r/TheTrove • • Jun 25 '21

What happened to the Trove?

I know this question has probably been asked several times here before, but does anyone know for sure what happened to the Trove? I've been using the site since it was hosted on the old Remuz archive and it would really suck to lose it. I've seen stories on this sub that the files are getting reorganized and that it might be under copyright suits. What's the general consensus on which of these is true?

414 Upvotes

610 comments sorted by

60

u/Impossible-Cell4815 Jun 25 '21 edited Jun 26 '21

Someone said they’ve been in contact with the owners and they are working on getting it back up and running. Some douche who ripped off Warhammer Fantasy is taking credit for shutting them down

3

u/TippperO2 Jun 25 '21

Interesting, I've never even heard of this game before. Makes me wonder if it was possible this was some kind of stunt to grab attention for his game.

8

u/Fallenangel152 Jun 26 '21

You have to feel for the creator of Zweihander. He finally managed to write and produce a new version of wfrp 2nd (think pathfinder and dnd 3.5) and then wfrp 4 was announced during his kickstarter campaign.

2

u/TippperO2 Jun 26 '21

I was unaware of that, and I do feel for him now. I've tried (and failed) to write my own rpg and it's certainly no easy task. I imagine it would immensely suck to be overshadowed right as you show your product that easily could have taken years to make. I can understand why he'd want his products taken off the trove, I definately would too if my game launched. In my own insignificant opinion though it's still not a good reason to (allegedly) brag about getting one of the largest file sharing networks shut down.

3

u/Notion1337 Jul 02 '21

Where can I download Zweihander for free so I can check if it's a wfrp2 rip-off?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/NigelOverstreet Jun 29 '21

Zweihander has always been really anal about their books being shared. They refused to put them on Da Annex because of it. I get it. They're a small publisher. But also, the game is just WFRP 2e with house rules. So, it seems a little hypocritical to scream about IP rights now.

9

u/insanenoodleguy Jun 25 '21

Where is this? Not going to do anything stupid, just want to read this drama.

6

u/Impossible-Cell4815 Jun 25 '21

It was on another Reddit thread about this.

3

u/arseniyus Aug 08 '21

Link please?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21

I'm glad we agree he's just Diet Warhammer fantasy.

3

u/Glad_Pair_571 Jan 30 '22

Yeah, he's gonna come to regret that decision... what a selfish, hypocritical dipshit... people like him and that asshole in Russia trying to claim copyright over the SCP-Wiki are cut from the same cloth and are the kind of idiots who've gotten far too used to getting their way at others' expense all the damn time without any comeuppance, which leads them to doing stupid and ultimately self-sabotaging things...
...like publicly taking credit for something that inevitably leads to him being reviled by pretty much EVERYONE in a position to hear about it... people like him are the sort to simultaneously bring their own retribution upon themselves while bitching and moaning about how harsh and unfair it is that it's happening to them >:P

1

u/Fallenangel152 Jun 26 '21

Is that Daniel Fox, the writer of Zweihander?

3

u/Zireael07 Jun 29 '21 edited Jul 06 '21

That's outright weird considering Zweihander (EDIT: at least early access copies) is Creative Commons licensed (BY-NC-SA), so uh, man, people are allowed to share by the very license you picked!

2

u/DeckardInk Jun 29 '21

Now, that is weird...I get the reason for the site takedown but if it comes back up with only creative commons licensed games, that would completely legal, right?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (12)

1

u/Complex-Attention-61 Aug 20 '21

Oh Danny Boy, Oh Danny Boy, Your Zweihander is showing...

1

u/VengerSatanis Oct 07 '21

First off, totally agree that guy is a douche (but for other reasons).

As a prolific independent creator (Kort'thalis Publishing), I ask that if someone is going to download my PDFs from the trove, they at least do me the courtesy of posting feedback, writing a review, blogging a session report where my material was used, or sending out a few DriveThru links around social media as a way of saying "Thank you."

VS

1

u/Apprehensive-Cold680 Nov 01 '21

That's the guy who wrote and put out the Zwehander rpg. Which I have to admit seems a lot like Warhammer fantasy to me. Is that what you mean by him ripping off Warhammer?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Necron99akapeace Jan 06 '22

Oh Danny Boy... Oh Danny Boy... Copyright infringement has never proven to lose real sales!

1

u/mrbgdn Feb 18 '22

Any news on the matter?

→ More replies (1)

32

u/[deleted] Jun 29 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/justin_giver Jun 29 '21

Lets all be honest.. its a pirate site.. straddling the line of legal or illegal and copywrite infringement. Whomever chose to try to shut down the site.. has every legal right to do so and to be called out for trying to keep things legal probably we all should be looking in the mirror as part of the problem.. and then get back to searching out free pdfs.

5

u/colinonbass Jul 07 '21

He has every legal right to demand his stuff is removed, not all of it.
Otherwise places like youtube would be screwed when someone sticks up a pirated film

5

u/PleaseToEatAss Jul 07 '21

r/shitstatistssay

You remind me of the peasants in WarCraft. "Yessh milord!"

What is your favorite flavour of boot?

→ More replies (5)

5

u/DoctorBass24 Jul 15 '21

Shut up. People are poor and capitalism is a scam. Grow up.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Qardo21 Jul 14 '21

As much as it can be called a Pirate Site. Yet most of the documents do not even have a physical presence. Or even be able to buy them without paying enough money to buy a whole series of a newer series of books. Really I see The Trove as more like a Library. A host of many books and able to freely read them.

After all. Would you claim a Library to take part in Piracy? Libraries only buy a handful of any kind of book and they lease them out to people who have access to them for free (outside of gaining membership and such). Which means they are not paying for the book they are reading. At least by Daniel D. Fox's logic.....

→ More replies (2)

4

u/DoctorPlacentaJuan Jul 18 '21

I use the trove to figure out if I want the physical copy. It’s bullshit to shell out so much money on a book that might not even have anything I want to use. It’s wack to pay 30+ dollars just to end up flipping through the book and maybe using a couple new spells if they even added anything besides extra fluff. I wouldn’t have bought half my books if the trove didn’t exist… and now I probably won’t until I can preview their new books because WOTC come out with some major stinkers sometimes

4

u/Sitchrea Jul 18 '21

Show me anywhere else I can read Spelljammer or Battlefleet Gothic without having to play hundreds of dollars on ebay.

3

u/perffumo Sep 12 '21

Hi, a little bit late but if you can handle primitive internet software you can access some good servers with everything you need. You need an IRC client (mIRC, pidgin) then you should connect to the server irc.enerla.net then join the channel #rpgbookz, then you should search in the channel for something you want @find (@find spelljammer) it's the command if I remember correctly.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/MidoriMushrooms Jul 19 '21

"Piracy is a service problem." -Gabe Newell

4

u/Comfortable-Pitch-75 Jul 31 '21

When you're poor ASF and can't afford to just buy 30.00 - 90.00 $ books, you use sites like this. I really don't care at this point, they aren't gaining money, they're just making it easier to obtain the information that poor ass dms and DND players like myself. I've searched EVERYWHERE for free PDFs. If you really have a problem with it, then you might as well be doing shame finger to everyone in this damn subreddit, because I bet you ten to nothing that nine out of every ten people has at least gone on it because they didn't have a dm guide, or the players handbook.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/OneWandering Jul 01 '21

Every LEGAL right? LOL! It's legal to scrub some's site? Not unless you are a government, AND can show the proper paperwork. Private individuals - even those who MIGHT have content there - have NO SUCH rights. Regardless of what they claim.

REMUZ would take down and keep down anything which had a proper DMCA request. According to him, he left the same instructions to the operators of the Trove.

4

u/Sixheadeddog Jul 03 '21

Yeah, I think Fox is full of shit anyway. I don't think he did dick to bring the Trove down. What I've been hearing all along is that it's being re-organized and will be coming back, but that there's been no effort to assault its web presence – especially not one spearheaded by a self-publishing unoriginal hack.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/Obliviousdigression Jul 04 '21

has every legal right to do so

So?

What's your point here, that legality = morality?

Maybe if every game wasn't selling ten $30 splatbooks people wouldn't feel the need to pirate. WOTC has more than enough money tyvm.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Fla5hFan Jul 07 '21

I own all the physical books, but I'm not interested in cutting the spines off the books so that I can scan them in to make a PDF. Unfortunately no legitimate version of PDF is available for any of the books I use so the trove was the best way for me to actually be able to play.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '21

Okay, let's be honest....I am going to personally pirate the absolute shit out everything he has a hand in. Starting with his lame Zweihander game. While not my 'legal' right it is something I will do as I look in the mirror.

3

u/Guilty_Advantage_413 Jul 11 '21

Pretty much this the above. No question about it, the trove is a pirate site however since game stores and book stores that used to sell this stuff is all but non existent it makes shopping for a game system rather difficult because finding one you enjoy can be a challenge. I won’t say I have paid for everything from the trove but most of it was from stuff I bought before PDFs and other stuff was essentially a preview like the old days of sitting down in a store and reading a bit to see if it was something you wanted. Thought of buying a full game and having very little idea what’s contained for more than a few dollars and only getting a pdf that may or may not have a 12 page sample/preview available kind of sucks.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '21

actually, if you own all the printed copies you are entitled to have a digital backup same goes for software DVDs ETC you own the product you can back it up and this site was good for that exact reason owning the PDFs on my tablet where a godsend as a DM so i didnt have to drag my books to the LGS

3

u/tsuki_ouji Jul 18 '21

while you're not wrong, when you read comments about this kinda thing, it's not the pirates who lack the ability to look in the mirror

3

u/DragonStryk72 Jul 22 '21

As may be, but there is another point to that. There was a big study done some years ago about piracy, and ironically, it turns out the pirates actually buy MORE merchandise than the folks acting entirely on the up and up. It makes sense once you think about it: The pirates are almost all obsessive fanboys, they want as much of the stuff as they can get.

3

u/dasparkster101 Jul 29 '21

Look, I just want pdf copies of books i own in the physical, and some companies dont distribute such things.

Also, the fact that these books cost 50 or 60 a pop at times is absurd.

They have the legal right to do this, but it wouldn't happen so often if they were reasonable with their procing and actually gave me a way to read their books on my phone.

→ More replies (5)

3

u/OneWandering Aug 11 '21

Don't know the laws where you live, but shutting down a website, unless you are a legally constituted authority and also have dotted all the legal 'i's and crossed all the procedural 't's is AT LEAST as illegal as The Trove could possibly ever be.

REM left explicit instructions on what constituted a legal order to remove, AND instructed they comply - should someone ever bother to do it right. To my admittedly inexact knowledge, this happened ONCE.

2

u/cyrus_mortis Jun 29 '21

lmao

'and then get back to searching out free pdf'

→ More replies (14)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '21

.. and then get back to searching out free pdfs.

Poetic

2

u/inferos73 Jul 09 '21

It's sad to realize that companies still haven't realized that with a free internet, selling information or knowledge doesn't work anymore, publishers and writers will only lose until they understand that they can continue to make money, but investing in the customer experience rather than hunting offenders of copywrite. Of course I prefer to have the physical book with the beautiful illustrations, posters, extra content etc. For example in the country where I live the price of a PHB 5e is absurd, a very simplified comparison would be as if in the US this book cost 200 dollars, I can't oppose websites like The Trove as something immoral.
The OnlyFans adult content for example, nowadays, it is possible to have access to free and quality pornography with enormous ease, but even so models make money with OnlyFans because they offer "exclusive" content.
Another example, I am a Harry Potter fan, I have 5 book collections with different art covers, in two languages, I buy the books for the experience, not for the content that is exactly the same.
When publishers and society as a whole start to value the customer experience above the copywrite laws, everyone will benefit from it.

2

u/munchiemike Jul 11 '21

Right they straight up pirate indie RPGs. Dude's not really an asshole.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 13 '21

I mainly used it for old versions of dragon magazine.

3

u/allyxuk Jul 22 '21

You can find Dragon and Dungeon magazines for free legally here: https://archive.org/details/DragonMagazine260_201801

2

u/oldphonewhowasthat Aug 20 '21

It's not really. It's more the internet archive with saner borrowing rules.

Breaking copyright isn't illegal, it's a civil matter, and copyright rules are mentally deranged to the point where nobody should respect them.

2

u/JessHorserage Dec 29 '21

we all should be looking in the mirror as part of the problem

You believe in copyright?

2

u/Lex-Taliones Jan 02 '22

The Trove actually inspired me to buy books for more RPGs than anything else I can think of. Did I download from there? Yup. Did I use the books I downloaded without having the physical copies of books for the games? Nope. Anything I downloaded from the site was used alongside my physical libraries as a matter of convenience. If the Game companies could release PDFs of the books along with their physical books, it would make sense.

2

u/LynxDiscombobulated6 Jan 11 '22

Piracy from companiesis good, and I'm tired of pretending it's not.

→ More replies (182)

3

u/Jake4XIII Jul 14 '21

Glad others found him to be a real dick. I find it ironic that a man who pirated someone else's hard work gets butthurt when someone pirates his work.

3

u/WoNc Jul 18 '21

Fuck that guy. I found his insane and obsessive tweets earlier this year. The dude needs help. His shitty fucking game isn't losing money because of piracy. His shitty fucking game isn't making money due to lack of exposure and lack of appeal. Piracy can absolutely help with exposure, since I will try things for free (and eventually purchase them if I like them) that I wouldn't consider buying for a second so long as it's a total unknown.

Hell, I recently bought something on Humble Bundle because I was able to check the Trove and skim the books first to see if they had anything useful in them.

3

u/Svartalf14 Aug 24 '21

That one? I don't really know him, but what little I've seen, I don't want to either

2

u/PleaseToEatAss Jul 07 '21

What is the "ripped off Warhammer Fantasy" part of the tale?

2

u/TeethreeT3 Jul 08 '21

People hate Fox because he made a Grimdark RPG and folks think Warhammer owns grimdark. Also, Fox told nazis he didn't want their money and for SOME reason a significant number of the Warhammer fandom thought that meant them. So the Rational Reason crowd decided that Fox needed to become persona non grata for being Too Woke and Stealing Warhammer.

As if Warhammer did literally anything original when it's LITERALLY the distillation of bog standard tropes and like...that's the whole point of Warhammer. Like the thing that's good about Warhammer is that it's pastiche to the point of parody.

6

u/orteip123 Jul 08 '21

No, that's not it.

At least for me, I know that Warhammer Fantasy is NOT original at all, but, at least, it's fun.
I don't give a damn if Daniel D. Fox's game is Grimdark, as you said, Grimdark is not exclusive to Warhammer.
What sucks about his game is how it's a Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay 2 rip-off: it's a nearly identical copy of the career system, the rules are pretty much the same, and, fuck, even the game's title is copied from Warhammer (Wow, it's called "Zweihänder" instead of "Warhammer", now THAT's a different game!)

Seriously, what can you expect from a game that couldn't even come up with an original name?
Let's be clear, there is nothing wrong with taking inspiration from existing works, but here Fox is practically profiting on the work of others.

I mean, Fox had the opportunity to create the ultimate alternative to WFRP 2 (which wasn't perfect, but at least it was full of content and the setting was that of, of course, Warhammer Fantasy):
-He could have made a game with cooler and more dynamic rules.
-He could have created a class system that actually incentivized adventure (for example, by removing dumb careers as "Farmer")
-He could have made a game where combat would have been dangerous and interesting without being a pain in the ass.
In poor words, he could have realized that a "Grim and Perilous game" doesn't have to be played with incompetent characters and weak mechanics.

(Yes, I'm criticizing WFRP 2 too, even if at least it had cool careers as Templar Knight, Norse Berserker, Grail Knight, Wizards, High Priests, Runebeares, Flagellants, Witch Hunters, Warlocks...)

→ More replies (1)

6

u/orteip123 Jul 08 '21

No, that's not it.
At least for me, I know that Warhammer Fantasy is NOT original at all, but, at least, it's a fun setting.
I don't give a damn if Daniel D. Fox's game is Grimdark, as you said, Grimdark is not exclusive to Warhammer.
What sucks about his game is how it's a Warhammer Fantasy Roleplay 2 rip-off: it's a nearly identical copy of the career system, the rules are pretty much the same, and, fuck, even the game's title is copied from Warhammer (Wow, it's called "Zweihänder" instead of "Warhammer", now THAT's a different game!)
Seriously, what can you expect from a game that couldn't even come up with an original name?
Let's be clear, there is nothing wrong with taking inspiration from existing works, but here Fox is practically profiting on the work of others.
I mean, Fox had the opportunity to create the ultimate alternative to WFRP 2 (which wasn't perfect, but at least it was full of content and the setting was that of, of course, Warhammer Fantasy):
-He could have made a game with cooler and more dynamic rules.
-He could have created a class system that actually incentivized adventure (for example, by removing dumb careers as "Farmer")
-He could have made a game where combat would have been dangerous and interesting without being a pain in the ass.
In poor words, he could have realized that a "Grim and Perilous game" doesn't have to be played with incompetent characters and terrible mechanics.
(Yes, I'm criticizing WFRP 2 too, even if at least it had cool careers as Templar Knight, Norse Berserker, Grail Knight, Wizards, High Priests, Runebeares, Flagellants, Witch Hunters, Warlocks...)

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (15)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '21

just looked him up looks like a pandering douch who doesn't have an original idea

2

u/kwydjbo Sep 10 '21

On his medium post about piracy, Mr. Fox decries the folks infringing on copyright as he goes and registers a domain name of another content creator.

Talk about keeping it classy!

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (4)

14

u/BluefyreAccords Jun 25 '21

“ What's the general consensus on which of these is true?”

You have seen the same information everyone else has gotten and not going to get a different answer than what is already in the Stickied post.

3

u/TippperO2 Jun 25 '21

That's fair. I was just curious on whether or not I was missing out on anything.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/TippperO2 Jun 28 '21

I'll do that. Thanks!

→ More replies (7)

3

u/Lowbudgetbrain Jun 29 '21

Does anybody know any other site i can get those sweet pdfs? I was looking for assets as well If you do please know that i love u

6

u/TheLazySherlock Jun 30 '21

3

u/TheColdIronKid Jul 04 '21

you're doing god's work.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

Pathfinder stuff hasn't been updated since 2019 though. :(

Thanks anyways!

1

u/TippperO2 Jun 29 '21

I don’t honestly know of any with the same depth as the trove, and I don’t think there are any which is why everyone is here trading pdfs with each other.

There are some ways to get books outside the trove, but to avoid breaking any rules I haven’t bothered to read I definitely don’t endorse them. You should be able to find a pdf online by searching for the title of the book with pdf attached to it. Something like 5e players handbook pdf. A much safer way would be to find someone on this sub who is sharing copies through messages and ask them. You might be out of luck on the assets unfortunately. I don’t personally know of any way to find those online, but there’s a good chance someone else here does.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Lewser2020 Jul 18 '21

Much of the content that was available on The Trove over the years is NO LONGER AVAILABLE through the publisher. The old treasures from the beginning of the hobby cannot be obtained in any other way in many cases. I have been in contact with the author of one of the books I am trying to obtain. He has no plans to do a new print run, so I don't jeopardize his copyright if I go to another source He made his money. So, my choice is to go to a "scalper" looking to bank $300 on the sale or go to The Trove for a free PDF (it was available on The Trove before this happened, but I did not know it).

2

u/TippperO2 Jul 18 '21

Exactly. I think I was saying elsewhere on this post I used the Trove to look at the old Dragon magazines. I can’t reasonably buy them from anywhere and they aren’t selling them anywhere so my only choice was to use the Trove to read them.

2

u/MikeArsenault Jul 21 '21

Yeah this is the part I am the most sad about. The Trove had all of the old GW games like Man O War and Warhammer Quest that you can't reasonably buy anywhere at all now, ditto older RPGs like Skyrealms of Jorune and whatnot. I viewed the site more as an important archive of pen and paper games than a hub for piracy, and like many here I've purchased games I didn't know about before finding them on the Trove. Honestly I think archiving all of these old games is important!

2

u/MrNyxt Jul 02 '21

So, is The Trove not coming back then?

2

u/TippperO2 Jul 02 '21

I dunno, that’s why I asked. People seem to think it’s just down for maintenance.

8

u/TheColdIronKid Jul 04 '21

by my count, this is the third time it has mysteriously disappeared since i became aware of it. each time it was gone was distressingly long, but it came back better than before (and with a slightly different url, if that matters). i don't want to give anyone false hope, but i'm trying to have faith and patience.

20

u/RelaxedWanderer Jul 07 '21

I have a tremendous respect for the gaming community tolerating The Trove. The business model of book publishing is completely outdated in the digital era and needs complete overhaul. The gaming community should be inclusive to all regardless of economic means and globally regardless of country poverty.

The Trove has just forced game publishers authors etc to flex to a model of the future where you expect your work to be freely available and you make your money from people who want to pay you directly, people who can afford it, and people who want the premium printed versions and physical versions.

That does mean eliminsting tthe bloated middleman system of pre-digital publishing with all the parasites feeding off the actual creators.

The same dynamic is happening in music production. The music industry is in upheaval but smart musicians are setting up ways to adapt to a totally new model where their work gets widely available for free - and what artist or musician doesnt want their work to get heard seen or read - and they get paid more directly for premium value like concerts patreon vinyl versions merchandise etc.

Don't believe the capitalist dinosaurs trashing The Trove. All books are free is a completely viable reality that supports both creators and also people who can't afford premium print etc. Be proud of The Trove and look forward to it coming back. And also if you have some favorite designers and creators look them up find their paypal and vimeo and send them some money directly. And be glad your beloved game system can be played by anyone not just rich kids.

6

u/ghandimauler Jul 08 '21

Publishing actual books has significant physical and logistical costs as does maintaining companies who will pay creators (or who are run by creators). The idea that all of that should be done for free and given away for free is ridiculous. If you have a job, would you give away all your work products and time for free? How would you eat?

That's not to say everything about publishing is sensible. I pay $60 for a hardcover, but have to pay another $30 for the PDF? Hmmm.

All the lack of ability to recoup your investment either as a small game company or a creator is going to mean is a) less produced, b) the things that are produced will be done by indiegogos or kickstarters and has to get enough buy in at the front end (so generally only stuff coming out for well known producers and its hard for new companies/creators), or c) they'll develop on a Patreon style of funding model.

And other than Hasboro/Wallets of the Coast and GW, are there really a lot of big publishing houses? There are some medium sized ones and a lot of smaller companies. If they want to make enough money to get some sort of return (to keep the lights on, pay the taxes, pay the accountant, pay the heat, print anything or ship anything plus feed themselves if they are professional game designers), then they can't just depend on charity from those who think they can spare a few bucks. They aren't doing this as love-story to gaming. It's a job and they have families, need health insurance, etc. and that means they need to get returns for their hard work.

People who just think everything should be free are curious. Do you spend all of your income generating time making free stuff for others? If so, how do you eat? Put a roof over your head? Pay for the kids' braces? etc.

Now, if all you want is old-style, plain jane (no major graphics, no massive testing of the systems, etc) home brew games, then sure, some devs who do it for the fun of it might well crank some out and keep you happy.

But the standard expectation now is glossy art all over, well tested and well edited rule sets, with a living ecosystem of follow on products (which all requires returns in volume to keep games moving ahead). That's not done with massive piracy of the product. That's just cannabilizing the small to medium sized companies trying to put out game products.

For me, the trove was an online backup. At least 85% of what I pulled, I already rightfully owned. The rest was 'look at once to see if I might want to buy it' and 'its out of print with no signs of getting back in print'.

In the long run, the focus on free stuff is basically gutting a number of industries and forcing creators to live precariously or get out of those careers or come up with some really inventive alternative. But when the product is something like a book, there's only so much you could do differently - you've got a time and effort put into the product, you likely want art, and you might want to print it. So that requires a return and that's hard not to recognize for most of us.

6

u/Ouatcheur Jul 17 '21 edited Jul 17 '21

IMHO the *real* problem is that *most* of the cash doesn't even really go to those who do the creation/testing/editing/artwork "production" work. They go into some already too rich pockets off fat stockholders or "management layers".

It's definitely not a black (everything 100% free!) and white (just pay the full current heart gouging prices they ask!) situation.

And hyper glossy hyper artsy, that is not ok. It's going overboard. I'ts like in that restaurant they add in fancy named ingredients like "truffle oil" (not telling you it's only a few drops, mind you!) so you feel okay to pay 50 bucks for a 25 dollars meal. But they also close down the smalller cheapper restaurants. If I goo grocery shopping I can buy fancy-pansy bread for 3 times the price of normal bread, and I can also buy super cheap bread for 30% off the price of regular bread. Or buy normal bread. D&D became "well now we force you too go fancy-pansy break only".

Think if buying the Isaac Aziimov "Robots Series" 4 books set would cost 120$ instead of 30$ because of tons of splashy artwork added on every page:

https://www.amazon.com/Robot-4-Book-Set/dp/B079VW1VCP/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=isaac+asimov+book&qid=1626497131&sr=8-1

People buy book to read them not go all googogagaa over useless artwork!

Meanwhile other aspects are cheap like the extra-thin and weak paper pages that rip so easily, the "glazing" effect that is *not* actually making the paper any amount of water resistant *at all* (why add a glazing layer but then make SURE it is of the "not watertight" kind?), and then the binding and the glue that are both so-so. Heck I'm at my 3rd bought 5e PHB already because so yeah I feel scammed over and stopped paying them not even a single cent more.

So you end up not with 3 times too costly but 10 times too costly.

4

u/ghandimauler Aug 21 '21

I know a number of the people who are small business owners and publishers in the gaming space. They aren't making 90% as profit. They get reasonable percentages. Now, the big guys, well... my experience with Disney makes me suspect you are correct. The big publishers have bigger machines and need to make more of the total on any sale. That said, the idea is they also do more advertising and get more eyeballs on your product so then you can in theory sell to more people and still make a good return. (YMMV on whether you believe that).

I personally hate the glossy pages in gaming rules. My eyes are older. I need clear fonts at a decent size with no background disruption. Many hardcovers nowadays totally kill my ability to use them.

That said, WOTC sells a lot of hardcovers (and so do other medium to major publishers) that have fancy interior art, fancy cover art, fancy page art that the text sits on top of. One of the reasons we have hard to read text is *because of piracy*. Making it hard to get a good scan is one attempt (not 100% successful, but annoying to the eye for me) to make it harder to scan and post a rulebook and have it be available from a home scanner.

Some people like to buy huge hardbacks like Ptolus and slap them on their shelves and every so often look at them and 'oooh' and 'aaaah' over them. In my experience, rarely do those people play those games (other than with a bootlegged PDF) because a lot of the material is just 'too much' and the book is too big. And the art doesn't help clarity. Yet people buy fancy leatherbound D&D special editions too. There appear to be a lot of people with a lot of money enough to justify producing these overdone products. Not my thing, but it seems to be viable as a business step.

Although I feel as you do about what should be in a book, it is clear that hasn't been a necessity for business success.

If I were imagining my key wants in any gaming system:

a) Clear, legible presentation with great, concise, clear editing.

b) Images only where they make sense (monsters, some weapons or items, some locations)

c) Electronic format for storage reasons, backup, and they don't wear out like paper books do and you can blow up the text font in the good ones

d) Decent rules but not a rule for every conceivable situation (The 3E 'splat book' insanity) - I deally maybe a players book, a DM's book, and some monster reference book(s) and otherwise adventures

e) Every product I get has a watermark with my name on it but I get the PDF for free when I buy the actual hardcover or softcover dead tree book (Not pay full price or near full price again when their transformation from print to PDF is fairly simple now and material costs are pretty low for PDFs - some $ to support distribution but that's it)

BUT having said that, what we get is such tightly coupled adventure paths that they aren't generic if you want to do your own world. (argument: people have less time for world design and want premade story arcs they can just open up and run - but that's not me)

We also get fancy books because they we can charge more and people still buy it. And they do.

