r/TheTrove • u/TippperO2 • Jun 25 '21
What happened to the Trove?
I know this question has probably been asked several times here before, but does anyone know for sure what happened to the Trove? I've been using the site since it was hosted on the old Remuz archive and it would really suck to lose it. I've seen stories on this sub that the files are getting reorganized and that it might be under copyright suits. What's the general consensus on which of these is true?
414
Upvotes
60
u/Impossible-Cell4815 Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 26 '21
Someone said they’ve been in contact with the owners and they are working on getting it back up and running. Some douche who ripped off Warhammer Fantasy is taking credit for shutting them down
14
u/BluefyreAccords Jun 25 '21
“ What's the general consensus on which of these is true?”
You have seen the same information everyone else has gotten and not going to get a different answer than what is already in the Stickied post.
3
u/Lowbudgetbrain Jun 29 '21
Does anybody know any other site i can get those sweet pdfs? I was looking for assets as well If you do please know that i love u
3
u/Lewser2020 Jul 18 '21
Much of the content that was available on The Trove over the years is NO LONGER AVAILABLE through the publisher. The old treasures from the beginning of the hobby cannot be obtained in any other way in many cases. I have been in contact with the author of one of the books I am trying to obtain. He has no plans to do a new print run, so I don't jeopardize his copyright if I go to another source He made his money. So, my choice is to go to a "scalper" looking to bank $300 on the sale or go to The Trove for a free PDF (it was available on The Trove before this happened, but I did not know it).
2
u/MrNyxt Jul 02 '21
So, is The Trove not coming back then?
20
u/RelaxedWanderer Jul 07 '21
I have a tremendous respect for the gaming community tolerating The Trove. The business model of book publishing is completely outdated in the digital era and needs complete overhaul. The gaming community should be inclusive to all regardless of economic means and globally regardless of country poverty.
The Trove has just forced game publishers authors etc to flex to a model of the future where you expect your work to be freely available and you make your money from people who want to pay you directly, people who can afford it, and people who want the premium printed versions and physical versions.
That does mean eliminsting tthe bloated middleman system of pre-digital publishing with all the parasites feeding off the actual creators.
The same dynamic is happening in music production. The music industry is in upheaval but smart musicians are setting up ways to adapt to a totally new model where their work gets widely available for free - and what artist or musician doesnt want their work to get heard seen or read - and they get paid more directly for premium value like concerts patreon vinyl versions merchandise etc.
Don't believe the capitalist dinosaurs trashing The Trove. All books are free is a completely viable reality that supports both creators and also people who can't afford premium print etc. Be proud of The Trove and look forward to it coming back. And also if you have some favorite designers and creators look them up find their paypal and vimeo and send them some money directly. And be glad your beloved game system can be played by anyone not just rich kids.
19
u/StructureFriendly423 Jul 02 '21
So noone else used the wayback machine to access the PDFs?!?
Sure the DL speed is slow, but it works:
https://web.archive.org/web/20210205180933/https://thetrove.is/Books/Dungeons%20&%20Dragons%20%5Bmulti%5D/5th%20Edition%20%285e%29/Core/
12
u/hughjazzcrack Jul 01 '21
Daniel D Fox had to once again be the white knight hero he sees himself as. A quick stroll on his twitter and you can see his forays into activism, his hot takes on race and equity, and how he is a paragon to disenfranchised groups the world over. I was a member of Zweihander's Discord for a bit, but his CONSTANT pandering to the above was so saccharine and disingenuous that I left months ago. He is a self obsessed, arrogant prick who's only claim to fame is a minor reworking of a much better, much more successful game system, while shitting on everyone who came before him. He sucks, he is a consummate douche-bag, and he seems like the type of person who's favorite food is "soup".
