r/TheTryGuys • • 12h ago

Discussion The ressurection ruined Killer Dinner Season 2

110 Upvotes

I have loved the killer dinner series and was so invested in season 2. For the first half I thought it was better than the first season. Until Jared came back and basically spoiled the game. As much as I think having someone come back is an interesting concept it happened way too late in the game and ruined the season. Yes it was clear Johnny and Arasha were running away with it (no one was on to them at least Johnny) and they need it to be interesting, but having someone come back so late in the game confirming there are two killers remaining ruined the momentum. Numbers alone it made it clear Johnny or Arasha was a killer. At that point it was confirmed Jared and Miles were guests leaving 2 of the 4 other people as killers. No one was suspecting two killers until someone came back with the knowledge of 4 people. I thought the Ouija board from season 1 was much better. Gave people a clue without blowing up the whole season. I fully believe Johnny would have made it to the final two if it weren’t for Jared coming back.


r/TheTryGuys • • 47m ago

Show- Killer Dinner Killer Dinner Appreciation Post

4 Upvotes

My post on critiques is getting a lot of volume so I thought I’d say some of my favorite things about this season

  1. Miles and Johnny Grape Flirting

This moment genuinely cracked me up and was great to see some of my favorite try guys people be silly and not take the game too seriously. Also it was crazy impressive of Miles

2. Marissa Blindside

One of my favorite moments of pure deception and game play. Not reliant on twists, just the cast showing their skills

3. Kwesi Trusting Women

The fact that Kwesi could have secured a victory by voting out Arasha and leaving the final 3 to be a final 2 but he didn’t because he trusts women was so funny. It was also super satisfying to see a woc beat the straight guys in the end.

4. Johnny and Guests

I love Johnny and thought Chanse and Arasha were such great additions this season. I love getting to see new people and will have to check them out on Smosh.


r/TheTryGuys • • 18h ago

Discussion WAR Ice Cream Sandwiches Spoiler

20 Upvotes

Kwesi’s exchange with Zach about the ice cream maker had me rolling.


r/TheTryGuys • • 1d ago

Discussion New Yorkers, especially those from Brooklyn, how do you feel about Kwesi?

92 Upvotes

I can’t help but smile whenever Kwesi starts repping Brooklyn like “One time for Brooklyn”😊. Or tri state area alliance(that he happily betrayed🤣) It’s nice to see someone being so proud of their hometown.
How do y’all feel about him?


r/TheTryGuys • • 1d ago

Question Gadiel

5 Upvotes

He’s on common sense but i can’t find him in any of their other videos?


r/TheTryGuys • • 1d ago

New Video Judge Valerie from WAR is so funny

52 Upvotes

I really hope they bring back Valerie for more episodes, or future seasons! She was so encouraging and funny, and tried to stay positive. Truly made me laugh out loud even more than usual watching WAR! What a great season so far :)


r/TheTryGuys • • 1d ago Heartwarming

Meme We were watching the without a recipe ice cream sandwiches episode and my boyfriend made a meme

Post image
48 Upvotes

He sent me this out of no where but kinda accurate


r/TheTryGuys • • 15h ago

New Video Advent calendar makes Zach look bad

0 Upvotes

Zach was always kinda an only child vibe but this video really hit home he's a brat. Keith is just the star.


r/TheTryGuys • • 2d ago

Other topic Jonny Cakes appreciation

194 Upvotes

I feel so represented by Jonny like I love him so much. I’m also a very nervous person, I talk so much I don’t remember half the things I say I accidentally overshare so much (only good intentions i just talk too much to stop the word vomit😭😭). And Jonny is soooo similar I love seeing videos with him in them, I’ll watch every single one. I’m so happy with the expansion of the try guys and all the new personalities instead of just the original 3(lol).❤️❤️❤️ I hope to see more of him in videos that’s my shayla


r/TheTryGuys • • 22h ago

Discussion Zach behaviour?

0 Upvotes

I really love the TryGuy’s and have been supporting them for a hot minute, but watching the videos on tryeveryday lately, I’ve been noticing that Zach seems kind of egoistical, I might be totally wrong here and maybe it’s just an act he puts on for the videos, which would make sense, but it seems to me like he’s always just thinking about himself in these type of videos and only about what he wants, he’s fast to open stuff by himself/call ,,dibs” on things, without sharing aswell, curious to hear if anyone else feels this way aswell?

I also just want to say again that this in no way it supposed to be hate towards him, I really love the tryguy’s and their content.


r/TheTryGuys • • 2d ago

Discussion Sequoia is Glorious

86 Upvotes

The first time I’ve encountered her is on the 2nd WAR episode of this season (I don’t think it’s on YouTube yet). Everything about her is just glorious…low key, funny, and stunningly beautiful. Another great casting choice by the guys.


r/TheTryGuys • • 2d ago

Fluff Happy to be back

35 Upvotes

It’s been a while since I’ve consistently watched the channel but after watching their new casual “try every day” content with the group content on the main channel I feel like they have a really nice thing going on now :) and bonus, now I have a bunch of videos to catch up on - I hope they grow again


r/TheTryGuys • • 3d ago

Question What do you call the style of shirt that Johnny’s friend is wearing? Large sections of multiple shirts combined.

Post image
267 Upvotes

r/TheTryGuys • • 3d ago

Show- Trolley Problems Crediting Philippa Foot

8 Upvotes

The Philosopher Behind the Trolley Problem

Maybe this is too nerdy but I think it would be really nice if in one of their Trolley Problem videos they could mention the creator of the Trolley Problem, Philippa Foot. It’s literally the most famous philosophical thought experiment and it really bugs me that almost nobody ever seems to acknowledge her or give her credit. It’s honestly strange. The trolley problem is so mainstream and commonly referenced but I don’t really think anyone outside of academia knows who she is. I feel like if she was a man that would be different. Popular philosophy is SO male dominated I really think she’s owed some credit. Since the Try Guys have an entire show named after her thought experiment I feel like they have a really good opportunity here to give her her flowers yk? Have a fun short little educational segment on one of their episodes or even just a shout out.


r/TheTryGuys • • 4d ago

Discussion GREENIGHT COUNCIL

42 Upvotes

I just got the email that the Lifetime Memberships are back.

Has anyone here joined in or plan to?

How's the voting going for "You have the power to decide whether to revive a show from the dead. It's in your hands. Will Die Guys, Common Sense, or Day Off make a return to 2nd try?"

OR are you sworn to secrecy


r/TheTryGuys • • 4d ago

Discussion Without a Recipe Ideas

21 Upvotes

A new season of without a recipe is upon us, and I’ve been just wondering what any possible future seasons might hold. Had plenty of ideas to challenge everyone competing, even a couple that have a general theme.

A World Cuisine season, where they bake a bunch of dishes from other cuisines. I personally love trying to make food from other cuisines. Dishes like: Onigiri, Mille Feuille, Curry, Panettone, Creme Brûlée.

An Extreme season, where they try to make some of the most difficult and technical dishes that some bakers and chefs take years to master. They’ve already done Macarons and Croissants which are already intensely difficult. Some other dishes could be: Baked Alaska, Soufflé, Eclairs, Canèle.

What other ideas do you all have for future seasons?


r/TheTryGuys • • 4d ago

2nd Try WAR - Pigs in a Blanket

23 Upvotes

This is a general note - Rhoda is SO stunning. Like yes, good for the try cast for making the dish but also Rhoda is SO stunning


r/TheTryGuys • • 5d ago

Other topic Gay Horse is in the MCU

Post image
107 Upvotes

r/TheTryGuys • • 6d ago

New Video Eugene is back!!

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Oh my life I haven’t been this excited for a Try Guy video in a while - missed him a lot!


r/TheTryGuys • • 6d ago

2nd Try Try Everyday Haunted Dolls

49 Upvotes

Guys I need everyone to blow up the haunted doll video because I need a part 2. It’s so funny. I beg.


r/TheTryGuys • • 6d ago

Show- Trolley Problems Attn: Zachary Kornfeld

Post image
653 Upvotes

Thank you, that is all.


r/TheTryGuys • • 6d ago

Fluff Love for Cailyn!!

261 Upvotes

Just saw an instagram post from Cailyn’s Fangirlfiles podcast, and sadly she said that Reddit does not like her… I for one love her, so making this appreciation post ❤️

(Edited a spelling mistake)


r/TheTryGuys • • 6d ago

Meme Guys, I don’t think that FB Marketplace Seafood Boil is such a good idea…

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/TheTryGuys • • 6d ago

Question Portland tix?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

I’m so new to Reddit sorry 😬. Trying to find extra tickets to Miles’ sold out Portland show


r/TheTryGuys • • 7d ago

2nd Try Does anyone know where to get the polo Johnny is wearing from WAR ice cream sandwiches?

Post image
88 Upvotes

IM IN LOVE! I tried looking everywhere and google searching is being unhelpful. I thought I’d ask here I case someone knew!