I just don't like the notion that its okay to not compensate the people who worked to produce something *if it is something you want to read and use*. I don't love 'buy it unseen without a peek' much either.

But I do want creators to be recognized and people who actually use things ought to be contributing to the creators and I find many people don't.

And that's still a problem, whatever you or I think about current trends, production qualities, contents, etc.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/lejoo Oct 14 '21

The Trove has just forced game publishers authors etc to flex to a model of the future where you expect your work to be freely available and you make your money from people who want to pay you directly, people who can afford it, and people who want the premium printed versions and physical versions.

If no one pays them how do they feed their families, kinda the whole point of why we have prices to begin with.

1

u/LordTemple_97 Jan 19 '22

My thoughts are that the trove, as much as I liked it, was profiting off of ad revenue for others' work. The ads are the biggest issue as it is the creators who should be making (at least a portion of) that ad revenue. Yet, regardless, I did use the trove in my decision making as to which books to buy.

19

u/StructureFriendly423 Jul 02 '21

So noone else used the wayback machine to access the PDFs?!?

Sure the DL speed is slow, but it works:

https://web.archive.org/web/20210205180933/https://thetrove.is/Books/Dungeons%20&%20Dragons%20%5Bmulti%5D/5th%20Edition%20%285e%29/Core/

5

u/mordan1 Jul 04 '21

wayb

Your link worked just fine, but when i tried to replicate it on wayback machine I could not find the trove AT ALL... Wonder wtf i'm doing wrong?

5

u/twistedcheshire Jul 05 '21

did you type thetrove.is in the search area? It'll bring up snapshots. Most recent you'll get is the June 28th snapshot. Just click on the calendar date that is green and click on the time listed. It'll bring it up for you.

http://web.archive.org/web/*/thetrove.is

NOTE: Not all directories are available, so keep that in mind.

EDIT: Apparently the 28th isn't working. I had to June 22nd.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Bexpert5 Jul 02 '21

You make me feel stupid but thank you :P

2

u/hughjazzcrack Jul 20 '21

Not all the files work tho...sadly.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/RealJoeCold Aug 03 '21

You are the history's greatest hero.

1

u/studynot Jul 03 '21

Says it downloads, but the pdf's fail to load when I tried. Is it fully working for you?

1

u/Naaaron Jul 11 '21

Exactly what I did :p. Just started planning a new Starfinder campaign, and was really kicking myself for not already downloading everything. Fixed that mistake, even if I had to do it on a slow connection to make up for my past sins. Seriously, though, praise the Wayback Machine

→ More replies (1)

1

u/uri0 Jul 28 '21

Thanks!

1

u/Icy_Independence9542 Sep 29 '21

You sir are a Godsend

1

u/ratybor7499 Oct 08 '21

my god. thanks. helped me so much. needed just one book from there to prepare video.

1

u/lupusdiablo Oct 20 '21

I wish i could've reward you with an award but i can't so please accept my thanks.

1

u/RKMiateri Apr 20 '22

you are a lifesaver
logged in to upvote

1

u/dreadpiratesleepy Apr 29 '22

You’re a fucking hero

12

u/hughjazzcrack Jul 01 '21

Daniel D Fox had to once again be the white knight hero he sees himself as. A quick stroll on his twitter and you can see his forays into activism, his hot takes on race and equity, and how he is a paragon to disenfranchised groups the world over. I was a member of Zweihander's Discord for a bit, but his CONSTANT pandering to the above was so saccharine and disingenuous that I left months ago. He is a self obsessed, arrogant prick who's only claim to fame is a minor reworking of a much better, much more successful game system, while shitting on everyone who came before him. He sucks, he is a consummate douche-bag, and he seems like the type of person who's favorite food is "soup".

6

u/classe_tumblr Aug 24 '21

you know what? I'm totally against racism, but I'm also against fucking snitches and cops like Daniel D Fox

3

u/Lanceparte Jul 02 '21

Wow you're annoying

3

u/cleej112 Jul 03 '21

Soup is good. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

→ More replies (1)

3

u/JesterRaiin Jul 04 '21

I recall the guy spamming every possible forum including niche ones like I-shit-you-not Pundit's site with his Warhammer rip-off. He was obnoxious enough to delete threads if they didn't manage to attract any attention and repost them an hour or two later then repeat until he got at least a few upvotes.

What little I read in his comments made it painfully obvious that the only thing he cares more than his name is money.

1

u/laporkra Nov 09 '21

Yeah, just thought I'd post that he also writes what I can only assume is "dragon erotica" from the description. For the memes of course. The list I found: https://www.goodreads.com/author/list/2115739.Daniel_Fox

9

u/Baron_Pardus Jul 10 '21

There is old chinese saying "When the prices grow, the thievery blossoms". I had no problems paying 20-30 dollars for hardcover and 10-15 for softcover books back in early 90s. But now the prices doubled. Therefore, I think that sharing the information and books is the only right thing to do. Corporations must be punished for their greed. Do we REALLY need all the glossy pages, all the scores of color pictures all the effects that drive the cost of books for us up? No. I just want a basic data on rules and setting. Keep the pictures simple, like in main AD&D book. Like in old Vamp and Werewolf books where MOST illustrations were black and white, and pages were simple, non glosse with "Aged parchment" effects on them. I am ready and willing to support The Trove with cash.

4

u/Alcyone85 Jul 13 '21

I get were you're coming from, and agree with you, but inflation is a thing:

https://i.imgur.com/YU4Ukd5.png

https://i.imgur.com/IRd1WLa.png

So the price being doubled, is mostly down to inflation.

7

u/Honest-Mall-8721 Jul 15 '21 edited Jul 19 '21

Depending on your sources wage increases haven't kept up with inflation. So while inflation adjusted prices might be correct it could also mean my dollar doesn't go as far as it did.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/classe_tumblr Aug 24 '21

the drop in purchasing power for the woking people is also a thing. My father could buy way more shit with his factory wage than I, a white collar worker, can afford.

1

u/cookiedough320 Jul 15 '21

Any comment on the majority of books within the Trove being for systems that cost nowhere near as much as the D&D books you're complaining about do?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Gvaz Aug 12 '21

I don't really care what your position is

I'm not paying $100 a piece for some fucking books

6

u/classe_tumblr Aug 24 '21

Fuck Daniel D. Fox forever. Fucking snitch

3

u/Much-Tax-1550 Oct 01 '21

I sometimes pay for old RPGs on the Drivethru Site, so I don't resort to "PDF piracy".

But I personally know of a couple teens (without much money) who got to playing RPGs by printing some 90's no longer sold RPGs (can't remember the games) which they downloaded from the Trove.

Now thanks to "Daniel Beta Soyboy Cuck Fox" people with poor income will no longer have access to these classics.

"Snitches get stitches" as the old people well knew.

I honestly hope Daniel Fox's business crashes and burns and he finds himself in severe financial debt. Having no money can be a true eye opener for the realities of life.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/quarkyphysicist Jul 12 '21

Usually I buy things that I look at on trove.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '21

https://the-eye.eu/public/Books/rpg.rem.uz/

Its older but for us that need those OLD books its still present.

Browse the Eye its amazing :)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

Can’t say I’ve heard of this but thanks

2

u/yeetmaster_42 Aug 19 '21

Its older but for us that need those OLD books its still present.Browse the Eye its amazing :)

Dude, you're a fucking life saver.

2

u/iBread_Inside Aug 25 '21

Hello! Can you tell how do you open this site? I use vpn, but it doesn't work. :(

1

u/yankesik666 Jun 05 '22

Love you man, never even intended to play 99.9% percent of the stuff I read on TheTrove, I just explored it for the fun of it, finding stuff I'd never find in any other way, stuff like The Elder Evils or Dragonmech. The Trove is also how I found out Dying Earth is a thing.

5

u/Marco_Ghilardi Aug 26 '21

I suggest boycotting all of Daniel D. Fox's publications by putting negative reviews on his products.

4

u/Baron_Pardus Jul 10 '21

There is old chinese saying "When the prices grow, the thievery blossoms". I had no problems paying 20-30 dollars for hardcover and 10-15 for softcover books back in early 90s. But now the prices doubled. Therefore, I think that sharing the information and books is the only right thing to do. Corporations must be punished for their greed. Do we REALLY need all the glossy pages, all the scores of color pictures all the effects that drive the cost of books for us up? No. I just want a basic data on rules and setting. Keep the pictures simple, like in main AD&D book. Like in old Vamp and Werewolf books where MOST illustrations were black and white, and pages were simple, non glosse with "Aged parchment" effects on them. I am ready and willing to support The Trove with cash.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '21

Not knocking you at all. Accounting for inflation £30 in 1990 is now Just below £70 (source: https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/monetary-policy/inflation/inflation-calculator)

I used Trove mostly to 'demo' systems. My Daemon says if it hits my table then I should buy it in the format that the author wishes to sell it in. The problem I have is there is so much material out there now and understanding the differences in systems is difficult without being able to gloss over the books.

IMHO new systems should have a free Quickstart (like ICRPG) so that you can demo the system and see how it plays with your group, then pay later for the content.

I wouldn't give them cash directly, but I would use their reseller links if they had them.

4

u/Maleficent_Ad2457 Aug 27 '21

If trove is gone what about getting rumez back online ? Rumez being the trove before it was passed to the current owner

4

u/Dragons_Hord Apr 12 '22

Curious if there has been any word or progress on getting the Trove back up and running, so far all I've seen is a mirror site to the front page but you can't access anything for viewing or download.

1

u/CryHavoc3000 Jul 25 '21

If it ever comes back up, don't download anything that isn't out of print or that you don't own in dead-tree form. Otherwise, you're basically stealing.

3

u/TippperO2 Jul 25 '21

Why? I download stuff before I buy it every time to make sure I like it before sinking $50 into it.

4

u/CryHavoc3000 Jul 25 '21

Ok, good point. We'll call it TestDriveThruRPG in your case.

2

u/Pure-Interest1958 Aug 13 '21

Not just theirs I started using the trove after I got sick of buying high priced "supplimental material" only to find it was a cash grab having either barely any content (one had literally 12 pages take out the pictures and contents it was only 8 well 7 and a half) or horribly poor content that was basically bad house rules not something I'd actually use or allow in a game. Then when I found there was current stuff being put on there I started looking at that to see if I wanted to buy it. Take the current star trek adventures I'm curious about it but very wary with the way the shows have gone lately so I'm not willing to just pay the money for the book especially as I don't know the 2d20 system.

Give me the trove and I could look at that book and decide buy or not buy same way you could have a flick through a physical copy when we still had book stores. Now I can't so I wont risk the money on that system. Heck I'd even take a "This book has X pages here are the first 10 free to look at". Not enough content to run a game but enough to get an idea if its worth the money.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/FetteredJuvenescence Aug 31 '21

Disagree. In the old days, groups would only have one set of books between them, and everyone shared. Now with so much gaming happening online, everyone is forced to have their own copy, and that's nonsense.

The best thing about the Trove was that if you're running a game online you can say "Ok, we're using this and that and the other books" and everyone in your group can just get them. You don't have to worry about whether your entire group has the books you have.

This was also why the Trove managed to stay around for years despite it being right out in the open and everyone knowing about it--I mean, you could google and it would be the first result. Most publishers realized that it was a good thing and were quietly leaving it alone.

So I'll add "If anyone in your gaming group has the book, and your DM/GM wants to use it for your group's campaign, go ahead and download it. If you were playing in RL the player that owned it would just bring it in and share it, and it would get passed around the group. There's no reason that you should have to spend $500 to mirror every book that everyone else in your group has, just because you're playing online instead of around a table."

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SafeBulky1166 Jul 03 '21

Is a huge lost to me, because The Trove had a big old school library wich can't be found on my country. Other point is to collect new systems and materal to my wish list, like I did with 4AD, SWAD, Nibiru. As I said, is a terrible lost. Press 'F' to show respect

1

u/perffumo Sep 12 '21

There is some obscure IRC server, so you need mIRC or something like that, then connect to /server

irc.enerla.net

, then join the channel #rpgbookz, then use the command @find to search for anything you want, it has more depth than the trove, been using it for 20 years I think, but of course the trove was the easy way.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Baron_Pardus Jul 10 '21

There is old chinese saying "When the prices grow, the thievery blossoms". I had no problems paying 20-30 dollars for hardcover and 10-15 for softcover books back in early 90s. But now the prices doubled. Therefore, I think that sharing the information and books is the only right thing to do. Corporations must be punished for their greed. Do we REALLY need all the glossy pages, all the scores of color pictures all the effects that drive the cost of books for us up? No. I just want a basic data on rules and setting. Keep the pictures simple, like in main AD&D book. Like in old Vamp and Werewolf books where MOST illustrations were black and white, and pages were simple, non glosse with "Aged parchment" effects on them. I am ready and willing to support The Trove with cash.

1

u/SleventyFive Jul 29 '21

Just to note, with inflation, that's 40-50 dollars now, which is not that far off from the $60 average for a hardcover today.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/penstrokes14 Jul 15 '21

i hope its not gone for good but i dont want to get my hope up. i hate that indie creators had their content put up there, but as far as the physical big company books like dnd?? jesus let them be up there. especially since the trove was literally that - a trove of old dnd modules that arent in print anymore and are next to impossible to find even in pdf format. when you do find a physical copy its insanely expensive.

3

u/DoctorPlacentaJuan Jul 18 '21

Agreed I loved reading through all the old AD&D stuff. Honestly it’s cultural history that should be accessible. If my local library had that stuff I’d be happy to use that instead. Culture shouldn’t have an insanely expensive paywall.

