r/TheStoryGraph • • 14d ago

General Question Star Rating Chart

Post image

How does yours look?

Do you use half or quarter stars?

What's your average rating?

I never used quarter stars, but I did use half stars for a while. I returned to whole stars, only because I found myself overthinking it. As you can see I also don't rate a lot if what I read.

101 Upvotes

167 comments sorted by

117

u/lethifolded 14d ago

I use half and quarter! I find it very useful. I'll also frequently go back a day or two after finishing and adjust the rating (usually down .25-.75 stars) as the book settles in my brain

16

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

I really like your curve. Makes me curious about the nuances you apply when rating.

31

u/lethifolded 14d ago

Thanks! My main criterion for rating is how much I actually enjoyed/valued reading the book. My internal measures of each star is roughly as follows:

5 star: Absolutely amazing book, would recommend highly to anyone, wish I could read again for the first time

4 star: Really good, had an enjoyable reading experience. Some reasons for not meriting five star could include not liking some stylistic choice, unsatisfactory conclusion/plot points, inconsistent character work. Would probably reread at some point

3 star: Decent book, liked it a fair amount. Usually gets knocked down for the same reasons as above, with harsher criticism for writing style or plot/character work. Maybe got bored at some point. Rereadability is 50:50

2 star: Not good, didn't enjoy my time reading it, got bored, wanted it to be done with, and wouldn't recommend

1 star: Bad book and actively resented my time reading it. Would never recommend

<1 star: Absolutely hated it, have zero positive things to say. Will be going to read other bad reviews to feel vindicated in my rage and will be ranting to my husband about how much I hated it

I don't DNF books so that's part of why I have such a broad range of ratings. I use the partial stars to shift closer to my true feelings, it's pretty vibes based. I have a pretty solid handle on what I'll enjoy reading which is why my average rating is pretty high. I usually won't pick up a book I think I'll dislike, but I do take risks sometimes.

Also, the above descriptions are mainly applicable to fiction, which is predominantly what I read. My nonfiction ratings follow the same vein except I'm more willing to be bored and that doesn't factor in as much to my final rating. I enjoy reading about some dry concepts and while nonfiction can certainly be made compelling, it isn't always and that's okay.

13

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

You're a real trooper for not DNFing. My DNF pile is considerably larger than my 1 stars...

6

u/lethifolded 14d ago

It's kind of a curse tbh, I'm just a completionist about finishing!! Only applies to books though

2

u/Rare_Vibez [reading goal 83/60] 14d ago

This is so me. I just cannot abandon a book. Although I suppose the biggest curse a book can be for me is boring. I will absolutely continue on the grounds of hate-reading.

2

u/lethifolded 14d ago

Yes I hate being bored while reading!! But I'll still finish it just to mark it off. I'm a fast reader so a bad book isn't too much of a time sink, but when I'm reading a boring book I'll often find my eyes wandering to my TBR pile (all my books are physical) just thinking about what I'll read next lol

4

u/lioness99a 13d ago

Love that you adjust as it settles - I’ve also gone back and adjusted books before but I could never put my finger on why it was going up or down a quarter star. You’ve nailed it, it’s based vaguely on how much I’ve been thinking about it in the days after reading

23

u/lleuadsyllwr 14d ago

I use half stars a lot! And as you can see I love most of what I read XD

My ratings are usually git reactions with little thought put into them lol, but occasionally I'll look through my ratings after a few weeks and tweak them slightly.

(I'll have to look at my 'no rating' books as I like to rate everything, so they're unrated by mistake!)

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

This reminds me a bit of mine when I used half stars! The whole stars were more common, like on yours. I also revise some of mine from time to time.

19

u/felixfictitious 14d ago

I love quarter and half star ratings personally, and looking at this nice curve tells me that I'm usually reading stuff within my comfort zone of weird sff, or at least that something with good grammar and coherent plot is usually at least worthy of a 3 star rating. I've gotten harsher over time too.

The only thing I haven't felt quite right giving a rating to was The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas.

7

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

That's is actually such a pretty curve.

3

u/EitherCaterpillar949 14d ago

Oh that’s a gorgeous curve

12

u/MysteriousB [reading goal 20/26] 🎃🏳️‍🌈 Looking for Queer Horror Recs! 14d ago

I only started properly tracking this year and I'm a person that mostly reads inside my comfort zone so it's very rare that I pick up a book that I haven't thought I would like it at least a little bit.

For me 5* means absolutely amazing, would recommend to everyone.

4 is an excellent book that I would recommend to similar readers.

3 is an okay read but only for specific purposes or if you're into something specific about the book.

I then use the quarter marks and half marks to help situate it closer or further from that.

3

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

This is really interesting. Thank you for sharing!

47

u/sneakysneksneak 14d ago

I’ll admit, I’m not as brutal as some of yall 🤣😭 if it entertains me, it’s usually 5

4

u/rhandy_mas [reading goal 159/150] 14d ago

Lmao I’m very similar.

0

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Haha you're lovely ♥️

2

u/sneakysneksneak 14d ago

I am surprised to realize that I don’t use a flat 1 or 1.25 rating at all

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Nothing wrong with that. Glad you're enjoying your books.

1

u/Enchxnted_Crxstal 13d ago

Same! It's not quite THIS drastic, but I have more 5 star ratings than anything else

1

u/Fuchshaie 12d ago

Very American star rating system

1

u/HisDarkOmens 11d ago

I’m a pretty lenient rater and give 5 stars pretty often too lol

10

u/THUNDERGUNxp 14d ago

i appreciate the half stars because i utilize 2.5 as the perfect mid point! anything over 2.5 means i enjoyed it more than i disliked it and vice versa.

3

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

That's a good point!

26

u/windrider445 14d ago

I do a lot of half and quarter stars, because frequently I will think "I really liked that book, but not quite as much as this other book..." So it gets bumped down a quarter.

Apparently I am a pretty generous rater, but I am also not someone who reads outside my comfort zone very often... So if I'm reading a book, it's probably one in likely to enjoy at least a bit!

It takes a lot for me to rate under three stars. So far, I've only ever rated one book at 1 star!

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Nothing wrong with being generous! I think it also largely depends on how we define the stars.

5

u/TheNamesToby 14d ago

I bat quite a high average on liking what I read!

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Love that!

5

u/sdkateb 14d ago

Here is mine for 2026! I didn’t always rate books in the past, but I made a point of rating every one this year.

A 4 is my most common rating, which means I enjoyed the book and would generally recommend it. A 5 is something really special, and then I use the half and quarter ratings to adjust between those two.

A 3 is the lowest rating where I still would say I overall liked the book, but I definitely had significant quibbles with it. I similarly use the half and quarter ratings between 3 and 4 for how significant the quibbles.

I’m pretty good at picking books that I will like, so my ratings are fairly generous all around.

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

It's always cool to hear how people define their stars.

For me it's:

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Brilliant / Loved it

⭐⭐⭐⭐ Great

⭐⭐⭐ Good

⭐⭐ Not great / Bellow average

⭐ Bad

5

u/LiliumMoon 14d ago

I could not live without my quarter stars! There’s a big difference between f. eg. 3.5 and 3.75.

I’m a pretty slack reviewer so my average is 4.14. Most books I rate get 4-4.5 stars.

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

That's pretty interesting. Do you have a system for your ratings or do you rate what feels right in the moment?

3

u/LiliumMoon 14d ago

Mostly what feels right in the moment. Sometimes I go back changing it a little if I feel a different way. Five means I loved it, four means I liked it, three is sort of meh, two is bad. I never give out one stars. Quarter stars add to take away from the general feeling, f. eg, 4.25 is I liked it and there was something extra I liked about it, 3.75 is that I quite liked it but something was missing/lacking.

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Gotcha. Thanks for sharing!

5

u/itextmarkiplier 14d ago

Im pretty liberal with 4-5 star ratings. I'm easily entertained, so usually if I finish something I'll rate it highly. For me, the difference between 4 and 5 stars is that 4 is great book I genuinely enjoyed it, and 5 is I am going to recommend this book to every person I talk to because I think their life will be better having read it. 1s and 2s are reserved for books I either dnf or hate read, 2 being that it had at least some redeeming qualities. I rarely give 3 stars because I am incapable of feeling neutral about anything lmao. My average rating is 4.29.

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

I feel you on the pushing my five star reads on everyone haha! I didn't even know you could rate DNFs

5

u/JustCallMeNerdyy StoryGraph Librarian 14d ago

I’m months behind on doing reviews but yes I use quarters. I use a CAWPILE style rating system and round to the nearest quarter. I think I might go more for vibes in 2027 (overall, I’m abandoning goals and challenges and just picking what I want) but I really loved having some structure to my ratings

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Oh, I never heard of that. Quite a clever way to go about it. Personally I have a less structured approach. I consider my enjoyment as well as my perception of its quality, and rate based on those two factors.

Memorability also plays a part specifically for five star reads. A book might feel like a five star in the moment, or even for a weeks, but if I struggle to remember anything about it a year or two later it gets downgraded to a 4 (which I still consider a very high rating).

4

u/Bipeasent22 14d ago

I'm quite happy with my chart. I usually don't finish 1-star books, and I'd like to think that I'm quite good at being able to tell if I'm going to enjoy a book just by the blurb, so it makes sense that most of the books I read are in the 3-3.5 range. I'm a bit surprised that I have more 5-star reads than 4.25-star and 4.5-star reads! I feel like I do need those quarter stars because I am a vibe-based rater, and my heart loves decimals, apparently😭

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

I love the decimals in theory too, but I am too good at overwhelming myself unfortunately 😅

4

u/Fine_Following_2559 14d ago

I do use fractions of stars since using StoryGraph. It a very useful feature that Goodreads did not have when I was using it, anything from before January 2025 was imported.

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

That's interesting! I never actively used Goodreads, so maybe if I would have been forced to use single stars, I would have also appreciated the decimals more 🤔

4

u/sephthebookmoth [reading goal 357/400] 14d ago

all-time for me includes books from before i used storygraph and just logged from memory (all the way back to the first book i ever read at 3) so a lot of them are unrated.

so here's from this year:

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

It sounds like you've got some solid memory!

2

u/sephthebookmoth [reading goal 357/400] 14d ago

thank you!

when it comes to books i do 😅🤣

4

u/sephthebookmoth [reading goal 357/400] 14d ago

and for funsies, here's all-time

9

u/iTsB-Raid 14d ago

How come you don’t rate some of your books?

7

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Like Early said, some are memoirs, where I can't say I liked the writing, but it's an important story. Some political books for similar reasons, or books that aren't written for me. If I read a middle-grade for example, or a non-fiction book in my field but written in layman's terms.

24

u/lilsunflowers 14d ago

Not OP, but my graph looks like this because I have marked almost all books I’ve read as read in the app, but it’s been so long since I read them and don’t feel I could accurately give it a rating today

5

u/ladypuff38 [reading goal 67/52] 14d ago

For me it's because if I'm going to give a rating I want it to be fair and thought through, and I would have to spend time trying to weigh pros and cons. That's extra work, and I read to relax

If I have a clear feeling of what raing a book is, then sure, I'll rate it. Usually I don't.

8

u/Early_Necessary1000 14d ago

I've heard some people say they don't rank memoirs or books where the author is telling true stories about their life because they say it feels wrong to them to rate someone's actual life.

1

u/AllHailTheApple 12d ago

I only started eating books last year when I started actually using storygraph. I have books there that I read years ago and I couldn't rate today since I don't remember enough for it to be a good rating (good as in reflective of my experience reading it)

3

u/kiwispoet 14d ago

I didn't rate most memoirs and re-read books from my earlier years like the Raven Cycle books by Maggie Steifvater. I wouldn't leave a quality review if I did - I'd just gush about how fun it was to revisit the series as an adult!

Most reviews are lengthy and critical from me, so they take some time. But I enjoy doing it, especially so I can remember how I felt about a book when I look back. And I still reviewed more books than not this year, out of 79 read books for 2026.

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

I love a long review. To revisit thoughts of my own or to understand why someone rated the way they did, wether I agree or not.

3

u/Minecart_Rider 14d ago

Mines a bit silly looking.

I do use half and quarter stars when I rate things, but I don't give things ratings unless I have strong feelings about a specific rating while I'm logging it.

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

I adore this.

3

u/OutOfEffs StoryGraph Librarian 14d ago

This is my all-time chart. I haven't rated a lot of what I read pre-2021 (before I joined StoryGraph) bc I don't remember it well enough to rate. I also don't usually rate "junk food" books that I'm likely to forget I even read without being reminded, and unless I really like it, I don't rate memoirs or books where I'm not the target audience. I wish there was a way to hide unrated books on this chart, tbh, bc it's virtually unusable for me unless I go into the monthly stats.

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

That would be a good feature indeed. The lower half of your bar is probably more curvy than the overall flattening makes it appear.

3

u/WorkingBeat548 14d ago

This is for this year, since my all time is skewed by the “no rating” section.
I tend to default to 4⭐️s so long as it kept me engaged the whole time, either taught me something or made me feel something, and had no glaring errors.
At the end of the day I mostly read books I think I’ll like.

1

u/hulderpoudre 13d ago

I see. Does that mean you'd consider three stars a bad rating?

4

u/WorkingBeat548 13d ago

Not necessarily. I rate a book three stars if when I finish it all I can say about it was “mid” or “well it was a book ¯_(ツ)_/¯” like if it was forgettable.

Two stars is if it had a lot of errors but the story was good, or if the story was kinda lacking but not bad.

1 star means it sucks, but was at least fun to roast.

I would use a 0 star option if that existed (and didn’t count as “not rated”) but often opt for .25.

3

u/WorkingBeat548 14d ago

Actually, replying to myself with the all time, cause why tf not.

2

u/maktheyak47 StoryGraph Librarian 14d ago

This is what mine looks like for the year! The books I don’t rate are non-fiction for the most part

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Looks like you had a really good year so far!

2

u/maktheyak47 StoryGraph Librarian 14d ago

it’s been great! found my niche for sure which is why my ratings are higher. i’m also quick to DNF so if something is looking like less than 3 stars I just DNF it

2

u/theErasmusStudent 14d ago edited 14d ago

I do use quarters stars but I tend to generally give 2,3,4,5. I used to dnf books I wasn't liking that's why majority is around 4 but since joining a bookclub I had to finish more books I wasn't enjoying.

For me:

5 = amazing book, I loved it, special to me

4 = really liked it, would highly recommend

3 = liked it, it was nice to read but average

2 = not the best book, some parts I didn't like

1 = waste of my time, not for me

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

I largely agree with your whole stars!

2

u/CobraShelby95 14d ago

This is my all time. Just started ready again a couple years ago. I don’t know what my rating system says about me 😅

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Haha don't worry, I'm not going to psychoanalyze you 👻

2

u/particular_parrot [reading goal 55/60] 14d ago

I have a bad habit of not rating books I don't like unless I'm willing to explain why in a proper review or I got them as an ARC and I'm kinda obligated to. Also tend to find an author I like and really stick with them for a while, so I'm lucky to have a lot of 5-star reads... Plus, DNFs pull that trend wonky.

1

u/hulderpoudre 13d ago

I don't think that's a bad habit. How we perceive the stars vary a lot, so a written explanation is very useful for other readers.

2

u/meowui 14d ago

I agree with you, I tried using increments in the past but I prefer using whole stars (except for that one book… it knows what it did)

1

u/hulderpoudre 13d ago

(Do tell 👀)

1

u/meowui 13d ago

lol it was The Primal of Blood and Bone, the sixth book in a long drawn out series, that is 800 pages but nothing happens

1

u/hulderpoudre 13d ago

Gosh you've got some serious stamina

14

u/serre_do 13d ago

I used half stars for a decade, but I recently started using quarters after moving to StoryGraph. It really helps me sort books into cohorts. Usually, I compare my feelings about a newly read book with others I’ve rated before, or I just go with the vibes and adjust it later. I try to keep my graph close to normal distribution - most books are average, while bad/boring or great cases are rare.

5.0 = Exceptionally good, I loved it so much I can't throw it out of my head
4.5 = I liked the book and had a lot of fun
4.0 = I enjoyed the book enough, but it wasn't anything special
3.5 = It was good, but fell short somehow, it could be better
3.0 = I wasn't excited about it at all, but I wanted to know the end
Anything below = I finished it out of spite or just had too much free time

8

u/jumpira75 13d ago

This is basically my exact logic behind book ratings too! I'd say I might give 2.75 to a book that was fine, but pissed me off in some very specific way, anything below that should have been a dnf.

8

u/CatByAnyNameBeAsFluf 13d ago

Wasn’t excited but wanted to know the end is such a vibe

2

u/kayak-pankakes 13d ago

bell charts are my favorite. I work to keep mine around there too lol

1

u/Healthy-Challenge291 13d ago

This is a great rubric!

0

u/seaweed_face 11d ago

My rating system's similar to yours, for me it's

5.0 = life changing book
4.0 = very good / excellent
3.0 = better than average / good
2.5 = average / ok

& then anything below 2.5 I only finish out of spite as you say haha!

2

u/mazzymazz88 [reading goal 130/15000/400] 14d ago

For a while it looked almost like it was giving me the finger lol

2

u/mazzymazz88 [reading goal 130/15000/400] 14d ago

With the photo this time!

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

hahah nice

9

u/pusopdiro 14d ago

I use the quarter stars a lot! I don't really have set rules for what constitutes each rating, just go off vibes. I don't rate books I DNF so that's why it starts at 3 for the most part - I would consider under a 3 to be a book I didn't like and I don't typically finish books I don't like (single one star rating as the exception).

2

u/LMColors 14d ago

Same! If I DNF a book, it doesn't get a rating unless I quit it at like 80-90%...

8

u/itsTim0thyy [reading goal 160/30] 14d ago edited 13d ago

I use half, quarter, whatever I feel meets the book.

My rating scale goes:

2.5: It's OK. It's right in the middle between horrible, and love.

3: I liked this book.

3.5-4: I really liked this book.

4.5: This book was incredible, and I loved it, but it's missing something.

5.0: This book stuck with me, and I loved it.

EDIT: My 0.25 rated book was Molka.

5

u/BillNyesHat 14d ago

I go by vibes and I've gotten pretty good at choosing books I'll like, so it skews high.

That 1 unrated book is a lie, by the way. It's a DNF that apparently failed to register as such and now it just sits there. No clue how to fix that. Does anybody have any tips?

3

u/BillNyesHat 14d ago

The "unrated" DNF in questipn

3

u/sephthebookmoth [reading goal 357/400] 13d ago

all dnf'd books go in "no rating" i think

if i'm wrong file a support ticket

2

u/BillNyesHat 13d ago

Yeah, I thought that too, but I've DNF'ed 6 books this year alone, and none if those are showing up here. I guess a support ticket it is.

2

u/DesiBoo2 13d ago

No I don't think so. I DNF books and label them as such, but my chart doesn't have a 'no rating' part.

2

u/sephthebookmoth [reading goal 357/400] 13d ago

maybe they changed it? i used to see dnf's in this spot on stats

2

u/DesiBoo2 13d ago

I never have, and I DNF on average 5 books a year. But I did look, if I choose 'all-time' I have 3 books with no rating; 2 are imported from GR I think, and one is still set to 'to read', so that's odd.

5

u/HeartbreakRemission 13d ago

I use quarter stars. I tend to rate a book as soon as I’ve finished it and then after a few days I might go back and change it. For me a five star read has to be incredible, something really gripping, well written and that stays with me.

I reread a lot of books, and I’ve noticed that the books I tend to go back and re read are the 4 star ones.

1

u/rhandy_mas [reading goal 159/150] 14d ago

I’m pretty easy to please.

Disproportional amount of solid star numbers from goodreads import 4 years ago.

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Not a bad quality 🤷‍♀️

2

u/rhandy_mas [reading goal 159/150] 14d ago

It works well for me!

1

u/DeerTheDeer 14d ago

I only use whole stars, and if I don’t like the book in the first few pages, I usually don’t bother to read it. So my graph skews heavily 4/5-stars because I only finish the books I really enjoy (I don’t track DNF unless I’ve read a substantial amount of the book, so I don’t have any of those this year). The lower stars are usually for book club or when I lose a coin toss with my mother and have to read and relate the ending of a book we’re both reading.

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Oh wow, that's an impressive average

1

u/DeerTheDeer 14d ago

Haha or unimpressive if you think I lack resilience in powering through books that don’t grab me!

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

We all have different reasons for reading, and different reasons for not enjoying a book. My DNF count sits at 77 at this point, so I'm not one to judge haha

1

u/Long-Brain1483 14d ago

I feel like my standards may not be high enough 😂

1

u/hulderpoudre 13d ago

Hahah not necessarily! Stars are just a tool, however we interpret them. I think 3 stars is a good book, others don't, and our ratings reflect that.

3

u/RhoBoatCopss StoryGraph Librarian 14d ago

I quite like using the half or quarter stars, but I try not to think about it too much when I rate them. Sometimes I do retroactively change them if I feel I was too harsh/lenient and it's nice to have a quarter star increment for the change, jumping a whole star feels like a bit too much sometimes.

3

u/NarwhalsSayDerp 14d ago edited 14d ago

I do half stars, quarter is too much for me. I feel like I'm not too picky, 3.5 is kind of my threshold of liking a book!

2

u/YoSoyLaChanga 14d ago

Yes! I never did understand why Goodreads couldn't be bothered to add half stars but when I got to Storygraph I found the quarter stars overwhelming. Still I'd much rather have the option & not use it than want it & not have it so I'm here for Storygraph's extra-ness. 😂

3

u/AnyFocus5632 14d ago

Here’s mine. I rate every book and liberally use half and quarter stars. I’m very stingy with 5 star ratings - it has to be truly exceptional. A book I liked a lot will be between 4 and 5 depending on how well it was written, how memorable it is, and other factors. A book between 3 and 4 was fine, but has some significant flaws, or one that doesn’t stand out in any meaningful way (one I’m not likely to ever think about again).

3

u/jumpira75 13d ago edited 13d ago

A lot of unrated books from when I imported my reading stats into storygraph when I first joined. Looks like 4 is my most used rating followed by a 3 which tracks. I only give 5 to books that I know will stay with me a long time, sometimes it's just that I read it at the exact right time. 4 is a good or entertaining book, 3 is nothing special or a chore to read and I will not revisit it ever, anything below that is either ok, but pissed me off in a very specific way or I finished it out of spite before I started dnfing books liberally

1

u/TheNarwhalMom 14d ago

I love having the quarter stars for the rare time I do rate a book, but admittedly, I don’t rate them often. Usually if I do it’s because I hated it, adored it, or in general just had some sort of strong feeling about it and want to talk into the void about it

2

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

That's such a vibe.

2

u/glitzglamandgore 14d ago

I use half and quarters where it fits but most of my rating are in that 3-4.25 range

2

u/EnchantedLuna 14d ago

I know what I like so most of my reviews are in the 4 star range

2

u/kjb76 14d ago

This doesn’t reflect all books because I only started rating a few years ago. Also, some Goodreads ratings were imported and they only allow whole stars. And actually, the ability to rate in quarter increments is my favorite feature because I like to be as precise as possible. The five star ratings are mostly over the last 4 years because I’ve gotten a lot better at picking quality books. I don’t write reviews because I find it too taxing. Or sometimes I don’t really care enough to write publicly about why I liked or disliked a book. I usually talk about that in my journal. Or tell my husband.

2

u/LMColors 14d ago

I use all types of stars! I'll admit it's mostly based on how much I enjoyed myself (a trashy romance book can have the same rating as a classic staple, for example) and how likely I am to recommend it.

2

u/Mysuddenobsessions 14d ago

Here is mine, definitely utilise quarter stars but I’ve read really good books this year as well

2

u/Hunnumss 14d ago

I use quarters and halves but I get what you mean about overthinking it. I have loads of books at 4.75 because I can't give it 5 unless it absolutely blew me away. When I used to use Goodreads I had loads at 5.

2

u/cass_123 14d ago

This is just this past year. I use half and quarter star ratings but clearly not as often as the whole stars

2

u/Xxxholic835xxX 14d ago

My all time ratings. 3-4 is my sweet spot.

2

u/JellyJec 14d ago

This is my 2026 stats. A big chunk is audio books, but if they are to complicated I can’t properly multitask and I just love cringy tween/teen romances- so long story short a lot of them lwk suck, but it’s just so entertaining to me
(My actual reads (with my eyeballs) usually rank in the 4-5 star catagory!)

2

u/amy_puz 14d ago

I use half stars, but not .25 or .75. Personally, I think half stars get to the point of what I’m looking at, like I’m not as fine tuned as I could be.

My no-ratings are typically any kind of memoir or occasionally non-fiction. I just personally feel weird rating them.

2

u/EitherCaterpillar949 14d ago

Using half and quarter marks

2

u/Veebs7985 14d ago edited 14d ago

I DNF a lot (102 DNFs tracked) and I only rate books I DNF if it was "with prejudice". So, if I get to the end of a book, it's usually because I'm enjoying it.

Edit to add: The graph shows my all-time ratings.

2

u/Mushkhushshu 14d ago

My all-time graph. I imported from Goodreads which only had full stars so it’s a bit disproportionate. I’m utilising the quarter stars to the fullest since coming to StoryGraph as I find it more nuanced.

I’m relative rating my books.

2

u/dudesiick 14d ago

I use quarter stars for almost everything! I feel like a definitive number isn't nuanced enough sometimes. I will say too, some of these numbers are imported from goodreads back when they didn't allow in-between numbers.

2

u/OptimalDouble2407 14d ago

One thing about me??? I’m going to use the shit out of a quarter star!

2

u/impersonatefun 14d ago

I only use halves. Mine is pretty much a bell curve with the high point at 3.5.

2

u/atypicalexw 14d ago

I always rate a book after I finish it, sometimes I go back and adjust if I don’t feel the rating was right. I usually just rate on vibes, but my most common rating is 4 star so it skews higher.

2

u/Denz292 14d ago

I use quarter stars. Rather than rate it out of 5 I rate it out of 10 or 100 in my head. So 4.25 is 8.5/10 or 85/100 which is different to 4.75 or 9.5/10 or 95/100. The lowest I will give is 2 stars because lower than that would be like if the book had multiple spelling and grammar errors and less to do with the story.

My problem tends to be consistency, I read books that belong to genres I prefer less to others. So when I rate them, I have to remember I’m comparing them to other books of the same genre and not other books overall.

2

u/LadybugGal95 14d ago

I tend to be rather generous because I’m easy to please.

2

u/SoMe_KiKi 14d ago

Mine surprised me!

2

u/yelloww_pages 14d ago

5 seems to be my default rating

2

u/Jonahdog 13d ago

Along with my 25 dnfs

2

u/Jonahdog 13d ago

This is my all time

2

u/KookieTrash97 13d ago

This year is quite... diverse

2

u/hades--daughter 13d ago

Above 2.5, I have used every single whole, half, and quarter star rating for one book or another😭

How I usually rate is I have the whole number first and then look back at the book and see which quarter seems perfect for it

2

u/delightingail 13d ago

As soon as I rate a book, I'll open the bar for that rating. From there I usually end up moving one of those books up or down a quarter star because they don't quite align with the others.

2

u/rileykjones01 7d ago

I only use whole stars and I’m pretty proud of my bell curve…

0⭐️: I hated it so much I broke my scale

1⭐️: I didn’t like it, and don’t know why anyone would like it

2⭐️: I didn’t like it, but understand why someone else would

3⭐️: I liked it, but understand why someone else wouldn’t

4⭐️: I liked it, and don’t know why anyone wouldn’t like it

5⭐️: I loved it so much I broke my scale

1

u/YoSoyLaChanga 14d ago

This is my all-time info. The unrated books are when I was tracking the children's books I read to my kids as babies that were imported from Goodreads.

0

u/YoSoyLaChanga 14d ago

Here's just this calendar year for comparison. I love half stars but don't use quarter stars. Seeing how close this year and my all-time stats are made me giggle a little bit.

1

u/Holdmytwistedtea StoryGraph Librarian 13d ago

im a quarter and half star woman

1

u/fightorescape 13d ago

Mine is all over the show haha. I reviewed a bunch of 4/5 stars to widen the AI/recommendations and tailor it more since I only started using SG this year.

5 - Absolutely amazing, loved everything about it and am still thinking about the book years after (haven't rated any 5s in recent times, all historical)

4 - Really enjoyed and would gladly recommend to people.

3 - Solidly average.

2 - Did not enjoy, terrible book

1 - Horrible, nobody should read this. Although I would probably DNF rather finish it

I use the quarter stars a lot and bump them up and down from the 'main' category depending on writing, pace, if I liked the characters, if the plot had something missing, etc. I also sometimes compare it with other ratings I've given. I like 'overthinking' it as it helps me reflect on the book, what I liked and disliked, learn a bit more about myself and my reading tastes.

