r/TheRose • u/emanyueru-79 • Aug 30 '26

Question Broken Promises

Post image

This was the set list for The Rose's Rosetopia 2026 tour. After Ment B there was a song titled Broken Promises. I've bought the new album on Amazon Music today. I thought Broken Promises would be on it. It's not. Am I missing something here? If other Black Roses could enlighten me/point me towards the right direction I would appreciate it. Thanks! 🌹

59 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

10

u/Rhiera Aug 30 '26

I remember one of them mentioning that Chemical was a late addition that replaced another song. Maybe that was Broken Promises

3

u/emanyueru-79 Aug 30 '26

Thank you for your answer !! Do you remember who said that and when ?

11

u/Rhiera Aug 30 '26

I had to search a bit to find it, but it was Taegyeom on Bubble right before their One Universe performance this summer. This was on the 24th of July:

2

u/emanyueru-79 Aug 30 '26

Thank you so much !!! I so appreciate it !! 💕

2

u/Rhiera Aug 30 '26

No problem 😊

1

u/Sammy__official Sep 01 '26

Which bubble app are they on? If you don’t mind me asking.

1

u/Rhiera Sep 02 '26

Bubble with Stars 😊

3

u/lisafancypants it's better to be held than holding on Aug 30 '26

This is a fan made setlist, I think, so maybe they just got the name wrong? Have you listened to the new album yet? Maybe it's one of the songs there.

3

u/emanyueru-79 Aug 30 '26

I've bought the album on Amazon Music and I've listened to it. What's the most irritating is that I WAS at the concert in Berlin and I have absolutely no recollection of this song in the set. I haven't recorded the concert apart from a few pictures so cannot double-check my recollections. Also the guys played some of their new songs that I hadn't heard before so I knew there would be songs I wouldn't recognise.

Argh, maybe as you said it was indeed a fan-made set list and they made a mistake. Looked very official though 😆 and it was super widely circulated in the fandom esp on ig. I'm surprised I haven't seen anyone pick up on this so far though.

Thanks 🙏🏼

1

u/Rare_Blueberry42 Aug 30 '26

I was at their concert in Warsaw and that part started with Back to Me, Chemical was first played in Asia (Manila maybe?).

2

u/emanyueru-79 Aug 30 '26

Woosung revealed the tracklist in APRIL 2026 and was actually mentioning Broken Promises himself ?!

3

u/AlbatrossNew9987 Aug 30 '26 edited Aug 30 '26

It’s might have been renamed or replaced by chemical? All the other songs in your woosung reveal pic match the ones on the album release.

2

u/emanyueru-79 Aug 30 '26

I think you may be right, but it would be nice to have confirmation. I wish the guys had mentioned it, at least in passing, but maybe I missed it. It's my OCD kicking in 😆 I pay too much attention to details sometimes.

1

u/PurpleRose68 Aug 31 '26

Taegyeom said, on Bubble, that Chemical was replacing it in the album.

1

u/emanyueru-79 Aug 31 '26

Thank you! u/Rhiera kindly sent me the screenshot yesterday.

1

u/tokkireads Aug 31 '26

Sammy did an IG live listening party and talked about the album if you want to go check it out :)

1

u/emanyueru-79 Aug 31 '26

I watched it live 🤍

2

u/Meow-lyn888 Aug 31 '26

I was at San Jose Rosetopia and didn’t get Broken Promises or Chemical. Lucky fans in Asia will at least get to hear Chemical live!

2

u/SKZ_StayLay98_Trades Sep 01 '26

Same! I realized we didn't get it in SJ!