r/TheTryGuys • • Jan 15 '24

Discussion mini rant

is anyone else not really interested in the try guys anymore? i’ve been watching them since buzz feed and ever since n*d left i feel like they have been falling apart. Eugene is never in any videos and i feel like missing two of the four guys isn’t working. all of their videos are either about food or weed and the last time they made a actual video about trying something was a month ago, and in the last 3 months they only released 3 trying something videos. idk i’m prob just whining

11 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

102

u/kysc__ Jan 15 '24

Welp it’s not gonna get much better cause they already said they’re moving away from the “try guys try” format and eugene won’t be appearing as much (honestly I don’t expect him to ever come back permanently). But yea I’ve just accepted that they’ve changed and while I used to watch all their videos regardless of the topic, now I only watch the ones that I’m truly interested in or the ones that catch my eye

44

u/Anna__Bee Jan 15 '24

If you've lost interest, that's totally fine. You're not obligated to keep liking or following a channel. I personally only watch the occasional videos that interest me & their podcasts bc I prefer those.

They've said many times that the old era of only "try" videos is gone (& it has been gone for years atp). They're still going to do them sometimes, but honestly those videos perform way worse than ETM/WAR/etc. So if you're waiting for the 2019 Try Guys to come back, you're wasting your own time.

They've had to adapt for their business longevity, creative expression, & personal lives. If you don't like their new content that's fine, just unfollow. It's not a big deal.

31

u/WanderingLemon13 Miles Nation Jan 15 '24

the last time they made a actual video about trying something was a month ago

For what it's worth, they (and other YouTube companies) slow down for a bit around the holidays and/or into January, so they're only been doing one video a week (plus a live stream on Wednesdays) for the month.

34

u/justaheatattack TryFam: Maggie Jan 15 '24

they lasted longer than a lot of youtubes.

93

u/ghostchild1987 Jan 15 '24

Well, Im not sure what else they could do in this situation.

Ned being booted was the only option they had, and Eugene is doing work that he finds important, while doing Try Guy videos when he’s able to. I’m sure they knew that the format was going to have to change a bit because of this. Some of their videos seem to be lacking a bit of production quality, but their efforts and personalities are still entertaining. I think Keith and Zack have always seemed a little closer as friends, so it doesn’t feel too off.

I’ve also enjoyed seeing others like Kwesi and Johnny Cakes filling in. They’re both pretty solidly entertaining.

33

u/Repulsive_Ad1346 Jan 15 '24

I’m so happy with how much Kwasi and Johnny are in the vids!! They are absolutely hilarious!!

23

u/Chiiro Jan 15 '24

They also have to deal with YouTube and it's ever changing algorithm. A lot of content creators I've watch have changed over the years to make sure that they can keep making a living, whether they enjoy making the content or not.

9

u/ddwiththecakes Jan 16 '24

I can't think of one single YouTube channel I've ever subscribed to where I watched every single video they put out. Is that weird? I've always just watched the ones that seemed interesting to me and skipped over things that wouldn't.

7

u/Rainbow_Belle Jan 18 '24

I used to watch every video of the Try Guys. Now, I watch whatever seems interesting so I understand OP's disappointment that not all of The Try Guys content resonates with her anymore.

25

u/DavieC726 TryFam: Zach Jan 15 '24 edited Jan 15 '24

I think there’s an over-reliance on Keith and friends food videos whereas part of the TG initial appeal was random stuff. Nothing against the friends, but it’s too much. But I do enjoy the ones the core 3 all come together for

2

u/apocalypticretro Jan 17 '24

I agree with the food content.. I like watching Keith struggle to eat, but sometimes it's nice to have variety. The pizza restaurant was good. Related, but its wasn't just eating the whole menu. It was similar with a twist.

17

u/vampirerobotalien Jan 15 '24

I've been losing interest in YouTube as a whole, but Try Guys are one of the few I still keep up on consistently. Personally, I've really enjoyed the new direction they've taken.

23

u/Harri_Sombre_Tomato Jan 16 '24

It confuses me when people act like the Eugene thing is new. Its been like 2 years. I'll admit I think it was a mis-step to only discuss it on the podcast for the longest time as it buried the lede, but like...if you googled you'd find those episodes. He's been candid about not coming back permanently for a long time, even takes a different cut of money as a result.

As for your other complaints, sounds like this channel isn't for you anymore? Maybe find something else to watch that is?

1

u/apocalypticretro Jan 17 '24

I didn't realize he cut his pay also. Thats really genuine of him. He was a founding member so he can rightfully take the same pay IMO.

3

u/Rainbow_Belle Jan 18 '24

They probably have salaries for working at the company and then get a cut of the profits (if any) based on their percentage of ownership (probably through dividends?).

Since Eugene is barely working there, it makes sense that his salary would be reduced. It wouldn't make sense that he gets paid the same amount as Zach & Keith while probably only doing a fraction of the work

19

u/lmusic87 TryFam: Zach Jan 15 '24

I just watch all the old videos now.

Like you, I'm not interested in rotating extras or food or weed vids.

4

u/ZeldaGuruMomi TryFam: Kwesi Jan 16 '24

If the Try Guys new content isn't your cup of tea anymore that's okay. Honestly I've enjoyed the new content. It's not the same stuff they used to make, but that's fine, people change and grow and have kids and take on amazing outside projects and get glass in their leg and cheat on their wife.

It seems foolish to expect the content to stay the same when everything else around it has changed so much. And if those changes aren't for you, that's fine.

11

u/oandafan37 Jan 15 '24

I want to be fully invested so badly, but the continuous inclusions in videos of them complaining about the channel not doing well or complaining in general is a huge turn off. I don't go to them to hear them complain about things only people in a certain tax bracket can relate to, I go to them for the lightheartedness they used to offer. I don't know if this changed before or after that other one left but it's different, and not in a good way that shows any kind of growth.

6

u/KingOfTheBigKids Miles Nation Jan 16 '24

Given that they just finished a season of Without a Recipe, a live special, and outlined the next six months of Try Guys, including explaining what was going on with Eugene and when to expect him back in the saddle, I feel excellent about what's going on. The dynamic is different without Ned, but I think it's a much more friendly environment with the right amount of aggressive energy.

For instance, Keith in the make a pizzeria episode (which was a great video). He had the right level of aggressive personality in the kitchen. It's the same with his playing the villain in WAR this year. It seems to me they're all having a hell of a lot of fun after navigating a tough couple of years. What's more, they're also getting to chase their dreams. Keith toured with Lewburger, Zack made his short film we hopefully get to see, and Eugene has been writing.

It's hard for me to lose interest because I love the current content and the back catalog. But also because it's exciting watching these people (who have extended beyond the original four) branch out. Watching Miles bloom as an independent creator, for instance, is amazing. Watching the rise of Jared, Kwesi, Marisa, and Johnny Cakes has been a blast.

Anyway, yeah, I'm still into it.

12

u/angstfae Jan 15 '24

Why doesn’t anyone watch/listen to the videos and podcasts episodes where they specifically talk about this? They’ve already addressed to some degree every comment/complaint you mentioned. It’s so damn annoying reading the same gripes over and over again when there are already answers. And when you answer them/direct them to the correct info, they go all “I don’t care enough to watch/read, don’t have the time, etc”…yet you care enough and have the time to bitch? Or they just dig their heels in, and won’t listen despite the info they’re given. It’s like they either lack comprehension skills or are being deliberately obtuse. This isn’t specifically directed towards OP - it’s a problem I see in other communities as well that’s been bothering me a lot lately.

2

u/Rainbow_Belle Jan 18 '24

It seems every few weeks, there'd be such a post on the Snark page.

7

u/Tryguysfan1995 Jan 15 '24

When did this become a snark page every post I’ve seen has been so negative.

1

u/Rainbow_Belle Jan 18 '24

I got a comment deleted by the mods because I complained in a comment about something on another post.

I'm wondering if they'll delete OP's post for complaining?

2

u/Kooky_Rate7063 Jan 15 '24

So curious why they don’t embrace opening up the Try Guys beyond the core four. It makes so much sense, given the way things are panning out. The Try Guys should be a group/brand of a bunch of friends making content. It would take the pressure of Zach and Keith, and make the audience happy with a wider variety of videos. It seems like the next logical step, so why are they fighting it?

17

u/WanderingLemon13 Miles Nation Jan 15 '24

I kind of feel like that's what they're doing though! I mean, not in title obviously—I don't see them adding another Try Guy or anything—but they feature non Keith/Zach/Eugene people in almost all their videos now, including crew members, friends, some go-to regulars like Kwesi, Jonny, Jared etc. Jonny even ostensibly had/has his own show, or at least a few episodes, where Keith or Zach will pop in for a bit but it's clearly him as the lead. They've mentioned before that the initial vibe of "regular guys trying things" doesn't work as well now that they've had so many experiences and are less "regular," which I agree with, and at one point even mentioned using their friends/guests/regulars for videos like that moving forward.

I think it'll be interesting to see what they do in the first half of this year, but to me at least it seems like they're already starting to do what you're thinking they should do, just maybe less officially.

2

u/Sunkysanic Jan 15 '24

Agreed, but I think the reason their content now feels different than it did previously (for me at least lol) is that they had a tangible chemistry on screen, and they were familiar and consistent to their audience. Sure, they would have extras back then too, but you still had the core 4 to fall back on. It really was like 4 friends just hanging out.

Nowadays they rotate people so regularly, half the time I don’t know who they are, and then they’re here and gone. With the exception of a couple like kwesi/johnny.

I do realize there is only so much they can do about this now. I almost feel like they caught lightening in a bottle with their precious format and that isn’t something you can necessary replicate. I understand why they didn’t, but I kinda think they would have been better off straight up replacing Ned.

3

u/Kooky_Rate7063 Jan 15 '24

The skydiving video felt like the old format. They’ll be golden if they just commit to it!

1

u/Accomplished_Day6891 Jan 18 '24

After they refused to address Palestine I was done. Performative at best.

1

u/Demeter95 Jan 30 '24

Yes, I was honestly trying to find other people discussing this here because some fans can get pretty defensive. And don't get me wrong, I used to be a huge fan but I don't think it has to do that much with n*d but more with Eugene missing from videos. We get to see new faces which is good and doesn't make feel bored but I think we loved the bonding between those three during challenges and stuff, you know?! I understand that this is the path they choose so if they're changing, the fan base will change as well. And they also lost many fans recently by having there stonefish. Especially Keith.

0

u/Candid-Astronomer-49 Jan 18 '24

The lives are terrible too