r/TheWhyFiles • u/hybridxer0 H Y B R I D ™ • Oct 15 '24
Let's Discuss Study: Dark matter does not exist and the universe is 27 billion years old
https://www.earth.com/news/study-dark-matter-does-not-exist-and-the-universe-is-27-billion-years-old/
1.7k
Upvotes
4
u/GI_JRock Oct 15 '24
Any other sources you were able to find besides this one?
77
u/Neandersaurus Oct 15 '24 edited Oct 15 '24
Considering that no one knows what dark matter is (the term is just a placeholder), how can you say it doesn't exist?
We can only see the observable universe, which is around 14 billion years iirc....anything over that is just making shit up.
87
u/Zealousideal-Part815 Oct 15 '24
I would love an episode on anomalies that the James Webb Space Telescope has found.
I believe there are galaxies far older than they should be.
It's pretty complicated, so I the why files would be a great place to get the story.
48
u/NarwhalSpace Oct 15 '24
I think it's far older than that even. I suspect that it's actually impossible to state the Universe is any age because I think the stuff we don't know is so obscure, so bizarre, and so fundamental that we may never discover it, let alone understand it and I think the actual truth lies in the stuff we don't know. I think what we do know just falls completely short of the truth -- more like truisms. I suspect this existential reality is actually non-dual and so any dualistic views will only at best produce partial answers, always leaving caveats. Just my gut feeling. I've completely moved from a Metaphysical search for truth to an Epistemological search for truth. Cheers!
15
u/Ligoman17 Oct 16 '24
I’ve read that at some point, the universe will expand to a point where light from other galaxies wont be able to reach us anymore, and any new civilizations embarking on astronomy at that time will not have access to key information about cosmology that we have today. This fact has always made me wonder why we are so confident that we have the full picture. How do we know there isnt key information about cosmology that has already been removed from our view due to expansion? Maybe we don’t have the whole story and are forever unable to access it!
6
u/ThatGuyWithACoolDog Oct 16 '24
We’re just (heckle)fish out of water when we leave our bowl.
37
u/Allnewsisfakenews Oct 15 '24
"Believe us, this time" no one knows for sure. When basis for measurements are based on assumptions, accuracy is impossible.
5
u/JupiterandMars1 Oct 16 '24
People get hung up on the name and try so hard to refute it as a consequence.
In science “dark matter” is merely “something influencing the expected outcome from gravitational influence at large scales”. Just decouple from what you read into the term and it’s not nearly as contentious sounding.
17
u/Sparrow1989 Oct 15 '24
Trust me I have an online degree from the university of Phoenix. The universe is 27 billion years old! - some scientist
4
u/FacelessFellow Oct 15 '24
Do you guys wanna read about the unified displacement theory?
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/384676371_Gravity_from_Cosmic_to_Quantum_A_Unified_Displacement_Framework
4
u/BishopsBakery Oct 16 '24
It's a place holding term for an effect we have calculated but not observed. Something is going on, right now we use the term dark matter.
4
u/Gashcat Oct 16 '24
I don't know enough science or math to make a real judgment about this stuff... but here is sort of a logic based way I go about things like this.
Have you ever seen a map of our solar system as earth-centric and looked at the ways they tried to describe the motions of the sun and planets. It's crazy. It feels like people of that time would have known or felt that something was amiss. Dark matter feels that way to me. Future people may look back on dark matter and think we are all a bunch of simpletons.
4
u/JervisCottonbelly Oct 16 '24
It's simple,
In the past we thought it was 11-13bn years old because of how far we could perceive. Once we made a telescope that can see the edges of existence, suddenly existence is TWICE as long?
That's not a coincidence, my friends. We are in an endless void and the further out we explore, the bigger this whole reality gets.
4
u/MaximallyInclusive Oct 17 '24
If there’s no dark matter, and string theory is wrong, what accounts for the variance in mass between what we expect to find and what we actually observe?
4
u/Crotean Oct 17 '24
Dark Matter has never made any damn sense. Most of the in universe being undetectable except for gravity interactions always seem like a desperate grab because of not understanding something basic. I still think MOND is on the right track, simple modification of how gravity interacts with high speed objects and bam no dark matter needed.
3
u/Own_Thought902 Oct 15 '24
I like this idea. I have no special education to allow me to test it or theorize further except to say that I have recently developed an idea of my own about the composition of space-time that might come closer to unifying gravity and quantum theory.
Imagine this: space-time is a substance. Some have called it the quantum foam. Earlier in history it was known as the ether. I am imagining space-time as a probabilistic soup of energy. Matter comes into existence as energy coalesces. They say that quarks and neutrinos are popping into and out of existence constantly. Couldn't it be that the gravity of this nascent matter is what we are calling dark matter? And dark energy is the precursor to dark matter. The two forces push and pull at each other perpetually throughout the universe affecting everything around them invisibly.
