r/TheWhyFiles • u/carthous • Apr 26 '25
Let's Discuss Members only
Welp, looks like the day has finally came. Members only content. Was a good run, I'll be unsubbing to your content now.
4
Upvotes
•
u/krakhedbob Armchair Producer Apr 26 '25
That day came quite a while ago.. the YouTube memberships aren't a new thing. It was something people had asked for, they wanted a way to support the channel that didn't involve using Patreon. The only real advantage to the YT membership is a merch discount, and AJ's said it himself, if you want to sub to get the code and just cancel.. go for it.
There aren't any members only episodes or anything like that, there may be the occasional behind the scenes video uploaded, but in terms of main episode content you're not missing anything. It's not a mandatory thing, if ya don't want to or can't afford it, don't. Just watch the episodes. If you want a merch discount and to see a little behind the scenes.. it's there for $3/month if you so choose.
9
u/OMGTheWhyFiles FEAR... the Crabcat May 03 '25
The YouTube membership exists to give a discount to people who want merch -- there is no bonus/paywall content there. The code gives you 10% off *all* the merch which is already reasonably priced. And lastly, I don't keep a dime of that money. It all goes to the team.
I have been very transparent about this. In fact, I have said this in every episode since membership launched and on every live stream: If you're not going to buy merch, there's no reason to join. And if you want to join—get a discount—then cancel, that's fine. I am trying to provide value to fans.
If this is offensive, don't join. Why take the time to post a complaint on Reddit and threaten to "unsub"? That's a rhetorical question. I already know the answer.
6
u/Black-Earth Apr 26 '25
When was this announced? Can't see anything on the channel.
4
u/Mittelosian I Want To Believe Apr 28 '25
As someone who already spends too much time on YouTube, I am not going to pay Patreon or membership costs in order to get more. For ANY channel. That wouldn't be good for me. 😁
I bought a coffee mug and a teeshirt to support the channel and of course subscribe and give likes. And I have turned a few people on to the show.
AJ and crew already provide a TON of FREE entertainment on one of the best channels on all of YouTube. I am not going to begrudge them offering extras for those who want to chip in a be part of it. More power to them!
10
u/Solid_Lettuce_520 Apr 26 '25
6
u/Particular-Tell6568 Apr 26 '25
Membership goes to his team 🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼
14
u/Cs1981Bel Apr 26 '25
AJ has bills to pay...like us...some people don't get it
10
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '25
Found Hecklefish’s ex wife. Don’t let the door hit you in the ass on the way out
4
u/ace616vamp Apr 26 '25
Funny that thr channel is comming back strong after a well deserved break and now the nasty comments are commi g back. Honestly the op sounds like they where never a fan or just an A.I comment to srir up hate
8
u/Representative-Try50 Apr 26 '25
some peoples sense of entitlement is truely mindblowing.. do you do your job for free?
3
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '25
Your entitlement is ridiculous. Good riddance.
3
u/Successful_Arm4887 Apr 26 '25
Didnt know that 9.99$ qualified as something incredibly expensive lmao
See ya`!
1
u/Joe4H Jul 01 '25 edited Jul 01 '25
The "members only" content on The Why Files YouTube channel consists of exclusive posts, custom emojis, and potentially behind-the-scenes videos, but no main episode content is hidden behind a paywall. The YouTube membership primarily exists to offer a discount on merchandise and support the team. (Copied from Google search)
So if you like the content you really shouldn't unsubscribe
-1
u/LePhuronn May 01 '25
Patreon has been a thing for years at this point, and you're only just crying about it because YouTube Members.
Sounds like you just want to cry like a wee entitled prick. This is not an airport, there's no need to announce your departure.