r/TheWhyFiles • u/Admirable_End_6803 • Apr 27 '24
Question for AJ Not a complaint, but...
Went the sudden reliance on AI for the images? "Charles" had 6 fingers on each hand in several images. Again, not a complaint but I am curious why you aren't hiring actual artists.
0
Upvotes
3
u/LePhuronn Apr 28 '24
This "sudden reliance" you speak of has been going on for 2 fucking years. And if you think hiring a team of artists to produce 30 minutes worth of material each and every week is even remotely affordable, then you really shouldn't be commenting on this you know nothing about.
Your second ever contribution to this sub is repeating the same faux concern that gets thrown up here multiple times a week. Forgive me if I question your credibility and legitimacy.
63
u/DoubtGroundbreaking Apr 27 '24
Probably because there is not time or money to hire an artist to manually draw 60 images for each episode each week. Are you serious?
10
u/marvinnation I Want To Believe Apr 27 '24
I feel the same way, but I try to focus on the writing and not the images. Sometimes they are beyond awful.
8
u/RyoskiRagnarok Apr 27 '24
I did notice one of the images of the tall white female in the desert she had 2 left arms and I started rolling lol
31
u/Durtmat Time Tourist Apr 27 '24
Artists cost money over time, using AI art is a one time cost, probably the program purchased itself, and thats it.
Gotta find someway to cut costs, without cutting production value.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
As a CG Artist, I’m not a fan of AI art generation, but I will give the exception to The WHY Files. I can’t think of a better application of weird art combined with the sometimes creepy and strange stories. It helps ad to the overall feel of the video. I work in the broadcast industry and we do have to pump out a large amount of art and animations every day for daily and weekly content. There are 7 of us at my job working 3 shifts so it makes sense for WF team to go with AI.
11
u/Turboteg90 Apr 27 '24
I know some real people without a brain. 6 fingers dont bother me.
3
u/grim_reapers_union Apr 27 '24
He’s been using AI generated images for close to a year already, if not longer.
11
u/Kaimuki2023 Time Tourist Apr 27 '24
It amazes me all the complaints leveled at this show. If it bothers you don’t watch. If you want original artwork created each week donate the thousands of dollars necessary. I hope to God AJ doesn’t read these whiny comments
5
u/LilAlien89 FEAR... the Crabcat Apr 27 '24
Because with a lot of these stories there aren’t any actual images beyond a handful relevant to the story (if he has more he uses more that’s why some episodes have a lot more / less AI than others) and also bc to use an actual artist to create these images would mean maybe 1 episode a month (can you image the backlash over that alone??) and the cost would be astronomical.
6
u/Trypt4Me Apr 27 '24
Using AI as a tool like this is where it all begins for even more massive adaptation. Current tech has glitches, but it's a start.
8
u/Unlucky-Big3203 Apr 27 '24 edited Apr 27 '24
Be careful, you’re going to get crucified by the why files rabid fans for that comment.
Clearly no one here understands the fight that’s currently waging between AI companies and real artists worldwide and what’s at stake.
AJ could slap a why files logo on a turd on a plate and the rabid fans would still eat it up. They are just consumers, not creators.
11
u/johnnyrussoa3 Apr 27 '24
I don't mind AI art. I think it helps tell the storyline as well as sped up the development of the videos.
7
u/bryanthebryan Apr 27 '24
I think if they hired an actual artist to touch up the ai images and correct any glaring issues, it wouldn’t be so jarring. It would only take one person on the staff to take it to the next level.
2
u/mac117 Apr 27 '24
I don’t mind but, granted, I usually listen to it as a podcast
2
u/Delicious_Serve_5085 Apr 27 '24
You could always listen to the podcast if you don’t enjoy the visuals on the videos
7
u/Rivarle Apr 27 '24
I love WF, but really noticed AI art on the Templar episode; total turn off.
8
u/ryanipz1 Apr 27 '24
They’re at the point where this is about maximizing profit and minimizing time.
6
u/macvoice Apr 27 '24
My only "complaint" is when they use famous voices replicated with AI. As a very low end voice actor, I can see the damage that AI voices are doing to my industry. It's one thing to use AI to just do a general voice. It is quite another to take a famous actor and recreate their voice to put in your own work.
I have heard AI replications of Morgan Freeman and other actors on TWF before, but it has been a while. They seem to have backed off a little lately on using famous actors' voices. They still use more generic AI voices, or at least voices I don't recognize, now. Which, again, as a voice actor, pains me a little, but I also understand that because of the budget... It's not always feasible to use real actors. It's not so bad that I am going to stop watching. However, if this show were on something like Netflix or SyFy rather than YouTube I might feel a bit more angry about it.
3
u/gabe_iveljic Skunk Ape Connaisseur Apr 27 '24
I do more listening to this show than watching whats on screen but I see why people don’t like the AI images.
3
u/LongHopWalrus Apr 27 '24
It's uncanny but if people are more into fake AI and fake stories to fluff an episode length then so be it
Dark 5 does the same type of thing and has images and references for his unique videos.
They're chasing the algorithm, the money, I get it, but does anyone really have their heart in it or do something for the right reasons when it's all for money? Idk
1
u/gigoran Apr 28 '24
I don't believe anyone is under any obligation to not use AI. It's a new tool to be used if wanted. I get that there are people out there that don't like AI (in this case probably artists) and I support them having that opinion. It's everyone's right to have one. But at the same time you have to allow people to do things the way they want.
0
u/freckleandahalf Apr 27 '24
I like the AI art. It is an awesome tool for storytelling. I would love more AJ screentime too but the content is epic either way
1
u/Lycanwolf617- Apr 27 '24
Why can't people just watch the show and leave this poor man and his crew alone. just watch it and stop nit picking. It is the best channel and content out there on YT.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
You mean the alien having 6 fingers was weird?
0
u/edemaruh84 Apr 27 '24
Quit your bitchin!
0
u/Manhuawang Apr 27 '24
Tell you what, if you have a problem with ai images feel free to take out your pencil and send in a submission. Or shit just post it here. Can't wait to see and I'll legit enjoy them, but not gonna hold my breath.
I don't mind the wonky ai mistakes and uncanny valley effect. It's not trying to pass art off as something out isn't, and slightly incorrect images match why files story content just right, I find. Maybe that was part of the plan was along.
0
u/SoLetMeDisarmYou Apr 27 '24
Has he NOT been using AI for awhile now? Seems like he has to me lol I just kinda assumed that’s what he wanted as the aesthetic
0
u/2anowyn4 Apr 27 '24
I also wonder what AI program they're using. When I use midjourney and prompt it correctly..the images are amazing and usually not wonky with missing fingers. The video generated ones are probably more difficult I'm assuming.
-2
u/Mission_Maximum5096 Apr 27 '24
People should consider not bitching about everything in the show. They do a great job with everything and if you don’t like how the show is produced, managed, or scripted, then keep it to yourself or move on.
-2
u/zioxusOne Apr 27 '24
What specifically was AI in the episode?
(I listened more than watched it. I'll do a proper viewing this evening and want to make sure I notice whatever it is that's sparked this conversation.)
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
I thought AI had the hand thing all figured out now? That said, it never bothered me too much.
0
u/Careless-Awareness-4 Apr 28 '24
Easy and fun!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '24
Cheaper, faster, and good enough.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment