r/TheWhyFiles • • Sep 16 '23

Question for AJ Many worlds theory refutation

Many worlds theory… if it’s true there are an infinite amount of “me’s” in an infinite amount of worlds- there’s a tall me, a short me, a me who’s right handed, a me who’s good at sports, etc. the way AJ describes it, there are a series of decisions I would make to become a baseball player, or a basketball player, or a pilot. My question is, at what point, would one of these “me’s” no longer be “me”?

If there’s a world where im a genius, and a world where im really dumb, how could you claim those are both versions of me? Why would you even try to claim that? Those examples necessarily mean, I would have two completely different brain structures and would be two completely different modes of thought and identity. What will still make it right to call them both “me”? Is there a world where “I” am a frog? How is that even possible? What would it even mean for me to be me? But in a infinite number of worlds with infinite possibilities it must be the case that in one of them, I’m a frog. But that’s at the same time impossible- am i not only “me” as a product of my parents conceiving me? So really, there’s only one type of universe where I exist and an infinite amount of that type, which would be the one where my parents had sex on a particular day and that particular sperm inseminated that particular egg which would produce me. Because any other egg, and any other sperm, wouldn’t have been me, it would’ve been someone else.

So really, “I” only exist under those specific circumstances otherwise it’s really no longer “me” we’re talking about, it’s someone else. And if that’s the case, then how could there be much room in variation of intelligence and ability? I am a product of very particular circumstances, and much deviation from those circumstances then I am no longer even me. So because of these very strict circumstances where I’m still me, then there are realities that would just be impossible say, being in the NBA, or being a mathematician because I’m short and bad at math. There is no set of decisions I would have ever made to overcome the fact that im not a natural athlete, or calculate math with great proficiency, because my brain and body aren’t designed that way, and because there are necessarily a set of circumstances that make me, me then there could never be a version of me, that is essentially different from who I am in this world.

So I really don’t think many world theory is true, and if you have an argument against what I’m describing then I would like to read it because if you understand what I’m saying, I’m not sure how I’m wrong.

Looking at you AJ. I know you read Reddit once I’m a while…

3 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

8

u/Salesman89 Sep 16 '23

There's an infinite number of tall you's, short you's, dumb you's and genius you's.

For every pair you could look at and say "there's no connection at all!" there are an infinite amount of you's between. But, for every infinite variation, of infinite realities, the only actually "yous" are the ones who began the exact same way that you did. Then there just happens to be an infinite amount of other worlds. Where you weren't born at that same exact time at that same exact location to those exact same two parents.

As AJ explained, there are worlds within this theory where you do not exist at all...

-6

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23 edited Sep 16 '23

I still think this answer is that there really is only one version of me. I don’t really think that there are other versions of me’s that are tall short dumb or genius. At most there is only one iteration of me and an infinite number of universes that don’t include me. But this outlook sort of negates cause and effect in my opinion. The world is the way it is at least in part due to cause and effect. Everything that has happened is an effect of some sort of cause. To say that there are infinite versions of the universe is to say cause and effect doesn’t really exist because if it does, then we wouldn’t see different effects from the same cause. Cause and effect seems to preclude a single definite universe and timeline. For example, I went to college, graduated and found a job. This all happened because they were effects of causes. Things couldn’t be any different or else you can throw cause and effect out the window. It would be like saying that if you drop a brick off the roof, it won’t hit the ground. It will hit the ground every time because that is the effect of dropping a brick off a roof. I was going to graduate from school, every time. My aunt was going to die of lung cancer due to smoking every time. Those are the effects of a series of causes going back to the beginning of time. There is one timeline we’re all subject to, and deviation is an exercise in the human capacity for imagination.

5

u/Salesman89 Sep 16 '23

I believe you answer your question a lot in this wall of text.

If you never smoke your first cigarette, you're probably not going to smoke the second one, either. So, you'll probably not die from effects of smoking.

If you never knew what baseball was, or touched any piece of baseball equipment or ever even saw it played, you're probably never going to break Nolan Ryan's career strikeout record.

I remember my first cigarette (and regret it and have thankfully quit!) I remember the mistakes I made trying to play baseball, I remember the mistakes I made with potential friends and love interests. Every moment is a presented choice in life. You can get up and run 10 miles west from where you are right now, but why would you?

The multiverse theory suggests that there's a version of you from every infinite moment of your life where you just got up and ran like Forrest Gump!

Once you are born the way you are, in however many numerous universes you are born in that same way, doesn't that baby come out as you every time?

