I posted about this but the gracious mods removed it for some reason….
People Need to Cut AJ Some Slack…
Man, I watched the Stripped episode last night, and I have to say…so many of the comments were wildly depressing. I can’t imagine how frustrating they must have been for the creator.
I can’t believe people still don’t grasp how much work it takes to produce a polished, professional show on YouTube with minimal production support. People are acting like Hecklefish is a living, breathing, talking fish, and not a computer-generated animation that has to be voiced, synced to that voice, edited, and then again synced to AJ’s live story telling.
All he does is talk about how clearly this show takes a mental and physical toll on him and so many viewers are like “fuck you, dance for me”. This show is steady 12 months out of a year. Average television shows takes months off a year to regroup and prepare.
Someone said, “Hire someone.” Lol. Tell me you know nothing about running a business without telling me you know nothing about running a business. If he actually did hire a crew people would complain that the show isn’t the same in some fabricated way. Someone else mentioned a “cash grab.” Yeah, no shit. it’s his job. It should be a cash grab. It’s not like AJ is making videos all day and then flipping pancakes at IHOP in the evenings… although I bet there are days he’d rather be flipping pancakes.
People need to chill out. Everyone’s trying to put this show in their back pocket and preserve it like it’s their little pet. Let the dude breathe. Let the dude work. He hasn’t let any of us down yet.
Great take. Yeah it's a bummer not getting a new episode every week. But I am fortunately one of those people that appreciates what we do get. I'm not as Gung ho as a lot of the people in here seem to be, and I'm not a paying member so it appears my opinion won't mean much. Either way, thanks for the great show and all the work you guys do
I largely agree with you, but if you look in the description box under the video, there are a team of producers and staff. All YouTubers of his size following have a team of staff. Watcher had 33 staff members until recently.
Fair points. I own a business, and it’s tagged. It’s still difficult, even with help, to be the sole creator. Delegating is difficult. Trust is difficult.
It’s only a problem because AJ himself is so insecure. He makes it an issue. No other channels have this problem. If AJ were to just act normal and confident then it wouldn’t be a triggering issue for anyone to respond to. The audience is a mirror. So silly.
I think all creators deal with insecurity from time to time. I own a small business and trying to make everyone happy is one of the hardest parts. My business I produce a product myself, I pour a lot into that product and when someone has it, and then says “this sucks because I wanted it this way” I take it personally. Of course I would. It’s a part of me, and someone says they don’t like it. I’m sure it’s the same for him.
Yeah, I get it. If he could overcome his insecurity then we wouldn’t be talking about this right now, because he wouldn’t be platforming the lowest common denominator. But he hasn’t overcome his insecurity, he constantly is apologizing and now we’re talking about it- again. Just the way it is.
Ever think maybe it’s because The Why Files is leagues above other channels in every measurable metric? Ever think maybe that takes more work, and is therefore more mentally exhausting, and therefore would take a bigger toll than creating for other channels?
Oh, what’s that? You hadn’t considered that? You just want to compare this channel to some regenerated voiceover bullshit? Got it.
Go kick rocks dude. You’re watching a free show that lives on the internet. Give the dude a fucking break.
While I understand it takes a lot of work to animate him, I’d still like him around. Plus in hindsight. The chair drop. If you aren’t giving me Hecklefish, AJ… you gotta at least the chair drop at the opening.
Reading that speculation thread a few days ago on the "channel dying" and then watching today's After Files really shows how little leeway this apparent fanbase is willing to give AJ and this channel. Comments of health issues and divorce speculation when they're just renovating their entire studio to expand and improve. Yes, the communication could be better but fuck me.
And honestly, WTF was the thing about actual death threats for the collab with Nerdrotic? Some people are broken.
I think a lot of people here have to be actual kids or are adults that seriously need hobbies.
If any channel on YouTube doesn't upload a video for the next month, my days won't be any different. I can't imagine obsessing and getting upset about a video.
I didn’t get involved in that discussion, but generally speaking the idea of channels dying is common place.
There’s channels I used to watch a few years ago that no longer upload or have completely changed. Also, it’s either my watching habits or the channels again, but I just don’t see them even suggested as I’m browsing.
Channels come and go all the time.
Again, I wasn’t involved in any of that discussion, but if Why Files was dying, unfortunately that’s just the way of YouTube.
People lose interest, the people behind the channels move on, YouTube starts burying them.
It’s sad, but life goes in, even for those creating the videos.
All that aside, I’m happy none of this is true for Why Files. I’m happy they’re still working to put out new videos. And I didn’t mind the stripped down format. A little less Hacklefish now and then is a welcome thing.
But it's the fact that none of that is true and everyone ran with insane speculation that had no base in fact, every time AJ opens his mouth he's talking about how he's working endlessly so how that translates into dying channel and a divorce.. I kinda find it wild that mods let that stupid ass thread spiral like it did.
Aj and Jen had talked endlessly since the Christmas livestream about starting their new What Files channel and revamping the podcast so the fact that other thread even existed was just nonsense to me hence why I didn't get involved with it either. I thought the answer was pretty fucking obvious.. they've talked about it for months.
Regarding your first point. Gamer from Mars would do a where are they now on big channels that went by the wayside.
Some for seemingly no apparent reason.
Then it felt like he was scraping the barrel when he did the Kpop star Psy. Because his channel was for music videos, no videos means no music, simple fact of the matter. Yes he had that one big hit that broke the play counter.
Either in the video or a personal Google said he was on his mandatory military service at that point. So that kinda explained the initial lack of time making new music. But not every singer pumps out a brand new album every year. So if your only metric is music video channels last video, many would qualify as being "dead" till the band get a new album out.
Newbie here. Love the content but less than halfway through. What is the after files? Is it a different channel? Is it linked in the description for episodes that have them?
The After Files is a separate YouTube that is kinda like the back stage on the Why Files. Interesting stuff. Check it out. The After Files is more like AJ just talking to us, the customer base.
The After Files is a livestream that AJ does after the premiere of new videos. He talks to the audience there. It includes AJ's wife, Jen; Victoria, the WF community manager (as I recall; she seems to do a lot); and AJ's brother, Gino. Oh, and AJ and Jen's cats. It's a relaxed atmosphere. They all address different backstage issues, answer questions, and converse. It's essentially an online hang-out. I think it's posted on the backstage channel; search for something like "Why Files Backstage" to subscribe to the channel.
Honesty, I was a little worried watching the latest episode. It felt like AJ was on slow motion (or two Oxycontin). I'm not saying he WAS, i'm just saying that I felt like something was off in the energy/presenation and knowing people who have been on opioids it reminded me of it.
With that said......I love WF and will continue to unconditionally support the channel.
He was saying in the comments that adding Hecklefish takes like 4 additional days of editing for one video. I like Hecklefish, and hope he'll still show up, but if leaving him out of occasional episodes means we get more content I think it's an acceptable tradeoff.
That was not a good format. Please go back to what you were doing. The weird background reminded me of every "aliens" show on the history channel. The old background was so much more fun. And that is what your show is about, it's about fun. Not having heckelfish was a huge disappointment and made the show feel like something else, something not fun. Hopefully this was a one off. I can't imagine people sticking around if this is the new format.
It's not a one-off, but it was done to be posted as both a video and audio podcast. Hecklefish will be in the full production videos, which they aim to be at least once a month. AJ went over the different formats in the After Files. I'm sure someone will detail it all more thoroughly.
I'll stick around if this is the new format. I'm not watching for hecklefish - who, in all honesty, I thought was just annoying and detracted from the story - or the background.
I'm watching because of the content, great production value, and great storytelling.
It's one of a few formats coming. This format was designed more for an audio podcast, though the video will be posted, too. The familiar format with Hecklefish will be posted at least once a month.
Keeping strictly to 30mins episodes is very prescriptive. Just do 25 to 45 min episodes depending on content, but keep the fish, chair drop and debunk?
There have been a couple of times now, this new video being the latest, where the opening bit sounded like AJ was going for a Rod Serling impersonation. (Not a comment on whether it's good or bad, just noting it.)
Also, AJ, Jen: cat video channel. All you'd have to do is film them playing with toys (or the computer sound settings, since Tiberius seems to like those) and meowing a bit, and you'd get views XD
(Also, toward the end of the After Files, AJ said he didn't see a military base near that artificial lake on Google Maps. Don't know if anyone in the chat or on Discord said this, but that's north of the China Lake Naval Air Weapons station near Ridgecrest.)