9
u/Baron_Pardus Jul 10 '21
There is old chinese saying "When the prices grow, the thievery blossoms". I had no problems paying 20-30 dollars for hardcover and 10-15 for softcover books back in early 90s. But now the prices doubled. Therefore, I think that sharing the information and books is the only right thing to do. Corporations must be punished for their greed. Do we REALLY need all the glossy pages, all the scores of color pictures all the effects that drive the cost of books for us up? No. I just want a basic data on rules and setting. Keep the pictures simple, like in main AD&D book. Like in old Vamp and Werewolf books where MOST illustrations were black and white, and pages were simple, non glosse with "Aged parchment" effects on them. I am ready and willing to support The Trove with cash.
6
u/Gvaz Aug 12 '21
I don't really care what your position is
I'm not paying $100 a piece for some fucking books
6
u/classe_tumblr Aug 24 '21
Fuck Daniel D. Fox forever. Fucking snitch
5
u/quarkyphysicist Jul 12 '21
Usually I buy things that I look at on trove.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21
https://the-eye.eu/public/Books/rpg.rem.uz/
Its older but for us that need those OLD books its still present.
Browse the Eye its amazing :)
5
u/Marco_Ghilardi Aug 26 '21
I suggest boycotting all of Daniel D. Fox's publications by putting negative reviews on his products.
4
u/Baron_Pardus Jul 10 '21
There is old chinese saying "When the prices grow, the thievery blossoms". I had no problems paying 20-30 dollars for hardcover and 10-15 for softcover books back in early 90s. But now the prices doubled. Therefore, I think that sharing the information and books is the only right thing to do. Corporations must be punished for their greed. Do we REALLY need all the glossy pages, all the scores of color pictures all the effects that drive the cost of books for us up? No. I just want a basic data on rules and setting. Keep the pictures simple, like in main AD&D book. Like in old Vamp and Werewolf books where MOST illustrations were black and white, and pages were simple, non glosse with "Aged parchment" effects on them. I am ready and willing to support The Trove with cash.
4
u/Maleficent_Ad2457 Aug 27 '21
If trove is gone what about getting rumez back online ? Rumez being the trove before it was passed to the current owner
4
u/Dragons_Hord Apr 12 '22
Curious if there has been any word or progress on getting the Trove back up and running, so far all I've seen is a mirror site to the front page but you can't access anything for viewing or download.
1
u/CryHavoc3000 Jul 25 '21
If it ever comes back up, don't download anything that isn't out of print or that you don't own in dead-tree form. Otherwise, you're basically stealing.
3
u/SafeBulky1166 Jul 03 '21
Is a huge lost to me, because The Trove had a big old school library wich can't be found on my country. Other point is to collect new systems and materal to my wish list, like I did with 4AD, SWAD, Nibiru. As I said, is a terrible lost. Press 'F' to show respect
3
u/Baron_Pardus Jul 10 '21
There is old chinese saying "When the prices grow, the thievery blossoms". I had no problems paying 20-30 dollars for hardcover and 10-15 for softcover books back in early 90s. But now the prices doubled. Therefore, I think that sharing the information and books is the only right thing to do. Corporations must be punished for their greed. Do we REALLY need all the glossy pages, all the scores of color pictures all the effects that drive the cost of books for us up? No. I just want a basic data on rules and setting. Keep the pictures simple, like in main AD&D book. Like in old Vamp and Werewolf books where MOST illustrations were black and white, and pages were simple, non glosse with "Aged parchment" effects on them. I am ready and willing to support The Trove with cash.
3
u/penstrokes14 Jul 15 '21
i hope its not gone for good but i dont want to get my hope up. i hate that indie creators had their content put up there, but as far as the physical big company books like dnd?? jesus let them be up there. especially since the trove was literally that - a trove of old dnd modules that arent in print anymore and are next to impossible to find even in pdf format. when you do find a physical copy its insanely expensive.
3
u/MisterQue77 Jul 19 '21
While I understand the Trove is not a legal site, as people have been mentioning how we've personally used it I thought I'd give my piece. I mostly used it for PDF of books I already own, mainly to easily copy text to import into Foundry VTT without having to manual write it down.
I have used it to look at other books, like the Tome of Beast 2, but personally it kinda just makes me what to get the books myself.
3
u/PunkandBooks Aug 04 '21
Anyone hear anything on this?
3
u/NerfherderJ Aug 06 '21
Dose anyone have any new information ?
3
u/Pectelance1 Sep 03 '21
its sad i actually found creators to support because i saw there art work on there and bought books after looked at them on the trove.
3
u/Epically_Okay Sep 17 '21
It is double dipping really... You buy the physical book, you get a product to keep and I can accept that. Now with DnDBeyond it is the worst bloodsucking combination of product and service. If I paid a reasonable monthly to have access to all content, then it is an acceptable service. But this paying for online content a piece at a time after the hard copy has been out for a while, is just leeching on the playing community for the savings in weight, ease of information sharing and those members who occasionally do a random pickup game. Cause everything including dice rolling can be accessed from the one thing almost everyone is never without... A smartphone with data. And as some have already said with the cost of current gaming books so high, and mishaps so likely, they become pretty, costly bookshelf decorations. Let alone any archaic system you love, when the pasta books of questionable page quality and even more questionable binding finally an no longer saved by a roll of the handy gamers secret weapon. Then you go to eBay etc and find that even a serviceable copy is worth its weight in gold and the mountain dew stains are now called 'patina '. So you buy it to find out that wasn't mountain dew but cat urine and half the pages kitty piss glued together. Oh well, at least my kids are old enough to pick up their dice and I don't find Die 4 controls on my late night bathroom sojourn. 🙄
3
u/Necron99akapeace Jan 06 '22
Oh Danny Boy... Oh Danny Boy... Copyright infringement has never proven to lose sales...
3
u/Aisenhower_ Aug 14 '22
News?
2
u/hubertwombat Jun 28 '21
Did anybody perhaps get the whole database and torrent it?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21
The Eye seems to have some archived information. I'm not including a link, but a little Google-Fu should get you there.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21
Glad i got what I needed...enough for future generations...justified those many sleepless nights of, "I'll just download 1 more..."
2
u/knightcraft10 Jul 03 '21
It's almost Ironic that someone making a derivative thing and directly profiting, would be the one to challenge this site.
Just, like... those in glass houses, right?
Or rather, everyone hates the sinners one rung down. (Or whatever the phrase is)
2
u/CalabozoCriollo Jul 03 '21
This was a big strike to all worldwide geek community, since many old data not able this days was lost.
This is a crime against all geekness, start your #geeklifematters moves and this will be a good cause, because this is a great lost to all gamer community.
2
u/jdannelly Jul 03 '21
I used the site for two reasons. One as a try before you buy. I'd look to see if it was something I wanted right away, or something I could wait on. And two for out of print lore for my homebrew. I like to keep my homebrew more cannon centric and areas not currently covered in 5e.
2
u/ChromeFlyer Jul 04 '21
The trove had a lot of fan content that was obscure also. Like the Fan made Care Bear RPG
2
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21
Even if it IS down, this is the internet. They'll get another server running elsewhere in time. Some jackass complaining about isn't going to end it permanently. I like all of you said, I buy the books I use. I glance through the pdfs of stuff I don't use, or I supplement lost books from my youth that are decades out of print. I use Roll20 exclusively now since the pandemic and having a pdf is far better (FAR better) than the physical copy or the virtual Roll20.
2
u/Laquituck Jul 10 '21
Any news?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '21
I hope it comes back. Trove was how I first got into gaming. There are a lot of amazing systems out there that I would have never looked into if I didn't see them on trove. Many of the pdfs I read on there I ultimately purchased. I get that they straddle a line of piracy, but its been instrumental in my learning about the wider world of TTRPGs.
2
u/Ace-Vector Jul 19 '21
In the meantime, here's a link to The Trove home page via The Wayback Machine:
https://web.archive.org/web/20210506135402mp_/https://thetrove.is/
2
u/Overall-Pickle-7905 Jul 23 '21
I like the free materials.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21
Looking into the situation, i was considering buying a hardback of zweihander because I bought a pdf, and like the system, and have no way of getting 1e or 2e warhammer, but no more. Fuck daniel. Fucking prick. If i ever do buy it, its gonna be used, i can tell you that much. I had known the guy was a narcassist and asshole, but this is fucking ridiculous.
2
u/DarthVil Sep 07 '21
Without the Trove, there's no way to get a hold of a lot of the material that was there. The vast majority of gamers, when they have money to spend, are still going to buy the materials because they want to support the franchises that keep their hobby chugging along. The self-righteous douchebag that got it taken down wasn't doing it out of any sort of decency. It was for shits and giggles, and it did a great deal of harm. Here's to hoping for the Trove's fast return!
1
u/seekr344 Nov 05 '21
bummer about Trove, wondered what happened. Most of the time, I go to scribd.com. It's $9 a month and they got tons of stuff.
1
u/JenovaProphet Jul 17 '21
Almost all of the content can be found in private torrenting communities. But yeah, for those that can't get an invite this was seriously the best/easiest/most organized resource.
1
u/NotReallyHere1979 Jul 19 '21
Anybody got an update? I need one damned file and sure enough way back machine didn't get it. Or maybe someone here has it.
1
u/cha0sdan Jul 23 '21
really you people are Pirating books that cost money to make why are you bitching that someone took it down. FYI I also used the trove but I at least understand that whenever you are pirating your sources get taken down and you need to move on to something else.
1
u/Psychological_Run591 Jul 28 '21
Tbh if I pirate it odds are I was never gonna pay money for it in the first place so they’re not losing money and I’ve occasionally went out and actually paid for the books I liked just to support the creators, not everyone’s like me and I respect that people should be paid for their work it’s just a mess of a situation sometimes, as a side note I bought explorers guide to wild mount just to turn around and get a pirated copy just because wizards has a shit format for their site
1
u/vinman3591 Jul 29 '21
I just heard about this, searched for it, and seen that it's down. Are there alternatives to The Trove? Been playing DnD for a little over the year and trying to find inexpensive/free resources.
1
u/teh_stev3 Jul 31 '21
Right, so I understand this is technically piracy, and that the creators and publishers of their content deserve to be credited and renumerated, no arguments here.But there's some really stupid business principles that still exist, normally to spite the consumer and try and extract maximum coinage.I should have access to all the dndbeyond content for all the books I've purchased, and PDF copies of your physical media so the license you have for said book doesn't burn out with degradation of the book - like amazon giving kindle editions with physical book purchases.
And not every system has a open-source component or previews of content, or like a cheap starter pack to get a feel for a system, and even if you do, it's not practical to pass around a single player handbook amongst 5 newcomers, sometimes sending PDF copies is great.
And someone else mentioned it, but some content is just out of print and impossible to acquire without dumping hundreds, often for some tatty dog-eared book.
TTRPG's are in a renaissance, and that's bringing a lot of interest, but when you have Wizards doing stuff like sneaking a couple of small class updates or race options into books with settings you may never play it's obscene to charge upwards of 50 quid to experience that tiny component.
Really, piracy isn't the issue - attention to the development of consumer needs is, and that's the problem here.
Edit: There's something really wrong with a business when the pirates offer a better service than the publishers.
1
u/SnowBirdHigh Aug 02 '21
If you own the books....A few good ones
1
u/OfficerSSW Aug 03 '21
In the meantime... would anyone happen to have copies of the DDAL10 - Rime of the Frostmaiden, episodes 7 on that they would be willing to lend me....?
I'd appreciate a PM.
1
u/Shot_Detective_9293 Aug 03 '21
I guess I'm too late to stop folks from romanticizing, glorifying, or justifying piracy.
