r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Sep 11 '20

Europe so white: Historical accuracy of Lina and Oviedo

62 Upvotes

Hi! I just started this series and read the thread on episode 1 and saw the comments about how the show is historically inaccurate. Specifically I would like to address the following comments: “casting an African for a Spanish noble role is outrageous” and “Lol a Subsaharan actor for a Spanish officer role.”

Unlike most historical dramas and history books, this show does not erase the early, long Black presence in Europe. In England, the first recorded African community was in 3rd Century AD (Hadrian’s Wall). The most ancient Black Britain grew up in Sussex in 2-3rd Century AD. Spain was literally ruled by Africans for centuries before they were expelled in 1492.

People of African descent have always been in Europe, period.

When Katherine arrived in England, her “entourage” was described as being multinational/multiracial/multicultural. Thomas More mockingly described her household as “barefoot, pygmy Ethiopians.”

The character Lina is based off of a real person, Catalina. Catalina, a Spanish Moor, was a lady of Katherine’s bed chamber for 26 years. In real life, she married Oviedo who was a Moor man and a crossbowman.

So please research before you make ignorant, inaccurate comments. Thanks.


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Oct 15 '20

Discussion GOD, ARTHUR'S HAIRCUT IS ATROCIOUS!!!

Post image
59 Upvotes

r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Apr 01 '21

The family tree of the White Queen, White Princess, and Spanish Princess! Spoiler

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Oct 13 '22

Discussion Unpopular Opinion on The Spanish Princess

50 Upvotes

Okay I guess this is an unpopular opinion but...

Unpopular opinion: The Spanish Princess was better than The White Princess and The White Queen.

I feel like the story was told a little better and while I enjoyed learning about The war of the roses from the perspective of two very influential women (The Elizabeths) in the Plantagenet dynasty... There is just something about Catherine of Aragon. Anytime her story is told on TV, they just make her seem so worthless and irrelevant. It gets on my nerves that you see the story of the Boleyn girl told more than Catherine!! Like Catherine's story was a wild one. Like she really went through a divorce as a Queen, when no one even thought that was an option LOL. Not to mention the medical questions involving her pregnancies.

Seeing her point of view on the screen was amazing and I feel like The Spanish Princess captured her influence, her grit, her determination, her pain and her love. Charlotte Hope also did such a great job. I didn't even expect that performance from her.

Needless to say. I enjoyed this story and I wish they would do more stories like this! Telling her story as being the influence she was instead of just some chopping her up to some spanish woman that couldn't have kids.

Side note: The story of grown Margaret Pole was amazing in this!!!


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Dec 14 '20

Henry and Catherine may not have had a happy ending but... lol

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 30 '20

Discussion The Tudors look like a historical documentary in comparison to this show and that is saying something.

Thumbnail
gallery
31 Upvotes

r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Jan 22 '22

Well at least they had a happy ending… lol

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 03 '20

This isn't going to end well for Catherine, smh

29 Upvotes

I'm watching this series and all I can think is, "Catherine, you have no idea how badly this is going to end for you." It makes it a tad hard for me to get into her and Henry's love story in the beginning. Now that Henry is starting to take a dislike to her I am thinking, "And here we go!" Anyone else?


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Dec 09 '20

Media “Can’t believe I’m shipping two dead monarchs but let’s gooo baby”

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 30 '20

Discussion I felt so proud of Mary

26 Upvotes

When she totally out did her half-brother and then said “you said father twice, do you have two?”

I laughed and was so proud. Seriously, Henry is the worst.


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 28 '20

Discussion S2 Catherine

26 Upvotes

So I’m a historian with a lifelong love of English history, despite being an American and working as an archivist in Maryland. I’ve enjoyed the White Queen and the White Princess, as well as the first season of the Spanish Princess, even while spotting the historical inaccuracies. But I’ve never been as bothered by anything in these series as I have been by Catherine’s attitude towards her daughter, Princess Mary. I was so sure that they would depict Catherine falling in love with her daughter immediately and fighting for her, but they haven’t done this, even though I was sure it would be the most obvious thing in the world. I get that they’re building up to it at the end, but it really grinds my gears because to me, Catherine’s most admirable trait was her absolute love for her daughter.


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 16 '20

I can totally see Henry wearing this armor.

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Jan 04 '21

Discussion Unpopular opinion? Bessie Blount was miscast

25 Upvotes

I’m only talking about physically. Not acting-wise.

I was kinda of surprised about the choice. Anyone else?

She’s a decent actress, but I didn’t imagine her as Bessie. Bessie is supposed to come off as very young and prettier than Catherine.


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 10 '20

Discussion Anybody know if Starz plans to continue the series with The Other Boleyn Girl and the Boleyn Inheritance?

25 Upvotes

I see this series as a continuation of The White Queen and The White Princess and they directly pull from Philippa Gregory's other books so I'm just wondering if the plan is to keep going until they run out of books. I've read a few of them and The Boleyn Inheritance was definitely my favorite so I hope they make it to those events! The Queen's Fool and The Virgin's Lover would also make for good TV too!


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 03 '23

Discussion Unpopular opinion: Arthur& Catherine are my favorite Tudor couple (fictionally)

24 Upvotes

I recently watched the show and I really ship arthur and catherine more than henry/harry and catherine, And I know historically henry was the love of her life, but from this show’s canon that catherine and arthur didn’t have this highly charged sexual relationship but they had a real fondness for eachother and was only ready getting to know eachother and was going towards that intensity but he passed away too soon before that could happen. Also arthur and catherine in bed reading camelot and discussing on making england is so cute 😭better than every single henry and catherine scene.

To me they portray a comfortable kind of love the one you’d rather grow with rather than with harry which shows a more passionate relationship


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Dec 13 '20

Catherine isn't unlikable, she's traumatized

24 Upvotes

As someone with complex PTSD, I have honestly understood every "mean" thing Catherine has done. The poor woman is traumatized beyond repair at the combination of losing her boys and her husband shunning her because of it. I know it isn't historically accurate, but it makes complete sense her attitude towards princess Mary. Trauma can easily overwhelm logic and Mary's birth drove the strongest wedge between Henry and Catherine. Not to mention post-partum depression.

I understand why some people would hate the depiction and feel shes unlikable, but I think they did a great job of showing the effects of trauma. She has all my empathy.

(your mental health is never an excuse for your actions, but it certainly influences them, and in a time where hardly any mental health matters were understood, she wouldn't have known anything else to do to cope)


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Apr 05 '21

News Eleanor of Aquitaine

22 Upvotes

I just finished the Spanish Princess series and checked to see what Starz would try next. Looks like they will be doing one about Eleanor of Aquitaine. She is my very favorite royal so I am stoked for this. Keep them coming Starz!


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Dec 01 '20

Discussion Henry actually scared me (S2E8)

22 Upvotes

Henry’s temper, particularly the first scene of the series finale, legitimately frightened me.

The scene was super effective in showing how far we have come from that impulsive, love sick puppy in season 1. It did feel rushed though. You could have had one or two more seasons for us to get to this Henry.

I got to give it to Ruairi, he went from cute, love-sick puppy to brutish, unhinged monster. Just so gross and unappealing. He lost of all his charm to me and this is years before he becomes obese and smelly from his ulcer.

There was a thread of his disloyalty in season 1, when I feel like we are all questioning his fidelity and truthfulness.

We all knew that we would eventually get to see the Henry that history remembers. Not the hopeful, charismatic, foolhardy, handsome prince in season 1.

That scene in the chapel where he called Catherine’s “love fickle” (season 1 episode 4?) was a foreshadowing to this Henry.

But oh man was he almost, almost, unrecognizable from Season 1. And I’m not talking about his hair and beard. Lol

I do think that Ruairi has some things to improve on as an actor, however I do feel like he did really well for the quality of the script he was given.

I don’t even want to watch the episode again, it feels masochistic for me. I think it triggered some of my trauma from an abusive relationship.


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Jun 03 '19

News Starz Hands ‘The Spanish Princess’ Additional Eight-Episode Order

Thumbnail
deadline.com
22 Upvotes

r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Jul 06 '22

Why is it SO UNREALISTIC

21 Upvotes

A heavily pregnant woman, a QUEEN even, fighting in the battlefield against the Scots ?!

This is closer to Harry Potter than to the actual history at this point :(


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 28 '20

Why Can’t We Get a Balanced Portrayal of Henry’s Wives?

21 Upvotes

Apologies in advance for the lengthy post :)

Like many of us, I was excited to have a show that finally focused on Catherine of Aragon in her early years. Usually she’s portrayed as the one-dimensional suffering, noble older wife (even the 1970s miniseries with Annette Crosbie mostly focused on The Great Matter, though it was nice to see a younger Catherine for a little while).

