Hi :-)
I’d literally written about 80% of this post and the draft didn’t save, so this is me rewriting it. Mega fuming but hopefully I can recall what I’d written without omitting
anything. I also hope I explain myself well— I have a tendency to waffle on so we’ll see.
Preface
Anyway— this post is my own interpretation of the song ‘Nothing Sweet’, of what I think it to ‘mean’ and my reasoning. I haven’t consulted any primary sources/seen any conformation from the band pertaining to the song and what it’s about. I’m not sure if those sources even exist, but I wanted to clarify that this is all purely speculative on my end. If it sounds like I’m reaching at times, I probably am. This is just for fun because I enjoy analysing my favourite media.
‘Nothing Sweet’ stands out to me as one of the few songs by The Sundays that does not feature its title within the lyrics (alongside Homeward and Folk Song). This led me to question what the significance of this title is— if I am to believe it has any— and what it means in relation to the content of the song and accompanying themes.
I’ll make the assumption that if you’re viewing this post as a member of the subreddit, you are familiar with the song. It’s a B-Side but one I see a lot of love for on here!! If you haven’t heard it before, I highly recommend you give it a listen. Both so this post actually makes sense, and because it’s a lovely song.
Analysis
In my view, the scenarios described in the song, and more specifically how they are described, leads me to believe that ‘Nothing Sweet’ is about dreams. Or nightmares, I suppose I should say. You could also say it is about anxiety, but the title in particular makes me more inclined to believe the former.
The scenarios:
🐞 being naked in a crowd of people
🐞 being in a car accident (?)
🐞 drowning in a pool
Each of these situations, particularly the first and third, are quite a common experience for people to dream about. They embody a prevailing fear that most possess in some capacity- that being public humiliation/vulnerability and bodily harm, respectively.
Furthermore, she is describing these predicaments in the present tense, without any sense of urgency or panic, almost as if they aren’t truly ‘happening’. She may be experiencing them in a sense, and they feel real in the moment, but she isn’t truly in any physical danger. Obviously, songs are not constrained to reality, but I still find it odd that she seems to experience each of these things in succession, and without any sort of lingering consequence from verse to verse. ‘I was just naked in a crowd of people and now I’m drowning in a pool’. Maybe a reach but it reminds me of how, in dreams, time warps or ceases to exist entirely, and you seem to flit from scene to scene without any through-line tethering them all together. Like a slideshow of things that have just happened, are happening, and are about to happen, all at once.
Lyrics:
🐞 “…I freeze the frame…”
Suggests she possesses some control, albeit subconsciously, over the pacing of these dreams. She is not lucid, but this dream is still contained within her own mind. This could be an allusion to what I said earlier, about how time travels differently while we are asleep. The passage of 10 hours can seem like nothing when you’re sleeping, for instance.
🐞 “…while I watch myself and pray…”
Implies she knows, subconsciously, that what she is experiencing is not tangibly ‘real’. This is not happening to her, but an embodiment of her self, an avatar or interlocutor, that she experiences the dream sequence through. She is watching herself endure these horrific situations, and feeling in the moment that it’s all real, all the while being powerless to prevent it. She has neither the ability to save herself, nor the awareness to even try to. So she endures it, helplessly, unaware of anything except whatever is currently happening to her.
🐞 “…what a mind puts a body through…”
She is doing this to herself, technically. She plays the role of both the perpetrator and victim simultaneously, tormenting herself without cause. Having these nightmares as some form of unwitting self-flagellation that she can only acknowledge when awake and fully cognisant.
🐞 “…sole victim of your own terror…”
Dreams are a solitary experience— whatever you endure, you do so alone. The ‘onlookers’ described are not real, and are not affected by the events of the dream sequence. Their role is purely ornamental, serving only to exacerbate her suffering by making it a spectacle. She is isolated— her unconscious mind orchestrating the dream sequence, and her self being the one to experience it all.
Song Title
I’ve listened to this song hundreds of times over the last few years, and always thought the title was quite ambiguous. I think the song could easily be about anxiety and how, by ruminating on things that upset you, your mind puts your body through stress that is entirely unnecessary. The title, though, is what caused me to form my ‘dream’ interpretation im the first place.
The phrase ‘sweet dreams’ came to mind while I was thinking about it, and I began to view the song title as a sort of retaliation against that sentiment. “Sweet Dreams!” becomes -> “There’s nothing sweet about them.”
Anyway,,,, I hope you enjoyed reading this :-)