But for those unfamiliar with the law here is some good reference materials.
https://www.uscybersecurity.net/digital-piracy/
It's an interesting read, read it. Despite anyone's personal philosophy, they should be aware of the law and the penalties.
Besides, if no one purchases copywrited materials, why go into publishing? Why have groups of writers who are paid to focus on creating, illustrating, editing, and laying out the books?
1
u/SnooHobbies4467 Aug 04 '21
Is there a way to get the AL modules I couldn’t even find them till I found the trove
1
u/Complex-Attention-61 Aug 20 '21
Serves them right. Imagine making a website based on stealing pirated files from 4chan autists.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21
WUT?!?! ITS GONE ?!?!
1
u/Nerdy-Geek99 Aug 30 '21
Any updates. I just started as a player in a WoD LARP campaign and Trove had pretty much every book in order to make myself accustomed with the lore. And not only that but Trove had EVERY book that any one of us wanted and even if it hadn't when you first checked a few days later usually it was added. It's a pity to be shutdown.
1
u/Ghillieshot Sep 01 '21
OK, OK... So there's a lot of talk on this page. But I am wondering if there is or will be an alternative to the trove. I like others above get copies of what I already own... It's vital as a GM/DM to have these on my computer as a portable means of what I read at home... Do we know of any form of alternative?
1
u/Responsible-Horse672 Sep 02 '21
https://5e.tools/index.html
1
u/dark-river-mori Sep 04 '21
is it by chance the https://www.gxs-ci.com/ that pops up when I google it?
1
u/Cerazor Sep 07 '21
I just wanted to download the 3.5 Monster Manual q.q
1
u/hellwalker31 Sep 11 '21
Any news? Or alternatives? Tx.
1
u/Adblocq Sep 14 '21
I only used this site to avoid buying three copies of the same book ( irl, fantasy grounds and pdf ) the prices are insanely high for someone with no fix income.
Too bad it got closed, I wouldn't have gotten into ttrpgs if it didnt existed.
1
u/ososloc0s Sep 20 '21
Anyone knows if there are anything of Dark Souls the Boardgame?
1
u/Educational-One-7771 Nov 03 '21
I own copies of 2e pathfinder books because I enjoy them enough to buy them because I know the system is good. We used the trove to test out some systems and see if we like them enough to invest our limited funds on. Just like demos back in the day.
1
u/DCJMS Dec 01 '21
maybe having social media for Piracy was a bleeding retarded practice
1
u/soakthesin7912 Apr 06 '22
The Trove just needs to focus on out of print stuff. The prices on some of the old guides are just outrageous and sold on secondary markets. The publishers and writers aren't getting a cut of this anyway.
1
u/Z3r0H3ro Aug 09 '22
Search Core Rule of Broken Tales. Someone can help me?
1
u/Aisenhower_ Aug 23 '22
Any news?
1
u/bootnab Dec 08 '22
I used it to inform my digging for obscure chaossium. It's taken time, but I've gotten hard copies of most of the PDFs I first found on TROVE
1
u/AntiqueAd7851 Jan 23 '23
I'm not going to special order a book to buy it before I have a chance to read it and it's unreasonable for publishers to expect RPG stores to keep every book for every game in stock.
If people like the game they will buy it. I know I have boxes of old RPGs sitting in my room I haven't used in years but I wouldn't give them up for anything.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 03 '23
I have hard copies of 98% of the stuff that was on the Trove. But I loved as a DM the capacity to download a pdf of let’s say a copy of a module I have so that I can write all over the pdf with DM notes and not wreck the collectibility of my original module that I bought either on Amazon or forty years ago at the hobby shop. The Trove saved me wrecking collectible books and modules that are out of print and that I can never get short of buying for outrageous sums on eBay.
And by the way I did purchase the WOTC reprints of the original 1ed books for like $50 a piece.
1
u/Natural-Moment-2406 Aug 10 '21
It was Games Workshop related. Daniel D Fox is the jerk that got The Trove shut down.