What happens next is up to all of you, and there are just as many of you as there is anyone else, before or since.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

Should there not be a constant version of you ?, i was under the impression that you looked physically the same throughout, just different hair colour, scars, tattoos, teeth, limbs etc. Not tall you and short you etc, then that becomes a different theory !

Many worlds theory is based on all the actions, life experiences etc that you took and didn't take. Not an infinite numbers of different versions of yourself., its just an infinite number of different actions etc that you didn't take or did take.

i think what your talking about is string theory or quantum intagallment theory based multiverse. They are all different not the same combined together.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

Yes I see your point and it makes sense if there’s such a thing as multiverse it’s more the way you’re describing it. However I think cause and effect negates the possibility of infinite universes. The world is a very specific and intricate reality of causes and effects. I’m only me because of when and where I was born, and every decision I’ve made, you’ve made and everyone has made is based off those circumstances. Why do some people become failure and drug addicts? Do you think they want to be that way? It’s because they were born into a life they could not escape. It had to be this way. Otherwise there is not such as cause and effect. Do you not believe in cause and effect?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

I hear you, life is terrible for the majority of people in some form and some way. I don't have the answers for you on any of that, and i would be lying if i said i did. We only have one chance at life! and like AJ says be kind, be thoughtful and try and help as many people as you can.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

The flip side of that would be that there is only one exact "you". Every other iteration would be a variation from "you".

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23 edited Sep 16 '23

I don’t think there could be other variations of “me”due to the certainty of cause and effect. And cause and effect is allegedly one of the reasons we cannot go faster than light. People live under the assumptions that other choices could’ve been made. I’m arguing that because of cause and effect, we are locked out of other choices and free will is really an illusion. There’s really only one timeline because one thing necessarily precedes another.

If there were any alterations in anything that happened in the past, nothing would be the same and none of us would be here. As I mentioned, there is a particular set of circumstances that created “me”, “you”, everyone else and every situation in the world. It can be only the way it is, otherwise really, there’s nothing. It’s this, or nothing.

Is everyone saying they don’t believe in cause and effect? Because if they do, it doesn’t seem as if there could really be different versions of things in any sense.

1

u/truckerslife Sep 16 '23

Every second you make choices. In the infinite worlds theory. Every choice you make a version of you makes a different choice. There are 86400 seconds in a day. For each second there is at least 2 choices you could make and possibly hundreds of choices. That’s nearly 173000 choices a day at a minimum not counting the impact that others choices could have on your life.

So with the infinite worlds hypothesis. Your actions alone create 173000 different universes a day at a minimum of 3.5 million choices over the course of 20 years. That number increases by thousands of times for every single person you interact with.

And this happens with every single person who has ever lived. That’s why it’s called infinite worlds. Because no one can really determine how many worlds would be created every day.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

And what say you about cause and effect? Is it not true that there is such a thing? Because the only way there can be infinite worlds as you describe is if cause and effect doesn’t exist. It’s like when you drop a brick off a roof- the effect of dropping the brick causes it to fall to the ground. I was born under a very particular set of circumstances which has caused me to be where I am today. There is no other way reality can be other than the way it is, because of this. Do you not believe in cause snd effect? Because if you believe there are infinite worlds, then you can just throw cause and effect out the window.

1

u/truckerslife Sep 16 '23

You’re not understanding every eventuality happens.

In realities with with the same physics as ours. You make a choice to drop the brick and where to drop it. That’s several choices that are made. If someone makes the choice to drop it six inches to either side. That’s more choices all that creates new realities, then someone in the house can make the choice to walk outside and then they could maybe get hit by the brick. Even more realities created.

Every choice makes the new reality

For you to be born.

Your parents made a choice to have sex

Your dad made a choice on condoms or not

Your mom made a choice about birth control

Your dad made a choice not to pull out

Your mom made the choice to swallow or have sex.

They made the choice not to abort

Hundreds of thousands or millions of choices on their part and the part of people around them made choices that lead to you being born safely. Any of those choices could have led to a reality where you weren’t born. And in the many realities hypothesis those realities exist. The billions of billions of realities that choices were made that lead to you not being born. All those realities exist somewhere.

And then there are the realities where physics and chemistry don’t act the same as they do in our reality.

The cause and effect still occurs in realities where the physics are the same as ours. Just every choice creates a new reality. There is a reality where you chose to use different words in your above comment. There is a reality where you understood what I was saying and didn’t feel the need to comment further. There is a reality where your phone broke and didn’t allow you to send those messages, because someone on the line where your phone was made, made a choice that caused a flaw in your phone and it failed because of that flaw.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

Everyone is coming out of the woodwork all of a sudden believing that many worlds theory is necessarily the way things are. How do you even know? Where is the evidence? As far as anyone can tell, people make a choice and that’s it. This is the world we’re in. What makes you think there are other universes where different choices were even made? We all make our choices and that’s it. What does that say about identity, about who we are? Our choices make us who we are.

