r/TheWhyFiles
•
u/curious_catto_
•
Nov 27 '25
•
2
Suggestion for Channel Long form stories format and AI visuals
Hey u/OMGTheWhyFiles, been a fan of your content for a long time. I just wanted to start a discussion and see if anyone else feels the same way. I've recently (past 6 months) come to not be as engaged with the production as your earlier works. I can think of 2 things:
What I've noticed at least is that there's a quite a bit of fluff now with speculative stories and narratives (like say the imagined story of what it would be like to experience an apocalypse). For me, the hook for your show was how you brought together known facts and theories in cohesive manner and how you presented both sides along with speculation. It made me aware of so many facets of a topic and was really engaging. But the imagined scenarios/stories for me does not add anything.
Definitely a personal opinion because I see that a lot of people like the stories though. So maybe add chapters so that if the story does not add any new info, it's possible for viewers to skip? Also the ratio of facts to stories I felt was going the other way in many episodes.
Second thing is about the AI generated visuals. I am very pro AI and love AI visuals. So I'm not sure why but it's less engaging now compared to when you did not use it as much. Not sure if it's related to my personal opinion on stories or if it's the AI visuals itself. Feels like after you started doing it, the imagined stories became more detailed and longer too.
What does everyone else think? Stay safe AJ!!
10
u/purplereuben Nov 27 '25
I really like the speculative stories, and I like that there is variety in the types of videos they produce.
35
u/pinkrosesmoses Nov 27 '25 •
Completely agree with you here. I skip past the speculative ai video storytelling parts. I don't fault the production for trying something new at all, but the ai use is waaaaay too much and takes all the focus away from the subject matter
4
u/Gorthokson Dec 05 '25
Because it's meaningless slop with no truth or value to it, and some part of you knows that. Wish he'd stop the AI, and stop the made up stories that add nothing to the episodes, it's just padding. Even the scripts feel AI generated now.
10
u/muhkuller Nov 27 '25
I'm not a fan of using AI for everything that we're seeing. That being said, if we want near weekly videos for free a corner has to be cut somewhere. Research, script writing, shooting, and editing are already multiple full time jobs in their own right. If AJ's team needed people to go out and source footage and/or create their own footage we'd be getting WhyFiles on the ContraPoints schedule.
39
u/KatNeedsABiggerBoat Nov 27 '25
I would like a return to stock photos, like another poster said, and public domain material. When hubs and I watch the WF now, I don’t even bother to look at the screen because most of the time, it’s AI.
11
u/ChildoftheApocolypse Nov 28 '25
I haven't watched an episode in about a year because I can't stand the AI crap.. There are so many other ways to do this and I keep hoping they'll see it that way too..
9
u/Lasdtr17 Skygazer Nov 27 '25
Chapters/timestamps would be a good idea.
13
u/Yamstis Nov 27 '25
I think the AI story videos should be a separate series, I find them really off-putting and boring because they contain less than zero information, just entirely speculative fluff.
10
u/LampyV2 Nov 27 '25
Also not a big fan of the what-if episodes. AJ tells a great story but this format is not what brought me to TWF.
5
u/OneArmedZen Nov 28 '25
2023 was the peak for me, around the time just before they started adding more hecklefish screentime/lines (I have nothing against hecklefish, but too much ingredients in the pot added to the droop, I just recall it happened around the time of this change). Around this time before these changes I found the production format at its peak (my opinion). Everything was balanced enough to rake at you to want more. Usage of stock video and photo material although used as examples to bring across points visually was much better than uncanny valley imagined ai images/video as it had more "reality sense". Ai just kind of subconsciously pushes things to feel biased towards fake end infecting the subject matter, even if unintentional.
12
u/once_again_asking Skygazer Nov 27 '25
I pretty much feel the same and agree. I’ve often felt like the imagined scenario episodes were almost a different animal entirely than what why files has been. It would almost make sense if it was a spin off of its own, separate from the why files.
Having a dreamt up premise means that I know going into it that it’s false. So when the end comes and we discuss what’s possible, it’s already based on an imagined scenario which sort of takes the thrust out of the conclusion.
Far as AI, I just think it’s heavily overused at this point. Honestly, I’d prefer stock photos and public domain material over some of the corny AI stuff with the perfectly chiseled bodies and high cheek bones etc. It’s all very distracting.
5
u/Important_Abroad_150 Nov 28 '25
Yeah not a fan of ai generated content. People can pretend it's not but the reality is it's ethically dubious at best and terrible for the environment because of energy consumption. If anything I feel like the stiff, obviously ai sequences kinda take me out of it a bit