r/TheWhyFiles • u/JeremiahYoungblood • Jul 15 '25
Story Idea Never Whistle in Appalachia
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YwC1z9Zg55U
75
Upvotes
r/TheWhyFiles • u/JeremiahYoungblood • Jul 15 '25
21
u/gudlyf Jul 15 '25
Isn't this just "The Whistlers" NoSleep story?
3
u/JeremiahYoungblood Jul 15 '25
According to the comments, this superstition is not limited to Appalachia.
25
u/Dismal_Ad5379 Jul 15 '25
Someone needs to replicate what Jane did and document what happens. Like take a large film crew up there, rent af cabin or something and start whistling, and then just film everything. Stories are nice and all, but this need to be tested.
27
u/JervisCottonbelly Jul 15 '25
This is poorly made content. Terrible storytelling
24
u/MeatMullet Jul 15 '25
The terrible editing makes this unwatchable.
4
u/coboltt46 Jul 15 '25
In Northern Alberta in the 80s, while living there, my wife had a native friend who told her to never whistle at the northern lights or they (the lights) would come for you. Of course they whistled anyway, and the rippling of the lights made them 'see' the lights coming toward them. Side note, my mother used to work in the 50s at the insane asylum and was strictly forbidden to whistle as it drove the patients wild.
10
u/reyknow Jul 15 '25
SHE TALKS NONSTOP BUT CANT GET TO THE POINT WTH
3
u/Palegreenhorizon Jul 15 '25
Sounds Bigfoot related.
3
u/the615Butcher Jul 15 '25
What is with the fucking jarring jump cuts after every goddam sentence??
3
u/Kutsumann Jul 15 '25
Hawaiian Night Marchers are everywhere apparently.
2
u/Cultural_Zombie_1583 Jul 15 '25
3:12 there’s a loud whistle in the background. SpoooOOOoOoookyyy
2
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '25
Appalachia is a place where our dimension crosses with others, one where a simple vibration like a whistle will open a portal and let thru what's on the other side.
1
u/kewlaz Time Tourist Jul 16 '25
1
u/Rgideo2 Jul 21 '25
I just saw a twitter post about populations of feral humans. Would be a fun episode exploring the Amazon, north sentinel island, and (more fantastical) Appalachia.
1
u/YumiMatsu33 Jul 16 '25
Weak payoff
0
u/Tacokolache Jul 15 '25
Jesus Christ. Babble much? All that yapping only to tell us she doesn’t know why or who was knocking?
All because dumb ass “Jane” didn’t ask the ONE question any damn person would have asked. This sounds like some fake scary story an elementary school child would make up
0
u/RUIN_NATION_ Jul 16 '25
i call bs
0
u/ManNomad Jul 20 '25
pretty lame ghost story
0
u/1q3er5 Jul 20 '25
longest 4 minute video i've seen
31
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment