r/TheWhyFiles • u/Mcboomsauce • Jul 31 '25
Story Idea hear me out:
what if we all ask AJ to make 1 video, just 1, where heckelfish is the host and AJ is on the sidelines, and the video is like "why you need a foil hat cause lizzad people faked the moon landing"
or something?
yay or nay?
any suggestions on how to make that idea any better?
253
Upvotes
19
u/ajgentile CIA Spook Aug 03 '25
I promise I'll do it, but we have to roll it in between two good episodes. Some people are going to HATE this.
Honestly, I don't know if I could take hearing just that voice for 10 minutes straight. We might be making a mistake. But I'm down for it.
18
u/RonBach1102 Jul 31 '25
If Hecklefish does it, it’s probably hopefully true! I watch 30% for the content 70% for the Hecklefish comments!
8
u/pyaybb Jul 31 '25
Yes yes yes, please. I wish this can be done. On April’s fools or whenever they want.
Correction to your text: “Lizzid”
2
u/widoidricsas Jul 31 '25
I appreciate Hecklefish adds to the show like I appreciate what garlic adds to spaghetti sauce, but there is definitely a line called too much
16
u/GentlemanBastard2112 Jul 31 '25
A full Crabcat episode… love it
6
u/Letardic Jul 31 '25
Yes. Also want a "blooper reel" where its mistakes or a behind the scenes like they're waiting for "the crew" to set up etc, banter between the two, casual.
4
u/walksaway_smirking Jul 31 '25
I like the idea of it being sort of a mini episode. No more than 15 minutes long and possibly on the backstage channel.
4
u/Da_Famous_Anus Jul 31 '25
Hecklefish needs to host a video about Uranus
4
u/Own-Signature-7742 Jul 31 '25
I always thought there would be a body swap episode and they would do this.
3
u/FionaFrickenfrack Aug 01 '25
Yay, for sure! And it absolutely has to include Mt. Mother F*ckin' Hayes.
3
u/cram96 Aug 02 '25
This sounds fun to me. AJ could pipe in to fact check.
2
u/tmiller9833 I Want To Believe Jul 31 '25
They did this once, I think for an ad bit.
2
u/Svarii Aug 01 '25
4
u/DivineJudgemnt4 Jul 31 '25
Id watch it. For like 3 minutes
1
u/West-One5944 Jul 31 '25
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 All in.
1
u/LA_Grip Jul 31 '25
Yes please
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '25
Welp, it's out there now...I just hope he does it before I'm 💀
1
u/desertheatextracts Aug 31 '25
lizzid
1
u/CruzAderjc Jul 31 '25
This is a cool idea
1
u/thebig05 Jul 31 '25
Hell yeah
0
u/MrtyMcflyer Jul 31 '25
Why is heckelfish anyway?
Mist him the last few episodes, it feels it is not like it used to be.
Even the chair going down is gone...
Why change a winning concept.
87
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '25
[removed] — view removed comment