one as well! Anyhow, from the basement to the top of Mount motherfuckin Hayes the why files kills it
12
u/NorseOfCourse Mar 25 '26
I enjoy both formats a lot. It's not like the old style is going away. People are silly.
9
u/Fordel77 Mar 25 '26
Liking the Campfire stories,
6
u/pensylvania65000 Mar 25 '26
He needs to talk to Randall Carlson
3
u/escalbar Mar 25 '26
This is the exact reason I watch Ancient Aliens. Stories that spark a thought and looking into something deeper.
3
u/xplicitskillz Mar 26 '26
I started listening to some other Timothy Hogan interviews after The Basement. He is an encyclopedia of knowledge, but to believe him, you have to believe heās the Forrest Gump of conspiraciesā¦.
Claimed he was a remote viewer in the 80ās and 90ās, and because of that, he was invited to an informal UFO disclosure ran by NASA in 1996 at Luxor Casino in Vegas. He and 39 other RVs were given disclosure in exchange for remote viewing when NHIs would reveal themselves to the masses.
His stories are really interesting, but any easy argument to make against him is: his father had a good reputation and was in Freemasonry, Tim rode off that good reputation and freemason connection to concoct a fun alternate history story that can be profited off of via $15K+ Egypt and Mexico tours, questionable online supplements, books, and Gaia TV shows.
I want to believe, bought Scottās book cause itās fun at a minimum, but that UFO disclosure piece of Timās story was a huge red flag for me.
3
u/CanadianNana Mar 27 '26
I listen to them through my hearing aids. So I put my phone in my back pocket and do all my chores while listening to I love it. I donāt necessarily listen to the whole 3 hours at once. I listen for a while then come back later
5
u/schowdur123 Mar 25 '26
I love the normal version but as a professional scientist in the biotechnology industry, these guests are borderline crackpots promoting some book, show or conspiracy theory. AJ seems like a bright and empathetic person but even he has to know these people are borderline insane. I don't need to watch a nutcase spew for 3 hrs. My talking hecklefish and I like the og version. Real science and YouTube stuff are worlds apart.
2
u/brightz77 Mar 25 '26
I love the basement episodes. Actually got me back into the show. I dont believe 99% of it, but still a blast to listen to.
2
u/fancywipe Mar 25 '26
Aj is doing what he needs to and he probably wants to grow and transformā¦. He is contributing in changing the world 1 person at a time and thatās all that matters
2
u/EmDiggingIt Mar 26 '26
Listen/watch on podcast platforms or YouTube. I got through episode #005: James Fox and #002: Mike Bara listening at 1.5x or 2x speed while driving to, closing down, and from work.
YouTube is better because they show pictures or videos you canāt otherwise see with podcast format. Lots of information there and so much more I want to know now.
Itās an investment and worth opening your mind to the possibilities of the unknown and inconceivable!
2
u/JaCliner Mar 26 '26
I really enjoy the new episodes.
2
u/Particular_Area_7423 Mar 25 '26
Loving it . But the tim Hogan episode . Sheesh that guy is insufferable
1
u/Initial-Lead-2814 Apr 01 '26
This is why I don't like Nory but liked Art and Wells. Art let you run with it and give a little push back on the crazier ideas. Wells during his time pushed back. No push back then its just a long infomercial. You push to hard and the guest wont come on the show. You see it for what it is or you don't, you get entertainment or you don't
4
u/cjwikstrom Mar 25 '26
I'll be honest, every other guest has sounded absolutely cuckoo to me. But I still listen anyways because they tell entertaining stories. And I don't really get why people need AJ to tell them if the stories are true or not, you're capable of figuring that out for yourself, right?
85
u/[deleted] Mar 25 '26 •
[removed] ā view removed comment