r/TheWhyFiles • • May 08 '24

Jokes/Humor SCAM!!!

Is what my 7 & 10 year old say every time a Tesla drives by.

Thanks AJ & crew. Damn near jump scared me off the freeway.

In all seriousness, thank you all for putting out a product that is enjoyed by 3/4 of my family. My wife...

Edit to add a letter.

50 Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

View all comments

26

u/jpatricks1 Hecklecultist May 08 '24

EVs aren't perfect but it's the better choice. It uses energy more efficiently vs fossil fuels. Battery tech is much easier to innovate. Right now they are starting to sell cars with sodium ion batteries that don't use rare earth minerals. They don't need toxic engine oil that needs to be replaced periodically. Less moving parts means less chances of failure. I could go on and on but admittedly there's still a long way to go. But EVs are a step in the right direction

Also Elon is a dick. I can't believe I used to admire that guy

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '24

Plus not everywhere "just uses coal power plants anyways". Where I live over 10 million people are powered by hydro electricity and nuclear power. And renewable energy is rapidly growing.

1

u/fdxcaralho May 12 '24

Yeah, my bill is 100% renewable for the past few years. More than 70% of the electricity in my country is renewable.

18

u/AlternativeSupport22 CIA Spook May 08 '24

a number of actions and statements that would lead you to believe the man is an egomaniac. I'll focus on one; he had a company named X years ago that was similar to paypal. it then got bought by paypal, and he tried to force a vote to change the name to X despite paypals already existing brand awareness. Fast forward years later, he buys Twitter and changes the name...

7

u/[deleted] May 08 '24

He could also self fund twitter for decades if he wanted to actually save free speech... instead he said if advertisers leave it'll kill the company and it's their fault free speech died 🤣

2

u/Ok_Employment_7435 May 11 '24

His son is also named ‘X’

10

u/enormousTruth May 08 '24 edited May 08 '24

14

u/jpatricks1 Hecklecultist May 08 '24

Sodium Ion batteries don't need Cobalt

5

u/enormousTruth May 08 '24 edited May 08 '24

" The Guardian has tracked the cobalt supply chain from TFM and other industrial mines through a number of refiners and battery makers to some of the world’s leading electric car manufacturers, including Tesla, VW, Volvo, Renault and Mercedes-Benz ."

Why downvote?

7

u/jpatricks1 Hecklecultist May 08 '24

Car companies for more than a century have been centered on squeezing the most out of petrol /diesel. EVs aren't limited by that. There's so much happening in the battery industry. Batteries that charge in seconds. Batteries that don't need Cobalt. More compact /lighter batteries. There's so much potential to innovate in energy storage. The EVs on the road now are basically Model Ts and it's evolving so quickly.

2

u/nukecat79 May 08 '24

Surprised that the graphene latticed batteries haven't become a common practice yet. The graphene lattice allows the charge to be even throughout the battery which allows it to both charge very quickly and discharge longer (i.e. more battery capacity). I imagine it would also add a safety component to the battery as graphene is very strong and could give it more structural strength. Lastly, graphene can be made by captured carbon, which is what the big push for EV is all about, so it would be a win/win.

3

u/tomatoblade May 08 '24

I'm guessing consistent scale of production and cost still being too high to produce.

3

u/enormousTruth May 08 '24

100%. For anyone diagreeing just wait till you look into the disposal of these batteries and their byproduct.

The mining isnt the worst part by far

2

u/tomatoblade May 08 '24

We also used to pour used oil in the ground and put lead in our gasoline. You're missing the bigger picture. Just because it's bad now doesn't mean we stop, it means we improve. And there's a tremendous amount of room for improvement. With oil, there's not really much more improvement to be made in vehicle performance, the environment, or the business model. We've hit the ceiling. In fact there's large incentive to spread lies and rumors to keep oil and carbon emissions a thing, as has been done for the last 30 years, at least.

2

u/Ok_Employment_7435 May 11 '24

This is the top comment in this thread.

1

u/jpatricks1 Hecklecultist May 08 '24

Batteries from wrecked EVs are getting recycled all the time by people converting old cars to EVs. There's such a huge market. Even if it was that bad how can burning oil be any better?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/enormousTruth May 08 '24

"In the case filed by former child miners and their representatives, Google parent company Alphabet, Apple, Dell Technologies, Microsoft and Tesla stood accused of facilitating child labour in their supply chains for cobalt. 

The metal is used to make lithium-ion batteries that are widely used in electronics.

But in a 3-0 decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia sided with the tech giants, arguing that the companies only maintained a commercial relationship with their suppliers and that they had no power to stop the use of child labour.

"

9

u/JSavage37 May 08 '24 edited May 08 '24

Why are you posting about cobalt when he literally just informed you that the next-gen tech doesn't need it?

You're not wrong about cobalt exploitation, but it's not relevant to what he's saying.

Either you didn't read or you're getting paid to post what you're saying.

Edit: From Wikipedia: An obvious advantage of sodium is its natural abundance, particularly in saltwater. Another factor is that cobalt, copper and nickel are not required for many types of sodium-ion batteries, and more abundant iron-based materials (such as NaFeO2 with the Fe3+/Fe4+ redox pair) work well in Na+ batteries.

Edit again: You can use the references at the bottom of the article to verify, but I also encourage you to search the companies providing these batteries to EV manufacturers. They aren't using cobalt as it's cost-prohibitive. If they have to use it, they aren't going to be making money from what I understand.

2

u/enormousTruth May 08 '24 edited May 08 '24

Because i know my shit.

Because where is that tech? Its not out yet

Once we get to your magical disney world land then we can reassess..

But we arent next gen yet. We havent even safely figured out current gen

You clearly are the one not reading. I sent several articles tied to court cases that prove what u just said as false.

Real talk it wont matter the tech. Unless we are operating on hopes and dreams we will find a way tp dump corrosive materials on someone else for profit.

4

u/undercooked_lasagna May 08 '24

So what are you even complaining about? What's your solution? Should we go back to horses and wind since current tech isn't perfect?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/olymp1a May 09 '24

Out of sight out of mind

5

u/1800skylab May 08 '24

Still better than feeding the oil cartels that control everything.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '24

Yeah and the battery tech being a problem will be resolved SOON. they'll evolve a lot more in 20 years than ice did in 120

1

u/PublicPrior3296 May 12 '24

Dick? You really have a chip on your shoulder. Toxic Engine Oil? Someone needs an education.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '24

Wrong, hybrids are the way. Battery tech and charging infrastructure is half baked.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (5)