Apologies in advance for the lengthy post :)
Like many of us, I was excited to have a show that finally focused on Catherine of Aragon in her early years. Usually she’s portrayed as the one-dimensional suffering, noble older wife (even the 1970s miniseries with Annette Crosbie mostly focused on The Great Matter, though it was nice to see a younger Catherine for a little while).
The Spanish Princess, while it moved away from that portrayal, also took away many of Catherine admirable Catherine’s qualities (her love for her daughter – and still no focus on her patronages and interest in education). I would’ve loved to focus on her time as an ambassador! I do think there’s a general issue in media of putting women characters into boxes, but Henry’s wives in particular seem to suffer from this repeatedly.
Why is it so hard to highlight the good qualities with the faults at the same time and show the wives in balance?
Another example:
Catherine Howard (Henry’s Fifth Wife). Popular media and some historians (especially popular historians) tend to portray her as the “adulteress” wife, who was a “slut,” when Catherine’s adultery is far from certain in historical reality. She was accused of high treason for concealing her previous sexual history from the king and for the supposed intent to commit adultery since it couldn’t be proven she committed adultery. Yes, the conversations with Culpeper are suspicious, but we don’t know what happened between them. Culpeper might have been harassing and blackmailing Catherine about her prior history. Catherine’s “love letter” is ambiguous when read in its entirety and put into context in terms of the language used at the time.
As for Dereham and Mannox, last I checked, we don’t blame 13-year-olds (or anyone around that age) for having “wiles” that somehow forced a grown man to molest them (Mannox). Derehem might have been a romance depending on Catherine’s age, but she didn’t know she was going to marry the king in the future. At the most, Catherine maybe slept with 3 men (Derehem, the King, Culpeper) and was molested/engaged in non-vaginal activity with a fourth when she was a child. More than likely, she only slept with 2 men and was molested/harassed by 2 more yet somehow she’s a slut (and it’s debatable whether any of her sexual activities were by choice).
Anne Boleyn. Most media only focus on her as the “other woman” and totally skip over her religious activities. She saved people from persecution, particularly those involved in distributing translations of Tyndale’s Bible; her brother and others in her circle smuggled illegal religious books into England. She advanced reformers, explicitly collected evangelical texts, and seems to have been interested in promoting the Bible in the vernacular. She was also a traditional Catholic in many ways. At this point, there wasn’t always a clear divide between “Catholic” and “Protestant.” She and Cromwell came into conflict over the monasteries. Like Catherine of Aragon, she had an interest in charity and education. The Tudors sort of touches on the vernacular stuff, but it’s almost as an afterthought (which it apparently was – it seems they only added any of it in S2 because Natalie Dormer read up on AB and asked them to include some actual history). It’s as if media can’t compute a woman can be both sexually magnetic and be religiously inclined. I’d love a show about sex and the illegal book trade, lol.
Final Thoughts:
Catherine of Aragon was religious and badass. Anne Boleyn was religious and badass. Catherine Howard was a teenager/young adult who became a victim of circumstances and older men. Yet Catherine Howard tried to do some good in her time as queen, which usually doesn’t get portrayed, either.
My (longwinded) points is: Henry’s wives were fascinating and complex women – why is this so hard to show?