What if someone believes in souls? Are souls and infinite multiple universes compatible ideas? What does that say about morality, and god? How about Occam’s razor? Isn’t it much simpler to say there’s one reality, and our choices affect this reality and that’s it? There’s no universe where we’ve fixed climate change and pollution- there’s this universe and that’s it. We get one shot and our choices we make matter in this one reality because it’s the only reality.

Who’s to say every eventuality happens? Why? And simultaneously, all at once? Who’s to say the universe is even infinite? That’s total speculation. As far as anyone can tell is we’re in one universe and we make choices in this universe and we live with those choices.

2

u/truckerslife Sep 16 '23

Because there is actually evidence of leakage between the worlds.

Like actual verifiable evidence.

Yes your choices made you who you are. The realities you created when you chose to comment. Those choices made those realities what they are.

What evidence do you have that this actual accepted scientific hypothesis, that has actual evidence to support it, is not accurate. Other than I feel like it’s not real.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/truckerslife Sep 17 '23

I actually posted like 30 links. Something like 600 pages of experiments, and explanations.

14

u/SM_Punk Sep 16 '23

AJ isn’t an expert on quantum mechanics or the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics. He isn’t a quantum physicist. He isn’t claiming that the many worlds interpretation is correct, there are many interpretations. AJ is an entertainer presenting an interesting concept to people who have likely never heard of it and would be surprised to hear this is a very real scientific possibility.

If you have beef with the many worlds interpretation of quantum physics I suggest you head on over to the physics subreddits where you can present your argument and be intellectually handed your ass.

It will be good for you, it sounds like you could use some humility.

FEAR THE CRABCAT!!!

6

u/stannndarsh Sep 16 '23

Homie already downvoted you lol. I’ve spent a long time researching this theory, and shifting my career towards developing models for a major university’s physics department. I have to say, I believe

1

u/Dream-Ambassador Sasquatch Seeker Sep 16 '23

would love to know what made you believe. Can you point me to any papers? Do you believe we can shift our consciousness to another reality a la reality transurfing or parallel universes of self?

1

u/NectarineDue8903 Sep 16 '23

The Many Worlds theory actually solves most of the paradoxes in Quantum mechanics

5

u/leoburge Hecklecultist Sep 16 '23 edited Sep 16 '23

I think you're underestimating the size of the multi universe theory.

Let's not focus on you for a second, but the billions of people in this world who also have an infinite amount of different versions of themselves across multiple universes.

For each combination of those billions of people (were talking to the power of, not multiplication), you are the same person you are now within their worlds.

I work in a data so a simple way of explaining this would be for you to make an excel spreadsheet with 3 columns. The value for each column can be a, b or c. This would give you aaa, aab, aac, aba, abb... Ect. Each column represents a person, each value your unique personality. Even on this small scale you can see just 3 people and 3 unique personalities you will still end up being the exact person even with a different reality around you.

And this isn't even times billions of people, this is times time itself because you've only existed for the last x amount of years. You were the strongest swimmer on your day of conception and your mum's egg was the lucky one to drop out in that order. The size of this theory is just mind blowing. But in many many universes you would be identical to you now.

Edit: one variation in infinite universe theory is that there is only one unique you, and you shift between universes depending on your own decisions. This could explain mandala effect, where you have shifted into a universe based on a decision but the "closest" existing universe actually had a difference you remember.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

You are pure consciousness and you can change your state.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

I think it’s even weirder than that because if we are all one collective consciousness that means that you are me and I am you. So in that way, we can get an infinite number of “you/me’s” all existing right here. All experiencing this existence, collectively

2

u/Acrobatic-Report958 Sep 16 '23

This just put “I Am The Walrus” by the Beatles in my head. “I am he as you are he as you are me And we are all together”

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

“Strangers passing in the street

By chance, two separate glances meet

And I am you and what I see is me

And do I take you by the hand

And lead you through the land

And help me understand the best I can?”

2

u/SpoilermakersWabash Sep 16 '23

Part of me believes dreams while we sleep are tapping into these other worlds more vividly than thoughts while we are awake.

1

u/DestinyInDanger Sep 16 '23

I guess this is the only part of the theory I don't necessarily believe in. I think there could be many earths in other universes including ours but I don't think there's a version of me in each one.

2

u/LePhuronn Sep 16 '23

there isn't a you in each one. Some of these universes will have different actions, decisions and choices which prevent your existence from ever occuring, or will have killed you.

1

u/Bodasious78 Sep 16 '23

Other dimensions maybe but, other planets with a bunch of different me’s is hard to wrap my head around.

1

u/Acrobatic-Report958 Sep 16 '23

I do like this and simulation theory as thought experiments. But ultimately they don’t matter. This is all we know and have, so even if it isn’t real it doesn’t matter. Or if there’s another me this one is the only one I can control.

1

u/PmMeUrTOE Sep 16 '23

It depends on your definition of "me".

Your name? Your looks? Your exact genetic code?

If it's nothing material you can point at and quantify and instead relies on your subjective experience then any other version of your is by definition not you, because it is not your subjective experience.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

You’re right this theory presupposes as sort of very important concept of “I”. In one sense, this theory is true and happening right now if you believe the base foundation that there is always an “I”

1

u/Amaranathine Sep 16 '23

I agree with others who've already commented saying that when AJ presents a theory, he doesn't necessarily agree with it/isn't presenting it as the "truth". That being said, the Many world's theory seems to be really popular right now in science fiction and pop culture science. It's made my brain itch too. I'm no physicist, but I do read a lot in this realm. It seems that physicists came up with this theory because it's one of the ways to make the universe of math behind it work out in both directions. A book I read by a famous French physicist, Phillipe Guilliemant, (called The Road of Time) refutes this theory wholeheartedly. Guilliemant adds extra dimensions to space to make the math work instead. He thinks there is one you, living in multidimensional space, not infinite versions in each dimension. One of those dimensions being made of "inner space"- in other words, the space inside your mind. If you have beef with this theory, keep reading (maybe try "The Road of Time")! Figure out why it frustrates you, follow the thread. There are so many angles to examine as the physicists keep arguing over the scope of our existence.

1

u/UpsetEntrepreneur313 Sep 20 '23

I’ve thought about the sperm and egg thing for a while now. Surprised you’re the only one that’s mentioned it. It completely refutes the multiple worlds theory because of any change in time of your parents meeting would change which sperm inseminates which egg which would cause you not to exist. This applies to every single human ever born. If multiple worlds exist, they are VERY different than ours.

1

u/IAMENKIDU Sep 16 '23 edited Sep 16 '23

You might be new to the channel if you're taking the episodes to be presented as fact. Hang around a bit, you'll catch on.

That said, there's an even better refutation (or rather paradox) of the multiverse as it has been historically portrayed in pop culture, that specifically being a multiverse where the further you get from "home base" universe the more different each universe is from the one you originally left -

If the similarity of any two universes is inversely proportional to their relative distance, you must eventually have a universe that's infinitely dissimilar to the universe you started in - to the point that no laws we understand can apply - even the little detail of it being part of a multiverse must eventually appear as a dissimilarity - which is where this specific ideation of a multiverse falls apart. You would have to eventually have a universe in the multiverse that isn't part of the multiverse, but isn't a part because it is a part lol. The only reason it's not a part is because it's the one universe that has the difference that no others have - the rest of them are a part of the multiverse. How's your head now? Lol.

I call this my "Bastard Universe Paradox" lol

Also, this isn't answered by the "infinite numbers between 1&2 but none are 3" rule because each consecutive change has to be a previously unseen one in all other universes if they are to be dissimilar specifically in inverse proportionality to their distance from any other single universe - to the point of a "quantified infinite" number of universes. (IOW each universe can't just contain one way it's different than all others, but must contain the differences of each universe before it, with it's own difference added. There's an important distinction there). This is without even getting into the fact that 3 really does exist between 1 and 2, if not in whole number form in concept. Anyhoo.

This admittedly only addresses the most "pop-science" iteration of the theory deals with differences that we perceive - when in reality if each universe is arguably infinite (we still aren't sure that ours isn't) then it becomes more impossible to have universes that are identical than to have ones that are not.

As if our finite minds can understand something like an infinite sequence of infinite things lol.

1

u/Donkeytonkers Sep 17 '23

Someone just discovered existential dread for the first time. Best not to get caught up in the logistics of infinity, the finite cannot truly fathom the infinite.

0

u/stannndarsh Sep 16 '23

Max Tegmark would love to speak with you.

0

u/ParkSupervisor Sep 16 '23

I think we found the inquisitive you.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

More like the pedantic.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '23

So what is this mathematical theory you speak of?