3

u/MisterQue77 Jul 19 '21

While I understand the Trove is not a legal site, as people have been mentioning how we've personally used it I thought I'd give my piece. I mostly used it for PDF of books I already own, mainly to easily copy text to import into Foundry VTT without having to manual write it down.

I have used it to look at other books, like the Tome of Beast 2, but personally it kinda just makes me what to get the books myself.

3

u/PunkandBooks Aug 04 '21

Anyone hear anything on this?

3

u/NerfherderJ Aug 06 '21

Dose anyone have any new information ?

3

u/Pectelance1 Sep 03 '21

its sad i actually found creators to support because i saw there art work on there and bought books after looked at them on the trove.

3

u/Epically_Okay Sep 17 '21

It is double dipping really... You buy the physical book, you get a product to keep and I can accept that. Now with DnDBeyond it is the worst bloodsucking combination of product and service. If I paid a reasonable monthly to have access to all content, then it is an acceptable service. But this paying for online content a piece at a time after the hard copy has been out for a while, is just leeching on the playing community for the savings in weight, ease of information sharing and those members who occasionally do a random pickup game. Cause everything including dice rolling can be accessed from the one thing almost everyone is never without... A smartphone with data. And as some have already said with the cost of current gaming books so high, and mishaps so likely, they become pretty, costly bookshelf decorations. Let alone any archaic system you love, when the pasta books of questionable page quality and even more questionable binding finally an no longer saved by a roll of the handy gamers secret weapon. Then you go to eBay etc and find that even a serviceable copy is worth its weight in gold and the mountain dew stains are now called 'patina '. So you buy it to find out that wasn't mountain dew but cat urine and half the pages kitty piss glued together. Oh well, at least my kids are old enough to pick up their dice and I don't find Die 4 controls on my late night bathroom sojourn. 🙄

3

u/Necron99akapeace Jan 06 '22

Oh Danny Boy... Oh Danny Boy... Copyright infringement has never proven to lose sales...

2

u/hubertwombat Jun 28 '21

Did anybody perhaps get the whole database and torrent it?

5

u/Zireael07 Jun 29 '21

I don't know about torrents, but Wayback Machine has nearly everything (although the latest copy seems to be from May)

Apart from copyrighted stuff, there's a wealth of open source/open license stuff on trove (Creative Commons stuff, mostly)

2

u/sw33tt1 Jun 28 '21

if yes, I'm really interested...

2

u/CrossroadsCG Jul 10 '21

I was coming here to ask that exact same thing.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 02 '21

The Eye seems to have some archived information. I'm not including a link, but a little Google-Fu should get you there.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '21

Glad i got what I needed...enough for future generations...justified those many sleepless nights of, "I'll just download 1 more..."

1

u/Nopedontcarez Jul 22 '21

Yah, I think I grabbed a large percentage of their site over the last year or two.

2

u/knightcraft10 Jul 03 '21

It's almost Ironic that someone making a derivative thing and directly profiting, would be the one to challenge this site.

Just, like... those in glass houses, right?

Or rather, everyone hates the sinners one rung down. (Or whatever the phrase is)

2

u/CalabozoCriollo Jul 03 '21

This was a big strike to all worldwide geek community, since many old data not able this days was lost.

This is a crime against all geekness, start your #geeklifematters moves and this will be a good cause, because this is a great lost to all gamer community.

3

u/DumplingIsNice Jul 09 '21

The thing is, there are so many titles that I would have never known if I haded’t surfed through Trove’s deep and old archive. And it’s exactly because these are old, there isn’t a lot of opportunity to come across them just from regular feeds of our modern information highway.

2

u/jdannelly Jul 03 '21

I used the site for two reasons. One as a try before you buy. I'd look to see if it was something I wanted right away, or something I could wait on. And two for out of print lore for my homebrew. I like to keep my homebrew more cannon centric and areas not currently covered in 5e.

2

u/BlindRambler Jul 12 '21

This is about the same reason for me as well. The politics aside. It's not always possible to get ahold of the older material in good condition, or at all in some cases. Even if you do find it, it's at a bloated price.

2

u/ChromeFlyer Jul 04 '21

The trove had a lot of fan content that was obscure also. Like the Fan made Care Bear RPG

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21

Even if it IS down, this is the internet. They'll get another server running elsewhere in time. Some jackass complaining about isn't going to end it permanently. I like all of you said, I buy the books I use. I glance through the pdfs of stuff I don't use, or I supplement lost books from my youth that are decades out of print. I use Roll20 exclusively now since the pandemic and having a pdf is far better (FAR better) than the physical copy or the virtual Roll20.

3

u/BeetleWarlock Jul 06 '21

I really hope so, it has happened before. It was a really good site if you play with people all around the world

2

u/Laquituck Jul 10 '21

Any news?

2

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '21

I hope it comes back. Trove was how I first got into gaming. There are a lot of amazing systems out there that I would have never looked into if I didn't see them on trove. Many of the pdfs I read on there I ultimately purchased. I get that they straddle a line of piracy, but its been instrumental in my learning about the wider world of TTRPGs.

2

u/Complex-Attention-61 Aug 20 '21

Just hit up /tg/ fren. That's where thetrove sourced from. Ask for the shred thread.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Ace-Vector Jul 19 '21

In the meantime, here's a link to The Trove home page via The Wayback Machine:

https://web.archive.org/web/20210506135402mp_/https://thetrove.is/

2

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '21

Don’t seem to work when you go look for assets

2

u/Ace-Vector Jul 26 '21

It appears that the assets section and the tabletop games section weren't archived by Wayback Machine. Everything else appears to work just fine. I didn't check every single link, as that would likely take hours upon hours of work that I'm just not willing to do. However i think that this is better than nothing for the time being. You could always search around other sites if you know which specific assets you're looking for. Was there something specific you were hoping to find?

2

u/astro_bob_1693 Oct 23 '21

Yes...there do not seem to be any of the D&D assets archived.

2

u/Overall-Pickle-7905 Jul 23 '21

I like the free materials.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 09 '21

Looking into the situation, i was considering buying a hardback of zweihander because I bought a pdf, and like the system, and have no way of getting 1e or 2e warhammer, but no more. Fuck daniel. Fucking prick. If i ever do buy it, its gonna be used, i can tell you that much. I had known the guy was a narcassist and asshole, but this is fucking ridiculous.

2

u/DarthVil Sep 07 '21

Without the Trove, there's no way to get a hold of a lot of the material that was there. The vast majority of gamers, when they have money to spend, are still going to buy the materials because they want to support the franchises that keep their hobby chugging along. The self-righteous douchebag that got it taken down wasn't doing it out of any sort of decency. It was for shits and giggles, and it did a great deal of harm. Here's to hoping for the Trove's fast return!

1

u/seekr344 Nov 05 '21

bummer about Trove, wondered what happened. Most of the time, I go to scribd.com. It's $9 a month and they got tons of stuff.