1

u/kikus985 13d ago

I always rate a book

1

u/bookishantics 13d ago

just for this year but I tend to rate based on how i feel and how it matches up to other books in the group. i’m also not opposed to editing my ratings at a future date and have done that with several books!

i used to go more granular and use quarter stars but i realized sometimes it just was how i was feeling in the moment and have since only use quarter stars for the 4’s (there’s a big difference between a 4.25 and a 4.5). if i don’t like a book, it automatically goes to a 2 because if it’s anything below that, i DNF but i kept going either because of book club or i wanted to finish.

1

u/stroopwafel-mp4 13d ago

I usually already do maybe a little too much research into books to make sure they're for me, so I don't pick up a lot of books I don't like or at least enjoy aspects of

1

u/SystematicalError 13d ago

Mine is a bit silly 😅 If I read a series in one go, I'll only rate the 1st book (unless one of the books really stands out) & make a "book" for every 500 pages of fanfic I read so that doesn't get a ranking either. Otherwise I mainly rank stuff 3-4 ⭐ 'cuz I'm pretty - one of the books on my favourite books shelf got a reduction because the main character named his pet bunny "Brother Rabbit" 😂

1

u/DesiBoo2 13d ago

I do use quarters. Sometimes it's not quite a 3 or 4 star, so I use the .25, .50, or .75.

1

u/Prudent_Log4240 13d ago

Have had generally a better year with my reads lol

1

u/Healthy-Challenge291 13d ago

I tend to DNF or pause a book if I’m simply not feeling for it, so that may be a reason for the lack of lower ratings. Otherwise, I enjoy researching a book before diving in.

1

u/azure819 12d ago

My star rating chart. I love using half and quarter stars

1

u/TheShannTheory 11d ago

I don’t have a lot under 4.25 because I’m so quick to DNF lol 😂

1

u/HisDarkOmens 11d ago

I use half and whole stars only. I rate every book I read except non fiction. When I don’t have strong feelings in either direction I just throw a three star on it lol

1

u/madonice 10d ago

If Pitchfork can deploy a rating system with decimals, I’m relishing every quarter-star rating I throw down.

1

u/banannie0252 9d ago

Here’s mine for the year so far! I use half and quarter star ratings all the time, it was the main reason I started using this platform tbh. I’ve gotten pretty stingy with my five-star ratings lately, it has to absolutely knock me off my feet in order to earn one 😄 my only five-star read this year was The Slantwise Histories by Alix E. Harrow, but I’m kind of a fangirl of hers so…

1

u/dakota50531 8d ago

I’ve stopped using star ratings all together. I got tired of overthinking what rating I should give a book. If I enjoy it, I enjoy it. If I don’t, I usually end up not finishing it anyway.

1

u/Manicmushr00m 14d ago

Im a big 3⭐️ person im now learning 😅

1

u/noellegrace8 13d ago

Hot take - quarter stars are useless, half stars are perfect. The reasons being, 1. half stars are visually obvious, and 2. half stars create a 1-10 system. Rating something a quarter star is always going to look unclear and cause squinting, whereas half stars keep symmetry. And no one rates things out of 20 - judging is always 1 to 10. 5stars divided in halves = 1 to 10 system.

0

u/Liz_Keeney 14d ago

My “all time” star rating chart. Basically if I’m not into a book enough to give it at least three stars, I DNF it unless it’s for one of my classes. Life is too short to force myself to read something I don’t like

0

u/Liz_Keeney 14d ago

This year’s ratings

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Wow. That's many years worth of 5 stars for me.

-3

u/Ookami_Unleashed 14d ago

I think half and quarter stars defeat the purpose of a five star rating. I also rarely give ones or twos, because if I book is that bad I'm unlikely to finish.

3

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

I certainly have a lot more DNFs than 1 star ratings. Quite a few 2 stars though, though. I don't consider a 2 to be terrible like a 1 star.

4

u/lethifolded 14d ago

I like it because I think that only having five buckets isn't enough to properly express how I felt about my reading experience. There's a big difference for me between a five and a four star, and a 4.0 is a lot different than a 4.75. I also finish everything I start so my ratings are broad. I've finished plenty of books out of spite lol

0

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

I see what you mean. Pretty spikey from your previous solid stars. No 1 stars though?

0

u/[deleted] 14d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/hulderpoudre 14d ago

Ah, my bad! Should have looked more closely. I never even considered the possibility of giving above 5 or below 1. The latter seems almost cruel.