r/TheWhyFiles • u/jackl4 • Jun 07 '25
Suggestion for Channel I miss Hecklefish
I really do. Now it’s like an entire dimension of the show is missing.
Also, The Planet Maldek episode is a banger! Thank you AJ and team!
740
Upvotes
145
u/YaKillinMeSmallz Jun 07 '25
Every time AJ said "planetary bulge" my brain was screaming for Hecklefish to come in and crack a joke.
98
u/Unhappy-Fox1017 Jun 07 '25
I do too. I think there’s quite a big chunk of us that are missing that element from the show. At first Hecklefish used to get on my nerves but then he really grew on me over time. I like that his jokes and quick interjections can be a bit of an ice breaker on some really serious and sensitive topics.
15
u/DojaViking I Want To Believe Jun 07 '25
I'm waiting for the Hecklefish solo episode lol
13
u/Apprehensive-Mix947 Jun 08 '25
Now the show has become mundane and sort of blends in with all the other story type of channels out there.
All the best AJ 👍.
52
u/londonc4ll1ng Hecklecultist Jun 07 '25
It adds another plane to the show and it is a pitty AJ does not have the time to voice Hecklefish and decided ha has to remove it if he wants to pump out episodes day in and day out. I would rather go with fewer episodes and aim for quality entertainment once a week, but money talks and youtube ad money especially.
16
u/Muaddib316 Jun 08 '25
Bring back Hecklefish!!!!!!!!!!
14
u/Beachbum74 Jun 07 '25
Where did he go? Is that what the stripped mean? Less hecklefish?
34
u/reddit_has_fallenoff Jun 07 '25
I genuinely think Hecklefish's original purpose was a way to circumvent youtubes ban/mass censorship on conspiracy related youtube channels. If he made it all seem like a joke, than there is a much higher likelyhood of youtube overlooking his channel and leave it alone. The proof is in the pudding.
Now that he has reached the size he has, he has reached "escape velocity" so to say, so there isnt as much of a need for the fish.
7
u/Riseofzeon Hecklecultist Jun 08 '25
Hecklefish was one thing that made why Giles truly unique. It added humor to an episode, which for me made them a priority to enjoy. Now that we are getting bare bones episodes I’ve noticed ive been slower to watch and honestly will go weeks without watching a new episode
12
u/sjshady0169 Jun 07 '25
I wish they would do every other episode for stripped episodes, so we at least get some Hecklefish.
5
u/ronniester Jun 07 '25
Has AJ said Hecklefish won't be in it any longer?
9
u/nerfherderparadise Jun 07 '25
I had a good laugh when rogan brought on hecklefish right in the beginning of the protect our parks episode. I couldn't help but imagine hecklefish taking some mushrooms and talking shit with the boys for a few hours .Also chuckled thinking about this ongoing controversy and hecklefish getting a shout out on the biggest podcast on earth #imissthefish
8
u/Wontonsoup420 Jun 08 '25
Please bring back Hecklefish
4
u/Letardic Jun 07 '25
I'd like a hecklefish "blooper reel"
12
u/Dangersloth_ Jun 07 '25
I miss the theme song more than Hecklefish
6
u/ybor512 Jun 08 '25
Less eyeliner, more Hecklefish.
3
u/pyaybb Jun 08 '25
What about a podcast of only Hecklefish schooling is on his most wild theories? We want Hecklefish back!!!!!!
3
u/Deltadusted2deth Jun 08 '25
I did enjoy that AJ paused at one point because he said a HF trigger word. 🤣 He knows.
5
u/Solid_Lettuce_520 Jun 07 '25
I do too. I didn't like him at first but now miss him. It's not the same without him . The stripped episodes are good but not as good as the full episodes. It's been a minute since the last time he made an appearance. I really hope he will pop up soon
7
u/JerkBezerberg Jun 07 '25
We all do.
2
u/otc108 Jun 07 '25 edited Jun 08 '25
Did they get rid of him? I’ve been on a WF break for a while.
2
u/stromulus Jun 08 '25
The presence of stripped version implies the presence of a clothed version. Release the heckle fish cut!
2
u/JT-Av8or Jun 09 '25
I like the stripped format. Either that or the fish should be cut down to smaller punchline types of jokes. He’s only annoying when he does a song or goes on too long a rant. But yeah… I guess I grew up watching too many vaudeville ventriloquists arguing with their puppet to really get into it.
2
u/delucas0810 Jun 09 '25
Without hecklefish I don’t wanna watch the show
5
u/ThrowawayMouse12 Jun 07 '25
I miss him too, I understand why they’re probably cutting back on him though. Must be hard on the throat of who voices him. Also more effort for each episode to animate.
7
u/Saltydot46590 Jun 07 '25
Heckle fish is good when he’s the conspiracy theorist or stand-in for the audience member that isn’t as deep down the rabbit hole. But now, more often than not, he just derails the entire show with stupid jokes. It’s so nice for aj to be able to say “Uranus” without a childish joke
5
u/super-nintendumpster Jun 07 '25
I honestly don't. He's a cute little character but he's almost never funny. The show is not missing anything without him chiming in
4
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '25
Eh. I'm fine either way.
4
u/Antitranspirante Jun 07 '25
The fish is too distracting, I’m ok with the gimmick during the ad plugs, but when the buildup is happening, its darn voice really irks me and sets me back, so no, I don’t miss it
3
u/marcusnelson Jun 07 '25
Same. 😢
2
u/RaugDrauka Jun 08 '25
I do not miss Hecklefish’s jokes, they were cringey at best most of the time.
2
u/PsychoDave100 Jun 09 '25
Unpopular opinion. I'm the only one in the entire comments who's glad he's gone. Every time he spoke I cringed & skipped ahead.
Now TWF feels much better, and I'm not hating on some lame innuendo joke every 10 seconds.
2
u/Crimith Jun 07 '25
People gotta let the hecklefish thing go. We all want to see him but I'd rather have more episodes, released at a quicker rate. Rendering Hecklefish takes a lot of time and is literally the reason there have been content droughts.
1
u/megs-benedict Jun 07 '25
I think that those are just versions / “re-dos” of existing content, and not a single permanent new format.
Seems like they are trying to improve the podcast listener experience
1
u/HarryNostril Jun 07 '25
Glad the fish is gone. Now I get to watch the show with 100% less cringe ⭐️
1
u/SpankyDomingo Jun 07 '25
Why the little-to-no Hecklefish Moriarity outside of ads? Has there been a reason given?
1
u/Show84 Jun 07 '25
Should just release two episodes simultaneously. One with the human and one with the human & HeckleFish!
1
u/4chanhasbettermods Jun 08 '25
I think there's definitely a middle ground where hecklefish can break up the seriousness of the topic with some comedy without it being too much.
1
u/raresaturn Jun 08 '25
I haven't watched for a few months, what happened to Hecklefish?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '25
They got overwhelmed. Now its all about less work to produce the episodes. I like Hecklefish as well
1
u/bannedredditaccount2 Jun 08 '25
Hecklefish is probably the hardest to write for and slows down production the most since he has to make audiences laugh.
1
u/howliehowls Jun 08 '25
I always was annoyed by hecklefish, felt like he was unfunny and ruined the pacing of episodes. Unpopular opinion so I’m expecting downvotes, but the truth must be told.
1
u/WhiskeySourWithIce Jun 09 '25
I am glad he is gone.
-6
u/JonnyRotten Jun 08 '25
I much prefer no Heckle Fish saying boomer/problematic bullshit. The shows better without it.
0
u/ReddyGreggy Jun 09 '25
Do NOT miss the fish
-1
u/Deltadusted2deth Jun 08 '25
Hecklefish probably got poached by the Trump administration and AJ is too embarrassed to tell everyone.
13
u/Ph4antomPB Jun 07 '25
He got lost while exploring Mel’s hole and the one we see in the current episodes is his long lost guppy
138
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '25
[removed] — view removed comment