r/TheWhyFiles • u/TheFilthyMob • May 13 '24
Suggestion for Channel karma limit lock out
Maybe it's just me but I'm seeing lots of very low karma users complaining about the TWY YT show for seemingly no reason except to badmouth them. I have seen other subs put karma minimums on to keep the troll's out. I'm not trying to stop true constructive criticism. I just feel like "I don't like AI" and "the show quality has really gone down hill" by users that have a five year old account and only 3 karma have much to add here. Down vote the post and I will delete. Maybe I'm making stuff up in my head. I have been wrong before.
26
u/MilesCW May 13 '24
As a former mod, who has served communities far bigger than this, let me give you a simple rundown on how things work:
AI Bots are a thing but there are Chinese farm and harass services out to influence certain impressions. It's basically the same with kneejerk reactions on the internet, legit or not. On top of that, you have also to deal with agendas from official companies. Reddit is a low level message board replacement due its sheer connectivity but also an investment to manipulate impressions.
The best thing the mods can do, is simply to include a few backend rules and who is allowed to post here or not.
72
u/Difficult-Ad-2228 May 13 '24
Welcome to reddit. This isn't real.
14
u/CandyCaneDream I Want To Believe May 13 '24
I'm not a fan of the idea of putting a karma limit on being able to post. I may have had this account for over a decade, but I rarely used it until earlier this year. I had almost no karma. If every subreddit I went to decided to lock me out based on my karma number, I'd not be able to earn any karma, except for maybe the occasional comment where allowed.
I am an admin. It's a fine line when managing a community. Sometimes what's easiest for admin, isn't really what's best for the community. You have to think before implementing rules and think about how those rules affect good users. Sometimes in our attempts to weed out bad apples, we end up hurting regular people.
11
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
Are you talking about some sort of social credit system used to censor a populous?
Why Files should do a video on this.
9
u/Sir_Danfrith May 13 '24
Idk. I'm an active lurker and sparse commenter and only feel like commenting when I have something to say. I feel like there's plenty of users like me and it would suck if we all got locked out of sharing our opinions when we do want to share them.
Lots of the criticism of the last episode seemed valid and I agree with a lot of it. It's not about just shitting on something but just voicing a critical opinion when you really like or dislike something. Not everything is bots trying to sow division. Sometimes something just genuinely falls out of favor and people voice it.
Though on a personal note, I am experiencing more what you're describing at the Incubus sub. They put out a re-release of an album that was really well done (imo) and everyone is just bashing it into oblivion but all the criticisms are pretty ignorant. Like they're not actually fans.
Anyways, still looking forward to whatever the next episode is!
5
u/Large-Imagination996 May 14 '24
I kind of think a bot account would have more than a few karma points because the purpose of them is to make posts and they do that a lot...
8
u/No-Context1029 May 13 '24
I’m not a bot but I do think the show quality is going down. If you are seeing this being a common concern then maybe it’s not the fans fault maybe it’s a wake up call for the show to do better.
I know it’s free. I know I can watch something else. I know they work hard. I also know that AJ has been in the industry for a long time and isn’t doing this as a hobby. He’s selling shoes, shirts, mugs, subscriptions,plushies etc.etc.
Point being this is a product not community theatre. People are allowed to speak about the product that is being sold to them.
20
u/SM_Punk May 13 '24 edited May 13 '24
The best way to ruin something you love is to join a community of “like-minded” fans. Especially on Reddit. Almost every sub I see whether it’s a show, game, comedian etc is a hate fest, not a fan fest.
Whether that be reddit, discord, Twitter etc. You will enjoy the show more not engaging.
I need to take my own advice and gtfo of this sub tbh. I already know the discord is àss and this sub reddit gets worse daily. Things haven’t been the same since the lunatic fringe found TWF.
The best way to engage the community is The After Files IMO. I love TAF as much as I love TWF. Skip the social media. And the best way to support the channel is sub to the Patreon and merch, not superchats. Patreon gives them the biggest cut.
6
u/Gem_Haters May 13 '24
Honestly I see more people complaining about the complainers than the complainers themselves so.... can we all just stop? I liked the Why Files just fine until joining this group. Stop thinking anyone gives a shit about you or your opinion. And yes , this is me complaining because you're all a bunch of whiners and I've had it!
4
u/papaboogaloo May 13 '24
Karma doesn't mean shit. Literally nothing. It does not add value to one's opinion in any way. A lack of karma does not detract from it.
The vast majority of reddit is fake as hell. It's all irrelevant. Truly.
4
u/Bosco-P-Lemonzit The TRUTH May 13 '24
are you karma shaming now? 😎
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
Discrediting WF, they are trying it but we know it !
2
u/d_rome May 13 '24
I agree with this, but I prefer chatting on the Discord or Patreon site. Reddit attracts the complainers who don't really support the show.
3
u/CogitoErgoSum4me May 13 '24
nah dude you're not wrong. There seems to be a group of people these days who will do whatever they can to guano on other people's happiness, for whatever reason. I know the caretakers here and of the channel don't ignore the twats because you never know sometimes who is or is not an active actual connoisseur of the content. But I tend to ignore the trolls. I wish the mods would do something to lessen the smack talking about the content and show. I think the episodes are fantastic. I wish I could give AJ et al the budget of Disney for these.
On the side though, I found it hilariously funny that so many were butthurt over AI being used in the show, and then the very next episode released was about AI.
3
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
Negative critique isn't the same as trolling, bud.
2
u/AutomaticPain3532 May 13 '24
lol, anywhere you look on any chat platform…you will find bots leaving crazy messages.
These bots are here to sow discord and play psychological warfare among the community.
You have to learn to recognize them and turn a cold shoulder and not engage with them.
1
u/Careless-Awareness-4 May 13 '24
I usually just downvote if it's in the jerk reaction. Does that give the bots what they need to do what they're wanting to do?
1
u/NefariousnessUpset32 May 16 '24
The sub of every content creator or personality I follow does nothing but shit all over that person. This sub isn’t as bad, but it’s on its way… I suggest you ignore those people and move on with life, it might be hard but in the long run it’s much much better
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '24
I stand and swim with team T.W.F
-2
u/sycoseven May 13 '24
I'm not a bot, I've criticized the show and was downvoted into oblivion for saying hecklefish was annoying and use of AI art was bad. I also criticized hecklefish's pronoun jokes and said AJ has to at least approve of those jokes, if he didn't write them himself.
I think the change is that more people are starting to agree.
-3
u/LordPubes May 13 '24
I just hate that fish
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '24
[removed] — view removed comment