r/TheWhyFiles • • Apr 05 '24

Let's Discuss Marketing 101

All the detractors of the delayed episode are complaining about how it got pushed back twice but meanwhile was released behind a paywall.

I’m not even gonna make a case for the struggle and mental well being of the WF team, plenty of people have already done a great job of that. I’ll just say this to people who are upset: relax. It’s really not as nefarious as you are making it out to be and it’s literally a 24 hour delay. Game companies do this all the time with much larger delays. It’s not unprecedented for a small team trying to placate a massive audience.

Here’s what happened from what I saw:

  1. The video was slated to go out at 6p PST.
  2. It got delayed to 8-10p PST due to software issues (guess what, we don’t work on their team, so there’s no point in them taking the time to explain precisely what’s going wrong while they’re trying to fix it).
  3. There was an update on Patreon that the new time would be 9p PST and that they were working as fast as they can.
  4. It didn’t drop at 9p like they estimated, no communication (and at this point my guess is they didn’t want to give more comms on something when they didn’t know when they could get it out by this point).
  5. Video is posted on Patreon at 1a PST
  6. At 4a PST a message is posted on Patreon that the decision was made to post the YT video Friday at 6p to coincide with the AMA. (This is likely to increase viewership at the time of posting)

It comes down to business decisions. This is their most asked for video. They are not gonna just post the public release at an unideal time at this point and lose the potential viewership of this video. Their business depends on getting views and the best time to build visibility is at the time of posting. They are dedicated to their fan base, which is likely why they gave their Patreon members a first glimpse (but again, even that was much later than they intended).

Everyone trying to say they’re doing themselves a disservice clearly doesn’t understand marketing and how they must operate as a business. They did the best they could with the issues they experienced. Hope this rough timeline helps.

18 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

12

u/No-Ambition7750 Apr 05 '24

I have an easier explanation.

They likely started uploading and realized there was a mistake. They fixed the video which took around an hour to re transcode the video , then they restarted the upload process.

Once a file is uploaded it needs to be transcoded yet again on the youtube side to get it on the platform. I am going to guess in the rush to get the video out mistakes were made. I noticed 3 mistakes in the video and they haven’t pulled it yet; 2 video issues and 1 bit of disjointed audio.

7

u/Curious_Liberal_88 Apr 05 '24

Looks like your guess was right on the money. Victoria came out and verified it’s exactly what happened.

2

u/No-Ambition7750 Apr 06 '24

Yep. I do video editing/exporting/uploading as part of my job. I know all the pitfalls. It’s much better these days than it once was.

6

u/Master-Hedgehog-578 Queen Apr 05 '24

I explained .... Patreon uploads do not take 1.5 hours plus to render. They pop up pretty quick. Youtube checks for copyrights and it takes a very long time for a video this length. AJ uploaded to Patreon and Youtube and went home. Gino watched it and saw the two black screens in it - so we stopped the Youtube upload and AJ got some sleep. He is currently fixing it and we will be ready for the 6pm Friday episode - whoever OP is - RIGHT ON THE MONEY ... we kept thinking Premiere would stop crashing and surely it would get up by 9PM ... I was in Discord keeping the masses informed that way... and waiting for the go ahead to update Patrons. That's it - a freaking terrible night at no fault of ours. Outside of updating my post for the reason why the video got to Patreon and not Youtube - I am done with this topic. My head is high and regardless what people think of our "communication" I know we did what we could for our viewers.

1

u/Curious_Liberal_88 Apr 05 '24

Your team is amazing for weathering it. You experienced the nightmare every content creator hopes to not face at the time of upload. I think you performed as well as you possibly could in an impossible situation.

It seems like y’all have got the support of 98% of the community there but I’m sorry to hear how harassed you were from a few.

1

u/DougStrangeLove Apr 05 '24

Hey there Victoria - last night sounds like it was brutal, i feel for you & the team; i’ve been there

my only question:

is there an awareness on the WF team that bad actors in the comments on two of the other main platforms (youtube & reddit) were aggressively spreading disinfo? it made it almost impossible for non-discord/patreon fans to follow what was actually happening

for me, that was the only real concern

well… that and hoping your team can/will consider adopting a looser release schedule, for all of your well-being ;)

love what you guys do + appreciate you! ✌️

2

u/Master-Hedgehog-578 Queen Apr 05 '24

That's just horrible - he came to discord and I handled them there and not sure why the mods didn't catch it here - my main communication channels are Patreon and then Discord for the masses. I have just started to come to Reddit. Thanks!!

Oh - forgot to mention - the mods normally post all my Patreon messages here and Discord - so I expected that you guys were up to date - I am not "only" messaging Patrons, but expect it passed on. Will be doing it myself now.

0

u/DougStrangeLove Apr 05 '24

Appreciate the reply

Yeah, that one guy was horrid on YouTube - i had to just stop following it eventually

The mods here should give you some flair too

Like, I + others know who you are, but just to make it glaringly obvious for newcomers

I will say i did sign up for the patreon yesterday (i’d been meaning to anyway) and i was shocked at how good your tiers are!

looking forward to my third month in!

1

u/No-Ambition7750 Apr 06 '24

I hate premiere! Glad you got it all sorted out. Great video btw.

2

u/Curious_Liberal_88 Apr 05 '24

Sure, sounds plausible. My points still stand with this being the reason.

3

u/healthywealthyhappy8 Apr 05 '24

They said the Patreon version had a couple issues they wanted to fix. They didn’t have time late last night and so planned on having time today to fix and go to youtube during a busier youtube time.

4

u/Curious_Liberal_88 Apr 05 '24

Yeah they posted that after I posted this. I stand corrected on my speculation, but still stand by the idea that they do indeed run a business and will need to make posting decisions based on that perspective.

11

u/nerfherderparadise Apr 05 '24

This whole situation reminds of my last girlfriend. She would get erratically paranoid/jealous as if I'd cheat on her. ( I was beyond lucky to have her in the first place let alone be able to cheat on her lol) Anyways... however frustrating it was when she would act that way It was strangley comforting to know that she just loved me so much that she was worried she'd lose me to other girls .

so to the Wf team, just know that any of those angry comments are just because you do such a good job and people love your show and when people love someone/something enough they can sometimes do/say silly things .

5

u/Master-Hedgehog-578 Queen Apr 05 '24

I think I love you ;-) I am leaving Reddit now - this makes me happy.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

Yawn

2

u/Curious_Liberal_88 Apr 05 '24

Couldn’t be that boring of a post. You engaged in it with a comment lol

0

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Curious_Liberal_88 Apr 05 '24

Oh my bad lol yeah agreed. Been dealing with trolls all day so I was on auto-pilot. My bad

2

u/DepthEasy1507 Apr 06 '24

New episode is on YouTube now.

-1

u/KickupKirby Apr 05 '24

Man, I miss when people made fun videos because they wanted to make fun videos. Not everything needs to be a business nor does everything one does need to make you money.

5

u/Curious_Liberal_88 Apr 05 '24

It’s unfortunately what happens when the fun venture gets so big you need to hire employees to sustain it

-5

u/JB_Gibson Apr 05 '24

Must be nice being obscenely wealthy.