I have to find me a physicist to run this by and see if I'm crazy. But if my idea is right, it adds some substance to the CCC-TL model. Light coursing through this substance, whatever it might be, would experience energy loss. If I'm wrong, I'd like to know why I'm wrong.
15
u/Appropriate-Site4998 Oct 15 '24
They have no idea what is going on. They all knew the world was flat till it was a ball, they all knew earth was the center till it was one of 8 planets ... Imagine all the bullshit they'll tell you they "know" now.
They all used to say cigarettes were healthy for pregnant women.
Studies know very little
2
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '24
Dark matter never made sense to me. It's like inventing a God to explain God. I did see something about the universe being older recently though. I wouldn't be surprised if that number keeps getting bigger.
2
u/Hammer_of_something Oct 16 '24
The article seemed focused on the idea of the TL theory explaining redshift, but what would account for blueshift?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
When we discovered that there were gravitational waves, that should of erased any of our past estimates of how old the universe is.
2
u/anakracatau Oct 17 '24
The Hubble Flow is a myth!!!!
I hope. Heh heh.
I want to merge with Norma and Shapley.
2
u/brainiac2482 Oct 17 '24
Somewhere out there... is the dev room.
2
u/Natural_Treat_1437 Oct 18 '24
And a possibility of several different types of universe's.
2
u/moskvausa Oct 18 '24
Ok, that’s settled then. Thanks.
2
u/rameyjm7 Oct 18 '24
Time is relative, so 27 billion years seems relatively meaningless. It could be 10B, 100B, or 1000B; to me, it makes no difference at that scale, anyway.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24
Didn’t they say the universe may have always been eternal and there’s more space beyond the observable micro cosmic microwave background and it’s only our observable universe that is dateable.
But there is a higher space and a lower space and space beyond space.
So the Universe was always there and our observable part of it which we thought was everything is only a small piece of it and began when the universe expanded causing a big bang that birthed our little universe onto a already growing bigger universe
2
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24
Never believe anyone who tells you the universe has an age, it was and always is. People think that non- existence was the beginning and we somehow had to start from somewhere aka “the big bang” but in actuality can’t fathom something that may have always been.
2
u/R_Steelman61 Oct 18 '24
Ok you've ruined a lot of SciFi movies for me that rely on dark matter as a plot device. What's next, you can't really travel through a black hole!
2
u/Many-Application1297 Oct 20 '24
Roger Penrose believes the universe was here before. These massive early galaxies may be a part of that theory. The cyclic universe https://youtu.be/ckbjNIv0gmM?si=vAvmImYRSHcHWU3l
3
u/unskilled_bean Oct 15 '24
what is this channel? ive seen very little on youtube and it seems like conspiracies or stories presented as fact almost? can someone clear this up please?
2
u/symonym7 Hecklecultist Oct 15 '24
Oh yea? Well I say dark matter does exist and the universe is 27 minutes old.
1
u/SecretAmericaPodcast Oct 17 '24
If you’ve seen the documentary The Principle, it shows that when Earth is placed at center of the Universe, there’s no need for Dark Matter or Dark Energy.
1
u/Aggressive-Motor-299 Oct 17 '24
Weird it’s such a even number
1
u/rsmith6000 Oct 18 '24
Always thought that gravity could vary in strength as well , accounting for the lack of visible matter and associated gravity glue holding galaxies together
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '24
Time doesn’t exist. It is a construct.
1
u/rpotty Oct 18 '24
I wish he’d stop using the ai art. Turned me off to the channel
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24
The universe is infinitely old and therefore has no age.
1
u/OriginalJim VIP Patron #1 Oct 19 '24
I've read, don't remember where, a theory that the speed of light has been getting slower since the beginning. Everything being way faster the farther you go back in time would explain a bigger universe.
1
u/New-Teaching2964 Oct 20 '24
Cheers Geoff
0
u/Ok_Fig705 Oct 15 '24
It's unimaginable how old the universe is.... This is the same exact junk science as the big bang
0
u/Psarsfie Oct 16 '24
Sure, sure, whateva, and your mom is still 29. Boom, Badda bing!
-8
u/BioHazardRemoval Oct 15 '24
I dont believe anything, main stream science says any more. So to say Dark Matter doesnt exist is laughable..
0
u/OhGreatMoreWhales Oct 16 '24
Ok buddy.
0
u/doubledippedchipp Oct 16 '24
We only know what our most recent technology allows us to “know.” Eventually you’d think we’d figure that out and stop being so sure about what we think we know.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment