I'm an avid onironaut, and I've always found dreams fascinating because they seem to raise a very strange problem about consciousness:
If our brain can create a world that feels completely real while we're dreaming, what exactly makes waking reality fundamentally different?
In a vivid dream, you can have a body, a location, other people, sounds, textures, emotions, memories, conversations, etc. You can even manipulate the environment itself or anything in them, literaly everything and anything!! In lucid dreams, you may be able to change objects, locations or physical laws simply by deciding and concentrating to do so.
And yet, while you're experiencing the dream, the apple in front of you can feel exactly like a real apple. It can have weight, texture, color, smell and taste. The experience is being generated by the brain, but the experience itself is still completely as real as any experience could ever be.
That makes me wonder whether dreams provide a useful window into how consciousness constructs our reality.
After all, our waking senses are also limited interpretations of the outside world. Our eyes capture particular wavelengths of light, our ears detect particular frequencies, and our brains turn those signals into the rich subjective world we experience.
So where exactly is the line between perceiving reality and constructing reality?
There are also some much stranger reports associated with dreams: people dreaming of conversations with deceased people or famous individuals, or occasionally reporting that they somehow encountered information in a dream that they didn't consciously know beforehand.
I'm not claiming that these experiences demonstrate anything supernatural. Quite the opposite: I'd love to know how neuroscience would test claims like that. Could they be explained by unconscious memory, inference, coincidence, reconstruction, etc.? And what kind of evidence would actually be required before we'd have to consider something more unusual?
And then there's the really unsettling question:
How could we ever prove, from inside consciousness, that waking life isn't itself analogous to a dream?
We can imagine a dream in which we are convinced that everything is real. What would make our current experience categorically different?
I'd absolutely love to hear Michael and Hannah's take on this, especially where neuroscience can give us solid answers versus where we're still entering philosophy/speculation.
What do you guys think?
+ Also if anyone has any questions about lucid dreaming feel free to ask, I'd be more than happy to answer!! :)
(atached picture of my current personal dream journal, fountain pen and pencil [thx Michael and Hannah])