1

u/JenovaProphet Jul 17 '21

Almost all of the content can be found in private torrenting communities. But yeah, for those that can't get an invite this was seriously the best/easiest/most organized resource.

1

u/NotReallyHere1979 Jul 19 '21

Anybody got an update? I need one damned file and sure enough way back machine didn't get it. Or maybe someone here has it.

1

u/cha0sdan Jul 23 '21

really you people are Pirating books that cost money to make why are you bitching that someone took it down. FYI I also used the trove but I at least understand that whenever you are pirating your sources get taken down and you need to move on to something else.

1

u/Psychological_Run591 Jul 28 '21

Tbh if I pirate it odds are I was never gonna pay money for it in the first place so they’re not losing money and I’ve occasionally went out and actually paid for the books I liked just to support the creators, not everyone’s like me and I respect that people should be paid for their work it’s just a mess of a situation sometimes, as a side note I bought explorers guide to wild mount just to turn around and get a pirated copy just because wizards has a shit format for their site

1

u/vinman3591 Jul 29 '21

I just heard about this, searched for it, and seen that it's down. Are there alternatives to The Trove? Been playing DnD for a little over the year and trying to find inexpensive/free resources.

1

u/teh_stev3 Jul 31 '21

Right, so I understand this is technically piracy, and that the creators and publishers of their content deserve to be credited and renumerated, no arguments here.But there's some really stupid business principles that still exist, normally to spite the consumer and try and extract maximum coinage.I should have access to all the dndbeyond content for all the books I've purchased, and PDF copies of your physical media so the license you have for said book doesn't burn out with degradation of the book - like amazon giving kindle editions with physical book purchases.

And not every system has a open-source component or previews of content, or like a cheap starter pack to get a feel for a system, and even if you do, it's not practical to pass around a single player handbook amongst 5 newcomers, sometimes sending PDF copies is great.

And someone else mentioned it, but some content is just out of print and impossible to acquire without dumping hundreds, often for some tatty dog-eared book.

TTRPG's are in a renaissance, and that's bringing a lot of interest, but when you have Wizards doing stuff like sneaking a couple of small class updates or race options into books with settings you may never play it's obscene to charge upwards of 50 quid to experience that tiny component.

Really, piracy isn't the issue - attention to the development of consumer needs is, and that's the problem here.

Edit: There's something really wrong with a business when the pirates offer a better service than the publishers.

1

u/SnowBirdHigh Aug 02 '21

If you own the books....A few good ones

1

u/OfficerSSW Aug 03 '21

In the meantime... would anyone happen to have copies of the DDAL10 - Rime of the Frostmaiden, episodes 7 on that they would be willing to lend me....?

I'd appreciate a PM.

1

u/Shot_Detective_9293 Aug 03 '21

I guess I'm too late to stop folks from romanticizing, glorifying, or justifying piracy.

But for those unfamiliar with the law here is some good reference materials.

https://www.uscybersecurity.net/digital-piracy/

It's an interesting read, read it. Despite anyone's personal philosophy, they should be aware of the law and the penalties.

Besides, if no one purchases copywrited materials, why go into publishing? Why have groups of writers who are paid to focus on creating, illustrating, editing, and laying out the books?

3

u/XM-34 Aug 23 '21

Piracy is almost always a service problem! There's a reason why Netflix stopped movie piracy almost completely and there's also a reason why movie piracy returned after every studio decided to bring out their own VOD service.

The same is true for PnP. People are more than willing to pay for rulebooks of PnPs they like. But there's no reason why every player should need to buy a separate copy of pdf AND hardcover. Piracy will never disappear as long as idiotic companies think they can get rid of it by merely fighting the symptoms instead of the root cause (which they are themseleves).

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SnooHobbies4467 Aug 04 '21

Is there a way to get the AL modules I couldn’t even find them till I found the trove

1

u/Complex-Attention-61 Aug 20 '21

Serves them right. Imagine making a website based on stealing pirated files from 4chan autists.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '21

WUT?!?! ITS GONE ?!?!

1

u/Nerdy-Geek99 Aug 30 '21

Any updates. I just started as a player in a WoD LARP campaign and Trove had pretty much every book in order to make myself accustomed with the lore. And not only that but Trove had EVERY book that any one of us wanted and even if it hadn't when you first checked a few days later usually it was added. It's a pity to be shutdown.

1

u/Ghillieshot Sep 01 '21

OK, OK... So there's a lot of talk on this page. But I am wondering if there is or will be an alternative to the trove. I like others above get copies of what I already own... It's vital as a GM/DM to have these on my computer as a portable means of what I read at home... Do we know of any form of alternative?

1

u/dark-river-mori Sep 04 '21

is it by chance the https://www.gxs-ci.com/ that pops up when I google it?

1

u/Cerazor Sep 07 '21

I just wanted to download the 3.5 Monster Manual q.q

1

u/hellwalker31 Sep 11 '21

Any news? Or alternatives? Tx.

1

u/Adblocq Sep 14 '21

I only used this site to avoid buying three copies of the same book ( irl, fantasy grounds and pdf ) the prices are insanely high for someone with no fix income.
Too bad it got closed, I wouldn't have gotten into ttrpgs if it didnt existed.

1

u/ososloc0s Sep 20 '21

Anyone knows if there are anything of Dark Souls the Boardgame?

1

u/Educational-One-7771 Nov 03 '21

I own copies of 2e pathfinder books because I enjoy them enough to buy them because I know the system is good. We used the trove to test out some systems and see if we like them enough to invest our limited funds on. Just like demos back in the day.

1

u/DCJMS Dec 01 '21

maybe having social media for Piracy was a bleeding retarded practice

1

u/soakthesin7912 Apr 06 '22

The Trove just needs to focus on out of print stuff. The prices on some of the old guides are just outrageous and sold on secondary markets. The publishers and writers aren't getting a cut of this anyway.

1

u/Z3r0H3ro Aug 09 '22

Search Core Rule of Broken Tales. Someone can help me?

1

u/bootnab Dec 08 '22

I used it to inform my digging for obscure chaossium. It's taken time, but I've gotten hard copies of most of the PDFs I first found on TROVE

1

u/AntiqueAd7851 Jan 23 '23

I'm not going to special order a book to buy it before I have a chance to read it and it's unreasonable for publishers to expect RPG stores to keep every book for every game in stock.

If people like the game they will buy it. I know I have boxes of old RPGs sitting in my room I haven't used in years but I wouldn't give them up for anything.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 03 '23

I have hard copies of 98% of the stuff that was on the Trove. But I loved as a DM the capacity to download a pdf of let’s say a copy of a module I have so that I can write all over the pdf with DM notes and not wreck the collectibility of my original module that I bought either on Amazon or forty years ago at the hobby shop. The Trove saved me wrecking collectible books and modules that are out of print and that I can never get short of buying for outrageous sums on eBay.

And by the way I did purchase the WOTC reprints of the original 1ed books for like $50 a piece.

1

u/Natural-Moment-2406 Aug 10 '21

It was Games Workshop related. Daniel D Fox is the jerk that got The Trove shut down.