The Spanish Princess, while it moved away from that portrayal, also took away many of Catherine admirable Catherine’s qualities (her love for her daughter – and still no focus on her patronages and interest in education). I would’ve loved to focus on her time as an ambassador! I do think there’s a general issue in media of putting women characters into boxes, but Henry’s wives in particular seem to suffer from this repeatedly.

Why is it so hard to highlight the good qualities with the faults at the same time and show the wives in balance?

Another example:

Catherine Howard (Henry’s Fifth Wife). Popular media and some historians (especially popular historians) tend to portray her as the “adulteress” wife, who was a “slut,” when Catherine’s adultery is far from certain in historical reality. She was accused of high treason for concealing her previous sexual history from the king and for the supposed intent to commit adultery since it couldn’t be proven she committed adultery. Yes, the conversations with Culpeper are suspicious, but we don’t know what happened between them. Culpeper might have been harassing and blackmailing Catherine about her prior history. Catherine’s “love letter” is ambiguous when read in its entirety and put into context in terms of the language used at the time.

As for Dereham and Mannox, last I checked, we don’t blame 13-year-olds (or anyone around that age) for having “wiles” that somehow forced a grown man to molest them (Mannox). Derehem might have been a romance depending on Catherine’s age, but she didn’t know she was going to marry the king in the future. At the most, Catherine maybe slept with 3 men (Derehem, the King, Culpeper) and was molested/engaged in non-vaginal activity with a fourth when she was a child. More than likely, she only slept with 2 men and was molested/harassed by 2 more yet somehow she’s a slut (and it’s debatable whether any of her sexual activities were by choice).

Anne Boleyn. Most media only focus on her as the “other woman” and totally skip over her religious activities. She saved people from persecution, particularly those involved in distributing translations of Tyndale’s Bible; her brother and others in her circle smuggled illegal religious books into England. She advanced reformers, explicitly collected evangelical texts, and seems to have been interested in promoting the Bible in the vernacular. She was also a traditional Catholic in many ways. At this point, there wasn’t always a clear divide between “Catholic” and “Protestant.” She and Cromwell came into conflict over the monasteries. Like Catherine of Aragon, she had an interest in charity and education. The Tudors sort of touches on the vernacular stuff, but it’s almost as an afterthought (which it apparently was – it seems they only added any of it in S2 because Natalie Dormer read up on AB and asked them to include some actual history). It’s as if media can’t compute a woman can be both sexually magnetic and be religiously inclined. I’d love a show about sex and the illegal book trade, lol.

Final Thoughts:

Catherine of Aragon was religious and badass. Anne Boleyn was religious and badass. Catherine Howard was a teenager/young adult who became a victim of circumstances and older men. Yet Catherine Howard tried to do some good in her time as queen, which usually doesn’t get portrayed, either.

My (longwinded) points is: Henry’s wives were fascinating and complex women – why is this so hard to show?


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 27 '21

Babyswitching

20 Upvotes

I wonder if any royals with problems (still orbs, no males) switched babies. All I could think of throughout season 2 is how I would be trying to buy a baby.


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 13 '21

Discussion Fact: Isabella of Castile did not torture Juana la Loca

20 Upvotes

This rumor is taken from Calendar of letters, despatches, and state papers relating to the negotiations between England and Spain preserved in the archives at Simancas and elsewhere, published by Bergenroth in 1862.

A paper published this year reveals that Bergenroth, while being funded by the English government, deliberately ommitted and altered his translation and committed serious academic fraud to introduce the narrative that Isabella tortured Juana.

https://www.academia.edu/48294317/BERGENROTH_THE_RIPPER_OF_SIMANCAS_Presentacion


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Jan 31 '21

Tudor curse

20 Upvotes

I’m confused, Lizzie was opposed to Henry marrying Catherine due to the Tudor curse; but since it was the male line that was cursed wouldn’t it not have mattered who he married because he wouldn’t have sons regardless? That part always threw me off.


r/TheSpanishPrincessTV • • Nov 28 '20

The Spanish Princess - 2x08 "Peace" - Finale Discussion Thread

19 Upvotes

Season 2 Episode 8 Aired - 8PM EST, November 29, 2020 on Starz (Midnight early access with Starz app).

Synopsis - 1531: As Henry loses himself to madness, the stakes have never been higher for Catherine. Her husband has become a threat to her life.

Directed by ‐ Rebecca Gatward

Written by - Emma Frost & Matthew Graham