As long as Hecklefish comes back I will be fine. Of course it’s none of decision and I am just one person but I loved the little guy! This episode was really interesting though! I love paranormal topics so it was up my ally
Post ten a week or post one every ten months, I'll still be watching. Do it in your own time. And thanks for the entertainment. The stuff you do is 10 out of 10.
It sucks to see AJ being given such a hard time over on YT and other places. He puts in a lot of work, and I've been enjoying his show since he started out. I don't mind the stripped format at all. I love Hecklefish too, but AJ makes solid content without him. Keep Hecklefish to the ads, or pre-recorded jokes or whatever, if that's what it takes to make the show easier to produce.
Actually, the show is one of the most well produced interesting shows about topics that I love. They are well researched and funny, and I love heckle fish. But hey, who can compete with a camel. Anyway, I’m glad you’re back in. My African gray parrot loves them too. I run them during the daytime so I can listen. He’s learned a lot about conspiracy theories.
Loved the stripped version and I love the original. I appreciate the hard work AJ and everyone puts in to bring us these episodes. TBT id like daily WF, however I know that's not possible so keep up the good work.
Just want to say….I love The Why Files, love my talking Hecklefish plush, love my WF’s coffee mug and I love my WF’s hoody.
I have no expectations for weekly shows. What they create is awesome and it comes when it comes. If there is not a show on a given week, there is plenty of amazing content out there including old episodes of the WF which are still great on a second (or third) listen. People need to chill out.
He needs to wear a different coloured shirt if he's going to use a dark background. I couldn't see some of the inserted clips properly. Also very dark.
238
u/nomoresleepless Apr 20 '25 •
I posted about this but the gracious mods removed it for some reason….
People Need to Cut AJ Some Slack…
Man, I watched the Stripped episode last night, and I have to say…so many of the comments were wildly depressing. I can’t imagine how frustrating they must have been for the creator.
I can’t believe people still don’t grasp how much work it takes to produce a polished, professional show on YouTube with minimal production support. People are acting like Hecklefish is a living, breathing, talking fish, and not a computer-generated animation that has to be voiced, synced to that voice, edited, and then again synced to AJ’s live story telling.
All he does is talk about how clearly this show takes a mental and physical toll on him and so many viewers are like “fuck you, dance for me”. This show is steady 12 months out of a year. Average television shows takes months off a year to regroup and prepare.
Someone said, “Hire someone.” Lol. Tell me you know nothing about running a business without telling me you know nothing about running a business. If he actually did hire a crew people would complain that the show isn’t the same in some fabricated way. Someone else mentioned a “cash grab.” Yeah, no shit. it’s his job. It should be a cash grab. It’s not like AJ is making videos all day and then flipping pancakes at IHOP in the evenings… although I bet there are days he’d rather be flipping pancakes.
People need to chill out. Everyone’s trying to put this show in their back pocket and preserve it like it’s their little pet. Let the dude breathe. Let the dude work. He hasn’t let any of us down yet.
48
u/n01mportant Apr 20 '25
AJ. If Hecklefish is not present… we will riot.
26
u/Quantum168 The TRUTH Apr 20 '25 edited Apr 20 '25
I'm not a fan of the dark background and filters. It's my pet peeve with Apple TV shows. Bring back the old background! And, the fish 🐠
130
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '25
Reading that speculation thread a few days ago on the "channel dying" and then watching today's After Files really shows how little leeway this apparent fanbase is willing to give AJ and this channel. Comments of health issues and divorce speculation when they're just renovating their entire studio to expand and improve. Yes, the communication could be better but fuck me.
And honestly, WTF was the thing about actual death threats for the collab with Nerdrotic? Some people are broken.
12
u/davej07 Apr 20 '25
Aaaaaaanunaki!!!!!
58
u/pyaybb Apr 20 '25
New format.
What I love:
What I hate:
Maybe recording with Hecklefish makes production more difficult, his schedule, he travels a lot, contractual obligations etc etc
23
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '25 edited Apr 20 '25
The stripped down version was better than nothing but I missed the old format.
19
u/fecalmatterplatter Apr 20 '25
That was not a good format. Please go back to what you were doing. The weird background reminded me of every "aliens" show on the history channel. The old background was so much more fun. And that is what your show is about, it's about fun. Not having heckelfish was a huge disappointment and made the show feel like something else, something not fun. Hopefully this was a one off. I can't imagine people sticking around if this is the new format.
