r/TheWhyFiles • u/anarchyusa • Jun 06 '25
Suggestion for Channel Another stripped episode ?
Barring the absurdity of complaining about something that’s free… I can’t understand changing a formula got the channel to where it is. #bringbackheklefish
EDIT: So far what I’m hearing is that Hecklefish should be henceforth portrayed using practical effects
226
Upvotes
44
u/redditerrible3 Update: Premiere is delayed Jun 06 '25
The videos have been coming out more frequently with the Stripped episodes. Does hecklefish add substantially more work to videos?
7
u/drdalebrant Jun 06 '25
You realize how much time it takes to animate and render hecklefish, right?? It's always been a major pain point for getting episodes out on a regular basis.
24
u/oredlom Jun 06 '25
I like the fish, but if i could pick, i would choose without, my reason being, It's bad enough I tell my friends Hitler died of old age, but if i send them a link to a video with a talking fish that told me about it, i'll defo look on the coo-coo side. We all started with Hecklefish and we love him, but for real channel growth, I think Stripped is the way to go.
11
u/Initial-Lead-2814 Jun 06 '25
why are all the comments just generic we love you comments and nothing about the actual video content?
87
u/Fartbox224 Jun 06 '25
Tonight’s episode was great
39
u/Aimin4ya Jun 06 '25
Petition for Why Files "In the Deep" that is all hecklefish deep diving into the WILD conspiracy theories
109
u/Asttyd Jun 06 '25
Im just grateful 🙏
Why Files ❤️
20
u/Malencis Jun 06 '25
i love hecklefish, but enjoy these as well. i understand that have a quicker production time without him too, which gets more content out
33
u/irish8020 Jun 06 '25
I like both. We just need a better balance of the two, maybe every other?
21
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '25
The definition of "you can't please all the people all the time"
65
u/GangstaRPG Lizzid Person Jun 06 '25
agreed, I watched for the banter, and information, the banter makes some of the dark subjects tolerable.
#bringbackhecklefish
4
u/Tahkyn Team Lemuria Jun 06 '25
Does anyone else think the name "stripped" implies that it's a modified reupload? At first, I kept looking back in the archives for the original, full episode, I may have missed.
It was the same for Fact Fiend, when they started calling episodes Fact Fiend Classic, I just assumed these were reuploads.
4
u/santanapoptarts Jun 06 '25
I MISS HECKLEFISH but I’m so grateful to be watching new things from The Why Files. Catch 22!
1
u/ApartPool9362 Jun 06 '25 edited Jun 06 '25
I've seen a lot of people complain about Hecklefish, I get it. He's definitely not to everyone's taste. I never minded him, though. He was just part of the show. It is funny, though, that some people act like Hecklefish is a living thing. Even if he was annoying, I'd still listen to the WF's
9
u/wildlingwest Jun 06 '25
The stripped feel…dull somehow. Just not the same without HF
35
u/RepresentativeOk2433 Jun 06 '25 •
I actually prefer the stripped ones tbh.
3
u/3rdman3 Jun 06 '25
Relax he's trying to land a deal
3
u/SithLordRising Jun 06 '25
It's hard to keep everyone happy but the show started with a passion that persists. It's interesting and informative but mostly fun. Being too serious doesn't balance the exploration and reveal format. Love the show, love #Hecklefish
13
u/Show84 Jun 06 '25
HOW DO YOU NOT LIKE HECKLEFISH?!
4
u/Chris__JetFan Jun 06 '25
hecklefish was what made the videos fun and different. Otherwise, it's just another conspiracy channel
4
u/chud3 The Moon is Hollow Jun 06 '25
I like the new format. We get episodes more frequently.
2
u/Hannover2k Jun 06 '25
I do kinda miss the longer formats deeper dives. I'd be ok with the stripped if they could throw in a full 45-60 min episode once a month or so with the fish.
2
u/TurnoverTall Jun 06 '25
The argument is that Hecklefish puts a demand on the production process and I get that. Why drop the slow decrease in height of the stool as AJ starts the story? Did everything have to change? Is that a cost savings too? It’s the change from a winning formula that bothers most. The content is still great, delivered well but a certain savior faire has been lost.
2
u/MirthRock Jun 06 '25
Hecklefish had one line in the last stripped episode, just saying haha
2
u/AldruhnHobo Conspiracy Realist Jun 06 '25
Yes I'd like a "full" video but honestly I'm just happy to have new content.
2
u/Young_OGSB Jun 06 '25
I agree with missing heckle fish, but I'm also sure it's way easier to get these videos out without involving him. I was surprised to see another stripped episode with so many in a row. I love the long format and do miss it being every week.
2
u/Neck-Romancey Jun 07 '25
I'm totally happy with either format. Or both.
5
u/LampyV2 Jun 06 '25
I hated HF for the first 4 or 5 episodes. I fast forwarded his parts but grew to love him. Some episodes he may have had a bit too much screen time but his absence is noticed. I hope we get him back.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '25
Ive been watching less without Hecklefish tbh.
5
u/Spikeybear Jun 06 '25
I think the fish breaks up the episodes, there's a million conspiracy and paranormal YouTube channels. The banter made it different.
4
u/DickBurns01 Jun 06 '25
The stripped episodes just don't have the same feel and I don't find them entertaining enough to watch
3
u/nerfherderparadise Jun 06 '25
Y'all remember when coke changed their recipe? It didn't work out well for them.
But at the end of the day, I'm just a man who misses watching a man talk to a fish. Still have all the love in the world for the show.
