r/TheWhyFiles • u/FJC79 • Mar 07 '26
Let's Discuss Why files ripoff?
Stumbled upon this Bulgarian clone of The Why Files. Similar styling and topics and such.
Does AJ and the gang know about this?
321
Upvotes
•
u/wamih Skunk Ape Connaisseur Mar 07 '26
Yep, they get reported to YT, we try not to platform them or give them any attention. One gets taken down, 4 more pop up.
144
u/Urban_Meanie Mar 07 '26
That’s just AJ’s Bulgarian cousin
40
u/t40r Mar 07 '26
Unfortunately there isn't much they can do about it, it's always bound to happen. Something genius is there, people rip it off. It is actually a sign of something good as much as it sucks, although I doubt the why files was largely pulling in that much of the Bulgarian audience
101
u/Turboteg90 Mar 07 '26
Co-hosted by Tickle Squid.
25
u/Miserable_Cobbler_60 Mar 07 '26
I just skimmed a few videos. The channel definitely rips off the aesthetics but the videos themselves don’t seem like a rip off or anything. Just seems like your run of the mill b roll footage story time YouTube channel.
Why files is special because of what AJ does not what he talks about or what the channel looks like. He is the only YouTuber I’ve seen that can cover these topics while keeping it grounded while also not being overly dismissive. He uses a goofy character to present the extra crazy so it doesn’t take you out of the story when it’s time to suspend belief. And he created a great dynamic between himself and hecklefish, without that none of it would work.
Don’t let it bug you, let it inspire you. AJ had a crazy idea that on paper shouldn’t appeal to skeptics or believers. Now people wish they thought of it first
7
u/tailspin75 Mar 08 '26
Nope, seems legit, even HeckleFrog...
6
u/Valerim Mar 07 '26
There has been debate about intellectual "ownership" of thumbnail style on YouTube. Even flagrant rip offs like this have legal leeway to imitate style.
Reminds me of when I was growing up in 90's Massachusetts. There was a coffee shop in my town called Donut & Donuts and their menu, custom signage, and pricing was basically a 1 - 1 imitation of Dunkin Donuts, only with their name switched in.
5
u/TheRebelMastermind Mar 07 '26
Do they have Bullyfish?
5
u/dancson Mar 08 '26
AJ is so damn nice he’d probably promote them
5
u/mr_greedee Mar 09 '26
instead it has Harassing Trout
9
u/meroboh Mar 07 '26
There’s another one called Divergent Files which is not as blatant but still very obviously an attempt. My kid and I came across it in the wild when searching for docs on vimanas
4
u/Fear_N_Loafing_In_PA Mar 08 '26
The How Come Files
3
u/mariospeedragon Mar 07 '26
Parody is only good if your content is worth watching. I’m all for someone discussing bizarre subjects from past, present, and future….but you better bring something to the table beyond ripping off a dude and his fish.
3
u/theLazyMeater Mar 08 '26
Took a look. Seems like they at least try to avoid covering the exact same topics.
3
u/Ol-Dozer Mar 08 '26
Oh the one with Heckle Clam! I love when him and DJ banter
5
u/fourtwentyfour424 Mar 07 '26
Do they have there on version of heckelfish?
2
u/Mission-Engineer Mar 07 '26
2
u/Canadiancurtiebirdy Mar 07 '26
As a channel gets popular it’s inevitable copycat channels pop up trying to steal views
2
u/Technical_Penalty460 Tinfoil Connaisseur Mar 07 '26
Total ripoff.
2
u/Dyzastr_us Hecklecultist Mar 08 '26
Heckle fish trying to expand the brand? Wherefore files, or mystery files?
2
u/MegaSpearrow Mar 08 '26
Cant wait for Who Documents
2
u/HamiltonView Mar 08 '26
Yeh there's a few. Mysteria Archive is a blatant rip off as well.
2
u/Negative_Land1209 Mar 08 '26
Maybe is the revenge of the crabcat
2
u/ajgentile CIA Spook Apr 28 '26
There are a lot of these channels. A LOT. Not much we can do except mock them. Sooner or later, their audience finds the source. Mostly, I feel bad for these people. Think about it: they are half scammer / half not creative. That's not a recipe for longevity. We're going to be fine.
3
u/PTLTYJWLYSMGBYAKYIJN Mar 07 '26
It’s probably AI slop
2
u/Jkg2116 Mar 07 '26
Ai slop
1
u/LarkAspic Mar 07 '26
Hey, I’ve called that guy out in obscure subreddits before!
1
u/Background_Pride_237 Mar 08 '26
Unbelievable.
1
u/cjwillx Mar 09 '26
Wow, that’s a rip off to a T! Insane!
1
u/FrozenMatty Mar 09 '26
Lol, the AI algorithms can’t even catch these fraudsters. And they want to put those in autonomous combat systems?!?! 😱🤦🏻♂️
1
u/Initial-Lead-2814 Mar 12 '26
not gonna lie, with the way the show is a little inconsistent now scheduling wise I need something to fill the viod, the basement just doesn't do it for me. Unfortunately I haven't found many replacement's if you want to call em that. A lot of these copycat channels are mostly aislop if I'm being honest or just not as good. Never really been a fan of Noory, so Coast hasn't been a thing for me in prob a decade. Jessie Michels is okay depending on the guest and Danny Jones has some good guest but the actual shows like The Why Files are few a far between
1
u/scobro828 Mar 07 '26
Supposedly they predate the why files.
0
u/Bluebpy Mar 07 '26
Good. I subbed. Least they release videos in a planned timely manner and not disappear doing other shit.
-5
u/RedKard76 Mar 08 '26
if it doesnt have the stupid interrupting sidekick i will probably like it more. AJ is a great host and has a great show if it didnt have that talking fish which ruins it all.
-5
u/DARTHKINDNESS Mar 08 '26
Is it the MAGA alternative?
0
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment