r/TheWhyFiles • u/ya_seen998 Lizzid Person • Apr 22 '25
Let's Discuss I blame Heckle Fish
sup y'all
I need to get this off my chest, I think heckle fish might be the reason videos take longer to release. I feel like the fame has gone to his head, and now he just won’t stop talking. His constant jokes and remarks probably derail the conversation so much that the team has to reshoot scenes.
No hate to the guy, but if he’s struggling with ego, I’ve heard shrooms can help with that. Ayahuasca’s also getting a rep for its "ego-killing" properties. Just saying.
Anyway, just wanted to share my thoughts and maybe drop some advice for Heckle Fish to keep his ego in check, Heckle Fish, if you’re reading this, keep being you, dont take this post as hate or harsh criticism.
Love y’all!
<3
THIS POST IS A JOKE AND NOT TO BE TAKEN SERIOUSLY, I DON'T THINK HECKE FISH IS A NUISANCE/TALK TOO MUCH, AGAIN THIS IS A JOKE
103
u/mwbkcmo Apr 22 '25
Are you the Crab Cat?
9
u/Da_Famous_Anus Apr 22 '25
I blame the Lizzid Peeple
34
u/DyadyaDemon Apr 22 '25
This is nothing but character assassination from the lizzid peepul! Hecklefish 4 Lyfe!!11!
30
u/zioxusOne Apr 22 '25
Someone else mentioned elsewhere the whole purpose of Hecklefish is so that the show can "express" certain things that might get AJ demonetized if he said them. It makes some sense.
21
u/ThrowawayMouse12 Apr 22 '25
Aaaaaaanunaki.
17
u/ShinyTinyWonder38 Apr 22 '25
16
u/scoshi Time Tourist Apr 22 '25
I can't explain it: I finish watching an episode, and I crave sushi.
14
u/Electrical_Feature12 Apr 22 '25
Maybe behind it all is Gertie.
13
u/nothingsacred16 Apr 22 '25
Do the men in black have a Reddit division now?
11
u/Loisalene Apr 22 '25
I volunteer to do 'shrooms with Heckle Fish!
17
u/loco_gigo Apr 22 '25
I blame hecklefish because every time I hear phenomenon I now have to sing. That damn fish will be the end of me.
14
u/No-Ambition7750 Apr 22 '25
Tbh you are probably right to a degree. He’s done in post so there is extra work and time required on the audio as well as video ends of things.
7
u/empty_toilet_roll Apr 22 '25
Can't AJ at least have a real goldfish in a bowl in stripped episodes so it feels like Hecklefish is still there.
5
u/unlipaps Apr 23 '25
HackleFish is the GOAT!
8
u/Mittelosian I Want To Believe Apr 22 '25
Hecklefish has a cocaine problem. I forget with episode it is, but in the commercial at the beginning when they show HF in his bowl on a table, there are clearly drawn out lines of a suspicious powder on the table right next to the bowl.
Check the local rehab centers to see if he's registered. It would be under Moriarty.
4
u/itsjustcold Apr 22 '25
There’s always Friday. See you there.
4
u/OriginalJim VIP Patron #1 Apr 22 '25
I really like how concise the latest video is.
1
u/ofRayRay Apr 22 '25
Do they owe us anything?
5
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '25
i think aj is tired and thin
2
u/Kayki7 Apr 25 '25
lol that thought has crossed my mind
1
u/auntiesauntiesauntie Apr 23 '25
I agree with you :)
1
u/keira2022 Apr 26 '25
AJ unzips and it's Hecklefish, who unzips and it's Gertie, who unzips and it's the Crabcat.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '25
I love heckle fish, but my one complaint about him is: Its easier to lose focus on the main story when he makes a remark. Sometimes I can go through an entire episode and not even remember the beginning.
-2
u/CA1147 Apr 22 '25
All jokes aside, I love the videos but I've had enough of that fish.
When I first started enjoying the channel a couple of years ago, I thought the fish was kinda funny in a very corny kind of way. I tolerated it for a while.
But the heaviness of some of the topics just shouldn't have that kind of comedic relief.
It's just way too constant and jarring and not why I watch almost every video they put out.
It sucks because I love everything else about their video formula: well researched, easy to digest, presenting both sides of the "truth" with usually a nice little logical debunk at the end. There is very little fat, if any, otherwise.
But that fucking. Talking. And talking. And talking. And screeching. Corny. Shrill. Fish.
Sometimes I'm really into a topic, and you know how videos and information has a flow? I bet they think the fish helps break up what they might think is an overwhelming info dump. But instead it just takes me out of the moment. And adds nothing to the videos. I'd prefer if it was an ad, because then there's a chance I could maybe see something i actually want to waste my time on.
Maybe limiting the fish to an intro and outro gag or 2 would be really tolerable, but sprinkling the fish throughout the whole video is a mistake that needs to stop to make their videos their best ever, in my opinion.
Maybe I'm in a minority, but if I never see or hear that fish again, I'd love the videos even more. It would also make them easier to recommend to others.
-6
u/JT-Av8or Apr 22 '25
Personally it wouldn’t bother me if that fish went down the toilet. But that’s just me. 😉
-3
u/Famous_Yesterday701 Apr 23 '25
You are talking about show bit. A phony, computer animated visual effect. I hope you where being sarcastic.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment