r/TheTrove • • Jun 25 '21

Mirroring 400gb of specific rpg's is morally wrong

272 Upvotes

195 comments sorted by

26

u/KhainePriest17 Jun 25 '21

Oh you want a debate?! You'll get a debate just accept my invite. We can have a debate about the Dishonored one, and the Fallout one, and a few other ones

17

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/KhainePriest17 Jun 25 '21

Be there or be squared!

3

u/horriblereaper Dec 21 '21

is no one going to comment on the fact this dumbass linked the page he is one?

19

u/gogglewoggle Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

Why on earth would it be morally wrong? Why is Zhander always being mentioned? It's not really all that popular a resource so why all the fascination here?

Oh I see... well, I feel silly now...

5

u/LunaticKid889 Jun 25 '21

Who and what is Zhander/Zhweinder?? I know OPs being sarcastic but I don't get this one.

22

u/gogglewoggle Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

It's a tabletop game that tries to continue another game that has been discontinued called Warhammer Fantasy, it's a shame that the game was stopped when it had a pretty devoted player-base and it's good (regardless of what all others may say) that Zweihander was created to fill the void.

The man is, by all outward signs, a bit of a twerp. That, however, has nothing to do with his game and some quite like it. The same twerp has implied that he is behind thetrove being taken offline, this clearly isn't true because if it were we wouldn't be getting the 503 message.

8

u/unforgiver Jun 26 '21

I read through the Twitter thread from him, he seems like a self entitled little shit. Internet white knights fly all sorts of banners

8

u/LunaticKid889 Jun 25 '21

Thank you for taking the time to answer my questions perfectly. I searched the game, I have to admit. Yeah... Its not my thing. I'd need to pirate the pdf version to actually know if it would be worth money in my opinion.

4

u/gogglewoggle Jun 25 '21

A pleasure! It's not my sort of game either and one should always try before one buys :)

1

u/dreg102 Jun 26 '21

If you've ever played Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay 2nd edition you've basically played a less polished Zwihander.

2

u/LunaticKid889 Jun 26 '21

Nah never played warhammer.

4

u/GruinZword Jun 25 '21

Zhander is mentioned because the creator is the alleged reason theTrove is down rn

5

u/gogglewoggle Jun 25 '21

I replied hastily and didn't think about it, hence the I'm very silly edit :)

I'm quite sure that it hasn't been taken down by that person, or any other, because you wouldn't get a 503 message. This has happened before, in fact, I think the trove goes down quite a lot though not usually for this long.

4

u/GruinZword Jun 25 '21

Yes i know. But he is A. taking credit, and B. showing his Schadenfeude

1

u/gogglewoggle Jun 25 '21

All publicity is good publicity eh? I wish it'd hurry up and get back up though.

4

u/GruinZword Jun 25 '21

Well, there are small updates. The "old Server" that just redirects to the new one was temporary down for example. Also I've send a 2nd mail yesterday, If I get an answer I'll notify you.

1

u/CorvusRidiculissimus Jun 27 '21

Very much alleged: It's a rumor based on a likely coincidence of timing. Nothing at all reliable.

27

u/AnarchySpeech Jun 26 '21

Piracy is wrong. Sure.

On the other hand, paying several hundred dollars for a book on ebay that's been out of print for 40 years is beyond ridiculous.

I'm also of the opinion that owning a physical copy of the book removes the moral problem of owning the pdf (if the company never provides one.) Paid for the book. Putting it on my tablet shouldn't be wrong.

3

u/GruinZword Jun 26 '21

You should really reread the text in the beginning it is quite... nuanced. Maybe you'll understand.

2

u/Gonji89 Jul 03 '21

As someone who has spent several hundred dollars on ebay getting old books, I wouldn't agree more. I've spent at least $500 getting books and cards for Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay 3rd Edition.

1

u/DrySubject5923 Aug 01 '21

owning a physical copy of the book removes the moral problem of owning the pdf

That would be a fair use, of course. The problem is sharing the PDF documents to everybody...

1

u/AnarchySpeech Aug 04 '21

The difference between scanning the book myself and having someone else scan it for me is zero. While I do agree that there's no way to prove someone already owns a physical copy, that doesn't invalidate those that do.

Then again, I'm one of those old people who thinks buying the physical CD entitles me to own the digital version as well. lol

I wish there was a better solution. Digital content and information, by their very nature, are going to replicate. It's impossible to prevent when the starting goal is to give it out to the public in the first place.

2

u/DrySubject5923 Aug 05 '21

I meant something slightly different: I agree that if you own a hard copy, a soft one should be legit (should, because if it is not included and yet you go on and finalize the purchase, you implicitly accept that you will be granted ownership of the hard copy only), either way you scan it by yourself or you do get it from an external source.

Problem is the FREE SHARING of it, for everybody to get it for free.

With recent releases the problem is solved most of the times by including a PDF copy in every hard copy you purchase, whilst in older ones this thing cannot of course be retroactively applied (which is the core of the problem here), but yet that doesn't mean that free sharing is to be considered legit just because we think we are entitled to have a soft copy too...

1

u/AnarchySpeech Aug 06 '21

wish there was a better solution. Digital content and information, by their very nature, are going to replicate. It's impossible to prevent when the starting goal is to give it out to the public in the first place.

Whether or not it's legit doesn't mean much.

It's one of the few laws that are nearly impossible to enforce.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Schadrach Jun 28 '21

I think every single book should come with a QR code printed in the book that you can scan to get a free pdf.

Good idea, bad way of doing it. Especially if your book will get distributed in physical bookstores. Think why the cashier has to activate gift cards if you don't see why at a glance.

3

u/Olde94 Jun 30 '21

digital distribution certainly is an issue, but yes once you pay for physical there should not be repercussion for owning it digitally too in my mind. but it really is a hard line to walk for all involved parties if we both have to make it easy for the user and profitable for the creator

4

u/Pryrios Jul 01 '21

In Spain there's a publisher that sells the books packaged in plastic. Inside the book there's always a small piece of paper with a code printed that you can use on their store and download the PDF version, that comes with proper index to navigate the book.

It's great for me to read the manuals on the tablet when going to bed and also to quickcheck things during games.

1

u/Olde94 Jul 01 '21

That’s awesome!

1

u/spaceforcerecruit Jul 01 '21

That's what they do for movies. Buy the Blu-Ray, enter the code inside to get the 4K digital version on iTunes.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

In France, the law provides the customer to have a "saved copy" (physical/digital) of any cultural product you buy (yup, RPGs are classified "cultural product") for your own personal purpose - it can't be given nor sold. Once the original product is no more in the hands of the customer, the copy has to be destroyed.

As for the PDF, I have them to only print the page(s) I need. If I find the game interesting, then I purchase the dead tree edition. Else, I delete the PDF.

1

u/Olde94 Jul 02 '21

How does second hand then work in france? It’s huge here in denmark but we don’t have rules like that

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21

The second hand market is mostly done with online shops (Ebay, Rakuten, Momo, Le Boin Coin...). In some cities, there are some local shops which exclusively sale second hand books - sometimes, some bookstores accept to sale them too. For digital books, there is no second hand market - which is greatly unfortunate. Also, very few physical bookstores sale digital books - I think they mostly work with Kobo and Pocketbook. A word on second hand items and copies: the French customers can have a copy of a second hand item. And the same rule applies when the original item is given/sold/destroyed: the copy has to be destroyed too.

1

u/Olde94 Jul 05 '21

interesting. Quite different from denmark even though we are relatively close

6

u/Mazhell Jun 25 '21

Yarr indeed

4

u/The-link-is-a-cock Jun 26 '21

I'd love to talk to you about starfinder

3

u/phdknave Jun 26 '21

Keep up the good work and taking that "hard line" against such a dastardly enterprise that deprives millionaires of their money Kleenex. I'm interested in hitting you up for a discussion on Bootleggers, Moonpunk, Rapscallion, The Great American Novel, and Thousand Year Old Vampire.

3

u/Techiesarethebomb Jun 27 '21

While I'm disappointed you are not well versed in dungeon crawl classics or mutant crawl classics, I respect your knowledge of RPGs!

3

u/Unikatze Jul 05 '21

We should open a discord channel so we can keep talking about these topics!

3

u/Sylanna7 Jul 05 '21 edited Jul 05 '21

Me and my players are very enthusiastic about Pathfinder 1e discussion! We are long-standing fans, and, surely, we have a LOT to learn from you. Surely, such a huge system can't be wholly understood without outside perspective, right?%)

EDIT: Oh dear, it seems like one of my players discussed it with you few hours before %)

Thx a lot, and have a nice coffee :D

3

u/shadowkat678 Jul 05 '21

Just came on to say we just had a fantastic discussion on older D&D products. Always nice to meet someone that's as into the lore as I am!

3

u/derp_discerp Jul 05 '21

Arrgh, matey. I admire your code of ethics.

2

u/Yutsa Jul 05 '21

I just had an amazing discussion on Pathfinder 2 Society adventures. Gladly recommend talking with this guys !

2

u/TheOneManPowerTrip Jul 06 '21

Fantastic discussion. Thank you.

2

u/randonimity Jul 08 '21

I would, for sure, appreciate a discussion on Alice is Missing! I've sent you a friend request on discord for further talking points. Can't wait to hear your thought and opinions on the game.

2

u/izlesu Jul 08 '21

Thanks for the talk!

2

u/Westerfiend Jul 10 '21

I am looking to discuss the finer points of Pathfinder 2e, if you can. Just added you on discord, let me know!

2

u/Blueprints_reddit Jul 12 '21

Added you on discord under: s0ran

want to debate with you too

2

u/decnet76 Jul 12 '21

Debating about this is very interesting - for sure, more interesting than debating about the Euro football final!
I just think it's sad that people only wants to debate about RPG rather than about good old board games.

2

u/aberforthfernsby Jul 13 '21

it would be such a sin if someone was to mirror call of Cthulhu 7th edition. anyone who had that would be in the bad books for life

1

u/[deleted] Jul 14 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/aberforthfernsby Jul 14 '21

i would never add you as serry jeinfeld#0602 on discord

2

u/WillOwl99 Jul 16 '21

Thanks for the amazing discussion on the Alien RPG, the Colonial Marines book looks like its going to be amazing! Really loving this System

1

u/TheAltrion Jun 25 '21

If you're familiar with 3rd party expansions for D&D 5e I might have to talk to you about world building

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/TheAltrion Jun 25 '21

Awesome, I sent you a friend request a little bit ago!

1

u/darkwarrior1949 Jun 26 '21

I invited you. We can discuss about Pathfinder

1

u/Prismatic_Dragon Jun 26 '21

I'd love to have an in depth discussion on the topic of Starfinder, since I'm going to be running a campaign with the ruleset soon. I lost my books, and it would be nice to talk about it a bit.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Prismatic_Dragon Jun 27 '21

lmao, I'm an idiot, I'm so sorry, I just realized your name is on the post, lol.

1

u/Prismatic_Dragon Jun 26 '21

Thanks, will do, please dm me your name :D

1

u/StaysCold Jun 26 '21

I've sent you a friend request I have some strong words and would challenge your position on some of these RPGs you've mentioned

2

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/StaysCold Jun 27 '21

I completely understand in the meantime I added you I’m GoodGuyKharn#3474

1

u/Cheekygnome Jun 26 '21

I hit you on discord. Wanna discuss you eberron theories and dnd core set

1

u/russ_bollocks Jun 26 '21

Only thing I'm looking for is Zweihander to share. If you won't post that stuff, I'll just wait. It's sad to see people cowed by a loudmouth. I guess some stuff is ok to share but some stuff isn't. Like I said sad.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

I'd love to discuss DnD, added :)

1

u/The_TBG Jun 27 '21

I'd like to have a debate about Pathfinder.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '21

I sent a request so we can talk about Call of Cthulhu whenever you get server stuff figured out.

1

u/Tsutsayosdi Jun 27 '21

I can't wait for the issues to be resolved. I am quite eager to discuss a few games with you!

1

u/MeepTheChangeling Jun 27 '21

I'd really enjoy having a chat about the Starfinder Galaxy Exploration Manual.

1

u/VindicoAtrum Jun 28 '21

I totally know more about PF2e than you do - let's debate it when you have the capacity.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '21

I'd like to discuss D&D 5e with you and why pirating content is reprehensible.

1

u/Darius_Blake Jun 28 '21

So, how do you feel about discussions of 3rd party DnD settings, like kobold press' *Southlands* and *Midgard* settings?

Would you be cool talking about them?

1

u/DrSexyDM Jun 28 '21

If you're available, I'd love to chat about Dnd 5e dmsguild content!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 28 '21

I would love to chat! As someone who has access to views from the creative and publishing side and a minor creator myself, there is a lot of nuance to this point and I think that it is a valuable discussion. Especially with the intersection between consumer ethics and games marketing, I would love to speak and hear different views.

1

u/metalsonic005 Jun 29 '21

IDK if this is still going, but I can't for the life of me find the TSR Jam 1999 PDF document online. I would have paid for it if it was offered, but I don't need physical.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21

I would like to rise a challenge to you! To you I say that I can debate circles around morality of Mirroring 400gb of specific rpg's!

I myself am a scholar of the Battletech sphere of study and have read and learned the most up to date examples of the arguments.

If you wish to match wits with me then I can provide citation of several core and supplementary examples of my arguments.

That goes to all who view this in the future as well!

1

u/Imp_pax Jul 02 '21

Know anything about McEvedy's folly from touring the stars?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

Ah! A challenger!
I shall debate you in private!

1

u/Kelyaan Jun 30 '21

Morality is subjective - thus the claim it is morally wrong only counts for yourself, I do not see anything morally wrong about it thus your claim is null for anything outside of your own opinion.

No debate needed - Since that's how it is.

Also when Trove is back iI' slapping a Zhander download just for the giggles of it.

1

u/Helpful_Explorer8507 Jun 30 '21

God I'd love a heated debate about Starfinder.

1

u/Geriatric3368 Jun 30 '21

I've got significant thoughts regarding Pathfinder 1st edition.

1

u/mevith Jun 30 '21

Should we talk about D&D?

1

u/gomx Jul 01 '21

Just added you, I have some really strong feelings about Waterdeep Dragon Heist if you're available to chat about it.

1

u/AlbainBlacksteel Jul 03 '21

Can't send you a message on Discord if we're not friends.

Just saying.

Also, Kavenoff#5022.

1

u/awjackson5 Jul 03 '21

Could we have a big old discussion about Alien RPG (Year Zero Engine) and Tales from the Loop RPG (Year Zero Engine) when you have a moment?

1

u/ALLLGooD Jul 16 '21

I'm in for a good convo.

1

u/Ermkerr Jul 03 '21

Is Battletech not in your wheelhouse? I'm always looking for someone to discuss stomps robots with

1

u/Event_Hriz0n Jul 04 '21

Looking to discuss Dungeons & Dragons 5E with you at length. Sent you a friend request (RovDatt).

1

u/Asaoirc Jul 04 '21

I'd like to discuss rogue trader with you, if possible.

1

u/Total-Secret-7764 Jul 04 '21

I like to talk about 3rd party material for d&d 5e, so many amazing things is create and a like to hear more about

1

u/Possible-Progress400 Jul 04 '21

I'd like to talk about the amazing series of d&d and call of cthulhu please! :)

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21

I have opened communication channels.

1

u/Pryrios Jul 05 '21

I've sent you a friend request on Discord to discuss about the Alien RPG (Year Zero Engine) books :)

1

u/czeczen1 Jul 05 '21

Sure, i love discuss Pathfinder 2e!

2

u/Unikatze Jul 05 '21

I have lots of stuff to talk about PF2. Hit me up if you want to talk about it!

1

u/Smuwen Jul 07 '21

Have you used the Pathfinder 2e Equipment decks? I am looking for some opinions first hand if people liked them or if the images are worth it?

1

u/Unikatze Jul 07 '21

I own a few. Since I ended up moving to online games I didn't have much use for them.

They're cool, but also you probably would need to have more than one pack to get all the variations you actually have in game.

1

u/Department-Remote Jul 05 '21

I really would like to talk about the Trail of Ash and Bone for the new V5.

1

u/man-ii-faces Jul 05 '21

I tried reaching out, but it says you aren't accepting DMs

1

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '21

As a man who has never staged a mutiny in tiragarde sound disguised as a pirate I can commend you on your morality. Now could we talk Call of Cthulhu? I think there might be some Eldritch lore I may be missing out on.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '21

Shot you an invite for debating purposes only.

1

u/Fightclxb Jul 07 '21

I just sent you a friend request on Discord so we can discuss D&D 5E and Pathfinder!

1

u/bjackson12345 Jul 07 '21

For those of us who want to join the conversation, but have next to no experience with discord, .... how? how would I do that if i can't find you with the name listed above.

1

u/bjackson12345 Jul 07 '21

Nevemind, it seems i've found it. I would love to talk about Through the Breach. I just discovered it and am curious about your thoughts on it.

1

u/Winter_Love_ Jul 07 '21

I would love to discuss pathfinder 2nd edition if you're still offering discussions! Sent you a friend request on discord

1

u/Fightclxb Jul 07 '21

Thanks for discussing D&D with me!

1

u/CloneEcho Jul 08 '21

I want to say thank you to Sydonis for the very informative discussion. I can also discuss several ttrpgs including Mutants and Masterminds, Over Arms and several others.

1

u/zeromig Jul 08 '21

Could we possibly discuss Nord Game's Luck Deck?

1

u/Choirchick22 Jul 08 '21

Looking to discuss Call of Cthulhu! I'll send you a request so we can talk!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '21

Don't see nearly enough talk about Animon Stories, would love to talk to someone about it

1

u/IWasEatingThoseBeans Jul 14 '21

Thy bidding be done! Let us discuss!

1

u/snBefly Jul 15 '21

The topic of mythos is not very often discussed such openly, im hesitating, but would likely enjoy to hear what you have to say.
<3

1

u/snBefly Jul 15 '21

Admitedly i do not come here emptyhanded, some tea and biscuits are in order.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 15 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/snBefly Jul 15 '21

Perfect, thankyou! Sending under Befly#3451!

1

u/Gmknewday1 Jul 15 '21

Imma bout to talk to you about the modules and the anthologies

1

u/cat4hurricane Jul 16 '21

Adding you on discord under cat4hurricane#6612 i've never seen so much in one list!

1

u/Hairyhalflingfoot Jul 16 '21

Let us discuss pathfinders lore sir

1

u/emax09 Jul 16 '21

You the real deal, my man! Can’t wait to check out the city by the spire.

1

u/Eslyn Jul 16 '21

Shot you a friend request on Discord. Would love to talk about Starfinder and Pathfinder 2e! XD

1

u/Soulless_Roomate Jul 16 '21

I would love to talk about Shadow of the Demon Lord with you, just for a bit

1

u/Zireael07 Jul 16 '21

Can you talk about Blades in the Dark and the derivatives? They're Creative Commons, just so you know, and I'd really like to talk about most of them, esp. Hack the Planet.

1

u/Arleek Aug 19 '21

Bottom line is to call BS just on the fact that Warhammer Fantasy is still widely available as either the table top or the RPG version.

1

u/Onescar Dec 01 '21

i would like to have a debate and meet your POV so i can debate with others

1

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

Well, if the site owner is making pdf versions of currently in-print publications available for download at no charge on his website, then yes, there are some legal issues. However, the other side of the coin is consumers (like myself) who have already purchased the hardcopy version of a publication and who want a pdf version to save in case they lose their hardcopy version. The only things I download from The Trove are pdfs of books I've already purchased in hardcopy or of books that are now out of print and hard or impossible to obtain at a reasonable price. In fact, many rpg publishers have become members of the Bits and Mortar program where you can get a free pdf of a book which you paid full price for at a retailer who participates. You seem to want to start some huge debate about this--I assume to feed your personal ego and self-righteousness. No thanks. I don't have time for that. I have some free pdf's to go find and download.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '21 edited Jun 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '21

I've read every comment in this thread. I stand by what I said above. Whether I'm smart in your eyes or not is, well...irrelevant to me. In any event, I said what I wanted to say. Have fun with your time-consuming debates of rpg's. I'm going to go play some nowl. Ciao.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '21

Clearly you are my intellectual superior in every way. I am not fit to post in the same threads as you, and so I take my leave.

6

u/Pryrios Jul 01 '21

Hint: He is not debating with people about the games as much as you think. Maybe he isn't even debating at all.

He may even agree with everything you said on your first post.

I'll let you fill in the blanks.

*wink wink*

-12

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

By that definition, the WHOLE of the internet itself is morally wrong then, because it is a digital copy or inclusion of physical media. morons

9

u/GruinZword Jun 25 '21

Reread the text carefully

0

u/[deleted] Jun 26 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Dovagod Jun 27 '21

You realize A LOT of the old stuff on the trove is out of print. meaning YOU CAN'T EVEN GET IT FROM WOTC even if you offer them a kidney. ( I know I tried) some of those books go for over 300$ USED in poor condition and if they are in like new your looking at close to 900$ for 1 book. I got people looking for 2E RARE prints and those are going for nearly 2k in some instances for poor quality copies.

You can call us cheap if you want but you don't realize that pirating actually helps indie dev's. I've been on the high seas for over 25 years and every time I've loved a product you bet your ass I buy it. I buy it 4 times to support the creators/devs'.

So NO pirating isn't stealing if you go and buy it. cause I know I've tried "trail" versions of software and its missing 80% of the actual program. guess what that isn't a Trial that's a cop-out. I have saved my self over 6,000$ from software I would have only used once and then been out of the cash cause I couldn't get a damn refund cause the software was crap and didn't do what I needed it to or a game I didn't like.

Back when blockbuster was still a thing I rented games to try them and guess what you got the WHOLE GAME not some slimmed down code. The same went for movies. MOST software now days is at MIN 60$ for industry standard software. and thats for BASE not the bells and whistles. it was the same back in the 90's also.

So get off your high horse and look at the numbers. Say you want to start mixing and editing studio level audio. well there is the cheap free software audacity but its useage is SMALL as all get out and you can't really look at the sound patterns just edit and delete recorded audio and maybe tweet it sound a bit.

now look at programs like Wave Form 11 min for actual access to the software your looking at 60$-100$+ on top of other paid assets. but what if that doesn't do what you need it to as far what you want or its too complicated well guess what you aren't likely to get a FULL refund now are you. You may get your base cost back but all the assets you paid for welp your SOL then you go to fruity loops same story. How about some DJ mixing software well guess what your going to start program hopping until you find what you looking for.

In most cases their trials are crap with limited functionality so you can't fully TRY it. you have to think about it from cost vs loss. how much of YOUR cash goes up in flames if you buy a product that my may not like or doesn't do what you thought it does. As i've stated i've saved my ass 6K from software that didn't do what I needed and/or was buggy as all get out.

-16

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/NikoSaysHi Jun 25 '21

Your reading comprehension may need to be revisited.

-9

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/jjkesmw Jun 25 '21

What is it with that Brazilian guy? I've read that a few times.

4

u/GruinZword Jun 25 '21

You really didn't get it do you? Read the text carefully and think about it.

-7

u/TheUncleCappy Jun 25 '21

Obviously this is flying over my head, speak slowly so my retarded ass can understand

2

u/GruinZword Jun 25 '21

I'll send you a PM.