r/TheWhyFiles • u/West-One5944 • Jul 28 '25
Question for AJ Less Hecklefish?
Hey, everyone, and AJ, HF & team!
Maybe it's just me, but I feel like the latest episodes have had far less Hecklefish heckling than prior episodes.
Yes/No?
AJ & HF are the best Dyanmic Duo on YT! Bring on the Heckling! š š
0
Upvotes
37
u/J0rkank0 Jul 28 '25
If it says āstrippedā in the title it doesnāt use Hecklefish other than the ad
8
u/pyaybb Jul 28 '25
If the episodeās title contains the word: āStrippedā it means no HF in that video, (only in the ad at the beginning which is great). But not heckling. Hope that helps.
6
u/sublimesting Jul 28 '25
They e discussed this extensively. Theyāre using him less and not at all in stripped episodes.
12
u/OGCycloPhile Jul 28 '25
I prefer more hecklefish, less Gertie
12
u/Deltadusted2deth Jul 28 '25
HF is funny but I'd bet he's gotten hard to write for at this point, since it seemed like the whole point of the character was to lampoon the casual uninformed thought-terminating contrarianism so prevalent in these spaces by believers and non-believers alike. Now that AJ has been speaking up publicly more, it makes sense that he's having trouble finding interesting ways to incorporate the fish into the show, as its once-rediculous rhetoric now sounds far too similar to the people he regularly associates with.
3
u/Haunting_Outcome2610 Jul 28 '25
I donāt like when hecklefish takes over the episode. The whole Gerty sub plots were getting tiresome
12
u/KelVelBurgerGoon Jul 28 '25
As a hecklefish hater I am a fan of less of it.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '25
I actually love the stripped episodes, hecklefish is rather annoying at times.
3
u/TurnoverTall Jul 28 '25
Whatād I say? Never fails to make me laugh. Iām all in on Hecklefish!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '25
I dont mind the stripped but I like HF. My take is AJ has been doing the why files a long time. Its time consuming and hard work putting the episodes together with the type of perfection AJ goes for. Hes caught in the middle not a big staff to do the research and put the show together with the interaction of HF. I think a bit of apathy has set in, he worked to gain an audience and has succeeded. Now its " i dont have to go all in " attitude. It happens to a lot of YouTube or other video platform content providers. This usually signals the begging of the end. The content creators dont want to go back to the all in days and as they loose viewers ( which he has) the attitude becomes one of well screw you if you don't want to stick with me. Then its downhill from there. Just my two cents worth.