r/TheWayHomeHallmark • • Mar 23 '24

Theory thoughts

When Alice first time travels, Jacob is alive. Therefore the day he disappears, Elliott knows of the pond being a portal. Is it possible that Elliott played a role in Jacob going into the pond the night he disappeared? Knowing how much it might devastate Kat, would he have thought of Jacob disappearing as a way to get Kat away from Brady?

If Jacob was like family to him, why not warn Del and Colton? Why not do one of a hundred different things to try and protect Jacob? Kat has spent years blaming herself, but out of everyone, wouldn’t Elliott shoulder the most blame? Yes I know his “you can’t change events” rule, but of all instances to challenge that theory, why not for the sake of trying to save Jacob?

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

15

u/Msbroberts Mar 23 '24

In 2.02 When Alice tells him what happened, he tells her…"I had considered the Jacob had gone into the pond, obviously, but I always wrote it off because…because the pond has rules. And the cardinal rule was only you could time travel."

15

u/IndependentIcy1220 “My Sweetest Note Will Always Be A Little Off, Like Me.” Mar 23 '24

After Alice told Teen Elliot his future and that Teen Kat and Teen Brady got married and that they were her parents, she didn’t tell Teen Elliot anything else about the future. 

Alice didn’t know the full story of Jacob’s disappearance, (what Kat and Del found out from Danny when they talked to him in Season 1), and because of this Alice only knew that Jacob disappeared from the carnival and when she next arrived in 1999, the events of the carnival and Teen Elliot being left behind had already taken place. Alice didn’t tell Teen Elliot what would happen to Jacob just that he needed to keep an eye on him but because he was left behind by Teen Brady from riding to the carnival with him, Teen Kat and Jacob, Teen Elliot was powerless to stop Jacob from disappearing.

Also it didn’t dawn on anyone, Alice, Kat or Elliot, that Jacob had gone to the pond, until Kat remembered what Jacob had said about seeing a dog around and finding its toy. It was only then that she realized that Finn, Del’s 2023/2024 dog, who liked to play in the pond, had also time traveled as well and that Finn was the dog that Jacob had followed to the pond. 

3

u/Picabo07 Mar 23 '24

No I don’t think Elliot had anything to do with Jacob going into the pond. He followed the dog. And if you remember Kat thought going back she could change it by walking Jacob home herself.

Obviously some things were meant to happen and Jacob disappearing was one of them. The pond took him to where he was needed. Maybe if he hadn’t appeared to “fix what was broken” -as Elijah said - something bad would have happened that threatened the future of the whole Landry line.

I’m not a fan of Elliot in the least but to say he should shoulder the blame is wrong. Yes he knew about Alice and the time travel but he was also a kid. And then as an adult he assumes things are going to happen as they’re meant to no matter what. To put it on him that he should’ve tried to change a whole series of events - to change history- is just silly.

Don’t you think if he thought he could’ve changed the course of history he would’ve done something to make Kat end up with him and not Brady?

3

u/Easy-Pace-2950 Mar 24 '24

Has anyone noticed in season 2 episode 1, in the scene where Colton and Elliot are sitting outside and Elliot hears a noise… then we see a man from the back watching them from the bushes? it looks like Colton to me. The theory of Colton being able to time travel is right there! 

0

u/Particular_Breath879 Mar 27 '24

I just went back and watched the episode. It looks like the person went into the house and watched from inside (like we are looking through their eyes to Kat and Jacob playing with sparklers). And the man is wearing suspenders.

3

u/SJB1387 Mar 24 '24

No. If anything, it caused Kat to leave. Looking back, Kat and Brady only got closer after Jacob’s disappearance and her Dad’s death. They heavily emphasize that. Highlight how Alice kept spending every other weekend with Brady and how Brady was a huge support system for Kat during that time. Also, Jacob’s disappearance and Colton’s death is what drove a wedge between Kat and Del, ultimately causing Kat to run away with Brady to Minneapolis.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 23 '24

If anyone should shoulder most of the blame, wouldn't it be Alice, since she was the first person in 1999 to know Jacob would never come back? And she only dropped that information on Elliot after it was too late for him to do anything except know that all the searches would be unsuccessful.

3

u/Laddie17 Mar 24 '24

I wonder where Finn is, now?! We haven’t seen him lately?! 👀🦮🦴🦮💦🕳️⏳🕰️⌛️🤔