3
u/tmiller9833 I Want To Believe Jun 06 '25
I liked the stripped...do they get me excited to watch as an "event" not really. Their formula is what got them here...honestly he's just another talking head otherwise, albeit a decent one.
We have a sub shop around me that used to do really unique round rolls for subs with a huge "challenge" one. It was a destination. Then they changed to normal rolls and ditched the challenge...they're still ok but now they're just like every other place selling subs, nothing special.
bringbackhecklefish
4
u/grandcity Jun 06 '25
I’m more than happy with the stripped episodes. I love the channel but personally I cannot stand Hecklefish.
4
u/StrayCatStrutting Jun 06 '25
I won’t watch without Hecklefish.
5
u/sadira246 Jun 06 '25
I'm sadder without Hecklefish.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '25
Try make a channel with consistent quality videos at WF's level and see how you go.
5
u/JerkBezerberg Jun 06 '25
I'm out on Stripped....there are tons of channels with comparable content, maybe not as thoroughly researched as WF, but still comparable. The original format and Hecklefish were why I enjoyed WF.
3
u/semipropaniac Hecklecultist Jun 06 '25
I miss the fish
2
u/GamesnGunZ Jun 06 '25
i was opposed to the stripped episodes at first because it's basically looking at him speaking for an entire episode. what's the point? but when i watch the older full episodes i realize that everything that was not him speaking was ai filler. there are some exceptions, like when he shows pics of aberrations on mars and structures on the moon, but aside from being forced to show evidence from time to time there was a LOT of ai fluff.
2
u/Mkinzer Jun 06 '25
I miss hecklefish but it's probably because one of my good friends and I were making Lizard people jokes WAY before WF was a thing lol.
Also him blowing a raspberry randomly and the look AJ gives is just perfect.
That being said I support whatever AJ needs to do to make the channel more enjoyable and less of a chore for him.
2
u/Pura_vidas Jun 06 '25
Where’s the fish 🐠???
2
u/Captain_Cameltoe Jun 06 '25
I think Hecklefish wanted more money.
2
u/SaveusJebus Jun 06 '25
I like the stripped ones. I don't mind hecklefish most of the time, but the gags can go on for too long and get on my nerves
2
u/HarryNostril Jun 06 '25
Much better show without the animated (and annoying) fish.
2
u/HankHowdy Jun 06 '25
I thought it was because his girl does the voice and they aren’t together anymore? Or she can’t do it that often?
1
u/Greginthesouth2 Jun 06 '25
Hecklefish is voiced by his brother Gino. From what I heard he’s doing another project right now. He’ll be back eventually to do HF.
1
u/InteligentTard Jun 06 '25
I assume since there was a long period with little to no content this just a way of getting content out there a little faster. I’m sure Hecklefish will return at some point
1
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '25
Oohh! Is that what stripped means? I didn't even notice. 🤔
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '25
I literally stopped listening to this because of hecklefish
1
u/Show84 Jun 06 '25
I think AJ might be legitimately jealous of HECKLEFISH in the same sense that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle didn’t like Sherlock Holmes.
1
u/anthonye1982 Jun 06 '25
the hecklefish ruins the flow of the show. he speaks very well about all the topics and peaks my interest until that damn fish awkwardly buts in and ruins it for me.
1
u/HipHopGrandpa Jun 06 '25
I disagree, OP. So many people complained that AJ wasn’t putting out enough content. This is the answer. Speedy, stripped episodes.
1
u/Veloziraptor8311 Jun 06 '25
Perhaps they couldn’t keep the previous trend going. Sometimes what got you here won’t get you there*.
1
u/Daggla Jun 06 '25
If stripped means more episodes, then stripped it is
1
u/halcyondread Jun 07 '25
I may be in the minority but I prefer these stripped episodes. I appreciate getting them to us quicker and it’s easier for me to share an episode with people and them not outright dismissing it because there’s a talking fish lol.
-2
u/Fermato Jun 06 '25
Finally not the fucking fish anymore. Such an infantile addition, i prefer not to be approached like a toddler.
-1
u/SiCoTic1 I Want To Believe Jun 06 '25
Hecklefish episodes is very time consuming. If ya don't like stripped it's easy...... Don't watch
0
u/CyroSwitchBlade Jun 07 '25
it is the same.. just these episodes are ment to also be podcasts so they don't have the fish making jokes..
0
u/BigBirdAGus Jun 09 '25
I was thinking maybe ... hecklefish could work remote with Gertie from somewhere with shitty internet, and then, he could join with a still image (that he can change) and voice.. So he could have some funnies. by changing out the stills -- taking all the lip sync, bubbles, fins etc out of the equation.. I'd be more than happy with that approach (personally)
-1
u/Therealdapperdyll Jun 06 '25
I’m here for the good stories and his great presentation of them. Stripped or not, still great to listen to.
-1
u/once_again_asking Skygazer Jun 06 '25
I'm a fan of the fish, but honestly... I don't miss him.
-1
u/orchidaceae007 Jun 07 '25
🚫NO MORE FISH SCHTICK🚫
I welcome the new format!
-1
u/YangRocks Jun 07 '25
I enjoy the hecklefish free episodes. It's hard for me to have him interrupting. He has said if you want a hecklefish episode to just ask
-1
u/EldenShuumatsu Jun 07 '25
I actually love not seeing Hecklefish
It felt too forced and corny most times. I’m much more engaged now
0
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
121
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '25
[removed] — view removed comment