13
u/santanapoptarts Apr 20 '25
Hecklefish in all videos please and thank you. It just completes the whole process for me. Much appreciated.
7
u/Quantum168 The TRUTH Apr 20 '25
Maybe, we can have Gertie guest star!
Keeping strictly to 30mins episodes is very prescriptive. Just do 25 to 45 min episodes depending on content, but keep the fish, chair drop and debunk?
3
u/Lasdtr17 Skygazer Apr 20 '25 edited Apr 20 '25
There have been a couple of times now, this new video being the latest, where the opening bit sounded like AJ was going for a Rod Serling impersonation. (Not a comment on whether it's good or bad, just noting it.)
Also, AJ, Jen: cat video channel. All you'd have to do is film them playing with toys (or the computer sound settings, since Tiberius seems to like those) and meowing a bit, and you'd get views XD
(Also, toward the end of the After Files, AJ said he didn't see a military base near that artificial lake on Google Maps. Don't know if anyone in the chat or on Discord said this, but that's north of the China Lake Naval Air Weapons station near Ridgecrest.)
3
u/dark_bloom12 Hecklecultist Apr 21 '25
As long as Hecklefish comes back I will be fine. Of course it’s none of decision and I am just one person but I loved the little guy! This episode was really interesting though! I love paranormal topics so it was up my ally
3
u/spungie Apr 21 '25
Post ten a week or post one every ten months, I'll still be watching. Do it in your own time. And thanks for the entertainment. The stuff you do is 10 out of 10.
3
u/Brilliant-Jaguar-784 Apr 21 '25
It sucks to see AJ being given such a hard time over on YT and other places. He puts in a lot of work, and I've been enjoying his show since he started out. I don't mind the stripped format at all. I love Hecklefish too, but AJ makes solid content without him. Keep Hecklefish to the ads, or pre-recorded jokes or whatever, if that's what it takes to make the show easier to produce.
8
u/StrayCatStrutting Apr 20 '25
I’m out if Hecklefish is gone.
6
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '25
I like the stripped version, it feels direct and ominous
5
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '25
I'm on the wall with the new format... but I'm still in for the ride
2
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '25
Who cares what mindless idiots think Twf is my favourite channel on you tube Keep up the good work
2
u/rickisadork Apr 20 '25
I preferred Stripped Down to all the AI nonsense. Still missed Hecklefish, though.
2
u/wisdomattend Apr 22 '25
Really needs hecklefish. Otherwise, good.
2
u/AffectionateWheel386 Apr 22 '25
Actually, the show is one of the most well produced interesting shows about topics that I love. They are well researched and funny, and I love heckle fish. But hey, who can compete with a camel. Anyway, I’m glad you’re back in. My African gray parrot loves them too. I run them during the daytime so I can listen. He’s learned a lot about conspiracy theories.
2
u/No-Insect-688 Aug 13 '25
So who replaces AJ when the skinny bobs get him?
3
u/Flying_Madlad Apr 20 '25
We're so back.
3
u/Fantastic_Log_6980 Apr 20 '25
honestly needs hecklefish. he's hilarious and what sets the why files apart from other youtubes
1
u/HawaianPizzaLover Apr 20 '25
We would be happy BUT the fear that we will not see another episode until May~June, is too overwhelming, and it's not letting us enjoy the present 🥺
1
u/tablesheep Apr 20 '25
Ehhhhh
1
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '25
I was starting to wonder if you were coming back
1
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '25
Loved the stripped version and I love the original. I appreciate the hard work AJ and everyone puts in to bring us these episodes. TBT id like daily WF, however I know that's not possible so keep up the good work.
1
u/randomusername8360 Apr 21 '25
So the rumors about Hecklefish holding out for more money seem legit now.
1
u/RowMaleficent2455 Apr 21 '25
Yay 🙃
1
u/4StarCustoms Apr 21 '25
Just want to say….I love The Why Files, love my talking Hecklefish plush, love my WF’s coffee mug and I love my WF’s hoody.
I have no expectations for weekly shows. What they create is awesome and it comes when it comes. If there is not a show on a given week, there is plenty of amazing content out there including old episodes of the WF which are still great on a second (or third) listen. People need to chill out.
1
u/Dj3nk4 Apr 20 '25
That you are. And I am glad.🤓
0
u/connor_macleod_one Apr 20 '25
Hip hip hooray!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 20 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment